r/backgammon • • Jun 20 '15

It's mostly luck

The more I play the game and the better I get the more I realize the game is mostly luck. The only time it might possibly come down to skill is when you have a severe mismatch of skill between the players and I mean severe, like xg playing a human. Let two computers go head to head. The only thing that determines the winner at that point is dice, pure luck. The reward for trying to actually learn the game is quite low in the end when you can play a match at under 3 ER and get beat by someone who played at a 17 ER. Kinda stupid when you really think about it.

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

3

u/Johopo Jun 20 '15

That's why most tournaments are played to 7 points or more. It reduces, but doesn't eliminate, the role of luck in the game.

1

u/blue-flight Jun 20 '15

If two computers played a match to 7 is there any more luck involved than if they play to 25? At the higher levels of play it basically all comes down luck

4

u/Johopo Jun 20 '15

With two evenly matched hypothetical opponents, yes it will come down to luck. Real world players are not like that, though. Even elite players have large enough differences in skill to have meaningful matches. I think you're looking for a situation where the better player will win 98% of their games. That's not what backgammon is. If you're good, you can win maybe 60% of your games against quality opposition.

7

u/Grohl_ Jun 20 '15

Chance is an aspect of backgammon that separates it from other games of pure skill, but your example is moot because even the top players in the world are human, and therefore, are fallible, thus making mistakes. Yes, occasionally a weaker player beats a stronger one, but again, that's what chance introduces to a game: the potential for anyone to beat anyone.

1

u/omgitsjoobs Jun 24 '15

This guy is spot on. I have a feeling you aren't playing live enough.

5

u/russkhan Jun 20 '15

Perhaps backgammon isn't the game for you. Maybe you should try chess or go. I play both and recommend them.

/r/chess

/r/baduk

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '15

[deleted]

2

u/russkhan Jun 20 '15

I'm not the one who has a problem with luck, but there is no luck involved in chess and go.

4

u/balljuggler9 Nov 10 '15

I'd like to point out that backgammon is not a popular game, and is widely misunderstood. Ergo, you really have to go out of your way to find good players. 99% of players are awful, and never play against a good player to see how much of a difference skill makes. That, and playing matches, rather than single games, increases the skill factor tremendously.

1

u/RAPBRS1984 Jun 26 '15

I once heard simborg say that the guy that's losing all the time is the one that blames it on the dice. This game is way more complicated than people think and the dice do play a part but checker movement and placement take skill and knowledge.

1

u/blue-flight Jun 26 '15

Of course, but there are plenty of times in every match where the outcome is clearly and only based on luck. When you have one last chance to roll a combination shot and you get it after your better playing opponent had no choice but to leave an indirect. These things are very common and are only based on luck.

2

u/cheaptom Jan 17 '24

Excellent and very true comment. The game is about 85% luck of the dice. No matter what some commenters say, if two experts play each other and they are both equally skilled, then luck will determine that result 100% of the time. I’ve played thousands and thousands of games over my life. Maybe three or four times have I ever said, “wow what a skillful and innovative move my opponent just made”. However, guess how many times I’ve said “what a lucky lucky roll of the dice.” (Both my own lucky dice rolls and my opponent’s)

2

u/MoonChubs May 22 '25

100% correct btw. Luck based

2

u/pcirone Jun 12 '25

Old thread, let's see if anyone reads my comment... I submit that there is NO luck in Backgammon at all, in the long run.

Proof:

Probability theory dictates that luck is short term, and after many trials all possibilities will even out. If two opponents (of equal or differing skill level, it doesn't matter) play an infinite number of games, both players will get 'lucky' equally as often. Therefore, the only thing left to determine who will win more games is skill, luck becomes irrelevant.

1

u/SignificantBelt8299 Dec 02 '25

erm, well given that we are mortal it isnt possible to play an infinite number of games. Therefore there is luck.

1

u/dugsanpedro Jun 20 '15

Depends on how you define mostly. If have a 57% win rate over 30,000 games against a wide variety of opponents, do you see that as evidence that supports your claim?

1

u/bubba_bath Jun 23 '15

ER meaning error rate, in this context? I haven't read up on the mathematics of how that works. Got a good reference? Philosophically, it seems like it's a bit circular though: a measure of what the algorithm thinks is a wrong according to the algorithm. In the limited sense of a computer program playing against itself, then yes, the outcome is mostly luck. The programs aren't perfect, this ain't checkers. And the programs don't get to the psychological aspect of play against another human. Spend less time with xg and more at a real board. Or, find a game you like better.

1

u/Sea-Distribution-291 May 16 '24

Backgammon is a game that can easily frustrate you. Despite your skill, you might play against a player who is simply on a roll (pun intended) in terms of luck. You might do all the "right" moves, but somehow the other player's dice negate all of them and you end up losing.
I have played with players who are obviously terrible (i.e. they don't even know how to play the most basic dice rolls, or they leave so many pawns open when they could easily create a double pawn at a spot) and I've lost simply because the dice were not it. And because the nature of the game is such, you can lose so many times to ridiculously bad players, that you start questioning your own skill and getting frustrated on how that is possible.

The only way to kind of avoid that, is to play a best-out-of-5 game, where losing 3 times in a row to a bad player is a lot less probable. But even then, noone guarantees that this will be the case.

To sum up, in any game where skill beats luck, the better player/team will most likely end up winning a series of many games. In backgammon, that is not always the case, and great players with knowledge and experience can end up losing a series of games to really bad players, simply because of pure luck (or lack thereof).

1

u/EndersGame_Reviewer Oct 21 '25

Every game I have won is due to skill.

Every game I have lost is due to luck.

1

u/AEntunus Jan 10 '26

There are some key positions to keep in mind and you can play risky and aggressively or more defensively, but when it comes down to the dice, it's 99% luck. Not skill. Luck.