History: Twenty years ago, undergrad me wanted to go to med school. So I enrolled in 1st-year chem, made it to the end of stoichiometry, but this thing kept nagging me:
Why do we believe in atoms in the first place?
(I was coming off of a year of philosophy classes. We are difficult people.)
The grad student TAs were very kind, tried to help me with the classwork, and told me I'd have to wait until 3rd year before learning the material that answered my question.
I tried to hold on, memorizing the rules of these imaginary little entities. But more and more, it felt like religion. "Trust us, it exists. Eventually, all will be revealed. Until then, just follow the program."
I tried. I really. But eventually my brain imploded. I flunked out of second semester. I figured I must just be too dumb to be a doctor.
Since then, I've joined Mensa, learned five languages (from different families), become obsessed with medical journals (I understand a lot of it through self-study), and I'm in need of a new career now that I'm out of the military. Am I really too dumb? Or do I just need to approach it from a different angle? I've also realized that for better or for worse, my brain is just on its own program.
I've tried reading up atomic theory, but I get lost in the ancient Greek guys and the French guy who married a child and then got guillotined ...
I don't care about the social history of atomic theory. I just need to understand the logical argument that made the atomic model the one that everyone agrees on.
Please help if you can. Thanks.