I saw Veer Zaara yesterday (only 19 years too late) and wanted to write my honest review of the movie. I know this sub-reddit loves the movie and I am going to get downvoted to hell for saying this, but I hated the movie!!
Spoiler alert for people who have not seen it in the 19 years since it released.
OK, first off, SRK falls in love with her. It's love at first sight, not uncommon to other love stories/movies, especially Indian movies. Preity is the manic pixie dream girl - she is cute and bubbly. SRK's parents love her. They spend 2 days with each other. There is undeniable chemistry. SRK keeps carrying her for whatever reason and it doesn't occur to her to tell him, "umm, could you not? I am engaged and us staring intently in each other's eyes while you are carrying me feels a bit weird to me". Fine, she also probably likes him and is conflicted. Good so far.
There are some cute songs as well to melt our heart into gooey chocolatey goodness.
The problem starts once Preity's fiancé enters the mix. Preity says that she is engaged. SRK, who's no hormonal teenager but a strapping Air Force officer, blurts out his undying love for her and offers to move mountains for her. Keep in mind, he's known her for a whopping 2 days at this point. But hey, let's not dwell on that, it gets weirder.
He decides to run off to Pakistan to whisk her away. Then he decides, "Eh, maybe not."
Preity's dad also emotionally blackmails her and tells her about how his political ambitions are now thwarted. She sees the error of her ways.
Things escalate and somehow SRK lands in prison. The fiancé is butt hurt that he was insulted and asks him to spend his life in jail or else he will make Preity's life miserable. Now, again at that point he had known her for a grand total of 3 days. It just felt really unbelievable that he would forsake his whole life for a girl he barely knew. You can argue that I just don't understand love, but seriously, he could have said yes and tried multiple ways to get out. SRK spends 22 years in solitary confinement, giving intense gazes to the walls and, presumably, his own reflection. No, he doesn't seem to mingle with anyone. Maybe they're all tired of his relentless staring contests.
Enter Rani. Why doesn't she have a back story? I know they say that she wants to be like her dad, but seriously, who is her dad? Why should we care about this "dad" person who we have never seen? How does she even come to know of SRK rotting in prison with nothing but his intense stares to give him company? Why is she so invested in the case? The story is already 3 hours long and maybe giving her a solid back story will make it 4 hours, but they could have cut down on some of the intense stares to maybe add a 10 minute back story.
Oh, and remember all that emotional blackmail from Preity's dad? Turns out it didn't matter because she broke off the engagement anyway. Her parents died, and we're left wondering, "What was the point of all that again?"
Also, the fiancé ended up going to a "foreign country" (they don't mention which) anyway. So he ended up not mattering either. He was probably like "What? He's still in prison? Get the poor guy out of there!"
She comes back to Pakistan after learning the truth. At that point, the judge is pretty pissed that Rani is not there. She comes with Preity and there restarts SRK/Preity's intent staring - this time for a good 10 minutes. The spinning circles comparing their youth to them in old age had me break into peals of laughter. I was just imagining the poor judge being like "Umm, if you guys are done staring, I have a case I need to get to."
So of course, Rani wins the case. SRK/Preity go back to India and live happily ever after.
BTW, SRK was probably 25 and Preity was probably 21 when they met? Which means they were 47 and 43 when they met again. Why did they look like 70 year old's?
And, oh my god, the melodrama!! If I had to look at SRK being sad from all possible angles for another frame, I would have thrown something at the TV.
What am I missing? Is it because I watched the movie in 2023 and seeing it with new lens that people did not have in 2004? Why is this movie so loved?
Edit: I seem to have ruffled a few feathers which I expected. I understand that I should not think too logically when I watch a bollywood romance movie. My question was more along the lines of - what is it about this movie that stood the test of time, when there are other romantic movies that did not? I don't know how everyone feels about "Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam", but I honestly loved that movie inspite of Salman's overacting. That was a beautiful love story where the girl realizes that the love she had for Salman was more an infatuation whereas the love she has for her husband is stronger. Maybe unrealistic movies like Veer Zaara is just not for me and that's ok, but my question still remains - Why is Veer Zaara a cult classic?