HYYH really went off really great for the boys because not only they did a concept that was unique at that time, HYYH pt.1 and 2 showed a more clear direction for the boys music-wise and (arguably) their identity that they have established now.
But the recent comebacks esp this one was, imo, kinda went far. Bighit has been milking the whole HYYH concept for 3 years now and created a narrative where each of the boys faces their own struggles. (Although I havent read too deeply into the hyyh notes, the HYYH era ended for me at Young Forever, where it should have ended). Although it's good that they're bringing all these issues into the spotlight, I think it has gone way too far at this point, like for when things kind of blew up with using the queercore collection
BTS has been known for openly talking about sensitive issues and I think this association with them being "woke" led to fans putting meaning in almost every content they put out. While it's good that they're using their popularity to bring awareness to certain issues, I feel like sometimes fans are just way too quick in jumping into conclusions.
This is dangerous because issues such as mental health, gender equality, and even their criticisms against capitalism are both personal AND societal issues. When you keep on associating the boys with being woke on these things (which made it worse because bighit keeps on extending the hyyh storyline), you are putting the burden on them to reflect all of these (systemic) issues, when in fact, they can because theyre too busy to engage deeply and learn more about the things they are supposed to advocate (for example, they can't possible know about the history and meaning of queercore). The things that helped established their identity and popularity can also backfire on them because if they failed to deliver--either by falling short or misrepresenting the issue, theyre gonna get some backlash, especially from international fans.
I feel like I'm probably one of the few fans who have concerns like this. I'd like to know what yall think as well
Edit: I don't know if this post will still be read by others but here goes LMAO
First of all, I would like to apologize for my poorly organized post. I didn't put more references and expounded my arguments better. English is also not my native language so I apologize if certain words made my arguments unclear and murky.
Because of this, I would also like to clarify some things regarding my post:
I am not asking fans to censor themselves when it comes to theorizing, since its now an important part of the fandom culture
I am not also asking fans to change how they theorize things, rather, I wanted to (1) present the dangers of how fans are currently theorizing, some of which are already happening; and (2) suggest a way to improve how we theorize, and (3) expand how we look at societal issues in a wider perspective because, these issues are not just our own only.
I am criticizing Bighit on the trajectory of their concepts since HYYH.
I am not blaming fans for these criticisms, but what I wanted to say is that Bighit used this particular fandom culture of theorizing to their advantage and capitalized on it.
As u/HeroicQuirk pointed out, Bighit welcomes (and imo, had a major role in creating) this image of BTS being a "socially conscious group" by:
incorporating input from the boys (BTS's creative freedom--nothing wrong with that)
fandom culture of theorizing (usually a good thing, but i can see issues that could arise if not handled well)
dragging the HYYH narrative by introducing new plots, new character backgrounds, and elaborating on the themes subtle introduced during the start of HYYH such as mental health and self-harm
The more connections (with socially relevant issues such as things mentioned above) are made the longer HYYH keeps on going, the stronger the association is with BTS with being "socially conscious", which presents a lot of dangers, and also leading to another clarification for this post.
6. There's nothing wrong with taking risks, after all, opposing ideals, although there's a good chance it can lead to disruption, allows us in fully explaining and understanding our thoughts. But what I'm worried about, more than the backlash and being problematic, are things concerning the fandom, BTS's creative output from hereon out, and the social issues BTS have presented so far.
u/wishawisha's tweet regarding theories being interpreted as irl facts [Clarification 6.1: Not all fans are like this, but I think that considering that posts like that have been made reminding fans to distinguish between what is real and what is not, I feel like this is an issue that at least, needed to be brought up]
BTS's creative output has been mainly relying on the culture of theorizing, putting symbols and cryptic messages here and there. Basically, their outputs were made to be vague, leaving room for fans to interpret. This is dangerous because most of these revolve around personal and societal issues, like mental health. These issues are not only relevant and relatable, but are also complex that is experienced not only limited in an individual level, but can be seen in our society in general.
Note: This looks like a topic that is completely irrelevant. I mean, maybe it's not that deep, but I've known people who have been experiencing the same struggles BTS has presented throughout their career: in their advocacy (women empowerment) the themes in their narratives (mental health) and the issues presented in their discography (such as critiques and negative, oppressive societal effects of capitalism). I got to learn how these issues affected them, and I've seen them passionately fight for these rights and critique the status quo and I've learned a lot from them.
What I'm saying is that...these are not just fictional narratives. These go beyond than mere interpretations of art. They are very real, and there are people risking their lives fighting for these rights and standing up to the oppressive status quo.
These issues are very important to me, and the reason why I stanned BTS was because they were able to bring light and awareness to these concerns. But, I think that post-HYYH concepts especially are leaning toward taking these issues RELATIVELY [as opposed to their previous songs] lightly because of how things are made to be vague.
I was trying to lay out the dangers of having BTS's content being put out in a vague way, mainly because:
Most of these revolve around personal and societal issues, like mental health
When discussing about these issues, its important that we need to be clear as to what extent and how deep these issues are being presented and reflected in their contents
There's nothing wrong with being socially conscious, but it's dangerous to make this as BTS's image mainly because it sets expectations for the boys to tackle issues like these. When there's a demand for socially relevant concepts, there's a chance that research on issues may be done in haste, which can lead to mistakes or misrepresenting the issue itself. In a way, it limits the boys to a certain (really demanding) standard, and when there's limited time to research and more importantly, immerse yourself and learn more about these issues through experience, ideally both in a personal and a societal level, it may result in criticisms not just from the public, but more importantly, from the people who are advocating for these issues on the ground.
Kinda Final thoughts:
Yes, I agree that people have the choice to follow to the storyline or not. But reading this thread, I have also come to realize that post-HYYH concepts are made for people who can follow to the storyline. I personally don't know how to feel about that. Of course, I enjoy listening to their music, and I love their personalities, and I always love hearing their thoughts and opinions on both complex and mundane issues.
I think A LOT of you will disagree with me on this, but at the end of the day, BTS is still a kpop group. As someone who became a fan during Danger era, I love them of their entirety whether their concept is an angsty boyfriend (Danger), or being cheesy romantic dudes (Haruman, For You). If there's one thing that sets kpop from others, its the ability to become one out of many concepts, and I really want to see a new side of them, even if its just a simple or heck, even cringey concept or MV .
I think there are still a lot of stuff I haven't explained, but there's not a lot reading this post anymore so idek why I did this lmaooo