r/bananocoin • u/TheProject2501 • Jun 11 '18
Open letter to the devs
One of the devs asked what kind of distribution was expected from the meme coin.
So here is my answer and a rant: (I'm posting it again as a new post for visibility)
I expected a fair distribution... One getting 46K Banano for having 120 nano and the other getting 19k Banano for having 6 NANO accounts with total less then 10K NANO is not fair.
The distribution was not done transparently, the rules were not set or followed. Participants were mislead. Trust has been broken. What was the goal? To randomly reward someone who had a small amount of NANO? To penalize (Why penalties??? especially in a meme coin???) someone who uses good practice of not having all their coins in one address? To penalize those who supported Nano project?
We (participants) were asked/offered to enter multiple XRB addresses only to be penalized for it... Why?
Collecting and abusing of IP addresses in this way was not moral and since GDPR maybe even illegal.
What is next? Next version of Banano Runner will track what phone I have and if it is a mid tier or high end tier phone I will get less banano in comparison to someone playing on a lower end phone? Will you track ping so that those with better ping may be considered wealthy and they should not get as much banano? etc...
I was very excited about this project although I played banano runner only 1 time. Now I don't even know how to feel. Reading developers answers in this thread I'm getting that devs don't even care.
This project seemed to have a fantastic potential of gathering crypto enthusiasts and also those who are totally new to the game while keeping everything fun and light. Unfortunately without firm foundations in sense of keeping your own rules, transparency, keeping your word etc. that will be very hard to achieve...
I've never been envious for someone else's success and I'm very glad that all who participated got banano. I hope that those who are living in a very bad conditions got more than enough to help them at least for some time. In the same time I feel bad for being penalized for something I didn't even know was wrong and I still don't think is wrong to have your coins in more addresses/accounts.
While I'm expressing my opinion, I must add that I find those flash/quick "games" that occasionally appear on the announcement channel not helpful in distributing the banano. For some reason I don't get any notifications although I tried setting it up. Even if I was getting notifications I either work or sleep during that time because of the time zones. Such flash giveaways should be better organized or left for the community to perform them. It also raises suspicion when devs announce something that is over so quickly that most people doesn't even have a chance to see it and even less to participate in it...
Also please use the announcement channels to spread a complete and thorough information. A thing like: "oh, btw, we have sent bananos via airdrop if you haven't noticed..." is not an announcement. Participants are left wondering what were the ratios and rules how the distribution was performed and are left with doing detective work on multiple platforms and endless scrolling on the ever growing chats to maybe find an answer and if they dare asking valid questions on reddit they are replied with snarky answers by the devs... Not a good thing to have.