Overview
As previously announced, r/Baltimore went private from June 12 through June 14th, and that remained in place through June 15th. This was done in solidarity with subreddits such as /r/blind and /r/Save3rdPartyApps, and with the thousands of other subreddits that - with the support of their users - chose to set their subreddits to either restricted mode or to private mode.
The net effect of this was widespread. Media coverage has been nonstop, reddit's advertisers are not happy, and reddit has been on an active disinformation campaign. In our initial assessment of how long the subreddit might remain private, we chose to wait for reddit's now-infamous AMA which was nothing short of a disaster. Coming out of that, we were absolutely unimpressed with the response from reddit leadership and their refusal to commit to providing tools that have been promised for years, and yet are still unavailable the better part of 20 years into reddit's existence.
How We Got Here
We presented our intention to shutdown to /r/baltimore, and the support was overwhelming. The question we find ourselves faced with is this: with the previously indicated period having ended, where do we go from here? The one thing that we are not going to do is give up and give in. This is not going to be an Instagram Black Square moment. Reddit leadership has been spreading the message that this will all blow over and that they're clearly not taking individual subreddits seriously.
What Came Next
The question you are likely wondering at this time is why we did not immediately reopen after the initially stated duration. The answer is that there has been a lack of desire to reopen subsequent to the indications of reddit and the sub-standard responses from administration. Nothing has changed from the part of reddit. They continue to refuse to provide answers, and we have no idea when the necessary tools we need to effectively moderate will come, nor have we seen an indication that reddit administration will be more responsive to issues faced by subreddits at large. Indeed, locally, /r/baltimore has been a continued frequent target of brigading from subreddits such as /r/CharmCity, /r/Conservative, and /r/Conspiracy - particularly after persons who violate subreddit rules are banned. Reddit has done nothing to stop this despite numerous reports. Concurrently, Reddit's own feature to identify accounts dodging bans does not work; and, while there are much more heavy-handed actions we can take to mitigate these accounts, the problem is that they would have negative ramifications for new and other users acting in good faith. We have not wanted to stifle their ability to participate and have avoided such actions as a result. Further, several attempts have been made to dox moderators of this subreddit with absolutely zero assistance from reddit in addressing the problem. Reddit has not actioned reports of revenge porn posted to this subreddit, sustained harassment campaigns, nor instances where persons have posted outright threats of violence - with specifically named targets and times.
Where We Are Now
As of now, it is our understanding that /r/blind, /r/ModCoord, and /r/Save3rdPartyApps are working on a next course of action. Concurrently, several other subreddits have remained private. Likewise, there are several subreddits that have ended their shutdown and resumed normal activity as public subreddits. In the middle, you have several subreddits that have gone into various states of Restricted - whether it be on a temporary basis, on a indefinite basis, or in the intermediary within which they are conducting various forms of polls ranging from using attempting to use the reddit poll feature, to attempting to use comment voting in order to determine the community's position on how to proceed. To that end, at this moment, you're probably wondering which way /r/Baltimore will be proceeding.
Going Forward
At this time, and for the immediate future, /r/Baltimore will not be reopening. Instead, the subreddit will be shifting from Private to Restricted in order to share this message, and to give persons a space within which to discuss, provide feedback, and just generally have a place to engage in.
Why are we not conducting a poll or engaging in a vote? The simple answer is that the veracity of them cannot be trusted. The short of the long is that there are too many ways for these methodologies to be abused in order to trust that they can be done in a fair and equitable manner. The longer version of that is as follows.
Reddit provides no means to restrict polls nor voting to actual subscribed members of a community - particularly those with a long standing history. This would also have the net effect of unintentionally restricting the most affected users - those who utilize reddit by way of third-party applications, and ironically those who use old.reddit.com - from being able to participate in the polling, and thus creating an environment where persons could not equitably participate in the process.
Likewise, when it comes to voting by way of providing comments, banned users are still able to upvote and downvote comments, regardless of whether or not they are subscribed to the specific subreddit. Also, nothing is there to stop users from downvoting the comment representing the action that they disagree with - therefore any such vote would inherently misrepresent the will of the persons involved - regardless of the result. This would not be fair to anyone.
Conversely, bot activity has risen significantly on reddit in the last week. Indeed, ChatGPT has frequently (and without even a hint of subtlety) been used to astroturf a wide-ranging number of subreddits across this website. Indeed, on the frequent t-shirt spamming posts that have been made here, we've seen these spam bots post them, the posts get caught by AutoModerator, and they'll still manage to reply to them and upvote them with literally over 50 upvotes while the post are still not visible on the subreddit.
In our last note and in our subreddit description, it was indicated that /r/baltimore /m/Baltimore indeed now has a present on KBin. Likewise, /r/Baltimore maintains a presence on Discord. Unfortunately, we do not yet have a group on ~tildes, but the tag usa.md.baltimore indeed does exist therein.
While moderators and users site-wide collaborate to determine the next steps, we'll remain in restricted mode for the time being. For more information on where things stand in general, please visit /r/Save3rdPartyApps.