From a purely scientific standpoint, the Quranic verse in Surah Al-Mu’minun 23:12-14 does not provide a precise or accurate description of human embryonic development as understood in modern embryology.
"Man We did create from a quintessence (of clay); then We placed him as (a drop of) sperm in a place of rest, firmly fixed; then We made the sperm into a clot of congealed blood; then of that clot We made a (foetus) lump; then We made out of that lump bones and clothed the bones with flesh; then We developed out of it another creature. So blessed be Allah, the Best to create!"
While the verses may be interpreted metaphorically or symbolically by some believers to align with modern embryological processes, the descriptions in the Quran are either not detailed enough or outright wrong, failing to match the scientific understanding of embryogenesis.
A common justification is that people in ancient times might have found it impossible to grasp complex scientific concepts. As a result, it is suggested that God opted for a simpler and metaphorical method to convey such information. However, the assumption that individuals in earlier eras were incapable of understanding intricate knowledge lacks validity. Historical records show that philosophers who lived centuries before Islam significantly contributed to the development of various scientific principles:
Aristotle (384–322 BCE): proposed the theory of epigenesis in embryology, suggesting gradual development with new structures forming over time.
Anaximander (c. 610–546 BCE): Proposed the idea of evolution and the emergence of life from a watery environment, as well as a proto-solar system.
Pythagoras (c. 570–495 BCE): Developed mathematical concepts, including the Pythagorean theorem.
Empedocles (c. 490–430 BCE): Suggested that matter is composed of four elements—earth, air, fire, and water—which foreshadowed later ideas about elements.
Democritus (c. 460–370 BCE): Formulated an atomic theory, proposing that everything is composed of indivisible particles called atoms.
Aristarchus of Samos (c. 310–230 BCE): Proposed a heliocentric model of the solar system, with the Sun at the center.
Modern embryology, based on scientific observation and research, describes the development of a human embryo through a series of well-defined stages involving processes such as fertilization, implantation, gastrulation, and organogenesis. These processes are explained in biological terms and are not mentioned in the Quranic verses.
In the other hand, what is indeed mentioned in the Quran contains many issues:
Creation from a Clot: The term "alaq" in the Quran is translated as "clot" or "leech-like clot," but this description does not align with the scientific understanding of the initial stages of embryonic development. In embryology, the formation of a zygote through fertilization is the starting point, and it doesn't resemble a clot or leech.
Semen as a Drop: Describing semen as a "drop" oversimplifies the scientific complexity of fertilization. Fertilization involves the fusion of a haploid sperm cell with a haploid egg cell, forming a diploid zygote, which undergoes subsequent mitotic divisions.
Development into a Lump: The description of the drop turning into a lump does not accurately represent the detailed stages of embryonic development. Essential processes such as cleavage, blastulation, gastrulation, and organogenesis are omitted in this description.
Stage as a Chewed-Like Substance (Mudghah): The term "mudghah," translated as a chewed-like substance, lacks specificity in capturing the complexities of embryogenesis. It does not correspond to the organized differentiation of cells into specific tissues and organs.
Bones Forming and Then Clothed with Flesh: The sequential description of bones forming and then being covered with flesh does not align with the simultaneous and coordinated processes of bone and muscle development in embryology.
Breathing of the Soul: The concept of breathing the soul into the formed body is a metaphysical and theological idea. From a scientific perspective, the existence and nature of the soul are not within the purview of empirical investigation.
Furthermore, the Quran's description of reproduction omits any mention of the female egg, raising poignant questions about the purported omniscience of God. How can such a fundamental factor be overlooked in divine knowledge? What a missed opportunity from God to revolutionize the field of embryology forever and introduce groundbreaking insights. Unfortunately, the discovery of the female egg's existence and its pivotal role only occurred centuries later, with the help of Karl Ernst von Baer in the early 19th century. Detailed knowledge further unfolded in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, attributed to the works of scientists such as Albert von Kölliker and Edgar Allen.
The knowledge available at the time was a mix of early medical writings, cultural beliefs, other religious influence and philosophical ideas. There are striking similarities between the description above and the known embryonic knowledge during the 7th century, such as:
Absence of the female eggs and ovum
Both traditions acknowledge the concept of different stages in the development of a living being. The Quranic verses describe stages from a "clot" to the formation of bones then flesh, while Greek philosophers like Aristotle proposed a theory of epigenesis, emphasizing gradual development.
Creation from a Drop of Fluid (Nutfah): The Quran describes the initial stage of human creation from a "drop of fluid" (Quran 16:4; 75:37), which aligns with the concept of conception in Galen's embryonic stages.
Formation into a Clinging Clot (Alaqah): The Quran refers to the subsequent stage as the creation turning into a "clinging clot" (Quran 23:14), resembling the early formation of the fetus described by Galen.
Formation into a Lump (Mudghah): The Quran then mentions the development into a "lump" (Quran 23:14), which corresponds to the general idea of organ and body part formation proposed by Galen.
And more listed in the following page
Muslims often point out that the prophet was illiterate, supporting the claim that he couldn't possibly have acquired knowledge from other civilizations. However, knowledge was passed down orally during that time (which is why it was important to memorize the Quranic verses), and he did not need to write or read.
Another claim suggests that the bedouins from the 7th century did not have any contact with other civilizations and could not in any way be exposed to foreign knowledge. This is outright wrong. The Arabian Peninsula was a crossroads for trade between many civilizations :
Byzantine Empire: The Byzantine Empire, with its capital in Constantinople (modern-day Istanbul), had a significant influence on the Arabian Peninsula, especially in the regions bordering the Byzantine territories.
Sassanian Empire: The Sassanian Empire, based in Persia (modern-day Iran), also had interactions with the Arabian Peninsula, especially in the eastern regions. The Arabian Peninsula served as a buffer zone between the Byzantine and Sassanian Empires.
Ethiopian Kingdoms: The Kingdom of Aksum in East Africa (modern-day Ethiopia and Eritrea) had trade and cultural interactions with the Arabian Peninsula, particularly in the southern regions.
Indian Ocean Trade: The Arabian Peninsula was a crucial geostrategic area of the Indian Ocean trade network, connecting with civilizations and cultures from the Indian subcontinent, East Africa, and Southeast Asia.
Nomadic Tribes: Besides major empires, the Bedouins had interactions with various nomadic tribes and groups in the surrounding deserts, contributing to cultural exchanges and trade.
Considering the geographical proximity of the Byzantine Empire and Greece, there was ongoing contact between the two regions. The Byzantines preserved and transmitted many aspects of Greek culture, philosophy, and knowledge. Scholars in the Byzantine Empire were well-acquainted with the works of ancient Greek philosophers and scientists.
As such, there might have been indirect exposure to some aspects of Greek knowledge and culture through these trade connections. The Greek physician Galen (129–c. 200 CE) had a significant influence on the medical field during this period, and his ideas were transmitted through translations into Arabic later on**.**
Some authentic hadiths confirm that the prophet and his companions knew about these other civilizations :
Hadith about the Persians: Narrated by Abu Huraira: "The Prophet (ﷺ) said, 'The Hour will not be established till the buttocks of the women of the tribe of Daus move while going round Dhi-al-Khalasa.' Dhi-al-Khalasa was the idol of the Daus tribe which they used to worship in the Pre-Islamic Period of ignorance." [Sahih al-Bukhari 3173]
Hadith about the Romans: Narrated by Abu Huraira: "Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, 'The Hour will not be established until you fight against the Romans, and the Romans will be an army consisting of the best soldiers of the people on the earth at that time.'" [Sahih al-Bukhari 2945]
Hadith about the Ethopians: Narrated by Anas bin Malik: "The Prophet (ﷺ) said, 'Listen and obey (your chief) even if an Ethiopian whose head is like a raisin were made your chief.'"[Sahih al-Bukhari 6939]
Hadith about the Turks: Narrated by Abu Huraira: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "The Hour will not be established until you fight with the Turks; people with small eyes, red faces, and flat noses. Their faces will look like shields coated with leather. The Hour will not be established till you fight with people whose shoes are made of hair." (Sahih al-Bukhari 7096)
The prophet Muhammad has been a merchant most of his life, he could have easily acquired his flawed knowledge by interacting with people on the roads or from other merchant peers.
Conclusion
The Quranic verses in Surah Al-Mu’minun 23:12-14 not only lack scientific precision in describing human embryonic development but also contain significant inaccuracies in stages of development. These inaccuracies can also be found in embryonic knowledge predating Islam. While some interpret them metaphorically, the specificity seen in modern embryology is absent within Islamic scriptures deemed "divine".
The argument that ancient minds couldn't grasp complex scientific concepts is countered by contributions from pre-Islamic philosophers to many different scientific fields. It is important to note that these philosophers did not have any divine help and were not considered to be prophets (or self-proclaimed as such), yet their contribution to humanity laid the foundation for the progress our species has achieved until today. In contrast, Islam had no contribution to the embryonic field, in fact, it just copied common flawed knowledge of its time.
To finish this article, please reflect on this: Which of these scenarios seem more likely?
God passed down flawed knowledge to His prophet (coincidentally resembling the understanding of 7th-century people), a knowledge that did not revolutionize or even impact the embriology field.
Advanced neighboring civilizations influenced the Arabian Peninsula with their knowledge gradually reaching the desert tribes via trade routes.