r/box5 • • 1h ago

Fanfic Have you ever done fanart, fanfiction, &/or fanfic OCs for other fandoms that were inspired by or based on POTO?

4 Upvotes

I have done quite a number of those! ^_^ Mainly with two fandoms:

My first fandom with POTO-inspired stuff is "The Great Mouse Detective". I have recurring fanfic characters based on Christine, Raoul, Carlotta, Madame Giry, & Meg Giry--& I may make the Phantom into one, too--plus I have a chapter of "Baker Street Tales" (one of many forthcoming 100-chapter story compendiums!) that parodies POTO & its plot. When I make some fanart of the POTO-inspired characters &/or the "Baker Street Tales" POTO chapter, I'll post them here for all of you to see. ^_^

My second POTO-crossed fandom is "Rock & Rule". Many years ago, during my early years as an R&R aficionado, I came up with a POTO-inspired parody called "The Sorcerer Of The Rock Hall"; I didn't get around to working on it for a long time, but, now, my progress on it is really heating up! Mok Swagger portrays the titular sorcerer who haunts the Radioactive City Music Hall in Nuke York City, while Angel fills in the role of Christine, Omar is Raoul, Cinderella & Dizzy are Carlotta & Piangi, Annie LeDay (my primary R&R fanfic character) is Meg Giry, & Aunt Edith is Madame Giry; meanwhile, other R&R characters portray all of the remaining POTO characters. The POTO songs are all rewritten to the tune of different 80s hits (e.g., "The Glory Of Love", "Father Figure", "Total Eclipse Of The Heart", "Take My Breath Away", & many more!). I have a draft of the first concept poster available for viewing...

...& I'll also upload the completed first poster, a second concept poster, & some fanart for TSOTRH later. :-)

Finally, I have a planned "Pagemaster"/POTO crossover fanfiction called "A Voice In The Gloom". The basic story is as follows: Twin siblings Emily & Emmitt pay a visit to the magic library, & are transported into the world of "The Phantom Of The Opera", but end up getting separated. Emmitt gets taken in by the De Chagny family, while Emily befriends Horror & the rising starlet Christine Daae. What happens when the two girls & their book companion get involved with the mysterious Phantom?

And that's everything POTO-based or POTO-inspired I've done for other fandoms so far. ^_^ What about all of you other Phans? :-)

P.S.: I couldn't decide whether to use Fanart or Fanfic as the flair, given that the post deals with both topics, so I went with the latter. (sighs in annoyance) If only we could choose multiple flairs for a post on Reddit...


r/box5 • • 23h ago

Art What book have I found exactly?

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

I’ve never heard of these illustrations or this artist but the work is drop dead gorgeous. Found at a local book store & taken home with me, of course.


r/box5 • • 1d ago

Discussion What scene do we think "Boules" was from?

12 Upvotes

I bit the bullet and paid $8 for the ALW "deluxe edition" of the 40th anniversary remix.

Three of the four "orchestral outtakes" are basically just karaoke tracks -- though as a musician, I'm amused by ALW's interjections on the AIAOY tape.

But does anyone have any idea where "Boules" was meant to be placed in the show? In order, these are the motifs I hear:

  • A brief orchestral bit, sounds like the ending to All I Ask of You

  • The melody for "We shall play his game, perform his work, but remember we hold the ace," repeated many times over. It sounds like "The Fairground" from the 2004 film at times.

  • The motif from "Box Five" (i.e. "Damn you, you little prying Pandora...")

  • The chords associated with reading the Phantom's notes ("Do not fear for Miss Daae, the Angel of Music has her under his wing...")

  • Frantic interchange of melodies from Notes I

  • A "dangerous"-sounding chord ending

My initial thought was that "Box Five" became "Boules," which ultimately became "Notes I" in the final cut. The instrumentation style and many of the motifs are similar.

Then again, the title "Boules" translates to "balls." Maybe this was originally a "Notes 1.5," where Raoul and the managers celebrate the Phantom's apparent disappearance and decide to host the masquerade ball. That would explain (1) the AIAOY-sounding intro, (2) the use of the "Raoul's horrible plan" motif, and (3) why the track ends forebodingly.

I also remember reading that Masquerade started off way too campy (I mean, just listen to the original demo), so "Boules" could also be an early attempt to write a more menacing underscore for the Masquerade sequence.

Anyway, I might well be the only person who bothered to pay for the extra tracks. Just curious if anyone had any thoughts.


r/box5 • • 1d ago

Discussion Does it bother anyone else that all the show merchandise has the full mask when the Phantom wears a half mask in the show?

27 Upvotes

I understand the mask was changed at the last minute for the original show, but I wonder why we don’t get half mask merchandise now?
I suppose the answer is that the full mask logo became iconic even if it’s not what Phantom wears in the show.


r/box5 • • 2d ago

Art I made this in class

Post image
145 Upvotes

This was my first time ever using fuse beads so I hope it came out okay.


r/box5 • • 2d ago

Art phantom drawing

Post image
53 Upvotes

i drew this as a sticker design for a con next week!


r/box5 • • 2d ago

Discussion Drew this in class today

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/box5 • • 2d ago

Discussion Rounded mug replacement 🫣

Post image
19 Upvotes

Hey everyone, hopefully someone can help me. I accidentally dropped my wifes mug which she absolutely loves, does anyone know in the Uk where i could source one from.

TIA -


r/box5 • • 2d ago

Theory Erik's original plan?

37 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm currently rereading Phantom, and I started wondering what Erik's plan was in the long run, since whatever it was, it got halted by Raoul's presence.

Raoul's appearance is the catalyst for everything that goes down in the book, basically, since he's the reason why Erik becomes so jealous and eventually proceeds to take Christine away. There's even that moment where Christine describes telling the voice about Raoul and it going silent, and later telling her that "if her heart belonged to someone on earth, the angel would have to leave" (i'm paraphrasing, as you can tell). That silence seems to me like a moment of realization for Erik.

What do you guys think his plan would have been if Raoul had never shown up? I do know that he expected to maybe form a connection with Christine (a more romantic one as opposed to the already intense spiritual/artistic one they had as singer/teacher) via repeated encounters ("as long as you thought me handsome, I know you would've come back").

If Christine's heart hadn't gotten the chance to fall for Raoul, where do you guys think the story would have gone?


r/box5 • • 3d ago

Discussion I finally saw the show last night in OKC!

Thumbnail
gallery
87 Upvotes

Firstly, I'm so blown away!!! I've been a phan for about 10 years now and it was my first time seeing the show live. I'm still feeling a bit shell shocked and don't know how I'm ever gonna recover LOL. To add to that, I brought my POTO vocal book to go to the stage door after the show and got some autographs + a picture with Isaiah Bailey 🩷

A few things that I absolutely loved and want to talk about!

-Carlotta!! Midori Marsh is absolutely phenomenal. Funny, haughty, and just pure prima donna lol. I'm a senior vocal major in college right now and she is SUCH an excellent soprano omg.

-The managers were absolutely hilarious! Honestly I've never really liked the Notes/ Primadonna sequence but seeing it live definitely changed that for me.

-Raoul was played so charming and sweet by Daniel Lopez and really convinced me as to why Christine would ultimately choose him!

-The ensemble is outstanding! I loved them especially during the Don Juan Rehearsal scene.

-Jordan Lee Gilbert's Wishing was a show stopper for me omg. I was teary eyed at the end!

Also I loved the acting choices she made in Point of No Return where she takes control of the situation. Final Lair was amazing with how she portrayed Christine!!

-Isaiah Bailey wowww. I was lucky enough to attend a free masterclass with him last week so seeing his technique in action was astounding. I loved all of the little nuances vocal wise that enhanced his portrayal. It was really hard to not sob at the end. He played a wonderfully pathetic Phantom 🤣

I'm so happy and grateful I got to see it!


r/box5 • • 3d ago

Other A Story

Post image
130 Upvotes

r/box5 • • 4d ago

Art Gorgeous Leroux novel edition I bought yesterday 😍

Thumbnail
gallery
77 Upvotes

Went inside Barnes & Noble for the first time in a while to find one POTO inspired novel (Phantom Heart by Kelly Creagh) plus order a trilogy from that same author (Nevermore), left successful on both fronts AND discovered while browsing this beautiful copy of Gaston Leroux's novel! (And on sale to boot, it was only $12!). Yes, Erik is wearing the wrong mask and Christine isn't blonde, but we'll let that go because this ARTWORK man! ✨It also weirdly enough matched the color scheme of my other POTO book...👀

I also got this pretty moon charm bookmark for that MOTN vibe. 😊


r/box5 • • 4d ago

Discussion phantom makeup change?

Thumbnail
gallery
96 Upvotes

watching a video of ramin karimloo in shanghai i was struck by how different his makeup was from the 25th anniversary show, mainly the lack of lip prosthetic and them being pinker, plus more blush. is this how they do the phantom's makeup now across the board or specific to the shanghai production? i haven't seen the show live in quite a while so was just wondering.


r/box5 • • 4d ago

Theory My medical & historical theory on Erik’s backstory (Book Canon): He wasn’t rotting—he had Gottron syndrome and severe birth trauma.

141 Upvotes

I’ve been doing a massive deep dive into Gaston Leroux’s original 1910 novel, and it drives me crazy when people claim Erik is literally "physically rotting" like a zombie. When you actually cross-reference the book's descriptions with 19th-century medical and social history, you can reverse-engineer a completely grounded, realistic backstory for him.

Here is my theory on how all the pieces of Erik’s life fit together:

  1. He wasn't rotting—he had Gottron syndrome (Acrogeria)

In the novel, Erik is called a "living corpse" because he has zero fat under his skin, deeply sunken eyes, and ultra-thin, yellowed, parchment-like skin stretched tight over his skull. That isn't decay—it matches Gottron syndrome (acrogeria), a super rare congenital disorder where a person is born with prematurely aged, paper-thin, hyper-fragile skin.

We also know from the book that Erik was recruited into traveling sideshows across Europe and Asia. Victorian sideshow recruiters specifically hunted for the rarest physical anomalies, and performers with severe fat loss and translucent skin were famously billed as "Living Skeletons."

2. What actually happened to his nose

If he wasn't rotting away, why does the book describe him as having two dark holes instead of a nose? My theory is that he was born with a nose, and it was torn off during a traumatic delivery.

Erik would have been born in rural France around the 1830s or 1840s. With Gottron syndrome, skin and cartilage are extraordinarily fragile—even normal pressure can cause severe shearing and tissue damage. If he got stuck in the birth canal during an obstructed labor, pressing against the pelvic bone or being pulled with heavy metal obstetric forceps could easily tear away his nasal cartilage.

On top of that, hand-cranked bone chainsaws (like the osteotome) were actively used by European surgeons in the 1830s to perform symphysiotomies—sawing through the mother's pubic cartilage to widen the pelvis during difficult births. Imagine a rushed, unanesthetized 1830s delivery with surgical saws and forceps inches away from a baby whose skin tears like wet tissue paper.

3. His mother’s trauma & why he builds hidden chambers

In the book, Erik mentions his mother couldn't bear to look at him without shuddering, and her first gift to him was a mask. While it's easy to paint her as a cruel villain, look at the psychological reality: she just survived a brutal, unanesthetized 1830s childbirth, likely suffered from severe untreated postpartum trauma, and faced the massive social stigma of having a visibly disabled child in the 1800s.

Back then, it was tragically common for families—especially in rural areas—to keep disabled children locked in hidden rooms, attics, or cellars to hide their "shame." That is why adult Erik is obsessed with building trapdoors, secret passages, and hidden chambers. Growing up hidden away meant secret rooms didn't feel like a prison to him; they were the only place in the world where he felt safe and free from people staring.

I know I might sound like a crazy scientist putting all of this together, but if you combine all those pieces, you see more than just a corpse given life—you see a man of the early 19th century.

What do you guys think? Are there any other medical or historical theories you have about book Erik?


r/box5 • • 4d ago

Discussion Piangi openly mocks the Phantom's opera so the Phantom makes his last words be "if I do not forget myself and laugh. Hahaha"

66 Upvotes

r/box5 • • 4d ago

Other 2004 - The Phantom of the Opera - Title Song Instrumental

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/box5 • • 5d ago

Discussion Most notable changes throughout the stage musical throughout the years?

30 Upvotes

I'm new to the fandom and fascinated how each actor plays and interprets the characters differently. I noticed also the stage play seems to change slightly over the years. Does anyone have a list of all the major (and if possible: minor) changes made to the stage directions and various presentations throughout the years? I'm curious about how the narrative has shaped itself overtime!

Or if even not a list, just details youve noticed change year after year would be nice!

Thank you!


r/box5 • • 5d ago

Discussion Stupid question - why does Christine grab phantoms hands and wrap them around him in point of no return song before abruptly sprinting?

27 Upvotes

I don't get what she was doing. Was she trying to distract him? I don't see exactly what the point of that was. Am I missing something obvious? Seems silly to get closer to and interlock fingers with someone if you want to do a full sprint. Is it as simple as "she wasn't thinking rationally?"


r/box5 • • 6d ago

Other The Digital Deluxe Edition

3 Upvotes

I downloaded from iTunes the digital deluxe edition of the new album mix and it said it included a ditital version of handwritten lyrics but I can’t find them anywhere does anyone know where I can find them or how I can get it?


r/box5 • • 6d ago

News LIMITED POSTER + THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA (THE ANDREW LLOYD WEBBER 2026 MIX) (2CD)

Thumbnail
uk.andrewlloydwebber.shop
11 Upvotes

r/box5 • • 6d ago

Other POTO 2026 Remix - Complete First Lair Sequence (Little Lotte - The Music of the Night (Instrumental)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

r/box5 • • 6d ago

Discussion Genuine question -- why have Erik remove his own mask in the restaged tour?

33 Upvotes

Like a lot of phans, my initial reaction to the restaged tour was "WTF"...but on further consideration, I do appreciate that it has a coherent vision. They weren't changing things just to change them -- I can at least see what they were going for.

  • Raoul walking in on Christine is because he's an entitled brat. Leroux!Raoul actually does worse -- he goes into Christine's dressing room when she isn't there without her permission.

  • The bed in MOTN suggests how the other characters perceive Christine's behavior (see: Notes/Prima Donna, where everyone assumes she's sleeping around).

  • Christine's, ah, rooftop moment comes from the original novel (though it happens in the novel's version of Final Lair).

  • Erik manhandling Christine comes from the novel, where, at the first unmasking, he rakes Christine's fingernails across his face until she draws blood.

You can tell they wanted a darker story, where neither Raoul nor the Phantom are particularly likable romantic heroes.

All of that said -- can anyone make heads or tails of the choice to have Christine not unmask Erik? It's a critical plot point that Christine wants to see what's behind the mask, and her curiosity is what causes the illusion to crumble (a la Beauty and the Beast, Pandora, Eve...)

The best I can figure is that they wanted to emphasize how innocent/helpless Christine is, by having Erik lose it over something that wasn't really her fault. But that doesn't jive with the other Leroux-esque changes, since Leroux!Christine has more agency than ALW!Christine, not less.

Any thoughts? Is there a way to make it make sense?


r/box5 • • 6d ago

Art He is not a spirit or a ghost. He is Erik.

Thumbnail
gallery
39 Upvotes

Phantom Pal #10 :)

I don't use AI btw 😀


r/box5 • • 7d ago

News [Ticket for Sale – Phantom of the Opera 40th Anniversary | 12 November | Shanghai Grand Theatre]

2 Upvotes

[Ticket for Sale – Phantom of the Opera 40th Anniversary | 12 November]

Hello everyone!

I’m looking to resell 1 SS ticket for The Phantom of the Opera 40th Anniversary performance at Shanghai Grand Theatre on 12 November, as unfortunately one of the members of my group is no longer able to attend.

Ticket details:
Date: 12 November 2026
Time: 19:30
Venue: Shanghai Grand Theatre, Shanghai, China
Seat: Row 10, Seat 34 (right-hand side of the auditorium)
Price: ¥1,280 (original purchase price – no markup)

I’m offering the ticket at exactly the price I paid, simply hoping another Phantom fan will be able to enjoy the performance in their place!

If you’re interested, please feel free to send me a private message. I’m happy to provide proof of purchase and arrange a safe, in-person exchange at a mutually agreed public location.

Thank you so much! Hope this ticket finds its way to another 'Phan'!