The simplest way for the Toronto Blue Jays to bolster baseball’s worst offence is with an outfield addition. But acquiring a big infield bat remains a possibility, and few players have a higher upside than Ketel Marte.
Toronto checked in on the Arizona Diamondbacks’ infielder last offseason, according to sources with knowledge of the talks but not authorized to speak publicly — though Arizona quickly balked at the ask. The Diamondbacks, the source said at the time, wanted controllable starting pitching in exchange for their All-Star second baseman, so it’s not a stretch to assume they honed in on Trey Yesavage coming off his postseason heroics.
Now, with more baggage attached to Marte after he mysteriously left the Diamondbacks mid-season, the price should be lower. The Jays, as they do with so many free agents and trade candidates, have checked in once again. Even if Arizona is holding a high asking price, if they’re motivated to move on from the second baseman, the ask may have to drop, potentially after a lockout.
Off-field concerns, alongside the nearly $90 million still owed to Marte over the next five years, will scare off some teams. The Jays have pounced on depreciated assets with owed money in the past, though, acquiring Andrés Giménez after his offensive decline in 2024 and trading for Shane Bieber months into his Tommy John recovery. Toronto has also shown a willingness to add players who, at least externally, are seen as questionable clubhouse characters. For example, the Jays met with free agent starter Framber Valdezearly last offseason before ultimately signing Dylan Cease.
Toronto’s decision-makers would surely consult some key players and coaches before trading for Marte or signing a player such as free agent Jazz Chisholm Jr., but they’re not simply out on those options because of some questionable past behaviour. That’s especially true for a player like Marte, who, at his best, could be an MVP candidate. He received votes for the award in 2019, 2024 and 2025.
By OPS, the 33-year-old’s 2026 season was his worst since 2020, but he still would’ve ranked second among qualified Jays hitters last year.
Marte can block trades due to 10-and-5 rights, but the Jays could be somewhere he’d waive to, as he’s married to Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s cousin. The pair also played together on the Dominican Republic team at the World Baseball Classic.
Arizona may still want starting pitching this winter, but as *The Athletic’*s Ken Rosenthal, Will Sammon and Katie Woo wrote on Wednesday, the Diamondbacks are looking to decrease payroll and could use a left-handed bat. The Jays’ Addison Barger, coming off a missed 2026 season due to ankle and elbow injuries, is both cheap and hits lefty.
Manager John Schneider said multiple times during Toronto’s 2026 season that Barger’s injury was an overlooked reason for the club’s offensive struggles. Getting the right fielder/third baseman back would add the sort of 30-homer thump and mid-lineup protection Toronto lacked last year. But the Jays have Kazuma Okamoto entrenched at third base.
If the Jays went out and signed a right fielder, Barger could be blocked at both his primary positions. If a sequence of events like that plays out, Barger could become a lot more movable.
It’s far from guaranteed the Jays and Diamondbacks line up on Marte. Just look at last winter. There’s plenty of reason to hold onto Barger, plus other infield trade options Toronto could consider. They may not even add an infielder at all if they find enough power through outfield additions. But if the Jays do take a big swing on an infield trade, Marte could be the best hitter moved this winter.
(Posted entire article due to possible paywall)