r/baconreader • u/onelouderchic 🥓 • Sep 29 '15
5.0 ANDROID UPDATE information
Thanks to those of you who have provided valuable feedback. We appreciate constructive feedback, as opposed to whining...but I guess it is reddit and we have to take both ;). Please respect our sidebar rules when posting.
For those who want the previous 4.1.1 version, a link has been posted in the sidebar. DELETE 5.0 before installing the old version!
We are getting ready to push an update to the free version, and to push to Premium.
WARNING TO PREMIUM USERS: If you think you may not 'like' the new version, we STRONGLY suggest downloading the FREE version first, because we will NOT be posting a link to the old PREMIUM build...so once you update, there is no turning back!
11
Oct 02 '15
Okay so this is the first time I'm actually complaining about an app. That has to do with the fact that the old BR was near perfect. I get it, the devs worked long and hard on this, and it does look pretty! However, I have never seen so much complaints about a new update. I really hope the team listens to the criticism, and acts accordingly. A lot of functionality was lost in the process. Here are some things I would like to see improved:
The bottom bar back. Putting everything on top makes this app very uncomfortable to use.
The search function should allow us to easily look through results from posts/subs/users, now we have to do 3 separate searches for that.
Clicking on the top left in a post used to take you to its particular sub, I really miss that feature. Should be easy to implement, right?
I hope the devs can work on this because if these functionalities don't return soon, I don't see any reason to keep using the new BR, pretty as it is.
2
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Oct 02 '15
Thanks for your input! We appreciate it. We are reviewing feedback and making some adjustments. We are considering a bottom action bar, but only when in detail view. That way you don't have to scroll to the top to vote, view link, etc. on the active post.
We have not yet considered changing Search, but I do see your point. At a minimum, what if we kept the last search string in the search field so you didn't have to type it again?
As for clicking the subname in the action bar, currently you can tap the hotlink of the subname in a post title if you are in detail/slideshow and that will take you to that sub. We realize the touch target is a bit small. We're looking into tapping sub name again to take you to a sub.
1
Oct 02 '15 edited Oct 02 '15
Thanks for replying. So no bottom action bar when browsing subreddits? But glad to hear you're working on it. (Edit: if you won't implement a permanent bottom bar, could you at least put a permanent button to open the menu at the bottom? Now it's in the upper left corner, the farthest away from my thumb.)
As for search, if you could then immediately switch the search field(posts, subreddits, users etc) then I guess that would make it a lot better.
As for the last thing, didn't know that! If it works it works, just hadn't seen it yet.
When do you think these things will be updated?
2
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Oct 02 '15
Some time next week. Trying to get as many changes in as possible...
2
u/innovativediscord Oct 02 '15
Clicking the top left sub name to go to a parent sub was my most used navigational feature and scrolling all the way to the top of the details page to hit the link (tiny or not) is a fairly poor substitute.
Similarly I'd echo that moving the incredibly well thought out position of buttons from right where my thumb was to the top of the phone, when phones are getting ever bigger, seems a strange choice.
Some of the other changes maybe I'll get used to, it certainly looks nice, but those ones are a real killer though.
1
9
u/winnipegtommy Oct 01 '15
It's really uncomfortable reading the comments in this bold font. I like how the front page looks, though.
6
u/goofygooberrock Oct 01 '15
Agreed. I quite liked how the front page looked until I clicked through and saw all the bold text. It is genuinely unreadable for me. As a BaconReader fan I'm really disappointed and am currently shopping around for a new Reddit app.
1
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Oct 01 '15
It's a medium weight font. We're looking at changing it in the next release.
8
u/winnipegtommy Oct 01 '15
The font I'm typing in looks perfect, and then the published comment is just too heavy. I've never tried other reddit apps on Android, but now I'm shopping around. I guess I'm already a bacon reader pro user, so I don't have anything to offer you guys, but I'd gladly buy pro again to have a font that's easier to read.
1
u/raisinhall Oct 04 '15
Please look into this soon! I'm fine with the new app, but this font is killing my head. I get an instant headache reading the bold font, and I've tried changing the font size.
1
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Oct 04 '15
Yep. Next update won't be the medium weight (which is what makes it look bold.). Also, the font sizes will be adjusted so what is currently large font will be medium in the update.
8
u/ASREV Android Sep 29 '15
Is there a reason I still can't update with the Premium version? Seems weird to hold those of us back who paid for the app.
6
Sep 29 '15
More free users = more feedback, letting free users test means premium users are happier. Makes sense from a development perspective. We can wait.
-4
u/Timboflex Sep 30 '15 edited May 09 '25
dinner vase chief profit rock school voracious abundant outgoing rinse
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
Sep 30 '15
Think about it this way:
Paid users have a lot more to say about the product than free users
0
Sep 30 '15
[deleted]
0
Sep 30 '15
[deleted]
-1
Sep 30 '15
I'm only going by what's in front of me. If you think that makes me an idiot, do you also think the Earth is only 6,000 years old?
Do you really think they're only excluding one user? Tell me how that works and what they gain from it?
1
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Sep 29 '15
It's in a staged rollout as well. Pushing to 50% so it should be coming soon.
5
u/paraplegic_T_Rex Sep 29 '15
How do you send a PM? This is one thing I cannot find.
1
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Sep 29 '15
In the build you have, the only place to do it is from your Inbox (upper right corner, tap the envelope)...but new build going out today (rev 21183), you will be able to do it from any users profile screen.
4
u/paraplegic_T_Rex Sep 29 '15
Yeah that definitely needs to be on the user page, since most times I am PMing someone I am going right from a comment thread to their profile, and then looking for that envelope.
2
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Sep 29 '15
:)
1
u/paraplegic_T_Rex Sep 29 '15
Hey keep up the good work though. If you want anyone with an outsider's perspective to take a look at some of these updates before you release them to the masses, let me know. I'd be interested.
1
3
u/SevenTwoThree Sep 29 '15
NSFW links are hidden even though my settings are set to display them... using Premium client (which automatically upgraded).
0
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Sep 29 '15 edited Sep 30 '15
Hmm. I'll check that out. We changed the default to not show them, but your prior setting should have been honored. Try disabling the setting, exit BR, relaunch and re-enable. Let me know if that doesn't work.
EDIT: Re-tested NSFW settings enabled in 4.1.1 premium, upgraded to 5.0.0 and my settings were retained.
3
u/textposts_only Sep 30 '15
you changed default settings to not show NSFW posts? Why would you do that?
3
u/duhdude Oct 01 '15
In the old version, when a comment was not all the way on the screen, the upvote / comment buttons would be centered in the visible area of the comment. Now, they're centered in the comment, so you have to scroll around to find the buttons. Very disappointing.
2
2
u/the_oogie_boogie_man Oct 02 '15
I don't love the new look, but it literally took me a minute or two to figure everything out.
I feel the people complaining aren't even giving it a chance. I'd prefer a couple things back the old way, like the main bar back at the bottom and to be permanent there. But it's way faster, the design is sleek, and everything is loading wonderfully.
1
2
u/sykee1991 Oct 03 '15
I'm not sure if this has been mentioned already, but the insanely bright orange on a highlighted post should be changed to how it was before, it makes it very difficult to read.
2
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Oct 03 '15
Thanks for the input. I think we are going back to mellower tone in light theme, and the blue tones in dark/black themes.
1
82
Sep 29 '15
If you could move the upvote/downvote/link bar to stay at the bottom of the screen like before, I would be perfectly happy. I didn't realize that was one of my favorite layouts until you changed it. So much easier to use.
27
u/Jkuz Sep 30 '15
Agreed! Baconreader is easily the most used app on my phone and the bottom bar was perfect for muscle memory. I'm not thrilled that it is gone.
18
u/Keets Oct 01 '15
Why do you have to scroll the whole way to the top to see the link now? I used the bottom link button all the time, both because it's more reachable and sometimes I'd read something in the comments I didn't notice in the link the first view.
7
u/EnigmasRevenge Oct 02 '15
Yea, I just noticed that. Now if I want to view the link, I'll essentially lose the comment if I'm deep in a thread. The bottom bar was a keeper. You even had the option to remove it if you wanted. I like a lot of the new features, but damn, some of the old ones were tight.
2
u/frikisada Oct 02 '15
I prefer it to stay on bottom, but I'd be ok with having it on top but always visible. Or an option for it
6
u/Foxata Android Sep 30 '15
This is my only question too. I use a galaxy note 3 and that button on the bottom was a god send. Now it feels like I have to use both hands to acces this app which is kind of a deal breaker to me.
3
u/Qw4zq Oct 01 '15
What could work for me is an expanding FAB. Hides the buttons when I don't need them (they really did take up too much space on the screen for my liking) and no need to scroll to the top.
101
u/Mattathon Sep 29 '15
I'm disappointed with this update. The new design is pretty, but it lacks the simple usability that the old version had, which is the reason I preferred it over other clients.
25
u/anonmeous Sep 29 '15
I honestly can't find how to post a comment. I can only reply to other comments.
13
10
u/Soul-Burn Sep 30 '15
Takes 2 more clicks to select another sub now. Took me 20 secs to find where to switch to a named sub (in the menu) and sub switching not available in post.
7
u/eugene_n_rusty Oct 01 '15
Text is smaller, so that there can be more whitespace? Clearly, BaconReader devs were not on newsstaff in high school.
24
u/procinct Sep 30 '15
The one recommendation I'd have would be to make it easier to open the link from the comment section. Currently you have to scroll back to the top which loses your place in the comments.
22
u/Hardworlder Sep 30 '15
Please put sticky buttons bottom again and change back the bold font. This app was so useful and simple it was the best. That's why I paid for the premium. I'm really getting frustrated using it now. Search function is pretty bad opposed to the previous one too. Finding a subreddit and going to it was really easy. Please revert back these changes..
20
u/Toasted_Badger Sep 30 '15
I really likes the old feature where when you clicked on the title of a post to open up the comments (from the front page) the top left had the link to that particular subreddit... Now there is just a link back to the front page - if I wanted to go back to the front page I could just use the back button!
Please fix this!
7
u/Hydra_fresh Oct 01 '15
Omg this so much. I tried like 5 other apps and none of them had that feature. It made browsing random subreddit so much easier on big ass screen phones like the nexus 6
17
u/lilpopjim0 Sep 30 '15
Damn auto updates. At least you guys have leave 4.1.1 for us to use. Thanks.
3
u/Bernkastel-Kues Oct 02 '15
Yeah, the ad filled version
1
u/lilpopjim0 Oct 02 '15
Eh.. I actually really like the new app.. few items take a while to do but it's nice.
55
u/Hurricane043 Sep 30 '15
This update does turns BaconReader into a half-assed clone of all the other Reddit apps on the store. If I wanted a flashy, material design Reddit app, I wouldn't have been using BR. I used BR for it's simplicity and usability that was severely lacking among all these other flashy Reddit apps that prioritize appearance over accessibility. Well, it looks like BR joined the trend. A weak attempt at fitting into the material design guidelines causes the app to loose all of its advantageous usability over other the other apps. And I emphasize that this was a weak attempt. Just to give examples, the bold text in the comments and action bar at the top of the screen demonstrates that the UI team must be incompetent.
It's no secret that BR has already been trailing behind most of the other Reddit apps in popularity. As it stands now, there is no reason to use BR over any of the other Reddit apps. In terms of appearance, it still doesn't come close to most of the other ones on the store. In terms of usability, which was BR's key advantage, it is no better than those apps, and actually worse in some cases.
I've been a loyal BR user for years, but now I'll be moving on to Relay. I've had it installed on my phone for some months now, but never could make the full switch because BR was easier to use. But that's not an issue any more.
15
u/etacarinae Sep 30 '15
Agreed entirely. There are so many other feature requests they could have acted on, and instead chose to focus on the abortion that is material design and its abject waste of screen real estate. A perfect example of this is within a subreddit or the front page, the sort by "what's hot, new, top etc" is now located on another row.
2
Oct 01 '15
And for me, sorting a post's comments by best, top etc. doesn't work near as well as it used to (it seems to give low scoring comments instead of ordering them by net upvotes like it used to)
2
u/TexasDex Android Oct 04 '15
I think the Material design itself is the problem. It's too focused on smooth, aesthetically-pleasing graphics and not enough on just getting shit done with your phone. Seriously, ICS was better at this.
30
Sep 30 '15
I've woke up today and mine has auto updated, as a premium are you saying I can't go back but unpaid versions can?
Have the people who run reddit taken over this app? Have you gone mental?!
5
u/ajsatx Oct 01 '15
How can you go back to the old unpaid app?
3
u/goofygooberrock Oct 01 '15
There is a link in the sidebar.
2
u/mcpoopybutt Oct 02 '15
Didn't work for me. Tried resetting my default apps, logged into Dropbox and tried downloading directly to no avail.
1
u/laniferous Oct 02 '15
I had the same problem, but then I updated drop box, tried it again, and it worked. WHEW, cause I do not like the new version!
-21
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
Maybe you should actually give the developers done constructive feedback so they know what you don't like.
They've been working on this redesign for a long time. Saying it sucks doesn't help them try to improve it. I doubt the overall design is going anywhere, but I'm sure they're willing to tweak things when enough people voice their opinions and it doesn't go against their design.
7
Sep 30 '15
I have in another thread. This is a different point so I posted it separately.
-13
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
Have the people who run reddit taken over this app? Have you gone mental?!
Developers are people too and rude accusations like this are discouraging. Unless the app ate your firstborn child, I see no reason to throw stuff out like this. If you're polite in your request, they're much more likely to try and appease it when possible, rather than trying to cater to people who show them no respect.
15
Sep 30 '15
Oh go away.
-6
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
Oh go away.
Oh, ok, since you said so. /s
But seriously, anytime you, as a customer, have a problem with something that's being provided to you, it helps to address that problem politely to try and get it resolved. When the rudeness comes out, people tend to not be as accommodating...
14
Sep 30 '15
I'm perfectly aware of this obvious information. I disagree I've been rude, matter of perspective.
Please go state the obvious elsewhere.
-11
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
So...
Have the people who run reddit taken over this app? Have you gone mental?!
...isn't considered rude? I'd hate to deal with you when you do think you're actually being rude.
And everyone, feel free to keep downvoting me for trying to keep some civility towards the developers when they put out an update that isn't liked by everyone. I'm not worried about fake internet points...
4
Sep 30 '15
Like I said it's a matter of perspective. I thought it was mildly amusing, I'm so sorry you didn't agree. Will that apology suffice to end this triviality.
-6
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
I don't feel I need an apology. I'm just trying to make sure the devs aren't spat on for trying to improve the app, even if it fell short of some peoples' expectations.
→ More replies (0)
7
u/IAMA_BAD_MAN_AMA Oct 02 '15
I paid for the premium version and auto update fucked me. OneLouder expects me to use the ad supported version to get back the product I paid for? Bugger off.
12
u/Craften Sep 30 '15
Seriously, I can't go back to the 4.1.1 premium build? This new update is awful, all the easy to reach buttons have been hidden behind this wannabe material design, definitely changing my rating :/
1
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
They hear peoples' complaints and they're looking into it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/baconreader/comments/3mufup/slug/cvj5f3k
6
6
u/GrandeLatte27 Oct 01 '15
Goodbye, BR. It was good while it lasted.
0
u/QAHmark913 Both Oct 01 '15
We always like constructive feedback if you have any.
But we do hope to earn you back with a few improvements we brewing because of feedback we've received thus far. It's a learning process...
6
u/greasedonkey Android Oct 01 '15
I don't love it, all features that I liked over other apps are gone.
The hability to switch from comment and link easily, now you have to scroll back up.
Same thing for upvote and downvote.
Long pressing the subreddit selector would allow you to type and navigate to a manual sub, now you need to click the top left icon and then the /r sub button. On top of that the keyboard doesn't open before I put the cursor in the input field.
The top left button in the detail virw where it would show the sub name is gone, made it harder to navigate to this sub.
Are you guys developing another reddit app similar to the old version and trying to make this one so bad that people will switch to it and pay for premium again?
2
u/QAHmark913 Both Oct 01 '15
Full disclosure 3 of your 4 you features that you noted were discussed today in a meeting with the team. Improvements will be made.
Nothing is intentional on that last piece.
6
u/MisterTruth Oct 02 '15
This update is just flat out awful. Instead of the buttons in nice places for your thumbs, everything is on top. I can no longer scroll through my subreddits, click off, and then still be on the same spot. Nothing is intuitive. The old version was fantastic and as a paid user for many years, I am extremely disappointed.
5
u/Albino_Echidna Sep 29 '15
Is there no option to have images auto load so they are on the same page as the comments? That was the whole reason I moved to bacon reader and even bought premium. It was on every version until now...
3
u/tylerdurden801 Sep 30 '15
Yeah, is there any way in tablet mode to have the image load on the right pane? Seems silly to have to click on the link button to see some cruddy meme and then click back to read the comments. Aside from this I like the update.
5
u/sinlad Oct 01 '15 edited Oct 01 '15
Why can't I go to subreddits directly without going to side bar? Bring back the bottom bar. Why when I go to a post from my front page is all the post info so tiny? I used to be able to go to that subreddit just by click up at the top bar. Everything about the side bar is terrible, you can't use it during comment sections either. If you think reddit users won't put up 2 seconds wait time for a gif or a webpage then, and don't improve this app is doomed. I'm uninstalling out of frustration. 1 star review on Google play right now. /Premium user
5
Oct 01 '15
Yeah, this is bad. The font became to small. When I increase it it just looks ugly. And the damned ads. I run adblock and now I got empty spaces everywhere.
4
u/Soul-Burn Sep 30 '15
Weird issue. When scrolling a text post, the post area sometimes dims which is quite distracting. I believe it comes from the update by scrolling up feature.
4
u/SkyWulf Oct 02 '15
Wow I actually really hate this update. The ads are incredibly intrusive and the app's whole style changed including navigation, which is the reason I went with BR in the first place.
1
u/Dark_Fury1000 Oct 02 '15
Does anyone have the link to the old version?
0
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Oct 02 '15
It's in the sidebar. Please delete 5.0 before installing.
2
u/EnigmaticTortoise Oct 02 '15
Only the free version. Apparently you actually care less about your paid users.
1
u/Hydra_fresh Oct 02 '15
Its taking a little getting used to but it's all manageable thanks for the update
The only complain I have is could it be possible to go to the from the post to the subreddit by clicking the big subreddit name on top rather than the tiny link under the OP's name? It's really annoying to aim for that tiny text on large screens like the nexus 6
2
1
u/assburgerslevelsmart Oct 03 '15
there is no way to comment to a thread on the new update. wtf. you can only comment to comments..
2
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Oct 03 '15
Top action bar, curved arrow icon...that's the reply icon. Likely changing the icon in next update...
1
u/assburgerslevelsmart Oct 03 '15
Thanks, the placement, look and everything was so drastically different that it never registered, its like going from windows to mac.
1
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Oct 03 '15
Yeah...location may change... Still looking at static action bar at the bottom when in detail or slideshow view. If we do that, the reply could be moved to that action bar.
3
u/r4wrdinosaur Sep 30 '15
I'm attempting to switch to the old app via the Dropbox link you posted. I've downloaded the file, but every time I attempt to install it says "App not installed." No idea what I'm doing wrong.
My main issues with the update: lack of link/voting bar at the bottom of the screen. All of the text appears to be bold? Also, forcing the sort by into its own bar is a huge waste of space.
Oh, and the ads are intrusive. But I'm sure you already knew that.
I use this app for hours every day. When I downloaded the new update and saw the ads, I figured it was time to really support you guys and download premium. But I'm glad I waited. The new updates make the app feel completely unusable. If it's not fixed soon, I'm going to start trying new apps.
2
u/Evillordfluffy Oct 01 '15
Do you have version 5.0 installed while you are trying to install the old app? If so your device is seeing a newer version of the app and refusing to install because Android doesn't handle rollbacks. Uninstall 5.0 then install the old app.
3
u/rand0mguydbp Oct 01 '15
I only have two gripes about the update: no full screen slideshow and no downvote/attachment bar at the bottom. For the second problem you could make it like in most browsers. Where you scroll up a little and the bar shows up instead of scrolling all the way back up. Other than that I'm loving the new update.
3
u/Steamships Android Oct 01 '15
Are all comments bold? While text posts don't look bold and are more gray, the comments are practically white and bold. It feels like there's extreme emphasis on everything and is harder for me to read.
3
u/mcmb211 Oct 01 '15
I miss the static bars! I hate having to scroll up to switch subbreddits or search. Otherwise I like the update. I was going to buy the pro version, but I'm going to wait. The update looks pretty, but doesn't function as nicely for me. Overall, I think it's a step in the right direction!
0
u/QAHmark913 Both Oct 01 '15
We appreciate your response. We will continue to address the feedback and respond. Those bars are one of the areas we've discussed internally and should make progress on.
1
u/mcmb211 Oct 01 '15
Great! I do really like the app and I'm looking forward to improvements. Thank you for responding.
1
1
Sep 30 '15
Digging the update so far - no regrets with blindly updating to the premium version.
One suggestion, though. Why does the "sort by" feature need its own bar? Seems like a terrible waste of space. Just stick that up in between the subreddit button and the search button. Even just putting the icon up there would be fine.
1
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Sep 30 '15
Thanks for the positive feedback! I'll pass your suggestion on to UI team, but short answer is it won't fit on many devices and would force some other action into a menu.
2
2
u/0wlington Oct 01 '15
Nexus 4, and that bar really is bothering me. It takes up a lot of real estate on the screen. Do we even need to know how it's sorted all the time?
1
u/Indefinitely_not Oct 01 '15
Love it!
Few points of attention:
Is it possible to reply to the main thread when you are in the thread already? I don't know how to do it, seems like an issue to me!
The font looks bold. This is weird and not pretty, in my opinion.
Other than that, I enjoy the update. The app looks great! 🙋
1
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Oct 01 '15
Thanks. To reply to a thread tap the reply arrow in the top title/action bar.
We're looking at font, intensity, etc. Some changes will be made.
4
u/EnigmaticTortoise Oct 02 '15
Absolutely horrendous UI. I will be downgrading immediately.
Edit: No link to the old premium version? Way to treat you paid users with respect, assholes. I will never recommend this app to anyone again. That you could think this was an improvement is stunning to me.
2
u/aperson 🥓 Sep 29 '15 edited Sep 29 '15
Read post titles are nearly unreadable with the black color scheme. Also, the link icon (the globe) looks off because it aligned with the post title. It should be centered and vertically aligned with the vote count.
-3
u/QAHmark913 Both Sep 29 '15
Unreadable, are you outside with your screen brightness set to very, very low?
It currently matches the same placements as the thumbnails. But you personally think it should be in the center of the upvote and downvote arrows?
4
u/aperson 🥓 Sep 29 '15
My screen brightness is set to auto and I am frequently inside and outside. The text is hardly readable in both situations. I have the text set to the medium size (had to up the size from small since this update). I have an amoled display if that means anything. Also, when I opened up your reply, I see that it is highlighted orange. That is also hard to read with white text, though much easier than the unread post titles.
As for the icon, yes.
2
u/the_dayman Oct 01 '15
Something about how the text is all bold makes it super hard for my eyes to focus on and read. Except on the list of posts, then I can't tell the difference between bold or not to know what I've read.
2
u/DiscoCaine Oct 01 '15
Could you clarify the premium thing? If I go back to the old one I have to stay there forever?
Could you fix the gifv download for the old one? Then it would be fine.
2
Oct 01 '15
Could you include a ability to disable the video ads? They really break the flow of the new UI (which so far I prefer over the old one), you guys did all this work to make a nice flowing UI and now it's being spoiled. Also I have a feeling these video ads are going to drain much more of my data plan. A simple ability to disable these types of ads would be greatly appreciated.
2
2
u/intensebeet Oct 03 '15
My biggest complaint is that when I click to switch between "hot" and "new" (which I do every time I load the app on the subs I frequent) the menu to select that option pops up on the other side of the screen which doesn't make any sense and seems completely unnatural.
I downloaded relay a while ago but continued using bacon reader because the interface was more appealing to me, the changes made in this update have bacon reader incorporating the features of relay that kept me from using that app regularly. I'm not a fan.
3
u/knockoutking Sep 30 '15 edited Sep 30 '15
Well looks like I made a huge mistake upgrading first :(
edit: upgrading first without checking to see if i could downgrade that is
3
2
u/TwitchingDed Sep 30 '15
New upgrade looks great, but now I can't seem to access a sub without scrolling through my list. I used to be able to tap the subreddit name at the top of a post and I would be taken to that subreddit. It was a great way to explore the posts that don't stay on my front page long enough.
I also can't seem to access any sidebar any more. Last version I could long-press a sub's name and get the sidebar. Now I can't find it.
1
u/QAHmark913 Both Oct 01 '15
We've noted this, talked about it today. I'd imagine it added back in in the near future.
Then see the top right overflow menu for the sidebar.
1
u/TwitchingDed Oct 02 '15
Thank you! I didn't notice that overflow menu. I'm glad it is still accessible. I miss the old way, it was quicker, but I'm probably one of the few who knew the long press did that. I'm not going to reiterate the same things as others, but on whole, I am really digging the new update. Keep up the good work!
2
Sep 29 '15
Happy to jump in feet first, but you better believe I do have a way back, it's called Titanium Backup. Or Reddit Sync. When I buy an app I want, I tend to buy two or three; one, I support Android development, and two, options. Love BaconReader but if I have an issue, I'll report it and use another client until it's fixed, if necessary. It's all good. Keep up the good work OneLouder.
1
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
Unfortunately, not everyone has their phone rooted, so Titanium Backup is not an option for everyone.
1
Sep 30 '15
What the hell are you talking about? How does other people not rooting change the fact that "I do have a way back." What other people do has got nothing to do with my phone and my solution.
-1
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
Your message didn't say it, but it did imply that anyone can easily return to the previous version.
I didn't want to assume you were just rubbing it into other peoples' faces that you have a way back when they don't, but I guess I shouldn't have given you the benefit of a doubt.
2
Sep 30 '15
No it didn't. I said that I have a way back. I didn't say anything about what other people can do.
If I wanted to just do what everyone else does, I'd have an iPhone. I own my device. I don't allow others to dictate what I do with it. And I don't care what others do with theirs. I will help when I'm able, and advise when it's asked, but what you and others do with yours has nothing to do with what I do with mine.
Almost anybody can root, by the way. If you choose Android, you chose choice. If you choose not to make a choice, some other choices will be unavailable to you.
-1
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
So, you basically did post that just to rub it in peoples' faces...
And while yes, everyone can root, it can make things really difficult in certain cases. I'm rooted (actually, I'm running a custom ROM), so now I can't use Android Pay. As a long time Google Wallet user, this is extremely annoying. I've been debating restoring the stock ROM and keeping this device unrooted, just so I can get tap to pay back since I used it all the time. Others are unable to use their bank app, or connect to their work email account when rooted.
Rooting isn't feasible for everyone's usage, but I'm glad it is for yours. But I see no reason for you to rub in the fact that you don't have to have the new build since you have a backup. That's just throwing gas in the fire. But I guess this is the internet, and you're free to do what you want...
2
Sep 30 '15
No, I simply said I had an option. You're talking about throwing gas in the fire, but look at yourself. You go around and pick people's posts apart looking for a fight. That's you. Whether that's all you'll ever amount to remains to be seen, but I hope it isn't.
1
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
What other reason would you post that you can return to your backup and then, when I mention that not everyone else can do that, you flat out say it wasn't about anyone else other than to throw gas in the fire? Or are you just oblivious to how many people want to return and can't because they have premium?
I'm comfortable with my online presence, both on reddit, and many other forums (if you're interested, feel free to Google my username, I don't hide behind any anonymity -- I've participated in a number of forums including xda, cyanogenmod, and linuxquestions). I try to add value with my posts, which is indicated with my initial reply to your first post. I thought you added value with yours, but I thought you were implying that everyone should have a backup, to which I responded that not everyone is rooted. You're the one who then decided to slam my post... which is certainly your prerogative. If you don't feel my posts add to the conversation, feel free to downvote and move on, but I will always stand by my posts, and reply whenever I feel it is needed.
2
Sep 30 '15
Because my initial post wasn't about anyone who can't roll back, it was about my ability to do so despite what the OP said. Wasn't to put down anyone else.
And what's this shit about anonymity? Who said anything about that? What, do you want my personal info because I have a better equipped phone and you want to beat me up over it? Do you want to steal my lunch money, too? I used the same name for 22 years online, and it was easy to Google it and get my real name. Then they named a movie after me, a band, a couple songs, and the real me got knocked down to page 2. It got to the point where my name was so big, people were registering it on sites I hadn't joined yet. I walked away from it, for the most part, because after all, I picked the name when I was 12. I like this one more. It's not about hiding, it's about not being a public figure. You aren't using a real name — maybe we should all use real names? I wouldn't agree with that.
Anyway, at this point, we are just talking past one another. This will amuse me for a couple more rounds, perhaps.
So basically, your whole point is, you think I'm an asshole because I boasted that I can roll back using a paid app that requires root. Okay, I accept that. I would be lying if I said I'm not an asshole. I try to be helpful, where I can, but sometimes, I am an asshole. And I'm okay with that. Maybe it was selfish to say... but if you're on XDA and CM, and you said you use a custom ROM and have root, then you should know as well as I do that it is a choice, and one not without risks, that is there for anyone to make. I choose root and ROM. My wife chooses pure stock. We both enjoy our phones.
2
u/bassmadrigal Oct 01 '15
I was trying to add to your post stating that not all users could roll back because not all users are rooted.
And the anonymity portion was only due to what you wrote here:
You're talking about throwing gas in the fire, but look at yourself. You go around and pick people's posts apart looking for a fight. That's you. Whether that's all you'll ever amount to remains to be seen, but I hope it isn't.
I only meant that if you look at my history between here and other sites, you'd be able to answer the "whether that's all you'll ever amount to remains to be seen", knowing I use the same name on pretty much all my sites. I only try to post when I feel it adds value to something and if you were to check my username at those other forums (not that I'm saying you need to), you'd see that I try to be professional and calm in any of my posts. I had no intention on implying whether or not you are trying to hide anything here.
But, this started because I thought I was adding value to your post, but you obviously didn't think so. That's fine. This is the internet. People will disagree. And I agree that it is certainly people's rights to use their phones how they like. There are benefits to rooting and/or custom ROMs, and there are benefits to staying stock. I've spent many years enjoying custom ROMs on my devices, but I don't flaunt it around. I saw your post as either assuming most have the ability to restore the backup or rubbing it in people's faces that you can and they can't. In my first response, I chose to think it was the former, and in subsequent posts, it seemed to be the latter. I realize now that it was just in response to the "there will be no turning back" portion that was posted. Sorry I misunderstood your meaning.
→ More replies (0)
1
u/lolsasha Sep 30 '15
The sort by best comments isn't working for me. Unless all the best comments were made "moments ago"
It seems I have to reselect it for it to actually sort properly, and even then it's not working on subregions, only front page posts.
1
u/BenjRubenstein Sep 30 '15
When you click on a post in the widget, it takes you to the post, but then you can't get from there to any other sub. The back button takes you out of the app. You used to be able to tap on the name of the sub and it would bring you back to the main app app you could navigate around. Plz2fix. Thanks.
1
u/tsar_kracken Oct 01 '15
Thanks for your activity through the update with the users. Some things that I have concern for: (things already said) the comment font and the dark bar for hidden comments. Another thing that I haven't seen anyone talk about is the differentiation between read and unread posts. I think it needs to be more visible as to which posts you've already clicked on for default ui.
1
u/jiarb Android Oct 01 '15
looks damn sexy but there's a lot of empty space now on list view for subs. particularly where the link globe is.
1
Oct 01 '15
I don't like it. Why doesn't the picture automatically open now on the right side of the screen?
0
u/QAHmark913 Both Oct 01 '15
Are you talking about the thumbnail and the area around it (above and below) opening the image?
1
Oct 01 '15
On my tablet there is an option to have the links on the left and the comments on the right. It used to open up images in a preview on the right but now it isn't.
1
u/compyface286 Oct 03 '15
I actually really like this update. It looks a lot sleeker and slideshow view is awesome with youtube embed! And the gifv music issue is fixed which is great. My only small issue is that there should be an option to move the upvote/downvote/link bar to the lower right side vertically or horizontally at the bottom. But when using slideshow this isnt a huge issue anyway. Thanks for being awesome!
1
u/alignedletters Oct 04 '15
Hey there,
I agree with most of the things that have been said here (Regarding the "underbar" and other changes), but I'd like to point out one more thing that I haven't seen:
When I swipe (left or right) on a thread title/post/comment in order to upvote or save or whatever, 85% of the time it "clicks" the post, thus going into the thread or collapsing the child-comments.
This means that in most cases when I only want to upvote/save, I have to return to the main page or uncollapse the comments. This never (ever!) happened to me in the old version, so I guess there's a minor bug in the new update.
Thanks for reading, guys.
1
1
u/Masterofunlocking1 Sep 30 '15
I like the new update so congrats to yall and thanks for the hard work. I do have a suggestion although it might be answered elsewhere. Is there a way to open a picture and hold down on it to save or share? If not can this be added? Also, I'm not too fond of the highlighting of posts when I scroll there my Frontpage. Other than these things, I love the app. Thanks for listening.
1
u/QAHmark913 Both Oct 01 '15
Press on an image to open up in the preview/in-app browser, top right overflow/extended menu has a save option that will work for images and most gifs.
That what you are looking for? Thanks for your kind words, they are nice to see, read, and feel.
1
u/Masterofunlocking1 Oct 01 '15
That works thanks. Has there been any thought about just give you an option to long press the picture after click the thumbnail on the right and a menu comes up to share, save, etc? I really like this app and it's probably the best on Droid.
1
u/mronosa Sep 30 '15
I am a huge fan of this design. I appropriate the material design. I feel that the user experience is greatly improved. Generally speaking, I don't have to think to use this application, which is a case for good design. I'm seeing a lot of criticism from the community (which is a good thing), so I just wanted to say that I find the updated refreshing and a step in the right direction. has premium and Nexus 6
1
0
0
Sep 30 '15
[deleted]
13
u/onelouderchic 🥓 Sep 30 '15
We hear you loud and clear. Seems to be a big complaint. We'll look into it.
12
u/Keets Oct 01 '15
How can you say you are looking into it when yesterday this was asked and the response was "no, deal with it"?
u/20047m posted
Personally, this makes browsing harder on a 5.5"+ screen. I always keep (or kept) my thumb near the bottom of the screen so I could go to the image link or hit back easily, but now I'm reaching to the top of the screen all the time which is much more inefficient. Is there any plan for bringing back a bottom bar?
u/QAHmark913 responded
Consulting with our UX team. It's not an easy change cannot confirm that it is or is not going to switch anytime soon, to be absolutely honest. But (almost) any feedback on these posts and about the Android Material Design update has been helpful.
2
u/QAHmark913 Both Oct 01 '15
/u/Keets, onelouderchic will have the final say with a lot of this stuff... we are indeed consulting our lead UX and Dev on it. So, furthering my statement the other day... there could be a change subjectively sooner than I had thought... however, still cannot make any promises in the area.
TL;DR: Figured to respond back, just know we are going back to the drawing board.
-10
5
u/Bernkastel-Kues Oct 02 '15
Yeah, the bottom bar is what made br so great for me. Now it's like the terrible apple version of br
0
Sep 30 '15
[deleted]
6
u/duhdude Oct 01 '15
Agree, these are very distracting, not just because of the color, but also because there is a small amount of whitespace on the right side. That contrast constantly pulls my eyes away from the text.
0
0
Oct 01 '15
[deleted]
1
u/Evillordfluffy Oct 01 '15
Slideshow is still around. Open a post and in the action bar or overflow menu the option will appear.
0
Sep 30 '15
[deleted]
1
u/bassmadrigal Sep 30 '15
They're rolling out the updates in percentages. It's up to Google on which users get the updates, and it's probably not determined by region.
Just give it time. I'm still waiting for my update and I'm in the US.
37
Sep 29 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
26
Sep 29 '15
Not to mention video ads use more data.
5
u/ajsatx Oct 01 '15
I haven't seen video ads..? I definately see bigger ads in between posts now, in addition to the small bammer ads at the bottom of the screen that were already there. Aside from some cosmetic changes, it seems like all that really changed is there are more ads. Also, they removed the name from the app icon. Wtf? I know I'm complaining about the free version, but I wish I could gp back to the last update..
2
u/supercheesepuffs Oct 01 '15
Yup, I have enjoyed the app, but with video ads it sucks my already limited data. I won't be continuing to use baconreader unless they make a data friendly version with no video ads
57
u/0wlington Sep 29 '15
This new version is awful. It's a pain to navigate, no slide show, the replacement slide show thing is stupid and doesn't let me click on pictures to open them, and I could go on. Unfortunately, I had my phone on auto update, so now I've lost my premium version that I have used for years. This sucks.