The project this character is for takes place in a town where humans and neighbors (non-humans) live together because the veil is thin. At night, in their homes, or around people they're comfortable with, they show aspects of their true forms in their moral forms/workshopped mortal body.
This character is a wayob medicine seller (a sorcerer that can turn into an animal when asleep, think like a WolfWalker). He left his clan because the magic of the moon and underworld has warped him-now, even while awake, he shows fox-like traits, which is a sign of power and becoming non-human.
Like I mentioned, I want him to have a form he takes while comfortable, but I actually dislike adding beast traits to humanoids in my designs-I often replace them with something that EVOKES the beast form, but isn't the trait. (The last two image were added to show this- those aren't her wings, it's a cape shaped like them made from her true form's feathers, and Muireall makes her hair into buns like cat ears).
Which "comfort" design looks best for him? I have beast trait blindness because of how I usually design. I'd prefer if only one trait is shown (like RWBY's faunus) but if both the ears and tail look pleasant to the average person,, I'll go with it.
Thank you for reading the background info and helping out! In order of designs, we have long ears AND long tail, short ears and short tail, no ears and long tail, long ears ONLY, short ears ONLY, and his medicine seller/main/day design.