r/bakeoff • • Nov 26 '24

I'm done with Dylan Spoiler

0 Upvotes

the dylan glazing is actually crazy. everyone treats him like he's this unstoppable child prodigy who's just perfect in every way, when I wouldn't even say he's better than georgie, he's just favourited by the judges which makes him look better.

if the judges liked georgie as much as they liked dylan she'd have more handshakes than him I'm telling you.

also gill got eliminated last week after doing NOTHING wrong, when dylan literally didn't even serve an entremee. paul said they'd take it into consideration but clearly they didn't considering there were no mistakes made in the showstopper apart from that, PLUS his signature was so bad.

I think he should've gone in week 6 to be honest. I'm just so sick of everyone acting like he's the perfect person and baker when he's far from.


r/bakeoff • • Sep 24 '22

Series 13 / Collection 10 Can she not Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/bakeoff • • Nov 23 '24

Am I the only one… Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Who didn’t like Dylan’s entremets?? I thought they looked messy and unappetizing. There were drips and messy bottoms. The whole point of patisserie is the details. It’s supposed to be exquisite. We had all these shining colorful perfect entremets and then we had Dylan’s broken box and dull avocados. If I saw them in a French patisserie I would leave.

I don’t want to be harsh I’m just super frustrated that there’s such heavy bias it’s unfair to all the bakers even Dylan.

Edit: even if this was illusion cake week and not PATISSERIE, it still wasn’t great. The details were sloppy. I’ve never been more fine with having an unpopular opinion


r/bakeoff • • Oct 05 '19

Tell the producers exactly how bad you think this season is. I sent them a message. If you want the show to get back to the way it used to be (based on baking, not looks), I encourage you to contact them.

Thumbnail
thegreatbritishbakeoff.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/bakeoff • • Oct 02 '23

ban marshmallow rice krispies, it aint baking

0 Upvotes

I like the new season overall, but when they all broke out the marshmallow rice krispies I suddenly felt like I was watching an episode of Nailed It.


r/bakeoff • • Oct 18 '24

My opinion of Noel has gone down Spoiler

4 Upvotes

(spoilers within)

I like Noel, but what he did in Caramel week is inexcusable.

First of all, you do not play cricket in a tent full of boiling hot caramel - are you kidding me? that could very easily have been an accident.

Then he didn't own up to what he did, and Nelly got points docked about her caramel, which was NO fault of hers.

Some comments say that maybe he did mention it and it wasn't shown, but that doesn't work - we can only see whats shown, and they edit all this very carefully, so there's a good chance he didn't. Unlike what Sue did when she made a mistake.

at the very least she should've been given an extra 10min - this could be done without Paul/Prue coming back - to make up for his stupidity.


r/bakeoff • • Mar 15 '19

Sanitation in the British Bake Off?

9 Upvotes

I love this show, however while watching I've noticed it has somewhat lax sanitation standards. Things like bakers blowing on their bread; multiple people touching/tasting the bakes and batter; bringing ingredients from home; eating undercooked bakes, etc. Does anyone have any thoughts on this? Potentially a cultural difference between the US/Europe?

Edit:

I don't know why I'm getting so many downvotes! As I said I love the show, I just find the norms a bit different. Are touching the floor and getting saliva in the food that controversial?


r/bakeoff • • Nov 08 '25

I'm sorry, Jasmine's flavors were always basic AF and the judges never gave her grief about it.

54 Upvotes

I know she was a great baker and very neat. But it was always Raspberry and lemon, strawberry and cream. I feel like in past seasons the told people they needed to be more daring with flavor combinations?


r/bakeoff • • Nov 26 '24

IM SO HAPPY !!! (spoilers) Spoiler

21 Upvotes

YES

GEORGIE WON YESSSSSS


r/bakeoff • • Oct 22 '22

Junior bake off needs to rethink how they judge the competition. How can a baker that’s been star baker 4 times go home before one that’s never been?

0 Upvotes

r/bakeoff • • Dec 04 '23

Disliked bakers

0 Upvotes

Does anything a baker that they just couldtenjoy even if they baked well? Tom from season 7 appeared so pompous


r/bakeoff • • Oct 22 '22

Series 13 / Collection 10 Paul Hollywood Ruins S’Mores on ‘The Great British Baking Show’ “Halloween Week” Spoiler

Thumbnail
decider.com
27 Upvotes

r/bakeoff • • Nov 26 '20

General dog

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/bakeoff • • Oct 26 '21

Favouritism.

1 Upvotes

Every year there is always one and it annoys me every single time. This year it’s definitely Jürgen ….

Why is it when he uses bright colours it’s seen as beautiful but when Lizzie does it’s gaudy and unsatisfactory…..

I do love this year, everyone is so lovely and funny and can actually bake which is great.

Am I being pathetic and should just get over it 🥲🍰


r/bakeoff • • 19d ago

Is there less educational content this season?

14 Upvotes

I miss the historical info they used to provide about the origins of dishes and the baking tips they would provide as they critiqued peoples’ bakes.


r/bakeoff • • Nov 14 '20

General Should GBBI stay away from Foreign food?

0 Upvotes

I can think of 2 major instances where they have completely ruined a foreign food challenge, American pies and basically all of Japan week. The American pie challenge was pretty much atrocious, I mean they weren’t even close to real American pies. And as for Japanese week, the signature was Chinese, the technical was French, and the showstopper was only Japanese in style. Now I can’t speak for when they do bakes that are danish, or Swedish, or Greek, or basically anything else besides American because I just don’t personally know enough about those foods to know if they are doing it right or not, but I do know I’ve seen some people comment that things like the Stroopwafel were also very questionable. So with all this in mind, maybe it’s just better that GBBO stay away from basically ANYTHING that isn’t British or has any real cultural relevance beyond England? Idk about you, but I’m over seeing them massacre amazing dishes, “katsu” curry and peanut butter chocolate pumpkin pie anyone?


r/bakeoff • • Jan 02 '18

the tale of Paul Hollywood's Savarin yeast cake

0 Upvotes

i was really excited to make this cake. until i saw this on GBBO i had no idea that yeast cakes existed. i used the hints from Marry Berry about using parchment paper and rewatched the GBBO 'masterclass' episode wherein Paul Hollywood gave details about making the cake. i took notes.

a made a few minor mistakes. i might have over beaten it but i don't think so. it's supposed to get smooth, shiny, and elastic. i know the first two but not the elastic. i thought it was going to be obvious, but no, so i just stopped when all the butter was incorporated. still, i don't think i over beat it.

i over proofed it the first time (it is proofed twice) simply because i couldn't hear the oven timer. there was some leeway in the time, so i think that was okay too.

i know i over baked it but only by a couple min. the color was still golden and even and the top was shiny. beautiful and gorgeous it was.

i need you to know that i was precise in my measurements. if you trust me in that statement you will understand that the revolting taste of this cake lies, not with me, but at the feet of every Brit who ever touched a packet of yeast and Paul Hollywood in particular.

my friends know that i often use hyperbole to carry my meaning. but i tell you, seriously, this cake was gross beyond measure. i've made the occasional mud pie and almost ate an oyster that tasted like a mud pie. i'd rather have one of those instead of this vile concoction. it had an awful nothingness flavor that attacked my tongue and threatened to hang on forever so i dared not chew. i spit it out in the sink.

my only consolation was that i had not wasted the rum since i had not yet made the rum syrup to soak the cake in. i threw the cake outside and had a couple glugs of rum to salve my disappointment.

...and that, dear redditors, is how the raccoons ate cake for the holidays.


r/bakeoff • • Oct 15 '19

David and his in Bulgaria... blah blah

7 Upvotes

It was mildly interesting the first few times. But if I hear my partner and Bulgaria one more bleeding time I'm going to throw custard pies at my telly


r/bakeoff • • Apr 06 '25

Mr. Hollywood frustrates me

0 Upvotes

I'm new to the show, and from the United States, so I don't even really know who Paul Hollywood is other than this show. I love the show and seeing what people make! I can't do any of the stuff that the contestants do. But I will say, Mr. Hollywood seems to favor the men? I find it very annoying. I'm currently on C6, E9 and I think Rahul should have gone home a long time ago? I just don't agree with his judging. I think he has a favorite in the beginning and then tries to carry them through until the end and excuses all of their mistakes along the way. I would be so annoyed and frustrated if I was a baker on the show. Am I the only one that feels this way?


r/bakeoff • • Jul 08 '21

General Least favourite contestants?

0 Upvotes

Who were your least and most favourite contestants on bake off throughout the series?


r/bakeoff • • Nov 24 '24

Dylan and Paul…and entitlement Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I fully believe that Paul is going to choose to mentor Dylan after this season and possibly fund the beginning of his career. Paul clearly has Dylan as a favorite (I’m guessing because he sees himself in Dylan), and it’s honestly getting a little annoying at this point in the season (giving advice for the croissants, seemingly unearned handshakes, etc.).

Idk, I could be wrong, but I just feel like he’s coming from a place of huge privilege and Paul seems to be attributing it to talent (which is probably how he feels about himself as well). This especially irked me when Gill was criticized for using canned peaches while Dylan was praised for using cured egg yolks. I think the baking world has a great deal of elitism, but part of what I love about this show is that people—genuine, humble people—come together for the love of baking, not as a career investment. It just feels different watching Dylan than the other people.

(Edit for clarity: I don’t dislike Dylan—just very different vibes from everyone else that I don’t feel fitting with the general spirit of the show. )


r/bakeoff • • Nov 27 '24

I vote Dylan for Below Deck! (No spoilers here, I promise)

1 Upvotes

The comp is over. So what's next for the contestants? Personally I'd love to see a glorious crossover of my guilty TV pleasures, and have Dylan turn up as a yacht chef in the Below Deck franchise. But which captain & ship would be he be a good fit for?


r/bakeoff • • Nov 03 '20

My show stopper, made for my mates 40th. NSFW

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/bakeoff • • Oct 08 '25

BBC Spoiler! Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Quick vent - I am SO ANNOYED the BBC put up an article today on who left last night with their picture as the thumbnail. It's not even been 24 hours!!!! So annoyed they spoiled it ☹️