r/cbaduk • u/[deleted] • Feb 18 '18
Current state of computer Go?
I recall back in around 2015, after first hearing about the AlphaGo version that beat Fan Hui, and the upcoming grand match/challenge that was supposed to take place in March of the following year against Lee Sedol, that at the time the strongest commercially available desktop version of a PC Go AI game was probably Crazy Stone. I was introduced to Crazy Stone after reading a Wired article that predicted it would be ten years at least for there to be an AI that bested top professionals. Some even thought it would never be possible.
It was a major excitement to me, at the time, when finally a “Deep Learning” version of Crazy Stone was made available and its creator purported it to be 7dan strength, and nearly 90% winrate against the then 2013 (non-DL) previous version of Crazy Stone, which up until AlphaGo was the best yet, with it even once winning against a Pro by getting 4 stone handicap from him.
Being someone who is interested in Go and the AI aspect of computer Go, but always relatively weak in the actual skillset and mechanics of playing the game, (around 25 kyu or thereabouts) I kept my ears open and soon heard about an up and coming contender called “Leela”. At first I thought what a funny name, but then over time I realized that Leela also started encorporating a deep learning version that made it far stronger, and although it wasn’t open source or anything it was completely free (unlike Crazy Stone which costs $80) and I really liked the heat maps and other functionality that were sorely lacking in Crazy Stone (Crazy Stone btw still had an User Interface reminiscent of the Windows 95 era, and absolutely no scaling and was basically unbearable on a 4k display), plus since I had a fairly beefy graphics card at the time, very quickly I realized that Leela was going to be far stronger on my setup than CrazyStone could ever hope to be (being that CS was only CPU and not using GPU such as the likes of Leela)
Fast forward couple more months and there is talks about an even stronger AI bot by the name of Ray or Rayon or whatever. And that better than Leela, Ray was not only open source but it scaled to more than one graphics card as long as one had the CUDA/Nvidia platform. That was pretty exciting news to me, but unable to get it to compile on my own, I downloaded the latest binary executable and ran it on the Sabaki gui against Leela and was shocked to find out that in all my tests no matter which parameters I used that Leela beat Ray each and every time. So in any case I went back to Leela and by this point Crazy Stone was all but a distance memory of the past.
Fast forward a bit more, AlphaGoZero research paper is published and the creator of Leela was once again quick to jump on the bandwagon and started implementing a “Leela Zero” version of Leela. At first I imagined this was purely academic and just for kicks and that it would be years before Leela Zero had any hopes of gaining parity with the then strongest version of Leela 11. But soon LZ gained lots of ground, and with the latest network [e1156879 ] being well over 8000 ELO it seems like it is basically already on par with the Leela 11, if not even stronger than it!
Recently for the first time I kept hearing word of this new bot called “AQ” and that it is stronger than Ray and also than Leela 11 and that unlike Leela this AQ is fully open source. However talk in town is that now with the imminent and impeding release of LeelaZero Next version and sporting the latest >8000 ELO self-learning networks that pretty soon LZ will catch up to AQ if not shortly thereafter surpass it altogether.
In recent weeks, Nick Sibicky’s Go friend Andrew Jackson of Google and friends posted on reddit and github and elsewhere that they are doing an AlphaGoZero recreation as well, and from what I can gather, it will be a more faithful recreation than the Leela Zero and one major difference is that it won’t be distributed crowd sourced but rather it will be ran on Google’s own homegrown cloud TPU resources.
No matter what happens, this is an exciting time for computer Go and even Go in general, in that in the span of a few short years we went from the then state of the art non-DL CrazyStone needing to get from an average pro about four or five handicap stones to even hope to be able to score an win, to very soon multiple publically available and open source /free AI go programs that will be bona fide Pro level or above, reaching and perhaps soon surpassing the Fan Hui version of AlphaGo. This isn’t even taking into account other bots like DeepZen, FineArt, etc that which aren’t publically available for use, it seems we are witnessing for the first time in thousands of years of Go history a sort of “Convergence” to perfect play or near perfection level of play, with so many tools reaching superhuman levels in such sort periods of time.
We are fastly entering the age in which everyone can run the equivalent of AlphaGo on their own desktops, as AI strength reaches parity with convergence to perfection, and computer “Go” becoming “solved” in much the same way as Computer Chess already has been for decades, perhaps ultimately there will be a return of interest in/to humans playing Go against other humans merely for the intrinsic value it provides and the aesthetic and visceral satisfaction that it affords. In that sense, AI bots can be viewed as human teachers, a great equalizer and vast multiplier of Go learning efforts, offering insights, perspectives, and as a forms and means of augmentation and supplementation that never before in the history of the game has been ever been possible before. AI here can be used as a democratization of knowledge, leveling the playing field, where any adult or child can have instant access to the best of “Go teachers”, at zero cost, forever. I believe in the age of AI besting humans at everything, the question will no longer be “what do you do best”, or “how good are you”, but that of “what are your true passions, hobbies and interests” based on the metric of intrinsic excitement and intentionality of curiosity, irregardless of skill level or mastery.





