r/cakefails • • Dec 17 '24 Polished Silver Turd Take My Silver Heart of Silver

I tried using a printed cake topper and it didn’t go well

Thumbnail
gallery
20.1k Upvotes

My friend was turning 25 and a funny gift I wanted to get her the 25 Leo cake. well, my plan was to order a cake from a box store and placed the topper on the cake but the box store never completed my order. So I get to the store they don’t have my order and I had to make some last-minute decisions. My friend really wants strawberry so I got a whipped strawberry cake to put the top on. Fine, right? NO. The strawberry mix on top of the cake ate through the topper and created this eldritch horror of a cake that you see here. We were laughing so hard! Honestly, it’s kind of better than the original and makes for a hilarious story 😂j


r/cakefails • • Dec 11 '24 Polished Silver Turd Take My Silver Heart of Silver

Showcase My brother used to work at DQ and made this cake for someone. We still laugh at him 😂

Thumbnail
gallery
16.2k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • Jan 26 '25 Snek Wholesome Seal Helpful

Tried to make a charizard cake for my son's birthday

Thumbnail
gallery
10.5k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • Apr 13 '26 LOL Bravo Popcorn

picked up a cake for my mom's 45th without checking the box

Thumbnail
gallery
8.9k Upvotes

cake was supposed to say "Happy Birthday Mama". my dad mangled the fondant a bit to get the second image. she had a very good laugh imagining poor abe at his 13th birthday party


r/cakefails • • Dec 08 '24 Diamonds are Forever Take My Silver

the cake that got my coworker fired

Post image
8.4k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • May 10 '25

Some strange cookie cakes at Kroger for mothers day

Thumbnail
gallery
7.8k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • Oct 31 '25

Question The baker I’ve used for years gave me a purple leopard cake instead of the brown/gold one I ordered 😭

Thumbnail
gallery
6.3k Upvotes

I ordered this gorgeous brown and gold leopard-print heart cake for my younger sister’s 26th birthday, sent the inspo pic SIX weeks ago, agreed on everything, paid in full. The whole party theme was gold, neutral, and glam. I go to collect it yesterday and… it’s purple and red. Like full-on disco leopard purple. I was speechless. When I told the baker it wasn’t what I ordered, she literally said, “is it a special birthday or something?” YES, actually; it’s for my sister who has Down syndrome, and we planned this entire day around her favourite theme. We even booked a VIP lion feeding trip for her in Turkey 🦁🐅 everything matched perfectly… except the cake. I refused to take it because it didn’t match anything and honestly, this isn’t the first time she’s messed up. She’s ruined two of our previous cakes but we let it go because we wanted to keep supporting her business. This time, though, I couldn’t just accept it. It wasn’t what I paid for and it ruined the look of the entire setup. People keep saying “at least it looked nice,” but I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect the colours and design you ordered, especially after paying weeks in advance. Anyway, here’s what I ordered vs. what I got (attached pics) tell me I’m not crazy for refusing this.


r/cakefails • • Jul 10 '26 Bravo

Showcase Happy birthday, fiancé?

Post image
6.2k Upvotes

Fiancé and I live near a great local ice cream shop, and they also do ice cream cakes/pies. So, when ordering fiancé's cake online last week, I thought it was weird that they didn't have a space for what you want written on top. Usually, that's the FIRST question on the order form, but whatever, maybe they don't DO writing on the cakes, that's fine.

At the very bottom, they had a box that said, "Please let our team know any special things you may need from us (plates and utensils, extra nuts in the gooey layer, no onions, etc)." And I laughed out loud, because WHY would an ice cream place even HAVE onions, you know? Doubly funny because fiancé LOATHES onions, so I typed into that box "No onions?! Lol =D"

Didn't even notice the top of the cake at pickup this morning, because I wasn't expecting ANY message on it at all. Oh well, at least fiancé knew for sure there were no onions in his ice cream cake...or WERE there??? I told him what had happened, because it definitely looked suspiciously suspicious!


r/cakefails • • Jun 05 '25

Showcase My mom is going to a veterans event this weekend and custom ordered a cake with an American flag on it. This is what she got:

Post image
6.2k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • Dec 23 '24 Heart of Silver

Showcase About a decade ago, my middle school friends and I attempted the ‘mirror cake’ trend

Thumbnail
gallery
6.2k Upvotes

Yes, it’s bad. We were like 13 and baking did not come naturally. I remember us thinking it was really funny, but everyone we showed was not at all impressed. Who cares; we giggled for hours.

The ‘inspo’ pic I just looked up today, but I’m pretty sure that was the exact Pinterest cake we were trying to replicate. Lmao.


r/cakefails • • Nov 07 '23

What I asked for vs what I got

Thumbnail
gallery
6.1k Upvotes

So the first two pictures were what I wanted for my college graduation cake last year. I wanted the graduate wearing a cap and gown sitting on the mini tier, my school’s logo and colors on the middle tier, and music notes on the bottom tier above my name. Fondant all over since it was going to be an outdoor party in the heat.

I got in touch with a bakery in my area that does custom cakes. I have ordered from them before in the past. They are known for making really stunning custom cakes of any design. They said that they could make the cake for me with 40 servings. I paid a deposit and that was it.

Fast forward to the day of my graduation party. I was running a little bit behind as I had to get to the venue early to help set up. I rushed to the bakery to pick up my cake. When I arrived, I told them I was there to pick up my cake. The lady working at the front went to the back room and brought out my cake. The cake was packaged in a cardboard box that was tape shut on all four sides, so I could not see the cake at all. I thought it was strange, but I was in such a hurry that I just paid and left.

I get to my party and start helping my family set up. I grab a box cutter and start opening the box containing the cake. The last three pictures were what I saw. The graduate at the top looked poorly designed, the school logo completely slid off of the cake due to the heat and the cake being made of buttercream instead of fondant like I had asked, blue icing was melting everywhere by the time I cut it, the black ribbons around the base were sliding off, the “music notes” at the bottom look like Hebrew, and the banner with my name slid off of the cake as well. Just terrible looking overall and not worth the $500 I paid.

I contacted the owner of the bakery, and it turns out that she was not even aware of this cake. She is the one that normally designs the custom cakes. She was out of town this particular weekend, so I guess one of her staff members took it upon themselves to try and make the cake so that they would not lose the order. She agreed that this was not the quality of work that she would have produced had she made it herself and refunded me for the cake as well as offered me 25% off of my next purchase. I was happy with that, and now it is just a funny memory that I can look back on. All I know is….someone definitely got fired lol.


r/cakefails • • Jun 16 '26 Heartwarming

Meme The funniest cookie cake I’ve seen

Post image
6.1k Upvotes

Yes, I found it on the shelf like this.

Yes, I did buy it solely because this little weirdo was made to exist on it.


r/cakefails • • Jul 14 '26

My mom paid $168 for this!!

Thumbnail
gallery
6.1k Upvotes

It was a vegan cake and came several hours late


r/cakefails • • Feb 24 '24

My dads 50th birthday cake

Post image
6.1k Upvotes

My dad loves to golf so my mom asked for a themed cake for his birthday and asked if they could have it look like the golf cart crashed…


r/cakefails • • Dec 04 '23

I was told my cake looks like a pile of cow shit

Post image
5.8k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • Dec 15 '24

this cake vs what I wanted…..

Thumbnail
gallery
5.8k Upvotes

happy birthday to me I guess


r/cakefails • • Jul 01 '25

My dramatic teenager made a cake

Post image
5.6k Upvotes

It was pretty good, ngl. Her journey of being gluten free has been...rough.


r/cakefails • • Nov 26 '25

Whole Foods charged $40 for this low effort mess

Post image
5.3k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • Nov 12 '23

The cake my step mum tried to copy vs what she actually made

Thumbnail
gallery
5.1k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • Dec 24 '24 Heart of Silver

My grandma made this cake… bless her heart. She tried, and it will be delicious, will be appreciated regardless of its appearance 😭

Post image
5.0k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • May 12 '25

Baby cake I made for my nephew’s first bidet party

Thumbnail
gallery
4.7k Upvotes

No one ate it…..


r/cakefails • • Nov 14 '24

close enough

Post image
4.5k Upvotes

r/cakefails • • Dec 09 '24

Picked up this cake from Safeway for a colleague's retirement party

Post image
4.4k Upvotes

They just kept adding more and more of those plastic balloons...


r/cakefails • • Jun 29 '25

I ordered a Rainbow Layered cake… I got Watermelon Minecraft blocks instead.

Post image
4.4k Upvotes

So I ordered a rainbow layered cake for a special occasion — you know, the classic red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and purple layers. I was imagining that beautiful rainbow slice when you cut into it.

What did I get instead?

Pink. And green. That’s it. Two sad layers. Just… watermelon vibes, I guess?

I even double-checked the order beforehand and specifically said rainbow. Not “Barbie meets Shrek.” Not “half a watermelon.” Not “let’s pick two colors and call it a day.”

I’m not even mad, I’m just so confused. Like… how do you go from 6 colors to 2 and think, “Yep, nailed it”?

Anyway, at least it still tastes good. But my dreams of a rainbow slice photo? Crushed. 🌈💔 Sorry birthday girl 😭