r/baldursgate • • Oct 11 '23

Meme Imoen, the best pink-haired girl

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/baldursgate • • Sep 16 '25

BG3 (Series Lore) I wish they didn't call it "Baldur's Gate 3"

468 Upvotes

The game is very good, don't get me wrong, but it feels like it doesn't have a strong connection to the previous titles. I wish they made it more like a spin-off of sort, kinda like the Dark Alliance titles

Also the fact that every single NPC is horny as Hells is a bit off putting


r/baldursgate • • May 12 '24

Baldurs Gate 4

5 Upvotes

Hey,

I played all bgs and now bg3… And I just don’t like it as much as bg2. I wanted to like it but it’s not the same…

Will we ever have another game like bg2? Even pillars felt off


r/baldursgate • • Dec 31 '22

Tiefling Joe Biden. It's time to Build Baldur's Gate Back Better! Voice Pack coming soon for BG1&2

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/baldursgate • • Dec 15 '23

BGEE The way the game strips control of your char sucks ass

0 Upvotes

I enjoy Baldur's Gate a lot but I've gotten more and more fed up with the game's trend of fake choices often with instant death punishment for noncompliance. Like holy shit the writing gets so bad at times it actually makes me mad.

  • If you tell a specific "polite" bandit to lay down and let you kill him he steals your money in a cutscene and disappears.

  • You're not allowed to refuse having a nymph kiss you and KO one of your party members.

  • When you get Soultaker dagger a cultist shows up and teleports the dagger out of your inventory to do their cultist shit.

  • Eltan press gangs you into helping him, and if you say no he instantly kills you in a cutscene. This is a supposedly "honorable" individual btw.

  • An assassin magically poisons you with a super special epic poison which can't be cured even if you haven't rested anywhere in Baldur's Gate and he wouldn't have the chance to do so. If you don't take his partner seriously you will die and can easily get yourself softlocked.

  • If you don't surrender to the Gatewarden after you're accused in Candlekeep they instantly kill you in a cutscene. You're not allowed to fight or flee from Candlekeep.

  • If you agree to meet Angelo you have no option to fight him then and there and if you aggravate him he instantly chunks one of your party members and puts you in jail anyways.

BG2 is a lot better about this in general but it still has plenty of bullshit writing. It's really interesting looking so far back and seeing how much writing in games has improved to emphasize player freedom because man it feels bad to have the game just instant kill you for not playing along exactly how it wants you too lol.


r/baldursgate • • Feb 27 '20

BG3 BG3 has nothing to do with the BG 1 and 2 besides setting - couldnt be disappointed more

20 Upvotes

If you showed this PAX gameplay footage of bg3 to thousand crpg fans familiar with bg and dos series not one of them would try to guess that this is bg3, eveyones guess d be dos3 - that imo speaks for itself

I hoped that larian will approach this in a same honest way as Obsidian did with PoE - create new engine with up to date graphics (like in Poe 1 or 2) while maintaining atmosphere and themes of the original series ....

instead Larian took the lazy way out - reused old dos engine

larian purchased world setting and name and decided to cash in on the baldurs gate brand .. i see this as sleazy disgusting marketing tactics which i would expect to see from someone like EA ... I didnt see it coming from Larian . very disappointed.. i thought they were better than this (loved dos1 and dos2) -

to me this is as if someone decided after 20years to make dark souls 4/sequel with devil may cry combat system and graphics, new counter strike or half life 3 in blizzard's overwatch engine - you got the idea... setting might be the same maybe even ruleset (DnD) but everything else is different game


r/baldursgate • • Feb 07 '25

Rant on BG1 NPC project

0 Upvotes

I have never seen buggier, more immersion breaking, more imbalanced, more vanilla quests interrupting, out of character writing, distracting, unnecessary mod ever.

This is the purest form of bloated ego of a modder. Instead of just enhancing, flavouring here and there you made this. Congratulations.

I hope years after releasing this some deep thinking were done in your minds.. sweet jesus..

I very much agree now with the review from Smoldering Mods. First i was very suprised - why so much criticism? Now i see it for my own eyes.

https://smolderingmodsbar.com/bg1-npc-project/

You can roast me now i don't care. nevertheless I strongly recommend never install that thing.


r/baldursgate • • Feb 27 '20

BG3 After months of being hyped over BG3, I am entitled to my own rant on reddit. Here it goes.

69 Upvotes

What the hell? Is this what we've been waiting for 20 years?

I've been googling "Baldur's gate 3" for 2 decades, reading about rumors, and although I still had a spark of hope, I was mostly coming to the realisation that BG 3 was not going to happen.

This was until I saw this tweet: https://twitter.com/BrianFargo/status/1047967566168174592

This really got my hopes up, and I was anticipating so much that I actually googled "BG3" the very same day Larian released the first hint that BG3 was being made, and I went absolutely bonkers over this.

10 days ago, when Larian announced the worldwide reveal at PAX, I marked my day on my calendar, and counted the hours until the reveal.

And so it begins.

Epic cinematic. Ultra hyped. This is going to be great.

And then, the gameplay!

I should have known...

He doesn't even address the elephant in the room, he just brushes it off with "D&D is turned based so we're turned based" and goes on like nothing happened.

BG was revolutionary for D&D (pen and paper) players such as myself, because it exploited the possibilities of video games to give us a real-time D&D experience. It was truly wonderful to see how Bioware had adapted these old clunky D&D rules to a RTwP game, and still manage to preserve the importance of strategic planning and positioning in combat.

To be honest,the only thing I was afraid about when I head Larian was making BG3 is that they would make it turned-based, but I honestly thought that they wouldn't dare, as it is so essential to the BG games spirit, or so I thought.

And I'm not going to argue about the whole RTwP vs Turned-based thing. I could argue in favor of both. I like RTwP because that's what I played as a kid on BG and it just feels familiar to me.

Ok, hard to swallow, but let's move on.

Swen Vincke then proceeds to show the gameplay of Divinity: Original Sins 3, titled "Baldur's gate 3", in a Forgotten Realms setting.

The only resemblance I found to baldur's gate was the magic missile's icon.

As usual, the fan community will be blamed for being whiny-angry-spoiled little children, but it seems completely unreasonable to me to attach the name "Baldur's Gate" to this game, and not expect the fanbase of the greates CRPG of all times to get upset when it looks nothing like the game we know and love.

I don't understand why they needed to shit on BG's legacy when they just wanted to make DoS 3.

But hey, you can throw your boots for some extra DPS! Thanks Larian.

EDIT:

Why do some people refuse to understand that when you make "something #3", it's natural to assume that it will somehow be related to "something #1 and #2" ?

I don't have anything against Larian making D&D RPGs with WoTC, I just don't agree that's its right to brand something as the third installment of a trilogy if you're going to do your own separate thing (and again, I'm not only talking about RTwP, as it's clear that what we saw has absolutely no connection to BG1&2 in any way, besides taking place in the same world ~100 years later).

Also, is it so hard to understand that it's not fair to the people who were actually waiting for a BG3? You can have your own RPGs ffs, we have the right to like this style of RPGs and to want to play it again, even if other RPGs can be awesome in their own other way.


r/baldursgate • • Feb 29 '20

Now THIS is what Baldur's Gate 3 should have looked and played like. Seven minutes of combat from upcoming Pathfinder game.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

r/baldursgate • • Apr 25 '24

SoD I didn’t realise sod was not created by BioWare

2 Upvotes

I though it was a dlc that came out after bg1 and I thought it was good. I did not realise it was a different team. I thought the writing was good because I didn’t realise it was a different team


r/baldursgate • • Oct 22 '23

Is BG3 well written?

9 Upvotes

I understand that this game has many qualities, and it's often considered a masterpiece. However, there's one aspect that gives me pause when considering a purchase. A few years ago, I bought Divinity: Original Sin 2 because it received heaps of praise. Despite its numerous strengths, such as the best combat system I've ever seen, one significant flaw hindered my enjoyment: the writing. It prevented me from fully appreciating the game. Years later, I purchased Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous, another game hailed as a masterpiece, and once again, despite its many merits, the writing was lackluster, and I lost interest at the end of the first act.

As a writer, my primary source of enjoyment in such games is the story. The game can boast the best combat mechanics globally, but if the story lacks intrigue, I'll lose interest after a few hours (as I experienced with Solasta: Crown of the Magister).

So, I'd like to ask the community if Baldur's Gate 3 delivers quality writing. To provide some context, here's a list of things I disliked in Divinity: Original Sin 2 and Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous:

  1. The world didn't feel as 'fantastic': I'm a huge fan of Tolkien, and I reread his books annually. I adore how Middle Earth feels like a completely different world, with its unique language, cultures, and stories that seem to originate from a context distinct from our own. Rivellon in Divinity: Original Sin 2 was fantastical due to its magic, elves, and monsters, but the world's culture felt somewhat artificial. It seemed like I was watching teenagers pretending to live in a medieval world rather than a genuine medieval setting. I never felt drawn into the various cultures of the world, which resembled a strangely egalitarian feudal society for an era with feudal societies. Pillars of Eternity 1 and 2, in my opinion, excel at crafting an exceptional universe that reflects ethnic and cultural distinctions within each faction through their writing.
    Perhaps my historian side strugglles to much to reconcile feudal societies where everyone seems to share the same moral sensibilities as those of the 21st century.

  2. The story was overwhelming: This is a problem found in many modern video games. Developers appear fixated on creating expansive games with a multitude of quests, factions, and characters. While this isn't inherently a flaw, Divinity: Original Sin 2's story became so convoluted with various factions that by the end, I couldn't even recall my quest's objective. Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous suffered from a similar issue.

  3. The game attempted to blend both humor and extreme seriousness simultaneously: I have no aversion to a touch of humor in my heroic quests, but when writers struggle to incorporate humor without undermining the narrative's urgency and gravitas, the results can be disastrous, unless the game intentionally doesn't take itself too seriously.

In any case, here are some games with writing that I admire: Pillars of Eternity 2, Tyranny (When will we get Tyranny 2?), Mass Effect Trilogy, and Expedition Rome. Do you think that writing this new masterpiece of the genre will disappoint me too?


r/baldursgate • • Mar 01 '20

Why turn-based action is great

0 Upvotes

We can all agree that DnD is a perfect system that works wonderfully when applied to all other media.

DnD novels? Yeah, they should be turn-based. "Mkilnor swung his broadsword in a sweeping ark," yet, due to having rolled a paltry 2, he suffered a critical miss. It was now the malicious mindsnuggler's turn."

DnD film? You guessed it. Turn-based. Maybe the voice-over could announce the results of a charisma roll?

BG3: No question. Turn-based. Nothing beats the sheer immersion of characters standing around stock-still while three goblins take 40 seconds to slightly reposition themselves on the battlefield. Also, since my life revolves around this game, I commend Larian for a system that allows me to spend three hours walking down a corridor filled with dragonbats.

All in all, I think we can all agree the franchise is in good hands because the rules of pen and paper are universal and apply everywhere and should be defended tooth and nail!


r/baldursgate • • Sep 05 '25

Why can't I romance Imoen?

0 Upvotes

She's so cute and she's my childhood friend too!


r/baldursgate • • Feb 28 '20

Search your feelings, you know it to be true.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/baldursgate • • Feb 01 '25

BG2EE Would Jesus Christ be a Mage or a Cleric?

9 Upvotes

Respectfully has anyone tried a Jesus run before? I had this shower thought a while ago about if Jesus would be a Cleric or a mage

Clerics do get divine power through their god which is very similar to what Jesus did but Mages do have a lot of power that work in the same way (Like using alteration to do some kind of miracle)

This is just an interesting question and is not meant to offend anyone's faith.


r/baldursgate • • Mar 02 '24

Should I play 1 and 2 before 3?

0 Upvotes

This question has probably been asked 100 times before but I've been seeing different answers so I thought I'd ask myself. Does it effect the experience in any way?


r/baldursgate • • Mar 18 '26

BG2EE Throne of Bhaal sucks

0 Upvotes

It really does. I know the development history, and yes, I play with Ascension. It still sucks. I played with SCS. The combat was fun but everything else around it...

*High level DND isn't much fun, and if you're past level 30, you are pretty much taking a victory lap.

*The writing is terrible. Like legitimately a total fall off from even BG1

*Part of the reason it suffers is BG2 had very little to do with BG1

*​Watcher's Keep is fun the first time. The second time, you see it's the same key puzzles repeated four times with an annoying maze in the middle.

*It legitimately feels like taking a victory lap on my current trio playthrough. It's an entire game's worth of map painting the last few counties in Crusader Kings.

*Melissan is the worst character ever.

*Every dungeon is microscopic and features an annoying puzzle that is only there to make sure you clear out the tiny map. I'm OP, let me watch my OP character mow through shit.

*Saradush makes Beregost look like NYC.

*The boss set pieces are a 10/10, but everything else is a slog. ​​​

*There is so much padding it's not funny. I'd say everything outside the boss fights and the pocket plane is mostly padding. ​​

But the worst part of it for me is... Why is some grand conflict of armies and godlings seemingly centred around a small desert village and two caves? Once you get past Yaga Shura, that's it. It's distractingly bizarre. Two small caves, at that. And no one ever mentions it again.

It's a shame that it's what concludes the series, really.

And I'm playing with my original CD. It's always bothered me how bad it is. ​


r/baldursgate • • Aug 10 '23

ARE BALDUR’S GATE 1 & 2 STILL WORTH PLAYING?

2 Upvotes

until I get a stream deck or ps5, all I got is Baldur’s Gate 1 and 2 Enhanced Edition on The Switch


r/baldursgate • • Oct 13 '23

Original BG1 Why do people mostly talk about dualing Imoen as Thief>Mage, and not Thief>Illusionist?

0 Upvotes

Is there a particular demand for a generalist mage in BG1, or is it solely because of "canon" reasons regarding her BG2 appearance?


r/baldursgate • • Feb 11 '23

Experience of playing divinity after BG

4 Upvotes

I would just like to share my attempt to complete Divinity Original Sin after both parts of Baldurs Gate. I just finished their walkthrough, they are such cool games, I was in full immersion in the whole plot, atmospheric characters, environment quests and so on. I did not notice how time flew by in the second part of Baldurs Gate, although I spent a lot of time and completed almost all the additional quests. After that, I downloaded Divinity Original Sin, created a character, watched the introduction, which consisted of two sentences: you are a mercenary and you need to kill a crazed magician - THATS ALL. I played 20 minutes, went through the prologue and deleted the game, it was so boring and uninteresting after baldur's gate that I was even disappointed.


r/baldursgate • • Feb 28 '20

Meme I want BG3

Post image
41 Upvotes

r/baldursgate • • Jun 08 '24

Which Baldur's Gate game should I Play after BG3?

0 Upvotes

I've been getting into the Baldur's Gate series because of BG3 and I want to know what games I should play after I finish BG3


r/baldursgate • • Mar 03 '20

BG3 BG3 really a BG Sequel?

23 Upvotes

I really hate how BG3 is being compared to Divinity 2 much more than the games it's meant to be a sequel to, the Infinity Engine BG series. Note this isn't just a community perspective driven by the fact that we know Divinity 2 was developed by Larian, but in the BG3 reveal and interviews since, the developers themselves are talking about the game as if it was some Divinity upgrade.

For example, look at this interview with a writer from Larian Studios:

“We’ve made changes to both [origin and custom] characters. Origin is much deeper and much more complex – the way they relate to each other and the world has also been deepened. The fact you can just be a vampire spawn is a huge change,” he said.

(article)

Wait what? What is an origin character? What part of BG did that come from? Even if we pass off the article's title as being the author's mistake, the devs are clearly picking up right where they left off with Divinity 2, and using BG's good name to do it. I'd really just rather see Divinity 3. At this point I don't care how good the game will be (and it does look good), I don't want to see the BG series high-jacked for basically marketing purposes.

I would have loved to see Beamdog do BG3 in the infinity engine =/ Instead we have WotC trying to push the 5e rules into a new computer game, and Larian Studios (who look really good at making games) making a Divinity sequel and calling it BG3.


r/baldursgate • • Feb 10 '24

Possible hot take about a certain third installment to a classic cRPG franchise

0 Upvotes

Now that the smoke has cleared on Baldur’s Gate 3, I think we can move from the honeymoon phase to the realistic conversation phase. I love bg3, I’ve loved it since early access, so I’m not an oldhead mad that times change. But I don’t think BG3 should be called BG3, I don’t think it’s similar enough in spirit or mechanically to be a successor. A great cRPG, yeah, a fun dnd game, of course, but for a game that says it’s the 3rd Baldur’s Gate, it’s not even the halfway close to resembling it. I find myself wishing that BG3 had been done by Owlcat because BG1 and 2 have more similarities to the Pathfinder games than BG3. Larian (for as much as I respect them) made a D:OS 2.5 set in the dnd universe, not a third Baldur’s Gate.

TLDR: bg3 is fun but I think it should’ve created by developers who would’ve stayed true to the Infinity Engine era.