r/bitlaw • • Mar 02 '14

Let us obsolete the state

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Dec 15 '13

What is Bitlaw

19 Upvotes

What is Bitlaw?

Bitlaw is an attempt to enable a polycentric legal system by building a voluntarist legal platform using technology.

Thus it's both an idea and an app/program that you would run. The idea is fairly well formed, the app still needs a lot of work.

If we were in a free society, people would be able to choose laws for themselves and their property, as individual sovereigns. There would be no one forcing law down your throat like states do now.

Thus people would need a means to send, receive, and edit law for themselves.

Bitlaw is trying to fill that gap.

It must hold your personal law set. It must be able to send laws to other people without dependency on a central server (thus P2P), much like you can send messages using Bitmessage.

You must be able to edit provisions in and out of the contract easily.

There needs to be a cryptographic signature mechanism which can hash the document with the time-stamp and provide proof of signature, sent to both parties upon signing so that both can prove it was signed, when it was signed, and the exact form of the contract when it was signed so that nothing can be changed.

With this in hand, a seastead could get up and running with a polycentric system almost immediately. You could conduct business with it easily enough, doing purchase and sales contracts which would be open-sourced or purchased (for bitcoin!) from law producers. We are looking at ways to wrap a creator's bitcoin address into them such that if you use someone's law-code snippet you can tip them thereby.

You should be able to easily issue receipts, so there may be purchase functionality in it.

While this would be of great use in a seastead, I think this could have broad application even here and now. Its use as a contract negotiating tool, allowing rapid back and forth edit and review before signing could be particularly attractive, allowing you to edit contracts in real time, make changes, send to the other party, have changes highlighted, etc.

Bitlaw is the future of polycentric legal technology.


Resources

Bitlaw Git Repository on Github

Bitlaw.info (under construction)


r/bitlaw • • Mar 22 '15

Forget Politicians: How To Crowdsource Better Laws (Tom W. Bell)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
13 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Jan 29 '14

Service Automatically Fights Parking Tickets For Car Owners

Thumbnail
psfk.com
12 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Nov 25 '13

6 likely characteristics of a polycentric legal system, as identified by Tom Bell

12 Upvotes

In the early 1990s, Tom Bell, then a student at University of Chicago Law School and now a Law Professor at Chapman, wrote a paper on Legal Polycentrism for some courses taught by Richard Posner. This paper was primarily an attempt to provide a theoretical justification for non-statist legal systems, for which Bell adapted (presumably from Michael Polanyi) the term “polycentric law,” its subcategories being cus- tomary law and privately-produced law. Around the same time, Bell published a paper on the same topic in the Human Studies Review and still later, a short paper on practical applications in a Cato Policy Report in 1998 (Bell 1991–92, 1992, and 1998).

Bell notes that, once one becomes familiar with the notion of poly- centric law, one sees instances of it everywhere—in churches, clubs, businesses, and so on. Without the focusing lens of the concept, poly- centric law is largely invisible. Although he provides a concise account of some historical examples of polycentric legal systems, Bell notes that a justification of polycentric law requires more than case studies of small and/or insular societies; it requires a justification for how poly- centric law would work here and now. Following Benson, he isolates 6 features common to most systems of customary law, the first 5 of which would likely be mirrored in systems of privately-produced law. Modified slightly, these are:

  1. individual rights and private property take centre stage;

  2. victims are the enforcers of the law;

  3. violence is avoided by the emergence of standard (and, I would add, mutually agreeable) adjudicative procedures;

  4. restitution/reparation (primarily economic) would follow from treating offenses as torts (invasions of personal rights) rather than crimes (offenses against the state);

  5. the enforcement mechanism is ostracism, blackballing, blacklisting, banishment, exclusion from society;

  6. legal change comes about by evolution rather than by (legislative) revolution.

From this article: Reflection on Legal Polycentrism


r/bitlaw • • Sep 14 '15

E-residency could one day let you select a nation in the same way as Uber lets you choose a taxi

Thumbnail
factor-tech.com
11 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Sep 22 '14

Modern government is organized on “clear law,” the false premise that by making laws detailed enough to take in all possible circumstances, we can avoid human error...

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
11 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Jan 06 '14

Bitlaw on Github

Thumbnail
github.com
11 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Sep 14 '13

Hey mister wanna buy some lemonade?

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Feb 25 '15

Feds raid Texas secessionist meeting

Thumbnail
mysanantonio.com
10 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Sep 11 '14

Digital natives are: Used to the concept of “exit,” comfortable with online relationships, and cynical about politics. Give them a low-cost alternative—like an app—and they’ll adopt it.

Thumbnail
fee.org
10 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Feb 23 '14

Cryptocontracts Will Turn Law Into a Programming Language [x-post, /r/Bitcoin]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Feb 17 '14

But Wouldn't Warlords Take Over? - Robert P. Murphy

Thumbnail
mises.org
10 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Jan 25 '14

Name: Tom W. Bell. What I do: Design legal systems for startup cities. : Anarcho_Capitalism

Thumbnail
reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Jan 24 '14

More on Ethereum, a platform for decentralized applications - an android of the cryptocurrency world, where all efforts can share a common set of APIs, trustless interactions and no compromises

10 Upvotes

When the grand experiment that is bitcoin began, the anonymous wizard desired to test two parameters- a trustless, decentralized database enjoying security enforced by the austere relentlessness of cryptography and a robust transaction system capable of sending value across the world without intermediaries. Yet the past five years years have painfully demonstrated a third missing feature: a sufficiently powerful Turing-complete scripting language. Up until this point, most innovation in advanced applications such as domain and identity registration, user-issued currencies, smart property, smart contracts, and decentralized exchange has been highly fragmented, and implementing any of these technologies has required creating an entire meta-protocol layer or even a specialized blockchain. Theoretically, however, each and every one of these innovations and more can potentially be made hundreds of times easier to implement, and easier to scale, if only there was a stronger foundational layer with a powerful scripting language for all of these protocols to build upon. And this need is what we seek to satisfy.

Ethereum is a modular, Turing-complete contract scripting system married to a blockchain and developed with a philosophy of simplicity, universality and non-discrimination. Our goal is to provide a platform for decentralized applications - an android of the cryptocurrency world, where all efforts can share a common set of APIs, trustless interactions and no compromises. We ask for the community to join us as volunteers, developers, investors and evangelists seeking to enable a fundamentally different paradigm for the internet and the relationships it provides.

Ethereum thread on Bitcointalk.org

Ethereum going public

Read the Ethereum Whitepaper


r/bitlaw • • Jan 16 '14

Stephen Kinsella: Law in a Libertarian World -- Legal Foundations of a Free Society

Thumbnail
stephankinsella.com
10 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Dec 31 '13

Twister, a P2P microblogging platform--this tech could be adapted into Bitlaw

Thumbnail
twister.net.co
10 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Dec 19 '13

When law is individually-chosen, regulatory capture is impossible; here's a run-down of abuses made possible by centralization of law, everything from Prohibition gangsterism to de-facto industry monopolies enabled by regulation

Thumbnail
panampost.com
10 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Mar 23 '15

A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace

Thumbnail
projects.eff.org
9 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Mar 21 '15

Law Without Government

9 Upvotes

I remain convinced that decentralization is the driver of dynamic change in many areas of life, first in economics--producing the modern revolution of capitalism and its resulting global prosperity, and now trickling down into other areas of life, communication (internet), money (bitcoin), manufacturing (3D-printing), city planning (seasteading), distribution (SilkRoad), and soon--law.

What appears to be happening is that decentralized structures seem to be antifragile, to route around damage, and able to replace less efficient and less organic centralized precursors.

Decentralized structures seem to curry this advantage by synchronizing with a fundamental human truth--that we are all individuals, and individual actors. Decentralized structures allow access to a much larger segment of society.

While many have recognized the impact of decentralization on these other fields, decentralized-law is still in theoretic stages, its impact yet to be felt, but I feel sure its impact will be felt more strongly than any that came before it.

What holds back much of the world is inequal access to good law, legal institutions, and property rights. The third world is broadly burdened by excessive regulation that makes something as simple as starting a business virtually impossible. In some South American countries, simply getting a contract notarized can cost over $1,000, something might cost $5 in the US.

By contrast, decentralized digital notary service is being worked on today as part of digital law services, at a cost of perhaps pennies.

Because of a lack of access to legitimate contractual solutions, much of the third world operates off the record where doing such simple things as transferring property is made more expensive and risky thereby.

With Bitlaw I want to create a very simple app that will allow anyone to write their own law, share it with contractees, and then encrypt it and transmit it to a notary service for storage, validation, and later retrieval at a marginal cost, paid for with bitcoin.

The most basic functionality must be the ability to write and edit contracts that will serve as private law to signees, to share this with others, and orchestrate an encryption method that will prove who signed it and when, including a hash of the entire document so that it cannot be changed later.

From there, users will be able to select their own notary(ies) and send it to them digitally and receive confirmation of receipt and storage.

Ideally it should be possible to create very simple sales receipts by making contract templates that get used over and over with just a few editable fields. This will allow retailers to simply process receipts digitally rather than the current practice of mandatory paper receipts. And hashing and encrypting the receipts will make them far more fraud resistant than paper receipts ever were.

Recently I asked David Friedman, the patron saint of polycentric law, why his model for a free society relied on dispute resolution organizations rather than allowing people and their agents to create their own laws.

His response was that there are economies of scale in law creation, and while I don't disagree with that that is not an argument against individual agency in law creation.

My concern is where the locus of control resides in society. If we are to maximize the decentralization of law then law creation power must reside in individuals themselves.

Even in such a scenario as I proposed where people can create their own laws, most will not. Most will still rely on an agent, a lawyer or the like who puts together a package of law based on their legal expertise and sells it to others.

We need not conflate law creation with law enforcement and interpretation as in Friedman's DRO model.

This is why rather than the term "polycentric-law" which I feel matches Friedman's DRO model, I prefer the term "decentralized law."

We will not have decentralized law until we have apps like Bitlaw that at last give individual people cheap and easy control over their own laws.

Ironically, the legal profession is one of the last professions in the world to adapt to the new digital reality.

I was struck recently upon visiting a lawyer's office to find them still carrying binders of paper on a case by case basis, nary a laptop or computer screen in sight.

Give law back to the people and see what they do with it. The results may surprise us all.


r/bitlaw • • Oct 29 '14

The Obviousness of Anarchy: The Creation of Rules Of Law

Thumbnail
notbeinggoverned.com
9 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Jul 25 '14

"The Four Pillars of a Decentralized Society" | Johann Gevers | TEDxZug

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • May 11 '14

Bitlaw in Dark Wallet, where we want to go... much conceptualising (will take time to plan) but its the start

Thumbnail wiki.unsystem.net
9 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Dec 19 '13

The Rise Of Emergent Networks

Thumbnail
greatestinstruments.net
9 Upvotes

r/bitlaw • • Dec 17 '13

Voluntary law stands legal Precedent on its head

9 Upvotes

Today precedent stands very strongly as a static force in law, hard to change, and some of the worst things about law are awful precedents forged in the past whose reasoning practically forever pollutes our legal future into today.

A society is influenced strongly by not just the law-makers, but those who determine the interpretation of that law in the form of precedent.

In America today, bad decisions of the past carried forward as precedents have done grave injury all over the legal landscape. Precedent is forced upon us as surely as law itself is.

But what would happen in a free society? In what way would precedent survive into a voluntary law society?

I do not think it would; certainly not in the same form of being mandatory on judges' decisions. Since voluntary law allows each person to choose their own laws, and legal disputes allow the disputants to choose their own court, it's likely that legal precedents would be handled in different ways.

Precedent will likely have a different life-cycle and use in a voluntarist context, perhaps something like so:

  • A contracts with B.

  • A has a dispute about B's conduct under their legal contract.

  • A and B go to court and the judge decides the case and proposes new legal language that could have avoided the dispute in the first place had it been included in their original contract, perhaps shoring up vague definitions or vague legal boundaries or expectations.

  • A and B continue to do business, except now they change their lawset and contract to use the improved language the judge suggested in all future business, resolving and preventing the original dispute from occurring. This is precedent in its new form as a legal reform rather than a legal-straightjacket.

That is, precedent becomes a lifecycle for law rather than a static thing set in stone that can only be changed by the "highest court"--a concept that doesn't even exist in a voluntarist society.

Precedent too thereby becomes voluntary. Rather than being a conservative force on society, holding back productive evolutionary change, it becomes a means of improving law and a way for judges to gain fame and business by their legal solutions to existing problems by improving law generally.

These are far better incentives on society, likely to result in far better outcomes than we have today.