r/badpolitics • u/[deleted] • May 30 '16
r/badpolitics • u/-AllIsVanity- • Oct 14 '16
"TIL about Horseshoe Theory" on the front page. >4000 fricking upvotes.
I'm exempt from R2 in this case, right? Please don't make me explain this.
73% upvoted. There's a top comment that refutes horseshoe theory, but it has 1000 fewer upvotes than the thread itself.
We are doomed. I swear to God.
r/badpolitics • u/mikiboss • Jun 18 '17
High-Effort R2 In where Sargon of Akkad exists.
Many subscribers are aware of YouTuber and ‘political commenter’ Carl Benjamin or his Alias, ‘Sargon of Akkad. Now Sargon got his start covering topics of social justice and gamergate, and while many of his views in this field are dubious, I will leave that to the kind folks over at r/badphilosophy to break down. I however will cover his more recent views and videos on politics and his ‘classic liberal’ thought process, but considering that there is so much to mock, ridicule and critic, I will break my biggest issues into categories.
**Sargon is seemingly unable to correctly label, well, himself.**“Talking much about oneself can also be a means to conceal oneself” - Friedrich Nietzsche
As I stated before, Sargon regularly identifies himself as a [‘Classic Liberal’] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mptrxcBNY7s) and [‘Left of Centre’] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKbQafBuCBc). Now while we could argue that ‘Classic Liberalism’ doesn’t align with ‘Center-left’ politics, but that would be semantics, what we can do however, is point out contradictions or anomalies in his identification. While Sargon is hesitant to give full statements on his direct beliefs, he has done two tests which reveal information about his beliefs. The tests he use are the [Political Compass Test] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gfOob-36OEo) and the [8 Values Test] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXqtdOfIa2g), and if we ignore the fact that he treats both hilariously incompetent tests with respect, they do provide us with some statements to work with. The image painted from these tests seems to be someone with moderately liberal social views, (Legalised Gay Marriage, Pro Choice, Pro Decriminalisation), but is somewhat more tricky on economic and domestic issues. While saying he disagrees with nationalism, he seems perfectly fine with supporting a [Hard Brexit] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_HQTkGa3N5g ) as it interferes with a country’s [National Identity] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5vpo9qzsfL4). This doesn’t necessarily sound like a contradiction, but when he also states in the video that his nation’s values are universal and should be spread, it seems quite like he does endorse nationalistic traits, at least in a way similar to neo-conservatism.
On economic issues, Sargon is a bit of a mess. On one hand, he seems much like a neoliberal, with support for some public institutions and regulation, but with not too much meddling in the economy or workers ownership. Yet when asked about these issues, Sargon seems to move much further [Left] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3eksUvN9jn0), advocating for workers’ rights (and yes, I did watch most of that 3 hour fucking clip), and then suddenly moves to the [Right] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWWU1ILvWdQ) for private rights which it seems that it would look better for him. Now, the issues is that his views of economics seem to contradict themselves, and he seems to take the approach that ‘To the left of me is Venezuela and to the right is killing workers, so I am perfect’, but the views in some of his videos seem to contradict within only 3 minutes of discussion. Also, for someone who identifies as a liberal, he seems all to content to admit that civil liberties and privacy from the government should be suspended for protection, which is awfully questionable considering one of the main tenants of Classical Liberalism is the protection of civil liberties. Considering that he is also supportive of some government intervention in the economy and holds these views, I would hesitate to fit him under liberalism at all, it doesn’t help that he stated he would have supported the social democrat Bernie Sanders against both Trump and Hilary and has now seemingly embraced Donald Trump. I understand and respect that people can hold views which change over time, but when they repeatedly contradict and wildly vary based on the scenario, I have to be ‘sceptical’ about your perspective.
**Sargon is unusually quick to accept Right-wing Populism, even when it goes against his ‘values’.**“A man without ethics is a wild beast loosed upon this world” – Albert Camus
It should be noted that for this section, when I refer to ‘Right-Wing Populism’, I mostly am referring to highly nationalistic candidates who wish to limit immigration, bolster national identity and tend to be protectionist. While I have already explained that Sargon is quite contradictory and seemingly incoherent, he does seem to give of the appearance of ‘Liberal’, or at least he seems to call himself as such, what makes this so strange however is that even while maintaining this view, he seems all too comfortable to support candidates who exemplify this ideology. The Earliest start was in the U.S. election of 2016, in where he supported Trump over Hilary, while her campaign was closest to his personal views, he seemed to imply that her personal issues surrounding her and the Clinton family were worrisome and that Donald Trump would be, in his own words ‘The Lessor of Two Evils’.
While I can support and understand people voting based on surrounding issues and possible corruption rather than policy, he seems to ignore the potential issues surrounding Trump and other candidates which likely had more of an impact (cough cough Russia cough cough). The issue grows even worse if we examine his video covering the Dutch election in which he offers cautious support to Geert Wilders[1] and says that he often talked about issues which are relevant and should be focused on. The same applies to the [French election] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VPFtwMcjzRs) in where he covered how Le Pen was focusing on issues which would allow her to win[2]. This is quite evident, as in all of these elections, candidates representing progressive and somewhat classic liberal ideas were present. In the US, while more neoliberal in her business approach, Clinton was a relatively progressive liberal, in the Dutch, D66 was quite liberal, alongside the conservative-liberal VVD and in France, Macron was a liberal is his purest form. The only issue with all of these candidates was the potential issue of the EU in the two latter, but they still represented liberalism, albeit in slightly different ways. Sargon however, seemed to support the antithesis of what he claims to support in his support for Trump, Wilders and Le Pen. His support for Trump seemed to focus on not being corrupt as Hillary, but when faced with Wilders receiving money from foreign investors, and Le Pen’s [Dubious ties to Russia] (http://www.palmerreport.com/politics/russia-marine-le-pen-french-president/2425/), he still seems to support these candidates based on them ‘Focusing on the Right Issues’. This clearly illustrates a man with no consistency in whom he supports, and someone who wishes either to ignore potential corruption or misaligning politics to an almost laughable level. Frankly I think that Sargon agrees with both Wilders and Le Pen, but was caught out in his support for corruption and illiberalism, but I will leave that for you to decide.
**‘Why Don't I Criticise the Right’**“Politics have no relation to morals” - Niccolo Machiavelli
For much of Sargon’s online presents, he has received support from some groups not usually accolated with liberalism, including those of Conservatism and those of the Far Right. This of course led to many asking why he only criticizes the left and never the right. This ultimately led to one of his most infamous videos, [‘Why Don't I Criticise the Right’] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFO0VytARXQ&t=177s). This video is ultimately full of amazing quotes and quips which would fill an entire post, which I might do one day later, but first I would just like to break down some points here which prove his contradictory nature (Seriously, watching Sargon is painful, but this is the second most embarrassing video he has ever released and I implore you to watch it).
The video states with him stating that ‘I rarely criticize the right, because I don’t really care about the right, as far as I am concerned, they are usually wrong’ and leads to him inferring that individualist liberals are left wing, as well as stating that the right ‘is not good to poor people, but I don’t think they are trying to undermine western civilization…pumping out an ideology which is going to advocate for, like, open boarders, advocate for communism and socialism and all this sort of crap’. Even if we ignore the fact that liberalism is not really a left wing ideology (Sargon should know, with his understanding of European politics), even if we ignore how overly simple it is to completely write of a political side because you don’t care for it, even if we ignore that his belief of ‘left wing’ (mostly what he calls SJWs and neoliberals) leading to Communism and Socialism is irrational and comedic, that this leaves the fact that he boils entire political sides into simple inaccurate statements and places himself as an all knowing political mastermind, who in reality, knows practically nothing.
He also argues that the right would only be ‘mildly oppressive for poor people’, and argues that he doesn’t want to improve the right, while still wanting to improve the left. Not only is this confusing, considering his support for public services which have been threatened by the ‘right’ (As in healthcare and some other public services of the like), but he also has at several points suggested against surveillance and any form of oppression, and despite his claims that he would “Advocate against it, whatever form of oppression they are imposing”, he seems very hesitant to criticise leaders on the right who impost those laws (See points 2 and 4). Alongside this, he repeatedly mentions ‘Cultural Marxism’, and ignoring the very chequer history of the term, he fails to fully explain himself in most of his videos beyond saying that it will destroy “Western Values”. He then goes on to mention how caring about Cultural Marxism is more important than protecting abortion rights, by saying (and I quote directly here) “Every other right is more important than your right to get an abortion”. While a debate about abortion is always going to be tricky, for someone who repeatedly claims to protect western liberal values and labels themselves as ‘centre-left’ is quickly turned around when topics surrounding actual civil liberties. Much of the rest of the video derails into a tangent about social justice courses on college campuses, but ignoring the fact that he is seemingly unaware of how college campuses work, as illustrated in Hbomberguy’s excellent response video, he seems to believe that the left “Command’s social capital”. As illustrated in several of the laws targeting Transgendered Individuals and laws appealing to [Christin Traditionalists](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_Freedom_Restoration_Act_(Indiana) have been present in ‘western society’ with only minor criticism, this is clearly not the case.
Finally, he seems to claim that his general views are somewhat accurate because despite the occasion hit piece on him, he is still more persuasive because of his subscriber count continuing to rise. I don’t even think I have to target this point other than saying that as long as content is being produced, the subscriber count will likely rise as well. The rest of the video seems to derail into arguments about ‘The Left’ and how they are quick to label people with ‘Right-Wing’ and ‘Fascist’, yet he fails to notice the notable hypocrisy in criticising the left as only leading to ‘socialism and communism’[3]. Ultimately this is a revealing video which shows how his labelling the left as “A Cancer” and his other criticism of the left would put him on the right. But he only seems to disagree with the religious right and fails likely fails to criticize the right as it seems to be a solid support of his Income.
**Coming all together for his view of the UK election of 2017**“What. A. Shitshow” -Carl Benjamin.
Earlier on in his YouTube career, Sargon seemed to loath the Conservative Party and the right, issuing two Seriously Condemning videos on the Conservative Party. I mean Seriously Condemning videos which illustrated his view of the party the party as being a party for the rich, which is corrupt and failing to even cut down on the debt. These videos are quite surprising, considering his later support for the conservative party in 2017. What’s funny however is the fact that much of his issues with the conservative party in 2015 are still consistent in 2017 in the cases of Privatisation, and Corruption. The only issue which seems to have changed however is Brexit, but before we analyse, let’s look that election video.
The clip opens with a coverage of Venezuela and comparing it to a society under Corbyn’s Labour, with rich investors leaving the country and focusing on the economic effects of his policies. While there is certainly some criticism of his economic plans to be had, the comparison to Venezuela is simply questionable, as Venezuela’s economy issues were mostly down to over-nationalization of businesses creating an unstable economy, rather than higher taxes and public services. For Corbyn’s labour, the services nationalised were mostly water and rail, rather than the comparison to Chavez’s nationalization of even small businesses. He also repeatedly brings up ‘Capital Flight’ , A term referring to investors and sources of income leaving a nation, however when presented with the same issue for Brexit, Sargon seems all too comfortable to ignore it in favour of supporting Brexit and states that a strong government could manoeuvre these issues, whilst laughing off the ideas of the Liberal Democrats and Labour for being to revolutionary. Sargon also argues that Corbyn’s policies which are from trade unions are representing the few, as trade union membership is low. What Sargon fails to ignore is that these laws which are pushed through will allow people to receive these policies even if they don’t join a union, leading to them representing what they see as ‘The many, not the few”. He also argues that if you are middle class and have an education in any field other than economics or political science, you are not able to understand this issue. Not only has Sargon not revealed his level of education, but some people with education have admitted admiration[4] to Corbyn’s promises, shooting a hole in Sargon’s theory that people versed in economics are opposed to Corbyn.
On the topic of the Tories however, Sargon is more realistic and admits for cuts to public services. At least I will give Sargon some recognition in acknowledging that his previous support for public services is likely being hit by the Conservative manifesto, but it is about to get even weirder. On the topic of security, he seems to return to biting into the Conservatives, with criticism of the Conservatives terrorism tackling plans. This seems to align with his ‘Classic Liberal’ views, which only makes his later statements even more confusing.
This leads to his final point, and that of Brexit. He claims that the EU wishes to appear strong and consistent, with member state maintaining to as many of the regulations as possible and that leaving the Union, and that a successful Brexit of the hands of the Conservative party could destroy the EU, or lead to mass exportation from the EU, which could be caused by a strong and stable government. This is quite a fallacy, as only a small group of Eurosceptic parties and individuals have gained ground in election and in representation, and most at the time of this videos release had failed, With Le Pen flopping in France, Wilders underperforming in the Netherlands and Hofer failed candidacy in Austria leaving only the ‘5 Star Movement in Italy’ with a strong enough voice representing real Euroscepticism. Sargon later argues that the UK would be best to try and hold off against the EU, and follow May’s belief of getting a good deal or “No deal”. His point of view is that this will either lead to a better deal with more compromise from the EU, or a European recession, both of which he seems to be either happy or at least content with. While his argument for a better deal is unlikely, considering Donald Tusk’s comments Regarding Brexit, that only leaves the latter, which would be an economic disaster on par of something akin to 2008-9. He then argues that Corbyn is giving in to the leverage set by EU chair people which would be used against the UK. The only issue with this is that Corbyn has stated that he would accept the deal likely because he wishes to avoid the ‘No Deal’ scenario. This leads to his ending statement, in where he endorses the Conservative Party, purely for their Brexit approach. As I have stated before, not only is this contrary to his beliefs of civil liberties and public services, but could potentially lead to economic instability of such severity, it could lead to an EU wide recession, which is awfully questionable for Sargon to support, as it would undeniably lead to undeniable death and disarray, in exchange of Sargon’s goal of dismantling the European Union.
The funny side of this however, was the video he produced following the results, which is undeniably the most embarrassing video he has ever produced. The video opens with him condemning Teresa May and the Tories manifesto, and may I remind you, a manifesto is not a piece of political advertising, it is a piece which illustrates what a party wishes to do, so he wholeheartedly supported a party, knowing that it had a bad manifesto. So Sargon essentially acts angry at this result and seems to act as though he never supported the Tory policies, but in supporting the Conservatives for 2017, he is. It is clear though the salty drag that was this video, Sargon wants to have his cake and eat it to, act as tough he supported the Conservatives if they won and act as tough he was hesitant if they lost, but his call for support backfired. Hard. He paints Corbyn’s mild celebration after a successful campaign is acting as tough he won the election, and fails to criticize him by calling him anything other than a “socialist”. This video is a cherry on top which shows a simply confirmation of his poor analysis.
Conclusion
Sargon is, to much of this sub, already a joke. With two Good Analyses on his poor political discourse existing, so why would I create a long winding post explain some of his deepest issues? The answer is simple, Sargon still wields a large influence and has a large group of people whom follow and admire him. As illustrated above, I believe that in the best case scenario, Sargon is someone who makes up arguments to gain support from alienated crowds, similar to someone like Glen Beck, or at worse, actually believe all of his points and continues to contradict himself. Sargon is, if anything, living proof that an English accent can get you a successful career, even if you have no clue about what you are talking about.
Notes
[1]. While even Sargon admits that his campaign is somewhat authoritarian and amateurish, I would argue that him stating that there are concerns he addresses and that “if the left-wing establish won’t answer them, then the right-wing will” registers as a mild endorsement or at least support.
[2]. Between relentless criticism of Macron and Memes he posts on twitter, I would consider that support.
[3]. I assume his mention of Communism is addressing the ‘Marxist-Leninist’ Belief, which is badpolitics for a whole different reason
[4]. I admit, ‘The Guardian’ is not the best source, but the article goes to disprove Sargon’s view on economists.
Oh, and first post. Please be gentle
r/badpolitics • u/Jimdude2435 • Apr 09 '16
Tomato Socialism 406 points in /r/The_Donald
r/badpolitics • u/big_al11 • Aug 30 '17
/r/politics user reveals a totally real ANTIFA manual "(not to be distributed to any cis white males aka fascists)"
Several highlights of the document include antifa saying they have control over the media and that they will achieve their goals through "white guilt".
Antifa's goals, according to the document:
To have a 70% non white USA
To microchip every human on the planet
To create a one world government
To create a database of DNA in order to determine a minimum level of blackness to be able to use the word "nigga"
To open up borders around the world so brown people can overwhelm white countries like the USA.
Convert container ships to ferry billions of brown people to Europe and the US.
Why this is bad politics should be obvious. Historian of Antifa Mark Bray says that Antifa is certainly not a hierarchical organization with leaders, but rather an idea, a tactic used across the world at different times. Antifa is strongly influenced by anarchism. And yet the book calls for an all-powerful one world government. Antifa is strongly influenced by anarchism. And yet the book calls for an all-powerful one world government- the direct opposite of an anarchistic society.
This document is an obvious hoax put together by the alt-right, who last week were exposed as conducting a fake social media campaign aimed at discrediting antifa.
But comes off as all the alt-right's fears and talking points projected onto a leaderless and transitory movement.
r/badpolitics • u/[deleted] • Jun 29 '16
neil degrasse tyson: "earth needs a virtual country: #rationalia, with a one-line constitution: all policy shall be based on the weight of evidence"
r/badpolitics • u/Trotskylvania • Jan 03 '17
Thread of the Year This man quit his day job to develop this wonderful political theory of everything.
Wew lad, we're in for a doozy.
Rick Raddatz, a former microsoft employee, decided to launch his career in political philosophy in a Reddit AMA. It only goes downhill from here.
I'm a former Microsoft product designer/developer and successful serial entrepreneur who decided in 2006 to change careers and become a full-time political philosopher. I've spent the last ten years researching and developing a new political theory called PENTANOMICS.
Yes, that's right, he already has a website. As you can guess by following the link to his snazzy website, Raddatz is clearly a businessman and marketer by trade. As we're going to see, the "philosophy", if you could call it that, was born in a marketing meeting.
...Pentanomics says the laws of economics...apply to ALL contexts of action, including public action, political action, foreign action and future action.
Now, were I an enterprising soul, I'd ask him what the opportunity cost of yawning is, but I'm afraid he'd attempt to give me a serious answer. Raddatz wants to reduce the sum total of human existence to the deeply contentious field of economics. It's a staple of badx for people to try to reduce other fields of science to a special case of their own field (see engineers like Kurzweil peddle their transhuman woo and try to reduce biology to a special case of computer engineering, etc.)
A good economist would never make such a fundamental error, and would stick to using economic theory to analyze problems of economics, i.e., the production, allocation and distribution of goods and services. Raddatz instead believes that he can reduce all problems of ethics, justice, and public good into simple problems of market exchange, and solve the problems of our commonwealth quickly and easily.
This is his stated goal.
Of course, his stated goal of providing a "unified" theory of government and thereby solving all of our outstanding political problems models (poorly) the institutions of liberal democratic capitalist governance.
A truly unified theory of politics, if one existed, would have equal explanatory power in modeling the problems and decisionmaking of a Bronze Age hydraulic despotism, a feudal manor, an ancient Greek polis, or a Stalinist totalitarian regime.
Here's a great example from the AMA about the Randian reductivism of Raddatz's thought. When asked what pentanomics said about wealth distribution, Raddatz replied:
This is the BIG ONE! The quick answer is that Pentanomics says we can't achieve social justice by burdening the private economy. Burdening the private economy with regulations, mandates, and high taxes only serves to lower prosperity. Pentanomics says the only way to achieve social justice is to properly structure the public economy via a reform called Cap and Prioritize. Cap and Prioritize will force spending ideas to compete for limited funds in a prioritized budget--a budget ranked from top to bottom. Over time, the competition for the highest spot on the priority list will force results to matter.
Holy buzzwords batman! In other words, a completely unregulated market, presumably taxed only the bare minimum to provide the defense of private property, will somehow achieve prosperity for all because governments will have different departments compete for an ever diminishing supply of public funds, and will face the ax if they don't achieve "results", whatever that means.
It's a perfect storm of Silicon Valley guru messiah complex, complete ignorance of the field, and and a panacea woo that can solve all our political problems so long as we all clap our hands and BELIEVE hard enough
r/badpolitics • u/Kiroen • Nov 11 '16
Bicycle Gulag "Utopias lead to the Soviet Union, gulags and 20 millions of deaths" local Spanish politician reasoning why he votes against expanding a bike lane
Though the content is in Spanish, this is so terribly golden bad politics that it deserved the effort of a translation.
Context ahead. This happened yesterday at Pamplona's (0,2 million population city) town hall.
(...) The councilor of Urban Ecology and Sustainable Mobility presented a plan to transform Pamplona's mobility (...) The plan intends to invest 4 million euros, 30% of which would be dedicated to build 30km of bike lane in addition to the already existing 60km.
Broadly speaking, this is what was supposed to be discussed, along with some traffic regulations. The representative of a party in the opposition had a particularly heated response, some fragments of which you can watch here. Translation:
Look, Mr. Cuenca, utopias, those you like so much, do you know what they have led to? To the USSR, to the Soviet Union, to Siberia, to concentration camps, to 20 million dead people - Yes, yes, utopias! Yes, yours! That, that is what utopias lead to. Then some talibans come, and all those utopias are turned into iron realities. So sure, they build the USSR, they build North Korea, which I'm sure you MUST love, one of the MOST COMMUNIST, collectivist countries. Chim Pon Chi, or whatever he's called, the one who dictates everything that's done there. (...) That leads to Cuba, and it leads, more recently, to Venezuela. The utopia of that ultraleft of yours. USSR, Korea, Cuba and Venezuela. Places no one wants to go, nor wants to be in. Places from where people have fled, places that have caused millions, MILLIONS, millions of deaths. Millions, your utopias. Well, but I recognize I've seen you moderate during your intervention. I think even Soraya knows you're not going to get your bike lanes done. You know that, right? Well, thank you very much.
Rule 2
Using a local institutional debate about adopting a more ecologist model of traffic, as an excuse to "debate" about the historical experiences of the Eastern Block and 21st century socialism is an Ode to Hyperbole by itself, though I fear it's the opposite: he uses his accusations of ultraleftism as an excuse to not to debate about ecologism. Let's see his actual arguments, there were any:
-Ecologism in the mentioned countries. Not only the USSR didn't have ecologist policies, it had several environmental problems during the years prior to its collapse. Cuba actually started practicing what today would be called ecologist agriculture due to need after the collapse of the Eastern Block, since the blockade prevented from buying fertilizers. North Korea and Venezuela aren't exactly known for its fanatical ecologism.
-Pursuing ecologism is utopic. I don't know If stopping global warming is utopic, but measures such as public parks and bike lanes are obviously common in several European contries, If not the majority of them.
-Pursuing utopias invariably leads to concentration camps. This is so ideological that is hard to tackle, but let's assume, for the sake of the argument, that the councilor was actually presenting a plan to collectivize the means of production so that they might be managed democratically by the whole of society. This could be accused of being utopian for seeking to solve great problems yet not having actually existed as a model in a large society during an extended period of time. However, the same could have been said about liberal democracies during the time of Rousseau, only to find them working considerably better than the Old Regime political systems two centuries later, having removed a great amount of violence inside its own borders.
-Bike Lanes are literally Communism. While he didn't explicitely say this, it's the general image that projects for making such an intervention within that context. This list, however, points to several cities with extensive bike infrastructures, none of which could be considered socialist.
r/badpolitics • u/[deleted] • Jan 30 '16
Chart This (racist) chart is so inaccurate, it made me laugh.
r/badpolitics • u/[deleted] • Sep 27 '16
Film Theory "Why The Star Trek Federation is Fascist "
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P4KBPaS-1PU
R2: My GOD! I thought that Game Theory was going downhill before, but this is RIDICULOUS. I'll go through some points here
-Seems to believe that all exploration is driven by selfish or imperialistic whims
-Gives the extremely simplified definition of fascism= big government
-seems incredulous that federation space uses federation materials and equipment
-Claims capitalism is designed to be democratic
-claims fascism is anti capitalist, WHILE using a Strasser quote, misattributing it to Hitler
-Claims the fact that no one uses money proves economic control proves fascist
-Uses "Human Nature" to hand wave away the idea that this society is possibly utopian
-Collectivism and basic fucking empathy is fascist
-Brings up the 'bundle of sticks' argument, so I guess Planet of the Apes is fascist as well.
-Brings up the fact that Kirk was exiled in Star Trek 2009, despite the fact that he was acting irrationally and putting the ship in danger, also seemingly hand waving away the fact that Spock had a personal grudge
-Forgets to mention Krall's problem was the Federation making peace with it's former enemies
-Forgetting to mention the Klingons made peace with and have joined a multi racial federation.
-Lastly, no mention of ANY typical fascist characteristics, such as racial superiority, scapegoating of minorities, outlaw of dissent, protection of private industry, powerful nationalism, or disdain for rights of other beings. Government does stuff, so government is fascist I guess
I'm Shocked someone made something like this, and while we're at it, I guess he's a fascist because he said that letting Chloe die is LiS benefited the many.
r/badpolitics • u/[deleted] • Jun 12 '17
High-Effort R2 "Fascism is a far-left ideology, so stop posting inaccuracies"
I don't understand why certain people are so focused on making fascism and national socialism "far-left" ideologies. Not even Third position, but "far-left".
A political ideology based on authoritarianism, corporatism and ultra-nationalism is "far-left"? Do these people realize the leftists were persecuted in fascist regimes?
r/badpolitics • u/-AllIsVanity- • Dec 13 '16
Turns out "TIL about Horseshoe Theory" got 19.5k upvotes, not ~4000
(Context: https://www.reddit.com/r/badpolitics/comments/57e9b7/til_about_horseshoe_theory_on_the_front_page_4000/ Reddit recently changed how upvotes are presented.)
Meanwhile, the refutation only got 5,500 upvotes and is the third most visible comment under /r/TIL's default sorting (which is "best," i.e. least controversial).
r/badpolitics • u/TwisterAce • Feb 23 '17
"The alt-right is a left-wing fascist group"
“There is a sinister organization that is trying to warp its way into our ranks,” said Dan Schneider, the executive director of the American Conservative Union, which runs CPAC. “We must not be deceived by [a] hateful, left-wing fascist group.”
Over a few confusing minutes, Schneider argued that the “alt-right,” a term coined then popularized by the National Policy Institute’s Richard Spencer, was philosophically left-wing because it departed from his definition of conservatism, in which “the individual” is sovereign.
“They hate the Constitution. They hate free markets. They hate pluralism,” Schneider said. “Fascists tend to want big government control.”
There are a few points I want to make to rebuke this claim that fascism and the alt-right are "leftist" ideologies:
Left-wing ideologies usually advocate egalitarianism, in which the people are equal socially and economically. Class structures and other forms of social stratification are eliminated or at least mitigated to some extent to promote equality. Racism, sexism, and other forms of bigotry are usually combated (although left-wingers can be bigots like anyone else). Fascism is inherently anti-egalitarian: certain racial, ethnic, national, or religious groups are deemed superior to all others; age and gender roles in society are emphasized; and a stratified class structure is maintained (although class conflict is neutralized through "class collaboration"). Right-wing ideologies usually advocate traditional values, social order, and hierarchical models of society, so fascism would fit in there.
Fascism is not inherently anti-capitalist. Fascists prefer a "third position" between Marxist socialism and laissez-faire capitalism. They want a mixed economy with both public and private ownership of the means of production, with elements of both free enterprise and state planning.
"Alt-right" is more of a catch-all term for various groups associated with the right-wing. But these groups, and the alt-right in general, can be considered right-wing because of the proliferation of anti-egalitarian views by people considered alt-right: racial supremacism and racial nationalism, anti-feminism, and religious intolerance (particularly by Christians against Muslims and - to a lesser extent - Jews). As far as I'm aware, no alt-right figures or groups are opposed to capitalism. They might oppose neoliberalism and free trade (on the grounds of economic nationalism), but overall they consider capitalism to be a better system than socialism. If anything they might adhere to the "third position" economic views of traditional fascists.
In regards to whether the alt-right is a "conservative" movement or not, it should be noted that the alt-right has drawn influence from paleoconservatives such as Pat Buchanan and Samuel T. Francis. Buchanan and Francis both oppose multiculturalism and high levels of immigration (both legal and illegal), and both support economic nationalism and elements of white nationalism (at the very least they believe the United States is a fundamentally European nation whose identity is being threatened by non-European immigrants). Buchanan has even promoted "white genocide" theories: his 2001 book The Death of the West claimed that Western civilization would "die out" because Westerners would be outbred by Asians, Africans, and Latin Americans. All in all, the alt-right is at least partly descended from paleoconservatism, which is considered a right-wing ideology.
TL;DR: Left-wingers advocate egalitarianism. Fascism and the alt-right are anti-egalitarian. Fascists and alt-righters are not opposed to capitalism, just some elements of it. The alt-right is descended from paleoconservatism, a right-wing ideology, so it makes sense to place it on the right.
r/badpolitics • u/SinlessSinnerSinning • Oct 11 '16
We need an authoritarian president because the current president is too authoritarian, it's almost anarchy
Paul LePage:
Sometimes I wonder that our Constitution is not only broken, but we need a Donald Trump to show some authoritarian power in our country and bring back the rule of law because we've had eight years of a president, he's an autocrat, he just does it on his own, he ignore Congress and every single day, we're slipping into anarchy.
R2: Autocrats are, by definition, authoritarian. So switching one for another doesn't solve the problem. Also anarchy is the lack of a government, not a stronger one.
Not to mention Obama has been dealing with an obstructionist Congress for some time that literally doesn't listen to him (case in point: Mitch McConnell saying Obama didn't warn him enough not to override his veto)
Also automod deleted this before since I didn't have enough characters.
r/badpolitics • u/ChrysalisQOTC • May 17 '16
Having closed borders = Saving Europe | Not having closed borders = EURABIA
r/badpolitics • u/Windows7Guy100 • May 28 '16
Even Wolfram Alpha is falling victim to Bad Politics
r/badpolitics • u/Cynical_Ostrich • Apr 14 '16
Chart Whatever the fuck this is supposed to be...
r/badpolitics • u/0m4ll3y • Jan 11 '17
Low Hanging Fruit RIP Politics and Farewell America
I, and I'm sure millions of people around the world, woke up in the morning and checked the news. I think I can speak on behalf of every non-American, and probably most Americans in saying: What the fuck are you doing America?
Just... what the everlasting actual fuck?
Okay, let me take a step back here. BadPolitics is:
a place to discuss the terrible application of Political Science, Political Theory, and Political History that we see every day.
Well, can anyone see a better example of the terrible application of political science, political theory and political history than the United States? Yes, all of the United States. Something has gone seriously wrong. Politics is wrong in your country. Its broken. No, not broken. Its dead. You murdered it. You've killed politics. Why would you do this?
I am, of course, referring to #GoldenShowers, #GoldenShowerGate, #WaterSportsGate or whatever the hell you want to call it. You must know the story by now. CNN released a story reporting that classified information given to Obama and Trump included allegations that Russian operatives held compromising information over Trump. Buzzfeed went #YOLO and published said allegations. One of these allegations was:
TRUMP's (perverted) conduct in Moscow included hiring the presidential suite of the Ritz Carlton Hotel, where he knew President and Mrs OBAMA (whom he hated) had stayed on one of their official trips to Russia, and defiling the bed where they had slept by employing a number of prostitutes to perform a 'golden showers' (urination) in front of him.
...
...
Now, I don't care where you stand on this allegation, whether you think its 100% true or 100% false, or whether you think its the most important issue in the world or if it distracts from other issues, this is now at the centre of political discussion. #GoldenShowers is trending on Twitter, the blogosphere is on fire, and even more prestigious news sites can't help but to reference the incident, even if as coyly as possible. Trump himself, of course, responded
FAKE NEWS - A TOTAL POLITICAL WITCH HUNT!
Russia just said the unverified report paid for by political opponents is "A COMPLETE AND TOTAL FABRICATION, UTTER NONSENSE." Very unfair!
Intelligence agencies should never have allowed this fake news to "leak" into the public. One last shot at me.Are we living in Nazi Germany?
"ALL CAPS!" "How can Russia be blackmailing me if Russia says they aren't!" "Something something NAZI GERMANY!"
Then, to add another twist to the story, people are claiming the entire thing originated from 4chan. The evidence of this? A post on 4chan saying that. The 4chan that says:
The stories and information posted here are artistic works of fiction and falsehood. Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact.
So to recap, you have the President Elect of the United States of America tweeting in ALL CAPS and about Nazis in order to defend himself against allegations that he hired prostitutes to hate-piss on a bed Obama slept in. Meanwhile, some of his supporters are using a 4chan screenshot as proof the whole thing is a hoax. Meanwhile, on the other side of the aisle, people are falling over themselves trying to get in as many pee jokes as possible.
So why is this bad politics? Well, what is politics? The 100% ever-reliable Wikipedia says:
Politics (from Greek: πολιτικός politikos, definition "of, for, or relating to citizens") is the process of making decisions applying to all members of each group. More narrowly, it refers to achieving and exercising positions of governance — organized control over a human community, particularly a state... Formal Politics refers to the operation of a constitutional system of government and publicly defined institutions and procedures
It's pretty broadly defined even in the narrow sense. But I think we can say that politics is the various institutions in America (congress, law enforcement agencies, the press corp) and that all these things working together is meant to lead to governance. What is the United States' system doing?
The President Elect of the United States of America is tweeting in ALL CAPS and about Nazis in order to defend himself against allegations that he hired prostitutes to hate-piss on a bed Obama slept in.
Clearly the entire system has failed if this is the outcome. Find me any political thinker who wanted this as an outcome? I guarantee that you won't find even one mention of Twitter in Plato's Republic. The Federalist Papers has zero talk of golden showers. Jean-Jacques Rousseau's Social Contract only lightly touches on hiring prostitutes to defile your political opponents bed. Clearly, from this we infer that this was not a desired outcome. Constitutional democracy has failed. The free press has failed. Public education has failed. Intelligence agencies have failed. Liberal democratic capitalism has failed.
All of these institutions and their related political theories can be shown to be bad politics due this unintended outcome. That's right, the 200 year American experiment is over, and it has failed. There is now only one hope left for America to fix its broken political system.
Sorry Mods, I know this isn't serious, and you're trying to be more like BadHistory than BadPhilosophy but I'm weeping at American political discourse. It was reddit shitpost or drinking at 9am.
r/badpolitics • u/Lukethehedgehog • Dec 04 '16
"Islam isn't a race. It's a totalitarian ideology, just like Stalinism, Hitler's Nazism, communism, Marx's socialism, etc. etc."
R2: So this comment basically shows just how much the average t_D user knows about politics (i.e. squat shit).
Islam isn't a race.
Technically correct, but there is a big overlap between the Islamic community and the Arab community, so really this is just a cop-out for people who say Islamophobic shit to say "I'm not racist since Islam isn't a race" even though they spout hatred against Arabs.
It's a totalitarian ideology,
Not any more totalitarian than Christianity. What this guy is thinking of is Islamism, an ideology that can be summed up as "Fascism for Muslims", espousing similat beliefs about superiority, purity, nationalism, etc. The reason Islamism exists is less because Islam is an inherently "worse" religion and more because the Middle East is an extremely poor, underdeveloped, and war-torn region.
(Please note that I'm not very knowledgeable on the topic of Islam so if I got anything wrong call me out on it)
just like Stalinism,
Basically true, Stalin was an authoritarian dictator.
Hitler's Nazism,
"Hitler's Nazism" is kind of a dumb thing to say. There really aren't any Nazi leaders or prolific writers of Nazi theory other than Hitler. There has never been a revision of Nazi ideology large enough to make it distinct from Hitler's, and even if it was, I doubt it would be anything other than authoritarian.
communism,
I doubt this needs to be explained for 99.99% of people on this sub, but I'll do it anyway: Communism is an ideology that looks to create a stateless, classless society via withering of the state. It would be impossible for such a society to be authoritarian, as there is no state. Also, there are many different variations of communism, and some of them (Such as Anarcho-Communism) look to destroy the state right away.
Marx's socialism, etc. etc.
Okay, first of all, in any case, it would be "Marxism" or "Marx's communism", not "Marx's socialism". Socialism is an extremely old ideology that had a plethora of different writers such as Joseph Pierre Proudhon, Mikhail Bakunin, etc. and it spans ideologies such as communism, anarchism, mutualism, democratic socialism (Which is not the same as social democracy, the ideology of Bernie Sanders and the Nordic countries), etc. Marx isn't really the figurehead of socialism, just a very well-regarded author in the large canon of socialist thinkers.
Second of all, as I already said a paragraph above, Marxism is about establishing a stateless, classless society, so it's not automatically authoritarian.
But you can't really expect the average t_D subscriber to know anything about socialism that isn't covered in McCarthyist propaganda, right?
r/badpolitics • u/transval • Aug 02 '18
The Spectre of Communism is an actual ghost
https://i.imgur.com/2b52jFg.png First off, the Young Hegelians, while influenced by Hegel, were also massive critics of some aspects of Hegelianism. Marx did not uncritically subscribe to Hegelianism, and while it was a major influence on his politics, he was interested more in a "scientific" socialism and material philosophy than most of the Young Hegelians.
Alright, now onto the whole "planet sized ghost" thing. Marx was using the idea of a spectre as a metaphor for the almost ghost like nature of socialists, being blamed for many, many affairs in the political world of Europe. Marx certainly did not think the souls of the dead, all amassed into one, would come in and create a socialist utopia, nor did he think that this ghost contained the solution to the implementation of socialism.
They may also be talking about the Weitgeist, which is a concept introduced in the Phenomenology of Spirit, and refers to world spanning concepts throughout history, not a mysterious socialism-loving ghost. The concept of metaphor is clearly lost, and I don't think that Marx meant literal vampires when he discussed the bourgeoisie, either.
Thirdly, this "ghost" according to this person would have implemented Communism, not workers. Marx clearly did not believe this, and was a materialist, not a spiritualist. Marx believed Communism to be a workers' movement, not the results of unforeseen consequences about ghosts. Even a basic perusal of the Communist Manifesto, a pamphlet that isn't actually the basis of socialist theory, would be enough to correct any misconceptions about "planet sized ghosts".
r/badpolitics • u/armin199 • Apr 11 '17
"...While communists are often fascists, not all fascists are communist."
https://np.reddit.com/r/BannedFromThe_Donald/comments/64kduy/trump_supporter_gets_banished/dg3hi7g/
OH BOY WHERE DO I BEGIN WITH THIS GLORIOUS COMMENT! THIS IS A ONCE IN A LIFE TIME OPPORTUNITY! GUYS PLEASE HOLD MY BEER, THIS IS MY MOMENT TO SHINE!
Communism is a left-wing internationalist movement which aims to abolish capitalism in its entirety.
Fascism is a right-wing nationalist movement.
Left wing internationalism =/ right wing nationalism
Conclusion: .face-palm
r/badpolitics • u/big_al11 • Nov 26 '16
"Please tell me how Bernie Sanders is any different to Hitler?"
It is odd for a person who esposes a neonazi ideology to simultaneously cast Hitler as left. But I suppose if you are that far right, everything is left to you.
Now, as to why this is bad politics:
Everybody understood at the time that the Nazis were a far-right party.
1). They were violently hostile to all center-left and far-left political parties for their entire existence as a party.
2). They formed coalitions with the traditional right in both electoral politics (the colation government that made Hitler Chancellor) and in bureaucratic politics (their uneasy detente with the German army, which becomes more of a co-option of the army as time goes on.
3). They were violently nationalist, and anti-internationalist , compared to the internationalism of the contemporary left.
4) As the 30's wear on, they form alliances with other far right governments.
5) They oppose class struggle, a central tenet of Marxists, Democratic and Bolshevik alike.