r/backgammon • • Aug 09 '21

Backgammon Galaxy Rant

BG Galaxy is a good site b/c I get to play quick games with people of all skill levels, well those who will accept my request to play.

But my issue is when I win and get 0 points for my rating. According to the analytics my error rate is higher but yet I still won, I should get a few points for the win.

Also, my issue with BG Galaxy is when I review my play and one of my "errors" would have resulted in me getting hit. How is my choice where I didn't get hit and error? I get that my choice may not have been statistically the best choice but after the roll shows my choice was better than the statistical choice.
Example, I used my roll of 2,1 for 13/10 (-0.107) red issue. But the BGG system says I should have hit the person on 6/3. But the next roll was my opponent rolling a 6,3. So I would have ended up getting hit myself in my own home.

I am working hard to win and hoping that winning will raise my rating but that doesn't seem to be the case. Pretty frustrating.

2 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

20

u/PrizeArticle1 Aug 09 '21 edited Aug 09 '21

I get your gripe about the rating system, but the fact that your opponent would have hit doesn't mean it's still not the best move. If you hit on a 20 and got 21 in blackjack, I would still tell you that was a foolish play

1

u/TuitionandIntuition Jan 29 '25

This is the single most stupid comment on BG I have ever read. Has nothing AT ALL to do with Blackjack!

13

u/MrPrettyKitty Aug 09 '21

Well, that’s not the way Galaxy works. You need to have a lower error rate AND win for points. The idea is to reward good play rather than just luck. And every roll is standalone, just like in real life. You can’t determine the efficacy of a roll by the luck of another roll.

2

u/bangroll Aug 10 '21

Do you think that in the real world of backgammon, luck in dice is not a natural thing? So luck should definitely be considered in rating.

1

u/TungstenYUNOMELT Aug 22 '21

Luck averages out over time, skill does not. The rating is an estimate of skill.

1

u/puntanegra May 14 '22

This is a dice game. Why you want to control it???!!!

1

u/puntanegra May 14 '22

For that same reason you develop skills, thats the purpose of considering probabilities than let luck play his part.

A beginner will have luck to certain point, but some ppl's BS is can NOT stand loosing to a beginner. So all this controlling dices and GR is more BS. They have taken the gift of this 3000 year game, controlling it

1

u/No_Statistician_8464 Mar 26 '23

If you don't want PR to affect the rating points, there are many other "normal" backgammon sites. Heroes, or Backgammon Hub, and the Galaxy app doesn't count errors against the result either.

1

u/MrPrettyKitty Aug 11 '21

Ok, so luck by definition is unknown, right? So at any point in time a potential move can only be judged by what is known. A move that is followed by great dice isn’t better than a move followed by lousy dice.

1

u/TuitionandIntuition Jan 29 '25

it is not really real Backgammon

1

u/MrPrettyKitty Jan 29 '25

Fake backgammon?

1

u/puntanegra May 14 '22

Galaxy is a sham!!! Controlling luck is only controlling who is to win. If you have low GR and you make thoughtful move and works its luck!!!! The algorithm works for higher GR. When higher GR are loosing they resign no points are taken. I believe the algorithm works for them to decide who is up and who is down. I wont bet money in this one is like all casinos. You are there to loose. Wonder if NJSoftware.com is behind Galaxy, Their algoritms work the same as playing with a computer.

1

u/MrPrettyKitty May 14 '22

What is GR? And it sounds like Heroes for you, eh?

6

u/morten_dm Aug 09 '21

There is no reason to differentiate between going for the win and going for a lower error rate. The best moves will give you both - in the long run.

1

u/UBKUBK Aug 17 '21

There are many situations where the move to make playing to win the match and the move to make going for a lower error rate are different.

1

u/morten_dm Aug 17 '21

Can you back that up with one example?

The errors are based on equity in the match. If you make a move that is an error that means that you lowered your chance of winning.

If you are talking about super advanced stuff like playing into the other players weakness or accounting for your own weakness then yes, you can pick a move that takes the game into a direction that might increase your chance of winning while giving you a small error. Other than that, I can't think of any examples.

1

u/UBKUBK Aug 17 '21

Playing to the opponent and yourself is basic strategy and not super advanced. The bot values are assuming best play according to the bot from then on which is not what is actually happening in a match between two humans. Here are a few ofher ways or reasons why strategy could be different in a PR match:

Realize that the bot is not perfect. Play a super deep backgame at yohr own risk in a PR game.

There are a lot of tricks involving decision counts. Suppose opponent has four on the ace and you have checkers on 1,2,3 and roll a 61. The best move in a PR match is 3/2/off since you can gain a decision if roll a one next turn. Similar things can occur by not running off a gammon yet when the race is lost for winning the game but the gammon save is assured.

Suppose you are in a bearoff where opponent has checkers all on the ace point and your are scattered and you get doubled and think it is a 1.01 pass. In a PR contest you might want to take in order to obtain the easy decisions that are upcoming.

Suppose you have a difficult play early in a 13 point match with the cube on 8 already. The high cube argues for using a lot more clock time than you would if the cube was centered even if it might mean some rushed plays and resulting errors later on. In a PR match though the errors are scaled to cube size so an error on the 8 cube does not hurt as much so again some strategy is different.

1

u/morten_dm Aug 17 '21

Sure. That is all super advanced and definitely not something that OP should be worrying about. I'm catching a sense that OP is not at that level and is more trying to understand what error rate is. But sure

1

u/puntanegra May 14 '22

Error rate is BS!!! who decides is an error when you are dealing w luck and probabilities.

When a beginner makes a thoughtful move and works is "luck"

When a beginner wins no reward is given bc he won with to many errors. BSSSSSSShit!!

This is a game that remains the same for centuries. A beginner's luck will come to an end eventually won't go far in a championship. Many Big players think loosing to a beginner is not fair. No big player will play w a beginner bc he is afraid of luck. BBBSSSShit thats all. Controlling this game is controlling everthing, worst when money is involved.

BSSSSS

1

u/No_Statistician_8464 Mar 26 '23

Ok, what you say about backgames is true: that is the bot's one weakness.

1

u/No_Statistician_8464 Mar 26 '23

That seems totally illogical. If you make a move that you THINK is better to win the match, and the computer analysis says a different move is better - it will win more often if you played it 1000 times, for example - then you are wrong to some degree, even a very small percent. The computer plays better than humans. I do not know ANY situation where what you say is true: you would have to give an example.

1

u/UBKUBK Mar 26 '23
  1. Even if the computer can play theoretically optimally there will be moves which are practically better taking into account that the opponent is not perfect. For example against a weak player you would play for contact instead of transitioning to a race where there would be less skill needed to play it well.

  2. There are a lot of little tricks one can do to artificially improve an error rate dealing with upping the decisions. For example suppose you know that a long race is an extremely close drop. If you take you get hit with a small error but then will benefit from having a lot of easy plays which ups the decision count.

  3. Deep containment games can be off the rails and the deep backgames preceding them. It could even extend to plays that might lead to a deep backgame with the bot hacing a bias towards avoiding them.

5

u/Mouse2799 Aug 09 '21

I get that my choice may not have been statistically the best choice but after the roll shows my choice was better than the statistical choice.

This is not how statistical analysis works... You can't look back on a "bad" move and say it was the best choice because you didn't get hit on rhe opponent's next roll.

4

u/Electronic-Ad712 Aug 09 '21

BG is not perfect but is amazing site for improving your backgammon skills. I love the Analysis tab, and going through my errors after games. Especially those scenarios that I have no idea what would be the best play, doing this over and over helps you become a much better player in time. I have never been better and more confident about my game, and I am easily better than all my family members and friends because of these few month playing on BG.

4

u/bowdownjesus Aug 09 '21

Backgammonstudio works the way you want it to. You don´t win as much every time though.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '21

As others have said, your second point sort of misses the boat: you need to play the odds in backgammon - a move isn't wrong just because it doesn't work out.

However, I do agree with your first point, and I think Backgammon Galaxy is deeply flawed as a result:

  1. To those who say, "jUsT pLaY bEtTer lol" - this ignores the fact that sometimes the difference between scores is so infinitesimal as to be negligible. I just lost a game where I played at a 1.47 (0.06 equity lost) and my opponent played at a 0.91 (0.04 equity lost). Neither of us made any errors. It was a simple, boring game where he ran out his back checkers within three moves and then won a race while I sat on his 4 point. He was a weaker player, so I lost 5 rating points. But I think my decisions were much more complicated than his, and the system doesn't take that into account. All this accomplishes is to disincentivize me from playing any weaker players - the risk isn't worth the reward, and that's a shame.

  2. I think there should be SOME reward for winning the game, even if you play like a rookie and your opponent plays like a grand master. Make it just one ELO point, I don't care - but there has to be something. Otherwise what are we playing for? The W-L record is irrelevant - it's barely displayed on your profile. All that matters is ELO, and a beginner might get lucky, but isn't going to luck their way into a 2k+ ELO.

  3. If we accept that winning ELO is really the goal of playing on Backgammon Galaxy, then it follows that the game we play on Galaxy isn't really backgammon. Backgammon is a cruel, beautiful game in which luck plays a role. Measuring your move selection against a computer removes the luck factor, and you're left with a watered-down version of the game. Try playing a cash game and then not paying up if your opponent wins because of luck and let me know how that goes. Luck matters in backgammon and so should have consequences.

  4. Playing backgammon well IMO is both an art and a science. The science is selecting the best move, but the art is picking up on weaknesses in your opponent's game and exploiting them. This is especially true with in-person play, and even more so with the use of the cube. But a computer can't account for any of that. So play on Backgammon Galaxy distills backgammon into a science, and takes away the art. The art is why I fell in love with the game, so I'm left feeling a bit hollow playing on Galaxy.

6

u/blue-flight Aug 09 '21

Nextgammon works the way you want btw, you may like it better. If you win and play worse you still get points but only half as much if you were to win and play better.

The move is still the wrong move because if you played your move every time in that position over say 100 games you would lose more points than if you were to make the statistically correct move over 100 games. Being a better player is all about making the moves that win you the most games and matches over the long run, that's how you rise to the top.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '21

When you lose the match but have a better PR than your opponent and don’t lose galaxy points aren’t you happy? It works both ways

0

u/bangroll Aug 11 '21

In my opinion, if someone who has won the game with more chances is given rating and the rating are not deducted from the opponent. This way of rating is more pleasing and of course fairer. I played in backgammongalaxy, I also played in nextgammon, It has an interesting rating system

0

u/UBKUBK Aug 17 '21

The overall ratings on average would go up up up. The ratings would become just as much about playing a lot as they are about playing well.

3

u/jolego101 Aug 09 '21

look at it this way

I have 9 blue ticket and 1 red in a box. I ask you to choose a color before I draw one. You choose red because "you feel like it". I draw and indeed, you got lucky as I got red.

Now can you say you made the right decision because red won? Absolutely not. You made a stupid decision as you had 10% of winning instead of 90%. You got lucky and "won the game", but you still made an horrible decision.

-1

u/BGCynic Aug 09 '21

Do you think people who win Euromillions lotteries make "stupid decisions" when they pick their numbers? After all, the odds of winning are millions to one?

2

u/jolego101 Aug 09 '21

no because there is an equal chance of winning for all numbers, so there is no strategy involved (pure luck). You pick whatever number you like and it's the ''right'' decision because it doesn't matter in the end.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/puntanegra May 14 '22

There yaaa go, It's a sham!!! They took the nicer part of a dice game, luck!!!

If you are a beginner and make a thoughtful move and works, its luck!!

You win and not rewarded controlling and giving more chances to better PR players. This game has centuries and now you want to control it. BSSSShit.

This is a casino, not a luck/probability game anymore.

2

u/FindOneInEveryCar Aug 09 '21

Yes, it's very frustrating. If I'm ahead in point count, with good checker distribution, and I make a safe move that doesn't expose a blot, it's annoying that this counts as an "error" because leaving a blot on my inner board with two potential direct hits is statistically a better move.

But that's how the website works. I don't doubt that the statistics are correct, and making the safer move now may be setting me up to (be more likely to) lose if my opponent gets a different lucky roll.

In any case, the point is to help you become a better player, as opposed to just having a friendly game. You've still got your win/loss ratio to show how you're actually doing in terms of games won.

2

u/bangroll Aug 10 '21

In my opinion, luck is also part of the backgammon game, otherwise there was no dice in the backgammon, so the chance should be counted for rating, I played in nextgammon and it had acceptable rating, if you play worse, you get half a point, but No points are deducted from the opponent

1

u/TuitionandIntuition Jan 29 '25

Why does Backgammon Galaxy allow Russians on the site when they are killing civilians in Ukraine? I dont want to play with Putin's Barbarians. Is the site run by Russians in Cyprus? No wonder the dice are crooked!

1

u/RegularWarning4191 Apr 19 '22

I keep seeing people say that backgammon doesn't reward luck. It does reward luck. When the error rates are so close, when player skill is almost equal, luck is the only thing that separates the two. So stop saying backgammon doesn't reward luck. Of course it does. Luck is a giant part of the game. And with the unnatural amount of Galaxy doubles and distubingly perfect timed rolls (amazing how many times I'm hit by a long distance 6-4 or 6-3 combos the second a blot opens).

That having been said, I'm more focused on winning a game and losing the error rate by a handful of points. Why in the name of God wouldn't you get points for WINNING? Pretty arrogant that Galaxy believes their way of playing is the only way you can win.

I could see not getting points if you won with a ridiculously high error rate and a ridiculously high luck rating.

But there's still an argument to be made that you should get something for winning. There should be some sort of differential. If the error rate is within say 5 points then the winner should still get 100% of whatever the point should have been, and don't penalize the person who lost, but had the better error rate.

There is nothing more frustrating than winning a game but losing the error rate by a few points. At a bare minimum, if you rate as an experienced player you should get points.

1

u/suezeeqz Oct 04 '22

One of the things I absolutely hated about that site is that I'd win the game, and I would too often have an error rate difference of less than 1% more than my opponent's, so I wouldn't increase my rating. That's just nonsense.

1

u/suezeeqz Oct 04 '22

There's nothing like a real game with a real board. I stopped playing there. I've been playing for over 40 years, and I just don't like online backgammon.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '23

Galaxy is a joke. They penalize so heavily for bad moves. I can pretty much guess the rolls at this point.

1

u/Electrical_Run_9658 Apr 28 '23

BackgammonGalaxy - best online site for user interface, but scoring - what a load of rubbish.

"If you don't play how I think you should play, then you get 0 TC even if you win with your player's counters still in your 'home'" - How ridiculous!

Worse still, I've won games, and lost TC points!

What a sad thing it would be to never take a calculated chance in backgammon, or choose whether to play aggressively or not! I can't get my TC up unless I become an AI and play like a robot - how incredibly boring! But that's what you've got to do, to be 'deemed' a good player - very sad.

Hmm, and as for the Luck rating ... I wonder if how much money you spend on the site comes into play at all :)

As to the analogy to Blackjack in of one of the replies, if you choose to take a card on 20 and win, then just because it's stupid to do so, doesn't mean the croupier takes your money!

1

u/playtavli Aug 09 '21

feeling the same way with bggalaxy

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21

[deleted]

2

u/playtavli Aug 11 '21

but it's the same behaviour, isn't it?

0

u/BGCynic Aug 09 '21

You need to take a large pinch of salt with some of these website / program recommendations. A very large pinch.

GNU Backgammon, for example. If it needs a 3 to hit me otherwise it'll definitely lose the game and it doesn't roll it, it will mark the move as "unlucky"!

Huh? The chances of rolling a 3 are 14 in 36. So I had 22 chances in 36 of getting away with it, which I did.....entirely in line with the expected probability for that roll.

2

u/j3r0n1m0 Aug 09 '21 edited Aug 10 '21

Lucky/unlucky has a very specific definition. It means the equity after a specific roll deviates more than some amount from the expectation across all the rolls. In XG, it's +/- 0.30. In GNU, it's probably the same or close.

In your example, let's say when the bot rolls a 3 (or 21 or 11), its equity is +1, but when it doesn't, its equity is -1.

The expectation is -0.22 (+1 * 14/36 + -1 * 22/36).

For all rolls of 3 (or 21 or 11), the equity deviation from expectation is +1.22. For all other rolls, it is -0.78.

This means every single roll is defined as either lucky or unlucky, because they all deviate more than 0.3 from the average.

This happens very often in high volatility end-game contact situations with blots.

It's nothing to take a grain of salt with. It's just a formula.

-1

u/BGCynic Aug 09 '21

The trouble is, newbies take this advice as gospel? "Oh I got lucky there, I won't do that again" when, in fact, "that" was probably a perfectly good move.

2

u/j3r0n1m0 Aug 09 '21 edited Aug 09 '21

Luck has nothing to do with the move. It has to do with the *roll*, before you even decide what to do with it. The computer calculates luck assuming you will make the perfect move no matter what. If you don't (e.g., if you were the one needing a 3, getting it, but then not hitting), it doesn't change your luck, it just means you blundered.

If someone forgot to hit, you wouldn't call them unlucky. You'd call them maybe distracted (which is what the bot usually calls a massive error rate).

Keep in mind, it's not advice. It's a statistical description of the roll. The advice is to take advantage of your luck, when you have it.

0

u/peterjoel Aug 10 '21

If you drive recklessly while drunk, it's still a crime, even if no one got hurt.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/jolego101 Aug 09 '21

I mean, what's the point of playing backgammon then? We play this game instead of chess because there is a luck factor and some RNG involved... this is the nature of the game, and that's why we like it

BGGalaxy rewards the player that was the "closest to being actual computer" inatead of, you know, rewarding the winner. It's a game after all, we play for fun, why does it always have to come back to "YOU MADE BLUNDERS YOU SHOULD HAVE LOST"

go play chess if all you're interested in is pure skills

anyway, in the long run, the better player will eventually get more wins, and the ranking system will still reward the best of the best

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21

It's a game after all, we play for fun

I mean, I agree with this, but if fun is the only thing you care about, then does it matter how Galaxy chooses to do their rating system? You can just ignore what your rating is, ignore the PRs, and play matches for fun.

[The other part of this is that improving your game is fun for some people because everyone has different definitions of fun, but that's a different point.]