r/beatles
•
u/exor0110
•
Sep 24 '26
Discussion The Beatles vs. Ed Sheeran: A Lesson On Having A Backbone
Didn’t realize they took a stand against segregated audiences (Jim Crow America). Based.
r/beatles
•
u/exor0110
•
Sep 24 '26
Didn’t realize they took a stand against segregated audiences (Jim Crow America). Based.
r/beatles • u/Express_Fox_5376 • Jul 04 '26
Ok so: I am late to the party, but I've just recently watched the "Get Back" documentary.
I've always considered the anti-Yoko Beatles fans who disliked her and considered her a key factor in the band's disbanding as an exaggeration mixed with a significant ammount of misogyny. I thought her leading John towards more social stances and awareness was something Beatles fans didn't like as they saw it as too hippie or something.
But then I saw this documentary and OH BOY. Now I get it. I was so PISSED, like personally annoyed by her presence during this whole creative process for the album and the whole project. She was such an intrusive, cringe and distracting presence, violating a very delicate environment she had no business being part of. At one point I was so tired of seeing her all the time, everywhere and I realized it was almost impossible to find a single shot of the band without her in it.
And what was it with the physical clinging to John while he was working with the boys? Man, she had no respect of boundaries and the band's work, it was really upsetting to watch and, as I said, it comes from someone who had 0 prejudice or bad feelings towards her before. The creative process of any artist is a sacred moment and having an external presence who is not part of it being constantly there, with 0 value and even useless contributions (I am sure her screeching will follow me in my nightmares for weeks to come) is honestly good enough to explain how she impacted the band's internal dynamics and contributed to new problems being added to the ones already there.
Paul's commentary in the documentary about her are quite polite, but his irritation towards her is still very clear and I could never blame him after seeing it with my own eyes. Also, from what I understood, Peter Jackson actually DIDN'T include a full representation of her disruption thorughout the process, so what we see is just the tip of the iceberg?
Jeez.
Sorry for the long rant, I just needed to share it 'cause I clearly lived under a rock until now 😅
r/beatles • u/sagarboi7 • Jan 07 '26
I get paul had a different vision for the song but for my money Phil spector production elevated the song to a eternal and holy prayer. Those strings are soul touching. I know some people prefer the naked version for its lighter feel but saying that original version is somehow bad is outright wrong.
My theory is that just because Paul said that he didn't liked the production led to people convincing themselves they also didn't enjoy the song.
r/beatles • u/Glad_Cloud_4176 • Jun 18 '26
Like Watching rainbows, return to pepper land, Suzy Paulor, harry pinsker, happy rishches song,
r/beatles
•
u/Solid-Perspective915
•
17d ago
Please don't make misogynistic comments on either of these women. I just wanna talk about a few problematic aspects of them. Doesn't mean these two are not also exceptionally kind and forgiving women who have risen through a lot of struggles and made the best of their lives.
Pattie
Overall she is a very brave woman who lived a tough life and I don't wanna slag her. Just a few problematic comments I found I wanna comment on because I think sometimes her idolization hurts Olivia's position in George's life and she has some antiquated views about stuff.
Apart from claiming George and her were soulmates and he is the love of her life even though she's married to someone else right now. It also seems so disrespectful to Olivia. It's kinda weird that she thinks Maureen stabbed her in the back when she still gushes over George who did way worse.
Also, her comments about Cynthia were kinda catty in her book. She has the whole tone like "i think Cynthia felt out of her depth in the sophisticated London scene as she was a northerner. I get along best with Jane because she's the only girl who can understand me these Liverpudlian girls (Cynthia and Maureen) and I can have nothing in common. Plus she also subtly bragged about Cynthia being insecure because John was attracted to her??
Apart from the Metoo comments about men not being allowed to profess their true nature in fear of sexual assault charges and also claims that George and Paul didn't really love each other (not sure how credible this is)???
May Pang
I mostly sympathise with her because both Yoko and John did her very dirty. But that's the problem, in most of her telling she minimizes John's ill-intentions because she wants to believe John loved her truly, yet she thinks Yoko completely hypnotized John?
I have finished a quarter of her book and since the initial start of the relationship it's obvious John is being very manipulative and fake understanding towards her. Even listening to her whole backstory and addressing her with her Chinese name to establish closeness. While all of this is happening he is fully aware him and Yoko have undue influence on this girl. She even cried the first night she had sex with him (she liked the sex it wasn't assault) but because of the mental pressure it was on her because one of the most powerful people in the industry were coercing her???
Yet, she always seems to blame Yoko and her intentions over John. Like John wasn't a dead brained idiot, girl.
r/beatles • u/Tea-Jay-Dogville • Aug 21 '26
Who had the best in the 1970s Paul or John?
r/beatles • u/Salty-Comb2042 • Oct 10 '25
Am I the only fan that wouldn't place either "Hey Jude" or "Let it Be" into their personal top-100 Beatles songs? I'm not saying they're bad or anything, or that I flat out don't like them, I would just rather listen to at least 100 other songs before them. If you were to cut out the last four minutes or so of HJ, it might sneak into the 90s for me, but as is, it goes on way too long for me.
r/beatles • u/BlackScienceMan2 • Jul 03 '25
I often read here and other places people praising the song but i just dont get it. Its the only song off sgt pepper i dislike.
What do people hear that i don’t. I am a huge Beatles fan but am also Gen Z so wasn’t around when it came out. Was it especially revolutionary for the time or what?
r/beatles • u/Opposite_Debt4645 • Apr 08 '26
r/beatles • u/Honest-J • Sep 20 '26
r/beatles • u/FC-1274 • Sep 21 '26
would just like to say i am NOT TRYING TO CANCEL HER so lets just get that out of the way right now. this isnt just me hating on her because im jealous she got to marry george harrison or something (i genuinely dont understand why people do that) im just trying to have an open and nuanced discussion about some things shes done that are super gross to me bc i’d like to hear other peoples point of view (and if i get anything wrong in this post please let me know and i’ll fix it)
hiding bill wyman in her house:
this is so super weird to me. so if you dont know, pattie mentions in her book that in the 80s her and eric clapton let bill wyman hide in her house (and this is one of the many reasons i dislike eric as well) to escape like a paparazzi storm. but see the reason for that storm is that bill was in his 40s (as were pattie and eric) dating a 13/14 year old girl named mandy smith. and its not like they didnt know why he was getting backlash. it was like a super super huge deal so they 100% knew why he needed to hide. why did they do this?
2. her comments about the me too movement
(link to the article with quotes from her: https://uk.news.yahoo.com/pattie-boyd-bemoans-lack-proper-100000817.html)
so pattie basically said that she doesnt support the me too movement. she said she feels bad for men because they have to”curb their natural behaviors” due to the fact that everyone is so”woke and over-sensitive” these days. i understand that she was raised in a different time and everything, but its super gross to me that shes willingly repeating those ideas in this day and age, and publicly too.
3. the whole eric-and paula situation
so in 1970 when eric was chasing after pattie, he began dating her little sister paula in an attempt to get closer to her. paula was 17 at the time (ands i know that the age of consent is 16, but the age you become an adult was either 18 or 21 so paula was still technically a child in the eyes of the law). eric and pattie were both in their mid 20s. and when talking about it in her book, pattie showed no concern for paula at all. i believe the quote is something along the lines of “the convent girl in me was scandalized, but i couldnt help but feel excited.” something in the ballpark of that. she knew eric was just using paula to get to her and she didnt seem to care at all.
obviously i feel very bad for pattie with everything she went through, and i understand she was raised in a different time but in my opinion that still doesnt make it okay. what do you all think?
edit: forgot to mention shes also good friends with jimmy page, another man who sexually abused a child.
r/beatles • u/alfayellow • Dec 30 '25
She was a favorite of all the Beatles. Has anyone heard comment from Paul or Ringo?
r/beatles • u/bindwardi • Dec 19 '23
r/beatles • u/1840_NO • Jun 19 '25
In my defense, I had only ever heard this song passively and I just assumed it was John due to the slap back echo and reverb. The song was playing in my head so I looked it up on Spotify and I was surprised to see it was a Wings song. The song also sounds a bit grittier than Paul's songs from around that time.
r/beatles • u/Expensive-Stuff3781 • Feb 10 '25
To his credit, Sean seems to avoid the drama and commend Kendrick as an artist. A valid take.
r/beatles • u/DayTripper73 • Apr 04 '26
r/beatles • u/SurvivorFanDan • Apr 26 '26
r/beatles • u/nickjlamb • Sep 23 '24
Here’s my track list:
Back in the U.S.S.R.
Dear Prudence
Glass Onion
While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Blackbird
Happiness is a Warm Gun
I’m So Tired
Julia
Helter Skelter
Revolution 1
Mother Nature’s Son
Sexy Sadie
Cry Baby Cry
r/beatles • u/That_guy826 • Sep 28 '25
Don’t get me wrong, I like The Beach Boys. But compared to the Beatles I see them as a middle school band who picked up instruments for the first time last week. I would rather listen to blue jay way than any other beach boys song, and that’s not even the best Beatles song
r/beatles • u/obama69420duck • Mar 26 '26
r/beatles • u/John_In_Parts • Aug 15 '23
I honestly can't think of one. Maybe "Magical Mystery Tour"...
r/beatles • u/[deleted] • Sep 22 '21
It's the only album of theirs I still haven't listened to all the way through, but I'm a little hesitant to since I've heard so many people say it's their worst album. Do you think that's true? Does it still have some highs that make the overall experience worth it? I just figure that maybe posting and talking about it will give me further incentive to give it a listen. The only songs from it I've remembered hearing are Get Back, Don't Let Me Down and (obviously) Let it Be.