I have heavily cleaned my Lodge cast iron, scrubbed with detergent and water, scraping it down and sanding lightly by hand (more to remove chunky old seasoning) and thoroughly washed over and over. I have done this with reseasoning twice, before again and most recently seasoning with two layers of Grapeseed Oil, wiped until dry each time. I baked for a couple hours at 205, the listed smog point was 216 degrees. Left in the stove overnight. The pan did not feel tacky to touch this morning, and I was happy with it with distant future intentions of doing a future proper strip down depending on how the pan went. It is now much smoother than when first bought, with many speckles of the iron visible through the factory seasoning now - that's how far down I've sanded and cleaned it.
I cooked eggs for the kids - olive oil, a little butter, chives, cheese, the first two are omelette and the third is a fried eggs. On a 3 on an induction stove. I realised there might be burnt butter and there is some cheese residue, so I wipe with a Handee Ultra paper towel. Nothing black and unpleasant comes away, . But maybe the towel has lint it is now leaving behind, too small for me to easily see.
On the fourth and fifth eggs, cooked at 4, adding a splash of water to steam, and wiped between, I have the residue as pictured.
My spouse thinks my seasoning is already coming off the pan.
I think it's just burnt bits of butter or paper towel, and a better wipe with lint free towel between would help.
Is there a way to definitively tell which it is, so that I can adjust and improve accordingly?