I haven't wanted to show my face online but finally decided to show some before and after. I hate the before picture but it's a good reminder.
1st image. Out to eat at chili's with friends, a little over 3.5 years ago, just before the wake up call. Though this image should have been the wake up call. I was busting out of XL shirts and having to wear XXL. Pants size was 40 though I could wear a 38 depending on the brand. This is what the SAD turned me into.
2nd image is from 2 days ago. I got vain and ordered one of those shirts that's supposed to make your muscles pop, and those cuts tend to be tighter by design. That's a M. I was shocked to realize I wear mediums now. And I'm in a size 30 pants. (Those shorts are a tad big but manageable with a belt. Slowly replacing warrobe.)
I'm 6'0, 51 years. I'm about 250 lbs in the older picture (was too embarrassed to weigh myself at my heaviest but when I started noticing changes I weighed in at 246. So I assume I topped 50 or more.
Today I'm 184 lbs. BMI is almost a useless number in individuals but for the first time since early college, mine is what the numbers say they should be. I'm at or at least close to my maintenance weight.
Now two caveats. First, I would occasionally have, not cheat meals but "exceptions" for business travel and eating occasionally with relatives. Probably why I didn't get to where I am now for so long. Then I moved, and about a year into the move I realized my "mostly carnivore" had become anything but. So, I didn't have to start from scratch, but I did have to go from Large shirts back to Extra Large.
That's the second thing. I did this mostly with carnivore. I ate when I was hungry, stopped when I was full, and started again when I was hungry. That's still my formula.
Eventually I felt good enough to work out (mostly weight resistance with body weight, dumbells, and kettlebells, swimming and learning to surf, and occasional short sprints.) I'd have never been able to do that without carnivore. And I don't think the workouts contributed to weight loss per say, if anything I've added muscle so it makes me weigh more than I would otherwise. But muscle also uses more fat for energy so it clearly helps with body composition.
And my appetite stabilized, which allowed intermittent fasting to start. I naturally eat 1 or 2 meals a day, depending on hunger. I now make a point to wait a minimum of 16 hours between my last meal of one day and my first meal the next. But honestly, I started tracking, and it's usually 20 or more, just because that's when I'm ready.
These are technically confounders but it's clear to me the majority of what worked for me is carnivore. If I had to give up all but one approach, that's what I'd stick with.
Hope this post and these pictures helps someone somehow.