Edit:I don’t mention it enough in the original post, this was made because I’m frustrated with the debate being made on the national stage. As you’ll see, I do see both arguments, but let me stress the fact that I don’t think this is Josh’s year for MVP and having the debate is just not worth it because it’s a losing venture.
Let me preface this by saying that I WANT Josh to be the MVP, but I am approaching this from two sides when I process it.
Why Anti-Josh Truthers are Hard to Argue
From a statistics standpoint, Josh Allen has been nearly completely outplayed. Burrow has one less win and has been absolutely slinging it, plus even if you want point out talent (or lack there of) Josh is at 13th and is beat by quarterbacks with far less talent than Burrow and slightly less than Josh. Then simultaneously to this, Purdy kinda takes away the case which really won Josh his award in 2024, the whole lack of talent argument. With James Cook bursting onto the scene, nobody in the National media is going to give Josh nearly as much credit as they did in 24. He’s the most valuable player on the team, that can’t be argued, but the same goes for any top 10 team. Which is why Purdy navigating all of the Niners’ injuries and the oldest WR core is going to draw attention. While it’s doesn’t negate the struggles Josh time in and timeout overcomes, it makes it so it is not a unique argument like I’d wager it was in 2024.
All of that is without mentioning the arguable inflation of Josh’s rushing touchdowns and the increase in interceptions.
Why Josh-Truthers are hard to argue
All of these are the valid arguments I’ve heard against Allen’s MVP case. On the other hand, Buffalo’s strength of schedule and final records are what any Allen debate are going to start and end with. If we’re the 1 seed (bonus points if it’s handedly) and Josh is still top 4 in total passing production, I could see him already attracting some votes. The next point I’d like to mention is that rushing stats ARE a QB stat; furthermore, the only reason Allen has so high of numbers is because he’s effective at running. Why pass or hand it off when the tush push is so effective. While I entertained the opposing argument, among the other candidates Josh is the most seminal to the success of his team. Looking at the other side of the ball, Buffalo easily could have started 0-6 based off of the way the defense performed (that said I’d wager that any mid level QB could’ve beat the ravens or jets to make our current record minus Josh probably 2-7). Every other candidate has far more effective defenses.
To conclude though. I don’t think this is Allen’s year. Stafford proved last year that throwing to an all time receiving core isn’t a knock as long as the production is out of worldly (which Burrow is on track to be). We’re only halfway through the season, but Allen would have so many counter arguments to overcome that I think honestly it’s in nobody in Bills mafia’s interest to expect that award. Which brings me a point which I’d like to end on, this season really hasn’t required the heroics of years past. Not really. We’ve lacked true blowouts, but we’ve won games off of attrition, run game, and taking plays when they’re available. WITH Allen at the helm, this is the most all around I think this offense has been, and is most easily a Super Bowl caliber offense. I think the only individual award Josh will win this season is Super Bowl MVP.