r/chefknives • u/[deleted] • Sep 11 '21
Discussion Why German knives are better than Japanese knives
Why German knives are better than Japanese knives
First off, let me start this by saying everyone has their own opinions and these are my own. I have owned and used both knives over the years and this has been my experiences. Please let me know if you have any differing opinions and would like to have a (civil) discussion.
Sharpening & maintenance
It is easier to sharpen German knives than Japanese ones. One of these reasons is because of rockwell hardness. Japanese knives are typically much harder than German ones and require much more skill and know-how to sharpen them effectively. This can involve different stages of whetstone grits, while German knives can be effectively sharpened easier with only one stone, and honed with a sharpening steel. Japanese knives are typically recommended to not use a steel, but rather a ceramic rod, which removes much more material and sharpens the edge, rather than a normal steel which only seeks to re-align the edge.
German knives also require far less maintenance as they are much more durable. Due to factors like full tangs, thicker blades, and lower rockwell hardness, German knives will last much longer and can survive accidental falls, while Japanese knives are much more brittle and can be prone to chipping, or even upright snapping. German knives can also be used to go through smaller bones while Japanese knives should be avoided from going anywhere near bone. Japanese knives require the user to treat them more delicately and cut with much more care, whereas with German knives you can go at it and not have to worry so much.
2. Cost
While Japanese knives can easily go several hundred dollars, even into the thousands, German knives are much more accessible to the average cook. A German knife forged in Solingen, Germany can cost only $80-100, while brands like Mercer offer even cheaper options that use the same exact steel used in Wusthof (x50 Cr Mo V15 steel) at only 30 bucks. While premium options such as Solingen knives made with wood handles can go into the $200-range, the highest quality German knives can be had within the $100-150 range, leaving you with room to spend on a whetstone or any other kitchen accessory. Japanese knives on the other hand are not unusual to be priced at several hundred dollars. On top of that, should you get a chip or a break in the knife at some point, you will have to spend money getting it professionally repaired/restored if you are not skilled enough with restoration whetstones on your own.
3. Rock chop
German knives are objectively much better if you like a rock-chop technique to cut foods with because of the curved edge from heel to tip, whereas Japanese knives have straighter blades and will typically be used for push-cuts or normal chops.
4. Bolsters and Weight
If you like full bolsters, German knives are your best option. The top brands have many options in this regard from full bolsters, to half/demi-bolsters, and other variations. Japanese knives will typically have one styling of bolster.
German knives have a higher variety of weight, with the option to buy one that is extremely heavy, or extremely light. For example, a Messermeister Meridian Elite chef knife weighs around 400 grams, while a Wusthof crafter chef knife weighs around 270 grams. German knives, known for being more robust, definitely have much heavier options if you prefer a lot of weight behind your knife.
5. Guests!
If you have some guests over or are cooking with family, it is better to let them use your German knives rather than to give them a Japanese one, which requires more care, knife skills, and general prep knowledge. The German knife will be used by them without you having to worry about them accidentally chipping it or doing little things with it that are normally no-goโs on brittle Japanese blades.
CONCLUSION
These are my reasons for preferring German knives over Japanese ones. That being said, if you are skilled and willing to pay more money, Japanese knives are much better for making precision cuts. For example, sushi! However for the standard chef, German knives are going to be more cost-effective and suit you better in a kitchen.
Again, these are just my opinions, which I try to back up with some sort of reasoning or source. Let me know what your experiences are and if thereโs any rebuttal youโd like to give.