Just hear me out. Sorry for the rant.
The toughest pill to swallow about Jimmy and Chuck's relationship is that Chuck is right about everything he says about Jimmy.
How he says he will never change. How he can never play straight. How he can't help it. And the fact that he's a lawyer makes him very dangerous with the potential to do a lot of damage.
I mean, he wasn't lying. We see throughout both shows how he can't help but be a crook, and how he uses his knowledge of the law to break it more effectively. He was the attorney of Heisenberg, and helped him get away with a lot. Along with many other criminals. Even in the early seasons of the show when he was on his best behavior, Jimmy was still committing crimes.
He was right to not want Jimmy in his firm. Jimmy was not going to be able to uphold the image and professionalism Chuck worked his whole life to build for his firm. Jimmy proved this when he was hired by Davis and Main. After all, Davis and Main is no different from HHM. He would have run into the same issues and Chuck knew it. This why the argument that "Jimmy would have changed if Chuck just gave him a chance" crumbles.
However, Chuck was definitely dead wrong to lie and deceive Jimmy for so long, hiding behind Howard. That's the one thing I can't defend about Chuck. Not only was it wrong, it also went against everything Chuck claims to stand for. Lying and deceiving others is exactly what he hates Jimmy for.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying Chuck's intentions are completely pure. Its clear he is strongly fueled by bitterness, jealousy and resentment towards Jimmy. There's no doubt he is jealous of how Jimmy is so likeable, as this is something he has always struggled with.
Although one part of this is jealousy, I think another part could also be frustration. Jimmy's charisma allows him to get away with everything. To the point where people dont even believe he is capable of the things that he does, which is precisely what happened with their parents.
Have you ever known someone who you just know is a shady person but no one believes you? Cause everyone likes them too much?
That's essentially what Chuck went through his whole life with Jimmy. His whole life he tried to tell people what Jimmy is, but in response he got gaslit every time. Meanwhile, he watched Jimmy destroy everyone's lives.
It is because of this he went crazy.
Yes Chuck resents Jimmy deeply, while Jimmy doesn't resent him at all. But why would he? Chuck never gave him a reason to resent him. But Jimmy did.
When Jimmy won the trial against Chuck, it is framed as a good thing. But Chuck was telling the truth. Jimmy was the liar.
To be clear, I dont like Chuck. As I said, he is intentionally unlikable. But we mostly see Jimmy as the good guy because the show is in his POV. We see him as "good intentioned" but is he really?
I understand nuance exists. No side is completely innocent. But nuance doesn't mean neutrality.
If you take a look at the bigger picture, Jimmy is a conman who hustled his own parents into financial collapse, and caused his own brother to lose his mind. Which lead to his demise.
He later became one of the biggest crooked lawyers in history. Either directly or indirectly, he destroyed or ended several people's lives. Chuck was right about everything.
Although he tried to take care of Chuck, he was ultimately irresponsible. He enabled his delusions and refused to get him the help he needed, despite knowing very well that Chuck was indeed delusional.
The series shows the importance of perspective. How someone could be so wrong yet still appear as the hero, or so right yet appear as the villain, solely from perspective. Many of the characters were blinded by their affection for Jimmy to truly see how destructive of a person he is, despite how much Chuck tried to tell them. And so was the audience.
TLDR: Jimmy is everything Chuck said he is. Chuck was never wrong about him. He's just unlikeable.