r/bioethics • • May 31 '26

Is Forced Conformity in Medical School an Ethical Issue

50 Upvotes

I would like to hear perspectives from people interested in ethics and education. In my medical college, first-year students are expected to maintain a prescribed appearance: very short hair, clean shaven faces, specific uniforms, and even specific bags. The justification is always discipline and professionalism. I understand the need for professional standards in medicine. Patients should be able to trust healthcare professionals, and institutions have a legitimate interest in maintaining order. However, I struggle with where the ethical line is drawn. Medicine teaches autonomy, dignity, informed consent, and respect for individual persons. Yet some institutions seem comfortable exercising significant control over the personal appearance of adult students who have already earned their place through merit. At what point does professionalism become conformity?
At what point does discipline become humiliation?
And is there an ethical contradiction in teaching future physicians to respect patient autonomy while expecting students to surrender aspects of their own autonomy without question?
I am not arguing against discipline. I am questioning whether enforcing uniformity of appearance is genuinely necessary for professional development, or whether it primarily serves to reinforce institutional authority.
Where do you think the balance should be between professionalism and personal autonomy in medical education?


r/bioethics • • Mar 21 '21

r/Bioethics is getting an overhaul - and we need your help!

43 Upvotes

Hello, bioethicists!

My name’s Rich, and it’s my pleasure to say I’m the sub’s new moderator (though u/PabloPicasso will also still be around for a while at least). I have degrees in philosophy and bioethics (a BA and an MA, respectively), and have spent the last few years writing about bioethics, health, science and technology in various lovely/gruesome/beautiful/human flavours for places like Wired, Vice Motherboard, TechRadar and the IET.

Nice to meet you!

I asked for this mod position because I think the sub deserves a shot in the arm. There are 4.6 thousand subscribers to r/bioethics. To me, that’s a perfect number: 4.6 thousand people from different backgrounds; from different countries and cultures; with different hopes, ideas and fears for the past, present and future. 4.6 thousand people is enough to debate almost anything, but not so many that people or topics get buried in an avalanche of new posts and replies. This sub could be - should be - thriving. But it’s not. So let’s fix that.

There are a hundred different ways we can do this, and all of them start with hearing your ideas. That’s what this sticky is for: tell me what changes you’d like to see and I will scurry off and do my best to make them happen.

Personally, I would like this sub to be a community, with regular community events. We can schedule weekly discussions and debate topics. We can put AMAs with serious bioethicists, scientists - whoever - on the calendar. We can start a book club. At the very least, we can make this sub into an escape from the boredom, isolation and lack of stimulation so many of us are stuck with thanks to Covid. We can stimulate each other! In the most strictly SFW way possible.

If that sounds good, tell us in the comments what you’d most like to see: new features, community events - whatever it is, I’ll find out if it’s possible and put in the time to make it work. In the meantime, I’m going to be making some nuts and bolts updates to the sub to spruce things up. Some will be cosmetic (we don’t have a banner), others will be even more important (we don’t have any rules). I’ll do my best not to break anything or otherwise disturb the day-to-day running of the sub. But if I do (or you have any thoughts you’d rather share privately), PM me.

I’m excited to be here and I’m looking forward to meeting you and seeing where the sub can go. Once we’re up and running, I’ll put up a second sticky post where people can introduce themselves and their interests properly, and we can get some decent discussions going.

All the best,

Rich


r/bioethics • • Jul 15 '23

Medically assisted suicide for mental illness

39 Upvotes

https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/shes-47-anorexic-wants-help-dying-canada-will-soon-allow-it-2023-07-15/?utm_source=reddit.com

First post here, but I think there’s some interesting discussion here. Medically assisted death is always a hot topic, but what is it’s role in mental illness? Can someone be coined terminally depressed or have terminal eating disorders? In theory these are illness where the underlying disease itself doesn’t cause death but the side effects become self harming.
I’d also question if someone can reasonably consent to medical decisions about their lives when they have what could be considered a derangement to self image or reality.
At what point in a mental illness do we begin to limit someone’s autonomy?

I’m not sure if I feel this is wrong or right; I know it is definitely a sign that we need more emphasis on mental health disorders and availability to treat them.


r/bioethics • • Dec 09 '25

I'm polling the public on artificial wombs. Which ethics questions should I ask?

35 Upvotes

I recently read Guid Oei's new book The Artificial Womb (Springer). I don’t think we’re prepared for the ethical questions this tech will raise, especially if the technology for conception-to-birth artificial wombs arrives sooner than expected. Matt Krisiloff recently mentioned at least four startups working on this.

If a fetus can be transferred to an artificial womb, could a pregnant person seeking to end their pregnancy be obligated to choose transfer over termination, i.e. to end the pregnancy but preserve the fetal life? It’s common for legal frameworks to assume the fetus is inside someone's body, so the right to end a pregnancy and the right to end the life are often treated as the same thing. If a fetus can be transferred to an artificial womb, that stops being true.

I think this is a good example of something the public will need to weigh in on sooner rather than later, I’m looking to include topics like this.

To be clear about where the tech stands: you might have seen photos of lambs floating in plastic bags from Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, which come up constantly in these discussions. I wouldn't call CHOP's device an artificial womb. It's an incubator for fetuses already viable at around 22 weeks, not something that gives an embryo somewhere to implant and develop from scratch. Dr. Jacob Hanna's lab has grown mouse embryos ex-vivo for ten days, but they're growing embryos in a nutrient bath for research purposes; they've confirmed this isn't a path to ectogenesis. Neither line of research raises novel ethical questions on its own.

What makes me think timelines could compress is the startup activity. Colossal Biosciences has raised $555 million; other groups have pulled in multi-million dollar rounds. One CHOP researcher warned me that some may be repackaging incubator tech, and privately-funded labs like TIGGR won't answer basic questions about their work. I think there's real uncertainty here.

I've talked to a few dozen researchers on the technical side, I want to hear from people thinking about the ethics of it. What ethical dilemmas should the survey cover?


r/bioethics • • Oct 21 '22

Ethics of Infant Male Circumcision

31 Upvotes

I wanted to discuss this issue because to me medically unnecessary infant circumcision seems obviously wrong. It removes a healthy body part from a non-consenting person with no medical necessity, which is permissible in no other case I can think of. It seems just as bad as removing the clitoral hood from an infant girl, yet that is considered a form of FGM according to the World Health Organization because it is "partial or total removal of external female genitalia," and all forms of FGM are widely accepted as immoral. Even if circumcision prevents some diseases, it doesn't seem like that would justify mutilating a child, just like how if it turned out that FGM could prevent some diseases that wouldn't morally justify it being done on infants. Additionally, circumcision is immoral even when done for religious reasons, just like all forms of FGM are immoral even when done for religious reasons. It also seems obviously immoral to forcibly circumcise a non-consenting adult man, but there doesn't seem to be a morally relevant difference between this and infant circumcision. I am at a loss to understand how it could be justified yet it is widely accepted in American society.

What do you guys think about this issue? I know there is a previous post on this, but it's from 10 years ago and the poster only included a link without summarizing a pro- or anti-circumcision position. I thought this issue could use an update.


r/bioethics • • Mar 18 '23

Bioethics Careers Thread

30 Upvotes

Greetings, bioethicists!

We've had a suggestion by a member of our community to create a thread for dealing with all questions about careers in bioethics (rather than just having similar threads asking similar questions pile up). We think that's an excellent idea, and so: here it is!

Whether you're a student who's about to graduate and wondering what to do next (or a student who's literally on their first day of school and really planning ahead), whether you're already working in healthcare and looking to make a change, or considering a shift into bioethics from something totally unrelated and wondering how you can use it to make a living, please post your questions here and the nice people of our sub will (hopefully!) be there to answer them.

This is a bit of an experiment, so we'll keep an eye on it and any suggestions for improvements/changes are welcome. We want this to be as helpful as possible so if you have an idea of how to handle this better, drop us a line on the modmail.

Enjoy!


r/bioethics • • Aug 15 '17

Does Female Genital Mutilation Have Health Benefits? The Problem with Medicalizing Morality [Brian D. Earp, Yale University]

Thumbnail j4mb.org.uk
26 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • Apr 18 '26

Your Conscience Is Not My Problem

25 Upvotes

Excerpts from the article:

A rape survivor in Denton, Texas walked into an Eckerd pharmacy with a prescription for emergency contraception. Three pharmacists refused to fill it, citing personal moral grounds. She eventually got it filled at another pharmacy. This was not an isolated event. As Cantor and Baum documented in the NEJM later that year, pharmacists in Missouri, Ohio, and New Hampshire were doing the same thing: refusing to fill prescriptions and refusing to direct patients elsewhere, and in one case berating a 21-year-old single mother until she pulled over and cried on the drive home.

The conventional wisdom in medical ethics goes like this: healthcare professionals are moral agents, and forcing them to violate their deepest convictions inflicts a kind of psychological wound called “moral injury.” The compassionate move, then, is to accommodate: let the objector step aside, as long as someone else steps in. This is the framework advanced most influentially by the bioethicist Mark Wicclair, and it’s the backbone of professional guidelines from the AMA to ACOG to Britain’s General Medical Council.

My view is different. I think the accommodation framework has it almost exactly backwards. It treats the clinician’s conscience as the thing that needs protecting and the patient’s access as the variable that can flex. The correct priority runs precisely the other way. And once you flip the priority, most conscientious objection in medicine starts to look less like an exercise of moral integrity and more like a refusal to do your job, with the costs offloaded onto the people least equipped to bear them.

The term “conscientious objection” carries enormous moral prestige, and it carries it for a reason: it was forged in the context of military conscription, where the state compels you to kill people. Quakers and Mennonites who refused to fight in World War I were not declining an optional service. They were resisting a coercive demand to participate in lethal violence, often at great personal cost (prison, social exile, sometimes death). Whatever you think of their theology, the structural position is one of powerlessness resisting power.

Now transport that label into a hospital. A pharmacist declines to dispense Plan B. An obstetrician refuses to perform (or refer for) an abortion. An oncologist declines to assess a patient’s eligibility for medical assistance in dying. The language is the same: “conscientious objection.” But as Stahl and Emanuel pointed out in a landmark 2017 NEJM essay, the structural position is inverted. Nobody conscripted these people into pharmacy or obstetrics. They applied to professional school, completed years of voluntary training, accepted a license that grants them a monopoly on certain services, and then announced that they won’t provide some of those services. The power dynamic runs entirely the other way: the objector is the gatekeeper, and the patient is the one who can’t get what they need.

The conscription analogy does most of the work in the literature, and it does that work dishonestly. Ronit Stahl and Ezekiel Emanuel were blunt: physicians are not conscripts. Nobody is forcing them into medicine. The entire moral architecture of “objection” presupposes a kind of compulsion that simply isn’t present when you voluntarily enter a licensed profession.

The sharpest version of the anti-accommodation view comes from the philosopher Julian Savulescu, writing in the BMJ in 2006. His argument goes like this: if a professional’s personal moral convictions prevent them from providing legal, evidence-based, patient-requested care, the correct response is not to carve out an exception but to find a different line of work.

Medicine is a publicly regulated, often publicly funded, fiduciary profession. Society grants physicians and pharmacists extraordinary privileges (the exclusive right to prescribe medications, admit patients to hospitals, perform surgery) in exchange for a commitment: you will use those privileges for the benefit of patients, within the bounds of law and evidence. When a clinician says “I won’t dispense this legal medication because of my personal beliefs,” they are, in Savulescu’s framing, taking the privileges while refusing the obligations.

And yes, the argument really does mean that a devout Catholic who becomes an OB-GYN and later finds that abortion referrals are expected of her should, if she cannot in good conscience refer, leave obstetrics. A hard outcome for a real human being who has invested a decade in training. Also, I think, the right outcome. The alternative is that her patients, who did not choose her and may not be able to choose someone else, bear the costs of her convictions.

Italy legalized abortion in 1978 under Law 194, which includes a broad conscience clause. In the decades since, the percentage of Italian gynecologists who register as conscientious objectors has risen to approximately 70% nationally. In the south, the numbers are worse: observations submitted to the European Committee of Social Rights in the CGIL complaint against Italy recorded objection rates of 85.7% in Molise, 85.2% in Basilicata, 83.9% in Campania, and 80.6% in Sicily, and cited LAIGA's finding that Lazio reached 91.3%. In those regions, finding a non-objecting physician can require traveling across multiple provinces.

Seven out of ten OB-GYNs in a country where abortion is legal have opted out of providing it.

Italy is the strongest empirical argument against broad accommodation. Law 194 technically requires hospitals to maintain service capacity. In practice, nobody enforces that requirement, and what follows from treating individual conscience as a trump card without building system-level enforcement is predictable: the system stops providing the service. Abortion didn’t get banned in Italy. It got accommodated into near-nonexistence.

And there's a second, more uncomfortable dynamic at play. Not every Italian OB-GYN who registers as a conscientious objector is experiencing a profound crisis of moral integrity. Some undoubtedly are. But in a professional culture where objectors face no career consequences and non-objectors absorb the extra workload, there are strong incentive effects to register as an objector: lighter schedules, better hours, no stigmatized procedural work. The conscience clause creates a free-rider problem. Non-objecting gynecologists do all the abortions while objectors enjoy the benefit of a more comfortable practice. This is the "hidden conscience tax" that gets little of the attention it deserves in the philosophical literature, because philosophers are analyzing the reasons for objection when they should also be analyzing the consequences of accommodation.

Under broad accommodation, the cost falls on the patient (who must find another provider, sometimes under time pressure, sometimes in a context saturated with judgment and shame). It falls on colleagues (who absorb the objector’s workload, creating the hidden conscience tax). It falls on the system (which must build and maintain redundant capacity to backfill every possible refusal). The one person who bears almost no cost is the objector, who gets to maintain their moral self-image, keep their job, and let everyone else figure it out.

If your conscience prevents you from providing legal care, and no institutional design can fully insulate patients from the consequences, then your conscience is your problem, not your patient’s. Find a specialty that doesn’t conflict. Advocate for the laws you believe in. Organize, write, protest, campaign. But when you show up for work, do your job or surrender the license.


r/bioethics • • Oct 26 '15

TIL that NASA has a Senior Bioethicist, which sounds like the coolest job in the world.

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
25 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • Mar 23 '21

Is there something inherently morally problematic about the idea of genetically improving humans?

23 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • Jul 11 '12

An Age of Consent for Circumcision? - Room for Debate - NYTimes.com

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
20 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • Apr 13 '24

Ethics in psychiatry: why does mental health feel excluded from or less addressed in bioethics?

19 Upvotes

I am newer to bioethics. I am slowly working on my masters, and with more exposure I feel more frustrated with the way mental illness is largely talked around because it doesn’t fit neatly into medicine. Like the definition of illness or disease for example.

My professional background is psychiatry (social work) in a medical hospital setting. I was motivated to pursue bioethics based on my experiences at the intersection of psychiatry and medicine. But I’m frustrated with the paucity of consideration of mental illness when it comes to bioethics, maybe more so applied ethics. End of life decisions, disability, defining illness, etc.

I think stigma, especially around severe and persistent mental illness, is at play. I wonder about subjectivity of psychiatry and if this keeps people from bringing it into the discourse more often. Whatever the case, I feel frustrated by this. I would love to attend a conference where ethics of psychiatry is the focus, but also hear mental illness more in disability ethics.

Am I just too new and not looking in the right places? Am I reading the room wrong? I often ask questions in class, to speakers, or search for seminars which are around but few, and feel like something is missing.

Can anyone point me in the right direction? To whatever corner of bioethics is chatting collectively about mental health the ways we discuss physical?

Thanks in advance for reading my ramble.


r/bioethics • • Nov 28 '25

A large American nonprofit is asking a population with known neurological issues to connect their electronic health records to their website. Is this ethical?

18 Upvotes

The Epilepsy Foundation just launched the EmpowER&D program.

They're asking people with epilepsy to “share their story” in social media ads. But that turns out to mean share their seizure history, treatment data, and connect their electronic health records.

But not a lot of transparency here. Red flags I saw:

Why is there a venture capital company, a venture fund, and pharmaceutical corporations involved?

How were patients and families included in designing and governing the program?
What safeguards are in place to ensure that anything developed with that data truly benefits epilepsy patients?

Will this anonymous database be free and available to everyone? And if so, will everyone have access at the same time? If not, why not?

Will this be a shared, open-source, scientific resource to benefit the entire, global epilepsy community? If not, why not?

How is it ethical to ask people to “share their experiences or stories,” then actually ask them to link their electronic medical records?

How are they meeting the principles of informed consent? Especially with such a vulnerable population?

I'd appreciate any expert insights here. I just want answers.

Link: https://www.epilepsy.com/research-funding/empowerd


r/bioethics • • Mar 25 '21

What are YOUR top bioethics resources?

18 Upvotes

Hello again, bioethicists!

Something that was suggested in the overhaul thread that went up a few days ago (and is still there, stickied, if people have any more ideas for the sub!) was a list of bioethics resources for members: websites, repositories of papers, podcasts, video series and so on. This was an excellent idea and the second one I'm going to check off the list (for those of you wondering what the first thing was: we have a first draft of some rules now!).

In the spirit of keeping the sub open to as many people as possible, I'm going to ask that we avoid links to things that require a subscription to access (the big academic repositories that require you to log in through a university or accredited research organisation, for example). Hearing about an amazing resource and then clicking head-first into a paywall sucks, so let's not do that to anyone.

Apart from that, if you've got a reliable daily source for bioethical news (a site or subsection of one), a bioethics podcast you never miss, or some hidden gem you're always amazed nobody else knows about - here is the place to share it. As people make suggestions, I'll go through them and find the most reader-friendly way to fit them into the sub for everyone.

Not every suggestion need be all bioethics all the time: some sites/blogs/podcasts etc. that do bioethics will naturally also cover other ethical fields as well. So long as you feel it's a good resource overall for bioethicists and the sub, please do post it up.

I will start with these two:

The Nuffield Council on Bioethics - Independent source of lots of UK research funding. Big catalogue of free, publicly available research on all areas of bioethics. Also publishes this annual interactive horizon-scanning document for super-helpful view of the field from the immediate to the near-future.

The Oxford Uehiro Centre for Practical Ethics - Part of the University of Oxford. Publishes open access papers and also lectures and podcasts on all areas of practical ethics, including bioethics. World-class research on some surprisingly niche topics as well as the big concerns of the day.

Genuinely looking forward to your recommendations!


r/bioethics • • Oct 21 '19

Scientists 'may have crossed ethical line' in growing human brains: Debate needed over research with ‘potential for something to suffer’, neuroscientists say

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
18 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • Jul 09 '19

After spending $100,000 and going through a twin pregnancy, couple relinquishes custody of babies after embryo mix-up.

Thumbnail
bbc.com
18 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • Sep 10 '25

Case Studies and Opinions on the use of Extra-corporeal Membrane Oxygenation (ECMO) as a Life-Saving Measure

17 Upvotes

Specifically, how does this therapy differ from traditional life-saving measures, such as ventilation? What differences in the technology introduce new or exacerbate existing bioethics issues in patient care?

ECMO was used heavily during COVID, and now it's commonly used to stabilize someone who crashes during surgery or when a ventillator isn't sufficient. I'm compiling an index of medical technologies and their benefits and trade-offs (i.e. resource allocation, patient autonomy, etc.).


r/bioethics • • Mar 05 '21

Eugenics: Over 1,000 Female Prisoners in California tricked or forced into being Sterilized

Thumbnail
humansarefree.com
17 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • Sep 28 '17

Belgian Ethics Committee Rules Against Infant Circumcision

Thumbnail
flanderstoday.eu
17 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • Jul 18 '12

"Dying in Court" by Peter Singer (a Canadian court establishes legal right to assisted suicide)

Thumbnail
project-syndicate.org
17 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • 4d ago

If you have a career in bioethics, what does it look like?

16 Upvotes

Title -- I'm interested in pursuing a PhD in bioethics and becoming a clinical ethicist. Because of my health issues, med school is not an option for me, and while I really enjoy research, I've never been gifted in terms of heavy math and science (hence why I don't feel I should pursue a PhD in say, neuroscience, and be in a wet lab all day). I don't have much interest in getting a JD, but I'm open. I have always been very interested and fascinated by medical ethics and conceptual cases, etc. I have always found it to be very challenging but enriching.

I really like the idea of being able to help people navigate difficult ethical decisions and end-of-life care. I would like my work to be patient + clinical facing, but could see myself also being happy teaching at university "on the side" etc.

I know this sounds ambitious, but I am a driven person and it doesn't seem so farfetched to me. I will graduate with my bachelors in psychology from a T20 school in May and I'm wondering if it's worth it to pursue a PhD in bioethics-- I've been reading some posts and get an energy that people are slightly jaded by the profession.

Also... if you're open to sharing... your location and your salary, haha. Not my main driver, but something important to take into account.

Also open to advice on other careers / PhDs you think would be a good fit for someone like me!


r/bioethics • • Nov 07 '25

I just wrote the Introduction to my book, “The Ethics of De-Extinction”

16 Upvotes

Hey folks. I have an important milestone to report on my book, “The Ethics of De-Extinction.” I just finished the Introduction.

I started the book by trying to answer the question: why are we so obsessed with de-extinction? Before I got into the science, the ethics, and the policy, I wanted to understand the human emotion fueling our attraction.

In this section, I discuss:

Jurassic Park: The power of popular fiction and scientific fact to fascinate and inspire.

Playing God: An ancient human desire to push beyond our limits and test our boundaries.

Frankenstein: The twin anxiety about unleashing forces we don’t understand and our responsibility to fix what is broken.

Undoing the past: A deep sense of guilt over our lost species and a powerful desire to “correct” the past.

The introduction also lays the groundwork for the rest of the book, which will focus on “how” and “should we.” I’m so excited to have this first piece of the book behind me.

Now, I have a question for you: What is the strongest driver of the de-extinction movement in your opinion? Is it hubris, guilt, or curiosity?


r/bioethics • • Oct 12 '13

a $99 kit to make a living cockroach into a cyborg (sand a patch of shell on its head so that the superglue and electrodes will stick, insert a groundwire into the thorax, trim the antennae and insert electrodes into them.)

Thumbnail
news.sciencemag.org
16 Upvotes

r/bioethics • • Apr 09 '26

Medical Paternalism Is Making a Comeback (And Maybe It Should)

15 Upvotes

Excerpts from the article:

In 1972, Jerry Canterbury went in for back surgery, suffered a postoperative fall from his hospital bed, and ended up paralyzed. His surgeon, Dr. William Spence, hadn't mentioned that paralysis was a risk. Canterbury sued, and the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that physicians have a duty to disclose whatever a reasonable patient would want to know before consenting to a procedure. The decision helped launch a revolution. Over the next three decades, American medicine would transform its foundational ethic from "the doctor decides" to "the patient decides," enshrining autonomy, informed consent, and patient choice as the bedrock principles of clinical care.

That revolution was right. It corrected real abuses: decades of physicians withholding diagnoses, performing procedures without meaningful consent, and treating patients as passive recipients of medical benevolence. The Belmont Report in 1979 made "respect for persons" a foundational principle. Informed consent law expanded. Bioethicists wrote entire careers' worth of scholarship on why the old paternalism had to go.

But somewhere between "the doctor should not decide for you" and "you must decide for yourself," the project went sideways. And a growing body of scholarship is arguing that we need to talk about it.

You might expect patients to want full decisional sovereignty. The empirical literature suggests otherwise, and the pattern is very consistent across studies.

A 2012 study of hospitalized patients at the University of Chicago found that 97% wanted their doctors to offer choices and consider their opinions. So far, so autonomy. But 67% of those same patients preferred to leave the final medical decision to the doctor. Read that again: two-thirds of patients, in a modern American hospital, wanted their physician to make the call. They wanted to be heard, not enthroned.

The paradox is that shared decision making (SDM), as commonly practiced, often degrades into exactly the thing it was designed to prevent. Many clinicians interpreted "shared decision-making" to mean "never recommend," fearing that any expression of professional opinion would make them paternalistic. The result was a distinctive clinical posture: scrupulously neutral, informationally generous, and existentially useless. Present the options, describe the risks, list the benefits, and then stare expectantly at the person in the hospital gown, as if they just materialized on earth five minutes ago with no preferences, no fears, no need for professional guidance.

The argument: in serious illness and end-of-life care, the autonomy framework often becomes a mechanism for offloading impossible decisions onto patients and families. A surrogate who is told "your mother can go on the ventilator or we can pursue comfort measures; it's your choice" isn't being respected. They're being burdened with a life-and-death decision they have no framework for making, and they may carry guilt about that decision for years.

The anti-paternalist revolution happened because physicians really did silence, mislead, and overrule patients. Patients were routinely not told they had cancer. Women were sterilized without consent. Research subjects were experimented on without knowledge. Any argument for restoring physician authority has to contend with the fact that physician authority was, within living memory, regularly abused. That history doesn't disappear because we've gotten better at ethics training.

But pure menu autonomy is often a fiction, and sometimes a cruel one. A frightened, exhausted, cognitively overloaded patient staring at a list of treatment options they cannot evaluate is not exercising self-governance in any philosophically serious sense. They are exercising the right to be confused and alone. Most patients don't want that. The informed consent data suggests they aren't getting real autonomy anyway. And the clinicians who refuse to recommend aren't being respectful; they're being absent.

None of this requires going back to the bad old days. Medicine is a relationship, not a vending machine. The patient puts in their values; the doctor puts in their knowledge; and what comes out, ideally, is a decision neither could have reached alone.

The pendulum swung away from paternalism for excellent reasons. But it swung too far. The profession built an elaborate ethical infrastructure around the idea that doctors should present and patients should choose, and in doing so it created a system where the most common patient encounter with “autonomy” is bewilderment. The interesting question now is how to build a clinical culture where physicians are neither dictators nor bystanders, where recommendations are expected and transparent and revisable, and where “autonomy” means something richer than being left alone with a terrible choice.

I think doctors should recommend more, hedge less, and trust that a patient who disagrees will say so. That’s not paternalism. But it’s closer to paternalism than the current orthodoxy is comfortable with, and I think the current orthodoxy is wrong.