r/bannersaga • • Jul 13 '21

Discussion Great series but some of it is ruined by story immersion breaks (SPOILERS) Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Really great series, but parts of it don't hold up the story.

For example, in game 2 I didn't actually choose to destroy the bridge. I helped fasolt defend it for three days before ivar eventually convinced the varl king to consent to destroying the bridge.

This seems to have been totally lost when the third game hits as fasolt (and the game) still treats you as if you chose to destroy the bridge when, in reality, I tried my best to defend it.

There's no option for me to say this either.

There are other issues as well, for example in game 2 when bolverk is on a 'death march' you can still make camp and literally rest for a full week in the middle of your 'not stopping for anything death march'

In game 2 when you leave the town in the old woods you still get a moral hit from staying at the town even if you didn't actually rest there.

It's really unfortunate because the game has great potential but these kinds of holes just show a lack of attention to detail and it can really throw off the immersion the game is working so hard to create.


r/bannersaga • • Feb 03 '24

Discussion I feel robbed after BS3 Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Ive helped on patreon, bought all 3 games, on multiple devices even, and just finished another play BS1-3 earlier..

I love the game, the mechanics, the hard ship, that sometimes you are not given good items on the market on some playthroughs, that my caravan is never gonna have a great morale again after the mid game so and so.

But like the title, I really feel robbed that after all that,

SPOILER**

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

The ending was... not bad but... lacking...

Bolverk being the final enemy was really underwhelming... He was scary in BS2, I even made him strong just for the added difficulty, but bs3 with the increase to lvl 15, items and titles. Bolverk was just another dredge. In spite I had Eyvind one shot him with 35 strength from umbrage/mend combo.

The Snake should may have been much better, or atleast a warped Bolverk is much better.

WTF happened to bellower? Bolverk doesnt seem to be taken by bellower anymore and yet red dude is gone... Immortal my ass. Would have been better if Juno and Bellower were buddy buddies by the end when the world ended.

Alette's love story with Egil was forgotten, what happened when Iver got back with the caravan, to Folka and the ravens, to Ludin, the republic after? Uhm Varls just died after 100 yrs I guess?

Did Dredge and horseborn co-existed peacefully?
All we had is if Alette dies, she meets her parents (best ending for her i guess, since Egil was thrown under the bus anyways) and Iver making Juno's godstone...

Like god damn its so easy to give us just a bit more of those credit drawings for our satisfaction. The story was already grim, and the ending gave hope.

Then fkn give us the hope!

THey could've literally took some fan arts, or asked arts from fans that would give some visuals for the aftermath of the good/bad ending.

but naaah, done with the money and on to the next!

fk.. done with my rant, gonna play again next yr.


r/bannersaga • • Apr 26 '18

Creation Banner Saga X MLP fan art!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/bannersaga • • Nov 07 '21

Discussion Characters of color in Banner Saga

3 Upvotes

I was surprised to see some brown/black characters in this game since it is inspired by Vikings. Although I shouldn't have been, as at that time I didn't know a very few brown and black people did end up in Scandinavia due to raids or joining as adventurers.

That said I have seen characters that look brown, black or at least very swarthy (Mediterranean complexion). And I'm not talking about just looking partly brown (that would be common for people in the older eras as they didn't have so many items for cleaning and beautification), but outright dark skin.

Some of the varls and humans look outright dark-skinned. This seems to be a conscious choice. But it doesn't go overboard and accurately reflects the presence of PoC in Scandinavia at that time, you won't find a lot of dark-skinned characters. So hey hooray to Stoic and sticking up for diversity!


r/bannersaga • • Jan 05 '17

Anybody else want to see an open world BS3?

0 Upvotes

It would be awesome if we could open the map and pick a location and start traveling there. And for the main quest you just go to the next location where the main quest is taking place. But if you don't want to do it then you could treasure hunting.


r/bannersaga • • Jul 17 '20

Discussion I wish I had not bought this game.

1 Upvotes

This game has no respect for my time at all. The game rewrites your saves whenever it feels like it, so unless you get in there and wrangle the save files directly, you don't really have an ability to backtrack without hours of effort. And you might kill one of your guys with a dialogue option (oops) or get chewed up in a fight because you misclicked and moved the wrong person to the wrong square. I'm not a kid anymore. I can't sacrifice hours of my time coping with the fact that the game has a brutalist attitude towards consequences.


r/bannersaga • • Feb 23 '24

Question Trying to enjoy the banner saga but

0 Upvotes

So I dont want to troll, but I'm trying to enjoy the game as I played it till the end at launch and gave up on the final fight since it seemed unbalanced. Trying to play it now is agonizing since I got heavily into wargaming and a lot of "obvious" stuff is just not there.

- Enemies can just walk all of the way to my backline past all of my troops and pound them to death and no amount of movement or positioning seems to stops this

- my troops *need* kills to level up so they simply aren't except for the varl who have enormous amounts of hp and strength and kick tons of ass, which means they're getting all of the EXP and stuff like my protagonists are not

- the game is unclear on just how much of their shield I need chunk down before I can hit their strength

- the golem things have a really fucking annoying ability where if I do hit them with an archer, they just immediately get a free attack on someone they're next to, what gives?

It's a shame, I really like the world and stuff but the gameplay just seems pointlessly punishing, and I'm a *Blood Bowl* fan, a literal "your best guy who you leveled up for months of play just slipped, broke his neck and died. fuck you. it's turn 1" game. I'd be fine if there was an engagement system or something that prevented the golems from going "oh, surrounded? I'll just step out of it and go hit your archer again (she's dead again, lol)" but it just seems like the battle system has absolutely no depth whatsoever


r/bannersaga • • Mar 24 '25

Discussion Isnt this just Ragnarök?

0 Upvotes

Title... well, i mean i just played the first title so far so idk what happens in the second and third one. But all i saw right until now is Ragnarök. The Dregde is the world burn Surtur. All gods are dead, just like the Arsen (nordic gods) in ragnarök. The Dregde are probably the Jötnar.

Why is write this is because, as far as i'm aware, the developers said they did not want to make an adaption of ragnarök but just get influenced by vikings and nordic Mythology. But this is obviously Ragnarök. Isnt it?


r/bannersaga • • Apr 02 '18

Can I play banner saga1 without using varles( Giants)?

2 Upvotes

I really don't like them and don't want to use them in battles too.

I would like to play only humans parties.

Thanks for the answer. It's shame to read some comments thought...


r/bannersaga • • Jul 02 '20

Discussion Brief Discussion Comparing Banner Sage 3 to Divinity Original Sin 2

0 Upvotes

Divinity Original Sin 2 was mentioned here in the recent past by 1 person as being a better or comparable tactics game, but people at r/DivinityOriginalSin have said that Divinity Original Sin 2 is not a tactics game. That it's mainly an rpg

Banner Sage 3 is a tactics game

For Divinity Original Sin 2, most people have said this game is good for tactical play / combat

But 1 person here said that builds don't matter as much as story. They said "fights get repetitive very soon and at that point you will quit eventually anyway so why bother"

People generally say it's better to pick Lohse for the story. I don't care about the story. Is really boring and long. Seems like 99% of the text and choices does not matter to the actual game of turn based tactical combat. So it's pointless to read any of it. It takes too long to get the next battle

The vast amount of people have said this game is good for tactical play / combat, but are they mistaken? Since 1 person here said that fights get repetitive

This is a tactical rpg, but maybe it's mainly just an rpg?

For companion, what companion you choose is meaningless if you just want to play the combat, someone said. So I guess this doesn't matter: Do any of the companions provide more interesting tactical play than the other options? https://www.gamersdecide.com/articles/divinity-original-sin-2-best-companions

The best guide seems to be on https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=Fextralife&sp=CAMSBAgFEAE%253D

But maybe none of this matters? Does any of these builds have the most interesting tactics?

Or should pick a different hero/person? Skills + talents are all part of the builds so don't care about those stuff. It's on the site that has the builds for the most interesting tactics

What's the best build for interesting tactics?

What's the best site that ranks builds by the most interesting tactics the build provides?

The vast majority of people have this game is good for tactical play / combat, but it seems most people on this Reddit is saying that's not the case? Do we have like totally different players or something?

Is it cos most people are casual players, and the players on r/DivinityOriginalSin played the game so much that they're hardcore players, and find the tactics combat boring? Is that what's going on?

How could there be such different groups of players with such mixed msgs? Those within r/DivinityOriginalSin and the rest of people outside of r/DivinityOriginalSin who apparently doesn't have the understanding that people in r/DivinityOriginalSin have ? Does everyone else have such an extreme lack of understanding of this game that apparently those in r/DivinityOriginalSin has?

Most people have said this game is good for tactical play / combat. Is that not the case and other games would be better for this? If so, what tactics game? I guess most people in r/DivinityOriginalSin are rpg players, and not tactics players, so I guess they won't know about this


r/bannersaga • • Feb 13 '17

I hate how Oddlief looks

2 Upvotes

Honestly, I love these games and this is just a tiny gripe of mine lol. I just hate how all of the OGs from Skogr look like nice, average townsfolk, and then there is Oddlief who looks like an ice fairy princess. Idk, it just kind of breaks the immersion for me. Is there a mod anyone knows of that maybe changes her appearance? I don't want my Rook romancing Elsa of Arrendeile!


r/bannersaga • • Jul 29 '18

Question [SPOILER][Egil dies defending Rook, and nobody cares](/s) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So I sided with the king, the caravan is moving around the breaches the Ruin made, I accepted the plan with oil barrels (At first turn I shoot her with Rook and she healed herself to max, so this plan sucked anyway).

But when we were moving to stop the breaches, first was the menders - I helped them collect stone and wood, Villagers - I took them in. And then the trap happened, It followed something like this:

Attacker runned through with this blade through Egil 2 times, because he standed between them to defend him. He basiclly saved Rook's life, hes no longer in heros building and nobody even said anything about his death. Is this bug or devs just hate him?


r/bannersaga • • Nov 04 '21

Question Newb here. Am I missing something?

0 Upvotes

So I saw this game as one of the most recommended games and bought it(saga2. Never played 1 before.). played couple of hours but oh boy. I feel so bored. The story may be interesting for those who had played part1, but for my part, I can only understand one or two things and they dont even seem that important in the plot. So what is the catch? Is this supposed to get interesting later? Should I ask for refund?


r/bannersaga • • Mar 25 '16

Bellows fight completely ruined game.

0 Upvotes

What the fuck were the devs thinking when they increased difficulty by 15 magnitudes for the bellows fight?

Sure it's supposed to be a bit harder, but by the time I've reloaded the fucking fight for the 25th time(for comparison I didn't lose a single fucking fight in the entire game previously, on normal setting, yet I still kept dying like a bitch against Bellows on easy) and finally beat that fucker the story of the games doesn't exist anymore, it's a game-mechanic puzzle with no emotional potential by that point, assuming you didn't simply alt+f4:ed out and uninstalled it.

So when I finally finished that shit whatever comes after means nothing anymore, whatever story that was carefully put together before was by that point completely pissed away.

Put a Red-Blue button switch in there instead if you want to compete with ME3 for worst game ending ever instead.

Great job on the devs part on throughly shitting away 18 hours of interesting game on the final hour(s) by turning the gameplay into rancid sphincter burning diarrhea.


r/bannersaga • • Jul 03 '25

Question just started playing and the random strength damage is annoying. one round im doing 4 damage and then next 1 damage with all defense on the enemy gone. wtf, and how does this shield and damage work because right now it seems like breaking defense sucks. I get more damage at the beginning (1st turn).

3 Upvotes

r/bannersaga • • Jun 12 '17

Ash of Gods Kickstarter

Thumbnail
kickstarter.com
5 Upvotes

r/bannersaga • • Jul 17 '18

Discussion Making The Banner Saga Trilogy physical release require a download on Nintendo Switch is greedy and insulting to core fans.

7 Upvotes

https://gonintendo.com/stories/313722-the-banner-saga-trilogy-physical-release-requires-a-download-ten

It seems that the physical release of The Banner Saga Trilogy will be compromised on Nintendo Switch. The retail box features a banner which states that a download is required to play the game and the cart will not hold the data, used similarly by Bethesda's Wolfenstein II.

In Wolfenstein II, the download is understandable. The game is clearly above 16gb in storage, and therefore would only fit on the presumably very expensive 32gb card, which would make it hard to sell for a reasonable price.

For The Banner Saga Trilogy, the download is not understandable. The entire Trilogy seems to be around 13gb, which would clearly fit on a 16gb card. Many games are on 16gb cards and are priced fairly.

The only reason for this seems to be greed. Using a lower, cheaper cartridge denomination to force the storage costs onto the consumer. This kind of behaviour is to be expected from large public companies like Capcom peddling games to audiences that might not be aware. However The Banner Saga is a game series that has enjoyed popularity from primarily a more core audience, and we notice.

Sabotaging the physical release in this manner almost completely invalidates the point of buying physical. We buy physical to save on storage costs, and to have a physical item which is appealing and will serve as a permanent offline copy of that game. You've pushed a good bit of the storage cost onto us on a system which already has an issue with storage, you've ruined the box art with that daft banner, and you've made the retail version useless as a physical archive.

Was a sure buy before I knew about this, certainly won't be buying now.


r/bannersaga • • Oct 12 '24

Question [Spoilers] What are the difficulty spikes of Banner Saga 2 & 3? Spoiler

8 Upvotes

I just finished the first Banner Saga and I've got to say that the experience has been nothing short of nerve wrecking, the game is extremely difficult and not in the most fair of ways. In general, it really seems like it's one of those games where it's very easy to end up in an unfinishable save unless you read the fucking walkthrough, which is really disapointing.

In the first game, there are two moments where the game pretty much decides to just cheat on you.

The first one is when you have to fight on the bridge at Einartoft. My entire party got wiped out in the fight to save Eyvind, save for Rook. But then the game takes away from you the ability to rest your characters which forces me into unwinnable fights, since it's impossible to win when your entire party is wounded. I get curbstomped and am forced to flee at the first opportunity without blowing the bridge, I don't know how much of a good outcome it is and hope it won't come back to bite me in the ass later.

The second one is when you get to Boersgard. First the game takes away your ability to rest and forces you into fights to be curbstomped, and then in the last fight against Howler you are forced to pick Alette, a character which I did not invest any XP, therefore I was forced to get in the fight with a useless unit and the fight was unwinnable. I order to finish the game I had to lower the difficulty down to easy which is as shameful as it can get.

Now I'm not really against games that are difficult, but I really FUCKING HATE IT when the developpers take cheap shots at you and just decide to pull the rug under your feet.

I'm not asking to be completly spoiled, but I would very much like to know what I should watch out for in the following games so I can be prepared for it.


r/bannersaga • • Apr 01 '17

Humor Know your Banner Saga Memes

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/bannersaga • • Apr 21 '16

The Banner Saga [Zagrajmy](https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLGb9qv7LhehyYkYMEEHySTNuye-CQIF_i)

0 Upvotes

Polecam nową serię Zagrajmy The Banner Saga, w której Huntterr próbuje przeżyć w mrocznym świecie, pełnym wyzwań i niebezpieczeństw.


r/bannersaga • • Jul 26 '18

100% solid (US) release date?

0 Upvotes

Can somebody please tell me the official set in stone release date for US? Xbox's store release date says it released 16 minutes ago (10pm central) but that's a lie because I still can't play the game. So I want a official date and time please.


r/bannersaga • • Jun 01 '16

The Adoring Fan

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/bannersaga • • Jan 19 '14

Madbird plays the Banner Saga playlist

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/bannersaga • • Jan 11 '19

Discussion [SPOILER]Just finished Banner Saga 2. Enjoyed it a lot until the shit-fucking-ending. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Really enjoyed the diverting stories, the characters and the increasing mystery. I'm fucking pissed off at how absolutely dogshit the ending is, which isn't even a cliffhanger as much as it is a slap in the face. It comes out of absolutely nowhere, makes any and all choices I've made seemingly irrelevant and explains nothing, clears nothing up, just suddenly tossing me into some idiotic fight that is pointless.

Banner Saga 1 ended on a cliffhanger, but still had a moment of magic with the corpse sendoff. This bullshit ends abruptly and gives absolutely no closure.

What was the point in me killing the Eyeless with the Ravens? I was proud of having pulled that off, thought it would matter. What about the Stonesinger I saved? What was all that darkness and shit about? What's Eyvind and Juno up to? Why does my boy Bolverk, that I fought so bloody hard to survive with, have to get fucked?

Eyvind and Juno, who seem to be absolutely psycho, go apeshit and Eyvind shoots lightning all over in some random-ass tower.

Fuck I hate being baited into buying the THIRD game in the installment just to maybe find out what happens to the world and what the fuck is going on.

Grah! GRRR! Greedy fuckin' devs. I was pumped for Banner Saga 3 until it became clear they decided to end Banner Saga 2 in the middle of nowhere.

Tell me, does Banner Saga 3 resolve anything? Or is it another bullshit fucking ending that takes 0 into account of the choices you made along the path?


r/bannersaga • • Apr 30 '16

Anyone has a spare Banner Saga 1 key?

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, if any of you happens to have a spare Banner Saga key I'd love to have it! Have some games to trade you too if you are interested. PM me please!