r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Weekly Recommendations and Discussion Thread

3 Upvotes

This is the weekly recommendations and discussion thread, for all of your questions or comments: what pour to buy at a bar, what bottle to try next, or what gift to get; and for some banter and discussions that don't fit as standalone posts.

While the "low-effort" rules are relaxed for this thread, please note that the rules for standalone posts haven't changed, and there is absolutely no buying, selling, or trading here or anywhere else on the sub.

This post will be refreshed every Sunday afternoon. Previous threads can be seen here.


r/bourbon • • 4h ago

REVIEW #39: Very Olde St. Nick "Straight Outta Bardstown" 11yr

Post image
60 Upvotes

Price: $270 OTD

Nose: pretty big, earthy, damp oak, toasted sugar, cinnamon, that oak funk all in it

Palate: sweetness galore backed by oak, vanilla, toffee, almost tastes like it's got a high rye mashbill, cinnamon and pepper, more of that damp or earthy feel on the palate that I get from the nose, an espresso bite in there, lastly a stout feel to this

Finish: long, sweetness disappates and barrel char is introduced, oak also along for the ride, those palate spices linger around and transitions back to a sweeter, but faint sweetness. Very intereating.

My thoughts: this is fire. It tastes like Christmas in a glass. I'm not one suggest pairings, but man would I love a warm berry pie with a scoop of ice cream with this. This is worth the coin.

Rating: 8.7/10

[Hey! You can find me on all socials at @plentyofbottles for video reviews and content]


r/bourbon • • 2h ago

Review # 044 — Parker’s Heritage American Kentucky Straight Whiskey Aged 11 Years (19th Edition)

Post image
27 Upvotes

Fun Fact: a portion of the proceeds from purchasing this bottle supports ALS research and patient care in honor of Heaven Hill Distillery’s Master Distiller Emeritus Parker Beam.

My expectation is that highly sought-after annual releases will pass me by unless I’m willing to pay a large markup. Last Black Friday, though, I was visiting my parents near the Virginia border for Thanksgiving and thought to myself “maybe they were nice and released some stuff to the ABC store for the holidays.” Sure enough, I walked into the store and immediately spotted this sitting on the shelf with everything else. If not for the large price tag, this would have gone unnoticed by the average (or even moderately-informed) consumer. A year later and its turn in the queue is upon us. This is my first experience with Parker’s, let’s see how we like it.

Price Paid: $179.99 before tax

Score: 8.5/10

The Background
Distillery: Heaven Hill

ABV: 61.25% (122.5 proof)

Age: 11 years

Mash Bill: unknown

Other: comprised of 15-year-old wheated bourbon, 11-year-old corn whiskey, and 12-year-old whiskey made from only rye and malted barley; barrel proof; not chill filtered.

The Experience
Nose: vanilla bean, caramel, pecan brittle. This has a syrupy sweet aroma.

Palate: cherry cordial, vanilla, brownie, plain raw pecan, charred oak. An earthy nuttiness meets a sweetness that makes this addictive.

Finish: cola, spice. The heat is strong in this one, but it does not pass without leaving behind an addictive savory quality.

The Summary
This started off odd but grew on me as I finished the glass. The odd mash bill is immediately apparent and makes it easy to write this off as being just a wacky experiment. The blenders were able to step in and create some magic, though, and the sweetness shows up in layers and gives this a dessert-like quality. I haven’t had anything else like it. That’s an experience worth $180 to me, but beware of secondary pricing.

T8KE Scoring System Used for Relevancy and Consistency:

0 | Unscored | New Make Spirit or Personal Selection.
1 | Disgusting | So bad I poured it out.
2 | Poor | I wouldn't consume by choice.
3 | Bad | Multiple flaws.
4 | Sub-par | Not bad, but many things I'd rather have.
5 | Good | Good; just fine.
6 | Very Good | One cut above.
7 | Great | Well above average.
8 | Excellent | Exceptional.
9 | Incredible | An all-time favorite.
10 | Perfect | Perfection.


r/bourbon • • 23h ago

Review #12: Fierce Whiskers Texas Straight Rye Whiskey Single Barrel (Barrel 282)

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Bourbz Review #253: Jack Daniel’s SiB Heritage Barrel

Thumbnail
gallery
119 Upvotes

Bourbz Review #253: Jack Daniel’s SiB Heritage Barrel

MASH BILL: 80% corn, 8% rye, 12% malted barley

AGE: 8 yr 9 mo

PROOF: 100

COST: $60 for 750mL bottle (Costco, South Carolina)

In 2018 and 2019, Jack Daniel’s had a special release that featured a distinct barrel toasting technique to create a richer character. In August of 2025, that special barrel toasting process became part of a new year-round offering in their single barrel collection.

Jack Daniel’s Heritage Barrel features whiskey from the classic JD mash bill that is filtered through sugar maple charcoal (Lincoln County Process) and is then barreled into unique barrels prepared using a high-toast, low-char process that was inspired by barrel-making traditions used in the early days of Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey. The whiskey is then aged for a minimum of 7 years and finally bottled at 100 proof.

While “toasted barrel” expressions have seemed to increase in popularity in recent years, this Heritage Barrel release is both Jack Daniel’s attempt to capitalize on that market momentum as well as make a statement that this is something they were doing “before it was popular.” In general, almost all expressions from the Jack Daniel’s single barrel collection tend to impress me, but as with all single barrels, milage may vary. I feel like this particular release has received a lot of positive attention since it dropped, with a few poor reviews that I chalk up to SiB variance. My friend picked up this bottle from Costco and we agreed to split it. After he split the bottle and tried it, he texted me and said he was thinking about keeping my half after all… I assume this is going to be a win.

This bottle is from barrel #26-03585, barreled on July 12, 2017 and bottled on April 4, 2026. Reviewed neat in a Glencairn.

APPEARANCE: A dark, caramelized oak color (1.6), a mild oiliness.

NOSE: Sugary sweetness with a touch of woody spice. Big brown sugar notes right away with a hint of maple syrup. A softer sweetness of toasted marshmallow starts to show up along with rich vanilla. Dipping my nose a bit deeper into the glen I some nice gingerbread spice, spicy oak, and graham cracker.

PALATE: Nice viscosity on the palate that is very coating. The nose transfers to the palate extremely well. I would say the notes on the nose were more simple while they’ve evolved to be more complex on the palate. The brown sugar remains consistent while the toasted marshmallow, graham cracker, and spicy oak meld into a nice sugary wood spice. The vanilla has more of a toastiness to it on that palate. There’s a mild tannic profile that starts to show up as I hold it on the palate that becomes slightly drying.

FINISH: Medium length finish. The brown sugar continues its consistent dominant presence. Graham cracker, tannic, charred oak, and a touch of cinnamon. There is a light spearmint note that creeps in. As time marches on, the spice notes start to drop off and I’m left with brown sugar, marshmallow, and vanilla. Santa dropped off some craft vanilla flavored marshmallows for Christmas a few years ago and this reminds me of those with a dusting of brown sugar caramelized on top.

RATING: 8.1/10

OVERALL: Easily one of the top value whiskies I’ve purchased this year! The use of the toasted barrel really shows up in this pour with tons of vanilla and wood sugars. The light char of the barrels is evident as well. I’ve seen the use of toasted barrels be counteracted by putting too heavy of a char on the barrels and getting too much bitter influence than the sweet wood sugars, but this is perfect. There’s a light char note and some tannic oak, but it still lets the thick red layer of the toasted barrels steal the spotlight with bold notes of brown sugar, marshmallow, and vanilla. While it’s delicious and very well executed, the only thing holding it back from a higher score is simply the lack further complexity. In particular, I personally wish the nose was a bit more robust and a few other notes sprinkled in along the way. But that’s just me being nit-picky.

 

1 | Disgusting | see my 1/10 ratings

2 | Poor | see my 2/10 ratings

3 | Bad | see my 3/10 ratings

4 | Sub-par | see my 4/10 ratings

5 | Good | see my 5/10 ratings

6 | Very Good | see my 6/10 ratings

7 | Great | see my 7/10 ratings

8 | Excellent | see my 8/10 ratings

9 | Incredible | see my 9/10 ratings

10 | Perfect | see my 10/10 ratings

 

If you enjoyed this review, check out all my reviews at Woodgrain & Whiskey.


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Just the Sip: Heaven Hill Unity Review

Post image
26 Upvotes

Verdicts Explained

  • Special Occasions: Rare, special pours that go well and above. Something you pour to celebrate.

  • Treat Yourself: Obligatory weekend pour. Worth having on hand at all times if possible.

  • Daily Drinker: Affordable, available and tasty. Could have every day and be perfectly content.

  • Penseur Pour: Puzzling pours that won’t be to everyone’s liking.

  • Trophy Bottle: Something to show off more than anything. Likely allocated and overpriced.

  • Cocktail Request: Shines best in a cocktail, as opposed to neat or on the rocks.

  • Good If Affordable: Only worth buying if the price comfortably fits within the budget.

  • Serve to Guests: Something accessible that you don’t mind sharing or parting ways with. Likely belongs in a decanter.

  • Couch Pour: Something enjoyable enough, but ideal for drinking while doing another activity (movies, TV, games, etc.).

  • Find a Mixer: Grab the Coke or Sprite and relax.

  • Drain Pour: No. You deserve better.

Link to blog post: https://thewhiskeyramble.com/2026/11/01/makers-mark-cask-strength-26-01-scoresheet-review/

More scoresheets available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpiritScoresheets/

A common experience in life is the sense of “they don’t make it like they used to,” a sentiment that’s far from exclusive to whiskey. There’s a layer of truth to it, but that truth is also more nuanced than I think many people realize. From what I’ve gathered, much of what this comes down to is a combination of lower barrel entry proof, older stocks, and older trees. Other than that first aspect, the actual process of creating whiskey hasn’t changed all that much, but the market certainly has. And with popularity comes a faster replacement cycle, meaning older whiskey made from older trees simply isn’t as feasible (if at all) compared to the days when most people would turn their noses up at bourbons priced anywhere near three figures.

So, what would happen if the two eras converged?

This is the hypothetical that Heaven Hill Unity seems built to answer. Released as a way to commemorate the opening of the new Heaven Hill Springs Distillery in Bardstown, Unity features a curious bourbon blend of 27 barrels, one of which was apparently the last remaining barrel from the Old Heaven Hill Springs Distillery. This is the same distillery that fell during the famous fire of 1996, an event that saw Heaven Hill move production to Louisville at the current Bernheim Distillery. 2025 saw a new Heaven Hill Springs distillery open up, ostensibly as a return-to-roots transition (pardon the pun). Production is meant to scale up so that it can match (or exceed) that of the Bernheim Distillery, which will almost certainly have people itching to compare future stocks after they come of age.

As for Heaven Hill Unity, 26 of the total 27 barrels were aged 6 to 14 years, with that final barrel from the Old Heaven Hill Springs distillery being an impressive 34 years old. Was it held that long because the whiskey was that good, or because Heaven Hill felt it’d work best in a blend? We’ll never know, but I have my suspicions. Let’s see if the product we did get is any good. Heaven Hill Unity was limited to around 4,000 bottles and carried an MSRP of $225.

Nose: Brown Sugar, Custard, Almond Butter, Dried Apple

Standard, Balanced, Creamy

Palate: Brown Sugar, Pepper, Nutmeg, Tobacco

Soft, Creamy, Tannic

Finish: Tobacco, Custard, Pepper, Burnt Orange

Mild, Warm, Tingly

There’s plenty to enjoy in Heaven Hill Unity. Everything feels nicely balanced and integrated, giving us a pour that epitomizes many of the distillery’s hallmarks, particularly from the standard bourbon mash bill. The sweet nuttiness is well developed, complemented by robust tobacco and oak notes. Altogether, it’s a rounded and accessible drinking experience that feels catered to bourbon fans who want something that’s a noticeable step above the distillery’s shelfers, albeit without hitting like a potent cask strength product, such as Elijah Craig Barrel Proof or Parker’s Heritage.

And yet, it’s difficult to see this bourbon as much more than a competently made limited release that struggles to justify its price or positioning. The novelty of including a barrel of 34-year pre-fire bourbon in a blend that, just based on specs, would otherwise read like a future Elijah Craig Barrel Proof, feels like just that: a novelty. Everything about Heaven Hill Unity screams competent; almost nothing about it screams impressive.


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Do you like Wild Turkey 101 or Rare Breed tastes better and why ?

22 Upvotes

I’ve been expanding my bourbon collection and trying to better understand my palate. Recently, I picked up a bottle of Wild Turkey 101 after hearing so many people praise it as one of the best everyday bourbons.
Unfortunately, something about it just tastes off to me.
From the initial smell all the way through the finish, I get a strange medicinal, almost chemical or artificial taste. Somewhere between rubbing alcohol, antiseptic, and plastic. I even tried making an Old Fashioned with it, thinking the bitters and other ingredients might balance it out. Nope. That same flavor was still there.
Here’s where it gets interesting.
I poured myself some Wild Turkey Rare Breed afterward, and that unpleasant flavor completely disappeared. Rare Breed is significantly higher proof, yet I find it much more enjoyable. The flavors seem richer, better balanced, and more natural to my palate.
I also really enjoy Buffalo Trace, so I’m beginning to realize that proof isn’t necessarily what determines whether I enjoy a bourbon.
I’m not saying 101 is bad whiskey. Obviously, plenty of people love it. I’m just curious why two bourbons from the same distillery, with the same mash bill, can taste so dramatically different to me.
Has anyone else experienced this with Wild Turkey 101? Is there a particular flavor characteristic I’m picking up on, or could I have gotten an unusual bottle?
I’m interested in hearing what others notice when comparing the two. I’m learning that developing a palate isn’t just about discovering what you like, but understanding why you don’t like something.


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Review: Single Barrel Saturday: Larrikin Single Barrel 9 Year, Saint Goose store pick (barrel E14)

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

122 proof | 9 years | high rye (75/21/4) | $109 | Saint Goose, Franklin TN

**Nose:** Some oak and some light fruit. Baking spices, almost a yeast smell like a good southern roll. Hint of fig. Ethanol isn't overpowering.

**Palate:** No dark fruit for me. More of a green apple, slightly sweet, fading to a little clove and baking spices. Medium complexity and a good mouthfeel. There is complexity there, it's all just subtle and goes by quickly.

**Finish:** Oaky. A little short and not overly sweet.

All in all this is a solid bourbon, easy to drink. It does everything well but nothing special. It would make a great everyday drinker if you wanted to sip on something and not think about it. It just doesn't do enough interesting things to justify the price point. Better everyday drinkers at half the price.

**Score: 6.5/10, Next Exit.** I wouldn't buy this one again, but I'm glad I tried it.

This is a veteran owned distillery, and although my personal palate doesn't like finished bourbons, I hear good things about their finished products. This bottle came up a little short for me, but it had enough promise for me to give them another shot.


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

REVIEW #24: Old Commonwealth Red Top Rye 7yr

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Review #79 - Russell's Reserve Single Barrel Rye Whiskey

Thumbnail
gallery
92 Upvotes

Intro:  Russell’s Reserve is well known and loved for its bourbons and rightfully so. That said, I rarely see anything about their rye whiskeys and currently there are two in the lineup; a 6-year batched product, and the bottle we’re looking at today, their single barrel. Let’s get into it!

Tale of the Tape
Bottle: Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
Proof: 104 / Age: NAS but people have speculated anywhere from 6 to 8 years old
Mashbill: Corn: 37% / Rye: 51% / Malted Barley: 12%
Bottle Price: $70 / Price per 1oz pour: $2.76

Impressions
Nose: Oak / Mint / Apple / Citrus / Tea / Pepper / Honey
Palate: Citrus / Caramel / Licorice / Cinnamon
Mouthfeel: Medium
Finish: Medium Cinnamon / Caramel / Honey / Vanilla
Rating: 5/10 - t8ke scale (modified to include half-points)

Tasting Notes: On the nose there’s mint that fades into an apple with a citrus tea note. Theres also a peppery spice along with some honey and vanilla sweetness. Nose it a little more and I get a hit of maltiness strong enough that reminds me of a single malt whiskey. On the palate the citrus is more oil than fruit, and that maltiness hits for a moment before shifting to a licorice with some caramel and cinnamon. The cinnamon carries into a familiar honey vanilla finish which is very welcome after everything that came before it.

Final Thoughts: There’s a lot going on here with all of the flavors and I just can’t come to grips with the licorice and maltiness that pops in with the other flavors. I’m a rye fan, but sometimes certain bottles just don’t line up with my palate, and this may just be this particular single barrel. Overall, I can see people that would like this bottle if they wanted to get away from the 95/5 ryes out there and I’ve heard that older bottles of this, leaned more on the sweeter end.

Swing by IG and say hey

10 | Perfection
9-9.5 | Incredible, An All-Time Favorite
8-8.5 | Excellent, Really Quite Exceptional
7-7.5 | Great, Well Above Average
6-6.5 | Very Good, A Cut Above
5-5.5 | Good, Just Fine
4 | Sub-Par, Not Bad, But Better Exists
3 | Bad, Multiple Flaws
2 | Poor, I Wouldn’t Consume by Choice
1 | Disgusting, So Bad I Poured it Out


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Review #24: Rare Character Curated Batch, Shelby’s Friends Batch 1

Post image
35 Upvotes

Summary

Rare Character’s Curated Batch offerings reflect the brand’s tendency to be defined by what it does and not what it says. The curated batch bottles vary in disclosure, some stating they are a blend while others lack that information. Evidently, they may be single barrels.

The idea is that each label is typically custom for a “partner”. Examples of partners are organizations, musicians, or bands. This particular bottle is for the Friends of Shelby Nonprofit, a non-profit foundation maintaining the Shelby Park and Bottoms in East Nashville. $10 of proceeds for each bottle were pledged to go toward the park.

Recently, a batch 2 was released for the decommissioned Cornelia Airpark attached to Shelby Park. Both batches were distributed among 3-4 liquor stores in the area.

I’ll treat this review as an idea of what a Curated Batch can offer, though of course they can be quite different from each other.

Stats

Age: NAS

Proof: 113.6

Mashbill: Unknown

Value

MSRP: $70

Secondary: N/A

Notes

Nose: Peanut brittle, bright red berries, allspice, light butterscotch, caramel

Palate: Red fruit, butterscotch, dark chocolate, allspice, cinnamon, leather, tobacco, oak tannins

Finish: Medium-long, somewhat drying, oak and rye spice

Final Impressions

This is a good bourbon. A majority of its depth is where the front palate meets the middle. Red fruits transform into a cinnamony allspice, which merges into leather and tobacco carrying into an oaky-fruity finish. This drinks like Barton, perhaps blended with Knob Creek but I’m mostly getting Barton from this. It’s not complex, but layered enough that you could enjoy this over conversation or by yourself.

I’m happy with the value here. Rare Character’s Limited Releases have been characterized as hit-or-miss at $99, but this is a hit for me at $70. I haven’t had a lot of base Barton offerings because it’s not my first choice, so not much to compare to here, but I would wager this is somewhere between 8-9 years old. Factor that in with $10 of proceeds used to maintain recreational space for a community, and I’m sold.

Comparable pours would be Rare Breed, JDSBBPR, and Belle Meade Cask Strength.

7.5 | Great | Well above average


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

REVIEW #38: Peerless (variety from my collection)

Thumbnail
gallery
93 Upvotes

This is my Peerless collection minus my 10yr Henry Kraver I sold last week because I didn't really care for it. Haven't touched these bottles in a while so I decided to go through them real quick.

Peerless Double Oak B.19 (108.4 proof)

- nose: is good, oak very present, brown sugars

- palate: molasses, oak, some spices

- finish: medium, flavors stick around, oak tannin

- overall: better than I remember

Rating: 8.0/10

Peerless Toasted Bourbon B.09 (111.8 proof)

- nose: soft, a little flat, oak, sugar

- palate: a medicinal cane sugar sweetness, a little oak

finish: a bit short, vanilla notes proof a little spicy, underwhelming

- overall: its just okay

Rating: 6.0/10

Peerless Cognac Barrel Bourbon B.01 (112.1 proof)

- nose: fruit, carmelize sugars, a bit bright

- palate: fruit, sugars, cognac bite, medicinal

- finish: medium, flavors from palate hold

- overall: better than I remember

Rating: 7.2/10

Peerless Toasted Rye B.01 (109.4 proof)

- nose: sweet rye, oak, great nose

- palate: sweet rye, a little viscous, cinnamon, spice

- finish: long, enjoyable, oak forward

- overall: this is good shit

Rating: 7.8/10

Peerless High Rye Bourbon (110.4 proof)

- nose: oak funk, dark sugar, has a darkness to the rye. Very nice.

- palate: rye really punching through, a sweet medicinal flavor, cherry, oak

- finish: no flavor drop off. Proof sitting well, a charred sweet rye rounding off the finish

- overall: yeah this is very good

Rating: 8.3/10

Peerless Small Batch Rye (111.6 proof)

- nose: rye, toasted sugars, spices, oak

- palate: sugar mixing well with a more minty proof, stone fruity, spices, kind of candy necklace sweetness on it

- finish: the rye really makes this last

- overall: this is genuinely good for the price

Rating: 8.0/10

Anyhow, these are just my opinions. Do whatever works for you.

[Find me on all social media accounts @plentyofbottles for video reviews and content ✌🏼]


r/bourbon • • 1d ago

Old Carter Very Small Batch Bourbon TN-4 Review

Post image
36 Upvotes

r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Review 75: Old Fitzgerald Decanter Series 10 Year Old Spring 2026

Post image
73 Upvotes

Age: 10 Years
Proof: 100
Color: Orangish Amber

Nose: Orange, caramel, and vanilla lead things off, followed by cinnamon roll and pound cake. There’s a really inviting bakery character here, with plenty of brown sugary goodness tying everything together. Chocolate-covered raisin adds a little depth alongside the brighter orange note. This is the kind of nose that makes you want to take your time before getting to the first sip.

Taste: Caramel and sugar hit up front, giving this a sweet opening before a nice wave of cinnamon and baking spice builds through the mid-palate. The spice gives it some welcome contrast without taking over. Toward the back, a pastry note comes through with chocolate, carrying that bakery character from the nose into the sip. On the second sip, peach starts to emerge alongside a little pipe tobacco. That combination adds another layer beyond the sweets and makes the palate more interesting as I work through the glass.

Feel: Very good overall. It leaves nice legs on the Glen, and the mouthfeel is oily, smooth, and creamy. There’s enough body to support those richer dessert notes, although it’s still a shade or two thinner than my personal preference. A little more weight would take this from a very good texture to exactly what I’m looking for.

Finish: A little pepper leads into stone fruit and tobacco before cherry and chocolate come through. I really enjoy that sequence, especially the cherry-and-chocolate combination toward the end. My main complaint is that the finish does most of its best work within the first 30–45 seconds. It lingers beyond that, but the more interesting flavors have already started to fade. I’d like those to hang around a little longer.

Overall: 8.25/10.
Really solid stuff. The caramel, brown sugar, and pastry notes give this plenty of dessert character, while the fruit, baking spice, and tobacco keep it from becoming too one-dimensional. I especially like how the fruit shifts throughout the pour—from orange on the nose to peach on the palate, then stone fruit and cherry on the finish.
The mouthfeel gets close to what I want, and the finish has a lot going for it, even if I wish it carried its best flavors a little longer. Those are the two things holding this back from a higher score, but neither takes much away from how enjoyable it is.
Honestly, I enjoyed this one more than Weller 12 and Pappy Lot B. For my palate, there’s a lot to like here, and it earns a strong 8.25.


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Review: Barrel King Wizard’s Call Blend of Straight Rye & Bourbon, Batch CW1

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

Barrel King Wizard’s Call Blend of Straight Rye & Bourbon, Batch CW1

Release date: November 13, 2026

Blended by Jacob Kiper of Coming Whiskey

Distilled by Jacob Call in Owensboro, Kentucky at O.Z. Tyler (Green River)

Jacob Call is the Wizard of O.Z. Tyler

The blend:
75%: 6+ year OZT rye: 95% rye, 5% malted barley

25%: 9+ year OZT bourbon: 70% corn, 21%, 9% malted barley

Proof: 116 (NCF)

MSRP: $150

A few months, Barrel King approached me about doing my own custom blend. Barrel King works with barrels sourced from multiple distilleries, but I know they own a lot of some of the oldest barrels of O.Z. Tyler. As a resident of Owensboro, I developed a strong relationship with the distillery from the moment it opened in 2016. I agreed to do a blend, but told Barrel King that I only wanted to work with whiskey distilled by Jacob Call in Owensboro… asking to work with bourbon and rye from OZT.

I worked with numerous barrels of 8 & 9 year bourbon and 6 year rye. I worked through a lot of combinations for blends…. and for me, this was the undisputed winner. Bourye blends are not particularly common, so I’m happy to have landed on a unique rye-heavy blend distilled in city.

As soon as I tasted my final blend, I couldn’t wait to tell Jacob Call & Caryn Wells… along with the rest of the staff at Western Kentucky Distilling & Green River.

Nose: Vanilla yogurt. Baked green apple. Sourdough bread. Cashews.

The fruity rye shows up, but the 9 year bourbon component adds the necessary oak to balance.

Palate: Grapefruit zest. Toffee. Candied ginger. Candied pineapple. Dense/thick mouthfeel.

Grapefruit zest is clear, but not overly bright. The candied pineapple and candied ginger work extremely well together.

Finish: Allspice. Mint. Dried apricot. Extremely long and spicy.

The spice shows up for the first time on the finish, but never feels unbalanced. The mint is very subdued. Dried apricot isn’t overly sweet.

I’m awfully proud of this blend. I love a good bourbon, but I tend to prefer a good rye… and this leans more into the fruit that comes w/ Owensboro rye… hitting my sweet spot. The 9 year bourbon component adds enough oak to limit the fruit from being too sweet.

Disclaimer: I blended this myself. My thoughts & opinions are genuine, but this is a blend that I created. Barrel King provided no guidance regarding my blending preferences.

Rating: 8 | Excellent | Really quite exceptional


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Review: Woodford DDO

Post image
124 Upvotes

I’ve tried this one a couple of times and was excited to try it but underwhelmed. I’d intended to buy a bottle but the $199 price tag seemed too high based on my couple of tastes.

Fast forward, I was gifted a bottle last month and decided to pop it tonight when we got home from dinner. So caveat - I’ve had a couple of drinks and dinner and I already feel like the bottle is a let-down. But I am going to try to be objective.

ABV: 45.2%

Age: NAS (generally understood to be 5-7 years)

Price paid: $0.00

Nose: The first thing that hits me is “classic brown Forman smell” which idk how to describe. Then a bit of vanilla and coffee. Some definite sweetness. It reminds me of what you might get if you mixed a bit of Jack Daniels 10 with a Starbucks dessert coffee.

Palate: chocolate up front. Little bits of caramel. Slight hints of apple and other fruits. On second sip the cherry is more front and center.

Finish: The cherry is more pronounced here. It’s a warm/medium finish that is stronger than you’d expect at the low ABV. It fades more quickly than you’d expect want it to but it’s pleasant. Maybe a bit of clove as it fades. The chocolate is there on the background too.

7.0/10

This is better than I remember it and so very different from the regular Woodford double oak.

It really isn’t bad at all. In fact it’s really good. At $89.99 I’d even say phenomenal. I just don’t see the value when I compare it to other $199 bottles.


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Review: Elijah Craig 15 Year Single Barrel (Barrel #102) vs. Elijah Craig Barrel Select "Hand Grenade" (125 Proof)

Thumbnail
gallery
73 Upvotes

Put two very different expressions of Elijah Craig head-to-head tonight. If you love Heaven Hill at its best, both of these are absolute bangers—just in completely different ways.
Pour 1: Elijah Craig Barrel Select "Hand Grenade" (200 mL Distillery Exclusive)
Proof: 125 proof (62.5% ABV)
Age: NAS (typically ~8+ years)
Nose: Classic Heaven Hill peanut brittle and roasted nuts upfront, backed by toasted vanilla, caramel, charred oak, and a clear punch of high-proof ethanol.
Palate: Punchy, bold, rich, and spicy with a thick, syrupy mouthfeel. It opens with a flash of caramel and vanilla sweetness right on the tip of the tongue before shifting into earthy cherry tobacco, dark chocolate, leather, smoky barrel char, and cracked black pepper.
Finish: Long, warm, and spicy—classic oak, lingering cherry, and a proper Kentucky hug that settles deep in the throat.
Score: 8.0 / 10
Pour 2: Elijah Craig 15 Year Single Barrel (Barrel #102)
Proof: 108 proof (54% ABV)
Age: 15 Years (Bottled 1-22-26)
Nose: Warm baking spice—cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg—layered over dark fruit, figs, burnt sugar, vanilla, and well-aged, seasoned oak.
Palate: Rich dark fruit and caramelized sugar sweetness with an oily, balanced 108-proof texture. What really sets it apart is the distinct three-stage progression across the palate: sweet caramelized oak and dark cherry upfront, roasted nuts and sweet tobacco through the mid-palate, and mature, non-bitter oak spice on the back of the tongue.
Finish: Long, cohesive, and indulgent—fading from crème brûlée sweetness into lingering ginger, clove, rye spice, and soft tobacco.
Score: 8.9 / 10
The Verdict
Both are really solid pours, and if you enjoy the best of what Elijah Craig puts out, you can't go wrong with either.
The Hand Grenade comes with the usual single-barrel caveat—your mileage may vary—but this bottle is a winner. If you find yourself at the Heaven Hill gift shop, don't hesitate to grab one.
The 15 Year Single Barrel is on another level, though. That 108 proof hits the sweet spot, giving it way more life, depth, and balance than the 90-proof Elijah Craig 18 Year Single Barrel without turning overly tannic. It's easily one of my favorite single barrels of the year, and with all the Bourbon of the Year buzz around it right now, it completely lives up to the hype—a lock for my Top 5 end-of-year flight


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Review: 1970s Austin Nichols Wild Turkey 101 8 year Decanter #7 vs Wild Turkey 101 70th Anniversary

Thumbnail
gallery
54 Upvotes

I went to an incredible estate sale today that consisted almost entirely of a 500+ decanter collection. I went in searching explicitly for Wild Turkey and Stitzel Weller sealed decanters, and I'm pretty sure these were the only two in the entire sale that even had any liquid in them much less were still sealed. I found a 1970s Wild Turkey 101 8 year and a 1969 Cabin Still 6 year Hillbilly decanter. Given the year, I'm very excited to eventually try my first whiskey distilled under the control of Pappy Van Winkle himself.

But in the meantime I am a huge Wild Turkey fan and have been on the hunt for a real dusty Turkey bottle since the beginnings of my bourbon fandom during the covid pandemic.

I got them home today and have absolutely no discipline, and the Wild Turkey is already open, its perfectly intact cork yeilding 605 mL of dark cherry red brown, fragrant liquid. Here is a very unfair head-to-head between my modern favorite Wild Turkey bottle, 101 70th anniversary and this 1970s Wild Turkey 101 8 year.

1970s 101 8 year

Nose: rich dried fruit, raisins or prunes, almost like balsamic vinegar up front, malty bread and cinnamon in the backbone, faint hints of cake icing

Palate: butterscotch immediately, dusty old oak and red raspberry, ripe peach, caramel and vanilla in waves- wild turkey funk to me tastes like the smell of a nice old book read while sitting in a leather recliner. Just gorgeous.

Finish: burnt sugar, banana, and cinnamon, just right.

T@ke score: 9.5

This is what I want in a whiskey. Bonkers, gorgeous, elegant but punchy.

101 70th anniversary

Nose: Cherry up front, nuttiness like pecan, maybe a hint of vanilla icing

Palate: almost an orange or citrus, vanilla note up front, pleasant but milder oak, cinnamon and red fruit on the back palate, terrific balance

Finish: nearly identical to the 1970 but a bit milder. To me the finish is where you can really see that the mash bills are the same

T@ke 8.0/10.0

This really is quite an unfair comparison as evaporation has could definitely altered the experience of the 1970 whiskey. You can tell they are related, but they are distant, distant cousins. After 50 years of slow evaporation, everything has undeniably concentrated and in a good way. I am truly grateful to have been able to experience this and will cherish the rest of what I have saved. That being said Wild Turkey is still bringing incredible whiskey to the market and they're far away my favorite distiller.


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Rittenhouse "Mission Exclusive" Single Barrel Bottled-in-Bond Rye – Mission Liquor – Review

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Quick stats

  • Barrel #: 8350035

  • Selected by: Mission Liquor, Greater Los Angeles area

  • Proof: 100 (50% ABV), bottled-in-bond

  • Age: about 7 years (barreled 3/21/2019, bottled spring 2026)

  • Rickhouse: L8, Floor 4

  • Price paid: $34.99 before tax

  • How I drank it: Neat in a Glencairn, rested 20 minutes

About me

My second review. I lean toward rye, but I'm still learning to taste critically, so treat this as one data point in my journey. I haven't had standard Rittenhouse neat. My only reference is an Old Fashioned at a Manhattan hotel bar, where it gave rye spice and citrus that balanced the sweetness nicely.

Why I bought it

Seven-year-old Rittenhouse for about $5 over a standard bottle was hard to pass up. For context, Pikesville, Heaven Hill's more premium rye, is 6 years and 110 proof. This barrel is about a year older and 10 proof points lower. Mission says it picked this barrel for "more vanilla and less rye spice," and that's what I got.

Nose

Vanilla extract, vanilla frosting, creamsicle, confectioner's sugar, cinnamon, pepper.

Palate

Vanilla, caramel, chocolate nougat (think 3 Musketeers), and more creamsicle.

Finish

The sweetness gives way to a short, sharp burst of freshly cracked black pepper, then fades into soft, tea-like oak tannins. Without that pepper you'd forget it's rye.

Value

$34.99 before tax, about $5 over a standard bottled-in-bond bottle. In a September 2026 listing, K&L's buyer David Othenin-Girard described Heaven Hill's Rittenhouse barrel program as recently retired, so picks like this may get scarce. I'm planning to grab a backup.

Score

7/10 (good, would rebuy)

Verdict

A vanilla bomb, and I love that. It's smooth enough that I could drink it all night, and the pepper at the end is the only reminder it's a rye. If you want a spicy, herbaceous rye, look elsewhere. If you want sweet and easy at this price, it's worth a bottle.


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Review #8 Ben Holladay 8 Year One Barrel

Post image
29 Upvotes

Ben Holladay One Barrel Bourbon
Age: 8
Type: Missouri Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Proof: 124.6 Proof (62.3%)
Price: $87

Nose: maraschino cherries, soft caramel, powdered sugar, vaguely cappuccino?

Palate: bing or maybe luxardo cherries, strawberry candy syrup, oaky sweetness, a little leathery, granny smith apple

Finish: pleasant bittersweetness, hot but not too hot for the proof, still has the hallmarks of a barrel proof though - tingly for a minute or two.

Notes: It's on the lighter, sweeter side while still being full bodied. Kind of reminds me of Four Roses or also a bit like EHT BiB. It's a bit of a flavor bomb within a somewhat narrow range of flavors.

t8ke: 8.2/10


r/bourbon • • 3d ago

REVIEW #37: Buckner's 13yr single barrel (Barrel Shoppe pick)(142.7 proof)

Post image
82 Upvotes

Price: $280

Nose: big, sweet oak, carmel, cherry, vanilla, dusty, proof is hitting

Palate: immediate blast of rich sweet oak, cherries galore, vanilla, spices, pepper notes, nutty, barrel char

Finish: long as hell, no flavor drop off, proof really warms my throat, peppery spice just feel so enjoyable, man this thing just goes on for days

My thoughts: this is incredibly good. It's just so satisfying. The depth of the 13 years is so necessary amongst all the flavors and the hazmat proof just takes it to another level. The cherry and nutty flavors here with the oak makes this thing a winner at the end of the day. Gonna land in my Top 20 list this year for sure.

Rating: 8.7/10

(If you want it: https://barrelshoppe.com/products/augusta-distillery-bourbon-shoppe-exclusive)

[Find at me @plentyofbottles on all social media and YouTube ✌🏼]


r/bourbon • • 3d ago

Review #190: Old Forester Single Barrel Barrel Strength Rye

Post image
65 Upvotes

If there's two thing Loki and myself enjoy, it's the color green and a good rye, so today we're taking a look at this Old Forester Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye! These used to be pretty difficult to come by, even more so at MSRP, but over the past few months my area was flooded with them. This was the very first Old Forester Green Label I got a few years ago and I've slowly nursed it thinking it'd be ages before I saw another. Crazy how much the whiskey world is changing. This specific barrel comes from floor 3 of warehouse G. Let's get into it.

Taken: Neat in a Glencairn, rested for 10 minutes.

Age: NAS

Proof: 128.7

Nose: Sweet brown sugar, tobacco, mint, and oak initially. I spot a dark cherry note on a deeper inhale and pink bubblegum. Swirling the glass brings out more mint and a strong floral aspect. A real rye lover's rye on the nose and smells every bit of its 128 proof point.

Palate: Good, oily viscosity of cinnamon, mint, and cherries. After a few sips, some earthy tones like tobacco and baking spices start to come out more with that bubblegum from the nose faintly there. Like the potent aromas, this drinks every bit of its proof.

Finish: Longer side of medium finish of bubblegum, mint, oak, and a nice lingering bright cherry that comes off as medicinal almost.

This rye is fantastic and I love that these are becoming easier to find at MSRP. If you've seen any of my prior reviews, you know I love myself a good cherry note and this Barrel Strength Rye delivers that on top of some wonderful cinnamon, mint, and tobacco notes. I have a few of these bottles now, but this is still the only one I've opened. This one has me very excited to crack into my others!

t8ke scale: 7.8/10 | Great | Well above average.

1 | Disgusting | So bad I poured it out.

2 | Poor | I wouldn’t consume by choice.

3 | Bad | Multiple flaws.

4 | Sub-par | Not bad, but better exists.

5 | Good | Good, just fine.

6 | Very Good | A cut above.

7 | Great | Well above average.

8 | Excellent | Really quite exceptional.

9 | Incredible | An all time favorite.

10 | Perfect | Perfect.


r/bourbon • • 3d ago

Review: Pinhook 10-year Vertical Series single barrel

Post image
24 Upvotes

Background:

Pinhook is one of those brands that I’ve been aware of but never given much of a close look. I knew they’d started as a sourcing NDP that eventually moved to contract-distilling at Castle & Key in 2017. They also have something called the Vertical Series, where they age the same lot of barrels and release a portion each year, with a climbing age statement.

I had a hankering for some MGP bourbon and stumbled upon a 10-year Pinhook single barrel that was MGP Indiana distillate, picked by an Australian whiskey group. In the US, those single barrels go for between 80 and 100 bucks; I paid a small premium on top of that for the Australian one.

I won't recount the whole Pinhook backstory and philosophy – their founder and blender Sean Josephs does a good job of it, so look up his interviews. I had some of their younger Castle & Key whiskey a couple of years ago and didn't find it memorable.

However, the Vertical Series are more interesting: Pinhook purchased 1350 barrels of MGP bourbon (they list it as 75/20.5/4.5 on their website, which should be the standard 21-percent rye MGP mash bill) in 2015 at just one year old. They age them at Castle & Key, and in 2019 they released the first edition at 4 years (they also have a parallel rye series). In 2020, they took out more barrels at 5 years, and so on. The initial plan was to keep putting them out annually until the bourbon hits 12 years in 2027. That journey has been extended to 16 years, once they realized the whiskey was not evaporating as quickly as they expected (more on that later).

The Vertical Series are offered in both the batched and single-barrel format, cask-strength and unfiltered. The 2026 11-year edition just dropped in mid-October. My single barrel is 10 years old, released at the end of 2025 at 117.5 proof. Tasted neat in a copita.

Nose:

Chocolate-covered hazelnut, stone fruit, oak, roasted peanut, caramel, strawberry.

Palate:

Dried apricot, red berries, hazelnut, cocoa, vanilla, honey roasted peanut, citrus, caramel.

Finish:

Red fruit, cinnamon, brown sugar, oak.

Rating: (t8ke scale for reference below): 7

1 | Disgusting | So bad I poured it out

2 | Poor | I wouldn’t consume by choice

3 | Bad | Multiple flaws

4 | Sub-par | Not bad, but many things I’d rather have

5 | Good | Good, just fine

6 | Very Good | A cut above

7 | Great | Well above average

8 | Excellent | Really quite exceptional

9 | Incredible | An all-time favorite

10 | Perfect | Perfect

Thoughts:

Whether you find the concept clever or gimmicky, I give Pinhook credit for being very transparent about what they are bottling and how they are aging it. Sean has mentioned that they decided to extend the Vertical Series from 12 years to 16 due to slower-than-expected aging conditions. Why is that?

If you look at Castle & Key (the current name of the restored Old Taylor Distillery), they have two main warehouses in active use: Warehouse B that was built from brick in 1917 and has the distinction of being the world's longest rickhouse, and Warehouse E from the 1950s, which is brick and concrete.

Then there is the location: Castle & Key sits in a valley, with more humidity and less air circulation than you’d get on higher ground. Combine that with the cooler brick and concrete buildings, and you don’t get as many extreme temperature swings that wood and metal warehouses go through. That means less evaporation, as more ethanol molecules escape and water is retained, dropping the proof. That effect also results in less volume loss as the whiskey ages. That’s why Pinhook’s cask-strength offerings are below 120 proof, which is the standard MGP barrel entry.

That kind of setup slows down the rate of extraction inside the barrels, so you need a little more time to achieve the same level of maturity as you would in a wood or metal rickhouse on a hill.

A famous example of a bourbon aged at Old Taylor is Wild Turkey’s Master’s Keep 17 from 2015. Turkey rented storage there in the late ‘90s and early 2000s. Eddie Russell talked about struggling with the “Stone Castle” barrels dropping proof and tasting 8 years old after 12 years of aging. That’s why MK17, which was partially matured at Old Taylor, was dumped at just 89 proof and bottled at 86.8.

I’ve heard about stone fruit notes often being present on bourbon aged that way, and they were on display here, along with the expected MGP fruitiness. The bourbon did not taste young by any means, but it had a refined, almost delicate presentation despite being barrel-proof and unfiltered. It drank as a very coherent whiskey, with a good balance of flavors – my personal pet peeve is when the nuttiness takes over, but in this case, it was well offset by chocolate, fruit and oak (it leans more toward hazelnut than peanut, which is a good thing in my book).

Another interesting angle Sean talks about is how they don’t have a set flavor-profile vision and blend each vintage to the best taste for that particular lot (a moot point with single barrels, obviously). The motto on the bottle states, “The best, not the same, whiskey every year.” That makes sense, considering Sean’s wine-sommelier background and his treatment of each vintage as its own thing. Predicting which year will be to your liking is tricky, but I can see how that could be a positive for someone who likes to try new things and is not afraid of being surprised.

Overall, I’ve enjoyed this single barrel and would recommend the Vertical Series to anyone curious about not just the vintage variations, but how aging locations affect the whiskey. I have a feeling it will really start hitting its stride as it gets closer to the 16-year finish line.

Thanks for reading and cheers!


r/bourbon • • 2d ago

Old Soul #2

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

I enjoyed the Old Soul Wheated Bourbon Cask Strength Single Barrel pick so much that I decided to branch out and give the regular bourbon Cask Strength Single Barrel Virginia ABC pick a shot.

I'm really enjoying the Wheated Single Barrel Cask Strength - lots of bright fruit notes, creamy caramel & vanilla, honey-drizzled toast, & warm baking spices.

I'm looking forward to seeing how the rye-based mash bill compares. I'll probably crack this one open tonight or tomorrow!


r/bourbon • • 3d ago

Review #993 - Found North Hell Diver 2026 Release

Thumbnail
gallery
64 Upvotes