27
u/Immediate-Material36 Feb 23 '25
Machine Girl isn't really a band though. It's a music project by one guy and some Songs are made by two guys.
7
u/teardropita Keep Politics in Breakcore Feb 24 '25
It's generally considered a project made by two people though
3
u/Immediate-Material36 Feb 24 '25
I was semi-serious with my comment. I thought my comment sort of sounded like the "gatekeeping" explanations in the vid.
Yeah, when I think of Machine Girl I also think of both Matt and Sean, but there are quite a lot of songs which only Matt made.
At the end of the day, you can call them whatever you want. I don't mind calling them a band, duo, music project, group, whatever ♥️
20
7
u/DanDoormouser Feb 25 '25
HOLY FUCK
2
u/teardropita Keep Politics in Breakcore Feb 25 '25
HELLO DOORMOUSE
I listened to morning star yesterday
1
8
u/Junior-Yoghurt-2291 Feb 23 '25
So is goreshit considered breakcore?
20
u/teardropita Keep Politics in Breakcore Feb 23 '25
Depends a lot by the album, i would consider him a breakcore artist, but he made a lot of other stuff.
10
Feb 23 '25
There’s some of his work that can be labeled as breakcore and some that falls more into the jungle or dnb side of things
2
Feb 24 '25
I think he's more lolicore, depending on the album, if we talk about the older ones probably lolicore, newer ones I guess dnb or jungle
3
3
94
124
u/Xx_4LiC3_xX Feb 23 '25
16
2
54
52
14
10
32
u/arrotive Feb 23 '25
i dont like this one its good intentioned but its pretentious as hell, like with the ones youre parodying its not like peter has a stick up his ass hes just explaining how it got this way 😭😭😭
4
u/Basedcase Feb 23 '25
Get a fucking life.
17
11
u/Icefang_GD Feb 23 '25 edited Feb 24 '25
The video proves some points though. Breakcore does have a definition, and it has fair enough requirements even though SOME people decided to push their own standards.
I’m not saying sewerslvt is a bad producer, in fact I listen to them often. However they can’t be classified as breakcore since their songs lack many of the required traits.
You really need to chill out, man.
6
6
13
u/Icefang_GD Feb 23 '25
How many more times are we gonna have this conversation?
7
u/Saucy_Pauper Feb 24 '25
In many ways, this conversation has been raging on since the endless 'what is breakcore?' posts in the soulseek breakcore chatroom of the mid-2000s. I see it as part and parcel of the scene these days really lol.
1
1
3
u/Worldly_District5533 Feb 25 '25
holy shit some mfs in the comments don’t know how to have fun. It’s just a funny breakcore brainrot meme jeez calm down🙄
3
u/Nervous-Deal-8765 Feb 26 '25
That last line from Peter is so true. In metal people get so pissed about "ugh gatekeeping elitists, they just hate everything" when genres are clarified. No, Lorna Shore is not death metal. You can like what you want, and music is subjective, but genres aren't. Thank you Peter.
2
1
u/Proof-Plan-298 Feb 26 '25
Bands often move through genres and their micro genres which makes such discussions really tyring.
3
4
u/Koboooold Feb 23 '25
Is bomberman hero breakcore
4
u/monotekdm Feb 23 '25 edited Feb 23 '25
No it’s not, it just happens to have amen breaks but a shit ton of genres use breaks. It’s not unique to just breakcore.
2
u/uncool_king Feb 23 '25
All breakcore needs is it to use amen breaks and to be hardcore edm, the rest is just up to opinion
2
u/Lance3015 Feb 24 '25
hmm same could be said for hardcore breaks, digital hardcore, crossbreed, breakbeat hardcore
1
u/iSmokeMDMA Feb 24 '25
This is an unpopular opinion but discerning breakbeat hardcore and breakcore is just redundant nowadays
4
7
2
u/_sergeant_pepper Feb 26 '25
both sides sound like people that would be part of my nightmare blunt rotation ngl
2
Apr 07 '25
I'll keep calling it breakcore, not because it's an accurate label, but to piss off breakcore fans so they call me slurs online
0
u/Keefshovel740 Feb 24 '25
So breakcore has to have breaks but it has to break in a certain way. So if I make a song with the amen beat, pads and breaks it’s technically not breakcore if it’s not broken in a certain way? Wtf
2
u/teardropita Keep Politics in Breakcore Feb 24 '25
I really hope this is satire, but, realistically responding, yes.
Even though a song doesn't need the breaks to be chopped to be considered breakcore as long as the amens are noisy and the energy is punk, even though that style of breakcore is basically absent in modern releases.
5
2
u/Arriorx Feb 25 '25
nothing is more stupid than some sweaty elitist nerds arguing about what is what 🤮
2
2
u/zenith_placidity Feb 24 '25
I am repelled by conversations with music elitists where they're splitting hairs over genres. I love talking about music but that shit is annoying as fuck. I like Igorrr. I like Machine Girl. They're different. They have similarities. I like both. Who fucking cares
1
u/binhan123ad Feb 24 '25
I don't know what I search or done or say and I don't even heard anything bout breakcore but I guess this is the time for me breaking down.
1
1
1
1
u/Stargali Feb 27 '25
Is hakita"s "Heaven Pierce Her" Breakcore? It's the only thing I heard for real and cannot tell the diference with him and any other breacore media tbh
1
u/miu_owo Mar 05 '25 edited Mar 05 '25
the relief from this, like a burden being dropped from my chest. this is what memes were created for
1
u/Icefang_GD Mar 14 '25
Me, a fan of both artists, casually watching it all break down in the worst flame war in the history r/breakcore like it’s a movie:

1
1
-4
Feb 23 '25 edited Aug 13 '25
lip elderly aromatic chase ghost ink violet chief numerous teeny
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6
-3
u/uncool_king Feb 23 '25
It may be true that sewerslvt is not breakcore but like that's no reason to be an asshole about it, breakcore is for the masses, if they like sewerslvut than reccomend some similar jungle beats and and move on
The only thing that makes break core break core is things: it has to have Amen breaks and it has to be hardcore edm
3
u/teardropita Keep Politics in Breakcore Feb 24 '25
No one is being an asshole?
If we put breaks and hardcore edm together we may get hardcore breaks or breakbeat hardcore, which arent breakcore
-1
u/spaarkkyyuu Feb 24 '25
em ye ok breakcore must have amen breaks 💔💔💔
2
1
0
u/epicnop Feb 24 '25
this is a cringe argument, genre designations aren't changeable, sacred, or rational
I went down the rec list though, dj scud is the fucking tightest
0
u/demon_908 Jul 20 '25
"When I'm in a being obnoxious competition and my opponent is a music nerd".
You will never hear something as true as this.
-2
14
7
u/thirdMindflayer Feb 24 '25
Breakcore is when I want to fucking break my nose this is successfully breakcore
3
u/Few-Drummer7403 Mar 04 '25
"M-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-machine g-g-g-g-g-g-g-g-g-g-g-g-g-g-girl????" I say as my penis SPLITS IN TWO from a MONUMENTAL eruption of CUM
1
u/boopsl Feb 24 '25
Tell your girlfriend to shave the dreadlocks off her pussy… then you’ll know what breakcore is
3
1
0
Feb 23 '25
[deleted]
14
4
0
Feb 23 '25
[deleted]
0
Feb 23 '25
[deleted]
0
46

47
u/ARG_men Feb 24 '25
I’m like #1 machine girl glazer and I honestly have no clue how people can even call them break core. Even their earlier Wolf girl albums sounds neither like real break core, or the atmospheric DnB that people mistake as break ore