r/bakker • • Dec 29 '25

I find r/Malazan to be the worst place to talk about Malazan or anything really.. so I’ll do it here.

3 Upvotes

I see so many comparisons between Erikson’s work and Bakker’s Second Apocalypse.

After reading The Second Apocalypse, I took note of all the unending opinions of Erikson’s Malazan series as some kind of equal, or at least equal in quality.

“If you finished Second Apocalypse, then you are definitely ready for Malazan.”…. Is a piece of wisdom I hear often.

I’ve heard Erikson being worshiped for his prose, world building, ideas, philosophical depth, intellectual value, seriousness, mythic wonder and whatever.

So I decided to finally jump into Malazan and…

It’s one of the worst series I’ve ever read.

It’s not that it isn’t as good as Bakker’s series, plenty of things aren’t but still have their own undeniable quality, it’s really just bad on its own terms and does not meet any of the criteria of the insanely high praise it gets.

It’s pulpy, magic is meaningless and overpowered to the point of making the entire story redundant.

Characters are essentially random stat sheets.

I’m not gamer, so that alone might mean this entire project simply isn’t designed for me.

Prose…. Why in the world would anyone believe that Erikson’s extremely plain and bloated prose is anywhere near writers like Bakker, Donaldson or Guy Gavriel Kay?

I suppose if I had come from Sanderson or someone equally YA I could maybe see myself being impressed by Erikson’s writing, it’s at least above Sanderson.

For all the seriousness and academic praise this story seems to get, I’m really let down.

Is Esslemont’s contribution to this series any better?

I feel like I’m reading a slightly more “big” Forgotten Realms series. It really does feel like I’m reading something out of the D&D books.

No shade to Forgotten realms or Dragonlance, I have enormous respect for them, because they know they aren’t high art, and their readers know that they aren’t high art, and the authors who write them know they aren’t writing high art.

I’m not sure Malazan, its author, or its fans have that level of self awareness though.

Bakker’s Second Apocalypse series is at least, even by Erikson’s own admission, an actual masterpiece.

Someone please convince me otherwise… I wanted to love this series so bad.

I want to see whatever everyone else is seeing.

**Additional Comment**

I forgot to add that structurally, I think Malazan is shockingly poor. And I think fans delude themselves into thinking that Erikson’s complete lack of structural awareness is some sort of intentional Avante Garde artistic direction he’s going because he’s just *that good*.

I think it’s just poorly designed. And people have imposed a massive cope onto themselves to ignore it.

Wheel of Time, which is not a masterpiece, has better pacing and structure.

________________

Updated thought, response to someone who compared Malazan to the film Rubber

I don’t find either that film or Malazan to be overly dense, confusing, or complicated.

This is a cope I often see from fans who are way too proud of themselves for reading a series that many believe is difficult to get through because of its “complexity”.

It’s not difficult or overly complex, it’s just bad.

It’s abysmally structured and poorly thought out and feels like a video game, not a story.

That’s what turns people away.

As for Rubber.

People who dislike that film dislike it because of its self worshiping pretentiousness.

So in that way, I guess you could compare it to Malazan.


r/bakker • • Oct 01 '26

I like this ai slop Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

This one pretty close to how I imagine it.


r/bakker • • Jul 17 '26

Malazan fans, sell it to me.

0 Upvotes

Here’s what you’re up against as a salesman.

Gardens of the moon is genuinely one of the worst books the person has ever read in their life.

A series that takes multiple books in order to get good or start making sense isn’t a good series.

The Malazan fan base is aggressively toxic, to the point where certain book tubers have left that fact in their reviews of Malazan.

The author believes he has produced something of academic philosophical and historical significance/brilliance , behaves like serious professor and sociologist in interviews, but has actually produced something that’s closer to Dragonlance and forgotten realms and its quality.

There is a sunken cost fallacy involved with the critical praise this series gets.

Poor structure and abysmal pacing and horrible exploration of the world is being repackaged and sold as “complex” and avant-garde.

The prose is only high to those who haven’t read high prose.

Assume that these are all things, a person believes about Malazan.

Change their mind.

Update

Malazan is the monster truck show of the fantasy genre. Same announcer and commercial voice actors and everything.


r/bakker • • Apr 17 '25 Polished Gold Turd

Ghibli-pocalypse

0 Upvotes

I should have published this when Ghiblifying was still in vogue, but I hope you'll enjoy anyway.
Kellhus:

Remaking this image:

Different attempt:

Esmenet:

Achamian:

Kelmomas and Samarmas:

Koringhus:

Sadly, I couldn't get a Cnauir that wouldn't look like a typical fantasy barbarian, also failed to get actual book-accurate Swazond.


r/bakker • • Apr 22 '26

Having a hard time getting the hype

0 Upvotes

I'm 140 pages into The Warrior Prophet and I'm having a hard time understanding the hype around these books. I don't think they're bad, but I'm not really understanding the hype about how the world is anymore realistic or the writing is any better than half the writing out there.

Someone help me understand. Half the time I'm spending the page remembering which faction is which or just saying screw it and keep going. I will say that I am engaged when Achamian is on the page the most, but if the chapter is focused on anyone else I don't really care.

I also like the glimpses of the evil we get with how some people are doppelgangers, etc but I wish there was more of it.

One of my coworkers saw me reading this and asked what the series is about and I honestly couldn't tell him. Is it about the holy war? Is it about people trying to stop the Second Apocalypse. I honestly don't know. I don't really even understand why there is the holy war in the first place. Maybe I'm just dumb.

Not sure why I'm posting this but every review is like this book is unlike anything else out there and I just don't really see it.


r/bakker • • Oct 09 '25

battles in the bakker series be like

20 Upvotes

r/bakker • • Nov 01 '25

The amount of glaze for khellus in the second book is insufferable

0 Upvotes

Like Im trying to get through it and I can't because the entire narrative is poised towards showing how everyone wants to give dude head. Not to mention there are no likeable characters. Everyone is a murderer or a rapist or a torturer or and completely humorless. Or theyre part of Khellus' harem. Not really my cup of tea. Cnaiur and Conphas are ok.


r/bakker • • Jul 26 '24

What holds the series back...

0 Upvotes

Is really the first book, some of the akka and esmenet chapters are so hard to get into, philosophically dense...

But mainly esmenet's story. I just, it was so bad.

I feel like he added her arc, just to sort of 'check' a mark or something, where the rest of the story originated more organically through some creative urge.

The entire series, tbh, her plot was a chore for me.

If you read the story once, its easier on a re-read cause you know its worthwhile however.

The second thing, is in the subsequent series, you follow akka on this massive quest with the idea of having the judging eye look at kellhus, just to 'oop too late'.

The end of the story was 'okay', if not good in certain ways. Its just the akka arc was like half the second series, and to end like that is trolling your fanbase. I thought there'd be some sort of confrontation or reunion akin to kellhus and cnaiur confronting meongus in TTT.

Literally nothing. Makes sense why but its just so unfilfilling.

I still would rate the series up there (especially the first series) in that top tier right behind LOTR. Just had potential to be more I think.


r/bakker • • Dec 23 '23

Hear me out... Philip Seymour Hoffman as Kellhus

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/bakker • • Nov 11 '25

Bakker AI Megathread NSFW Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Post it here - AI generated content inspired by the works of R. Scott Bakker.

Some fans hate it and some don't. Post it here and then it won't be elsewhere and won't be removed just for being AI.


r/bakker • • Oct 31 '24

How big is Kellhus D? NSFW

0 Upvotes

I can't this get out of my mind until finally my intrusive thoughts finally won. It must be pretty huge right, to the point Mimara literally can't handle anymore and gave her husband the pass to literally bang other girls, which sadly too much for them to handle too. What are your thoughts?


r/bakker • • 5d ago

Rings of power 3

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Some scenes gave me Bakker vibes or at least thats how imagine it with that brutal, dark and mystic world especialy when Gandalf talks to the fire. What do you guys think?


r/bakker • • Aug 27 '24

The Names, Ye Gods! The Names!

0 Upvotes

I came to this subreddit to share this one thought.

Resting on my shelves for about twenty years, I finally picked up "The Darkness that Comes Before".

All I have to say is, if not for the Fantasy-Gibberish names; it would be one of the finest fantasy novels, or novels, I have ever ever read. And I read a lot.

Does anyone know why he used such long and tongue-splitting names? It really makes me forget who I am reading about.

Is it Byzantine, Hindi, Arabic, what caused that calamity?

It is making it so very very hard to read. Isn't Martemus exotic enough?


r/bakker • • Sep 08 '23

Qualms

0 Upvotes

So I’m a HUGE fan of Bakker. His worldbuilding, philosophies, magic systems etc are all superb. Kellhus is a total badass and the characters are so well written. Except the women 👀

I know I’ll probably get drama for this opinion, but does anyone else notice that he can’t write women to save his life? That he approaches femininity and being a woman as something objectified? To be used? And I’m not even talking about the way the world treats women I’m talking about how he writes them.

Thoughts?


r/bakker • • May 31 '25

Generic sranc meme

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/bakker • • Jun 08 '26

Favorite Queer Character?

2 Upvotes

Earwa isn't the best place for a Pride Month, given that everyone is a socipathic lunatic but I thought I'd list the queer characters and ask who your favorite is:

Drusas Achamian (bisexual implied): While Akka has a preference for women it is implied that while he was a student at Atyersus he had a romantic relationship with a peer*

Cnauir urs Skiotha (pansexual, preference for men): Everyone's favorite barbarian who was tormented by his unaccepted sexuality. He falls in love with Anasurimbor Moenghus and later sleeps with a skin-spy who appears as Serwe but with male genitalia.

Anasurimbor Kellhus (demi-sexual): Like all Dunyain his passions have been whittled to a stump. Still, he's able to do what's necessary with women and men.

Anasurimbor Theliopa (asexual): While utterly brilliant, Theliopa has a severe aversion to human contact. Inrilatas deduced that the best way to torment her then was through sexually assaulting her.

Immiriccas Cinialrig, The Malcontent (gay): A horrendously violent soul. For his crimes, Nil'giccas gave him the option to choose between being killed and going to Hell or having his soul incased in the Amiolas. When Sorweel wears the Amiolas he sees Immiriccas' lover depraved and insane.

Zsoronga ut Nganka’kull (bisexual): Prince of High Holy Zeum, he has sex with Sorweel, telling him that in Zeumi culture warriors sleep with each other to bond.

Inchoroi (pansexual): The evil rape aliens who violate all laws of decency to heap damnation upon themselves, regardless of gender, species, etc.

Skin-spy Serwe (ladyboy/transgender??): Hard to classify this one; to fit Cnauir's preference the skin-spy had Serwe's body but male genitalia.

Any I missed? Who is your favorite?

*(forgot his name, it was the boy who said that sorcerers are moral because only those who did good without the bribe of paradise are truly good).


r/bakker • • Jan 19 '26

Rereading the series for the xth time and the clumsiness of the mimara retcon is really standing out in the first book

2 Upvotes

still great but that could have been done more gracefully. not only is she actually alive but she’s a different age so she can be the main characters kid and plus also she has very special powers

could have made her proyas’s outcast daughter or something but then you don’t get the akka grandpa molestering I guess (borat voice DEGRADATION)


r/bakker • • Nov 18 '25

Emotions chart

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/bakker • • May 11 '26

Starting aspect emperor series and i dont know what to think about the tonne

3 Upvotes

Read the first trilogy and thought of it as marvellous, both because of the characters i particulary liked cnaiur and conphas and the whole crusade analogy stuff since i am big history fan, there was politicking yes but politics inside of the holy war so i felt invested. Kelhus whole arc of a pure duyain to the end of book two and three was very interessing as well.

Jump to book 4 and suddenly i should care for Emnesth (never liked her much anyway) monster family inspired by the adams ? Wharever those sub-cults of the three seas are about ? Mimara and achamanian arc ironically remenber me some sort of coming of age hero journey specially with her shouting at his tower in the beginning.

The great ordeal parts are nice, it remenber me the first three books but i read half of the 4 and it barely appeal, emnesth monster family and akka relation with mimara and wharever that weird cult is take the major part.

The series will change or will continue in the same way ?


r/bakker • • Jul 30 '25

Pretty close to how I imagine them

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Young Akka, old Akka, young Cnaiur


r/bakker • • Aug 03 '19

Trying to get in touch with Mr. Bakker

1 Upvotes

So here's my story. Years and years ago I set out to write my own story after creating this "movie" in my head, really just a compilation of all my favourite things and ideas from everything I've ever seen, read or heard. I finished my first draft and was incredibly proud of what I had created. Until I read the Prince of Nothing and admittedly logged more than enough hours playing the Witcher 3, both of these mature masterpieces revolutionized the way I envisioned this story, and how I would tell it. After another year or two or basically re-writing the entire story, I'm finally prepared to release it into the world. However, before I continued writing the series I would be absolutely thrilled if you were willing to take a look! I had a contract out of Sarnia last year and I'm still beating myself up that I never made the trip to Fanshawe while I was in the area. I'm from Sudbury, up in the north, really just a fan who's written something of his own and would love to discuss anything or everything with you Mr. Bakker, from who you've created such incredible vivid characters to the way you make readers pause, lower their book and take a moment to let what they just read sink in with deep contemplation. I want to create a series where reader argue which is the "best" character and why, a series that compels others to spread the works until it inspires.


r/bakker • • 25d ago

maybe creating the no god will ai will be good actually.

0 Upvotes

maybe creating the no god will ai will be good actually. you dont know. maybe it will be awesome


r/bakker • • 9d ago

Any other Bakker fans working on AI safety?

4 Upvotes

Kellhus' character was one of the first things that made me realise that intelligence can be perfected, and that we should be terrified at what happens when we build it.

I'm now working on AI safety in hopes that we don't build the no-god.