r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Jan 04 '22

Spoilers Chapter 22 Book 3, the homage to Dorothea continues

0 Upvotes

The argument for sarcasm is supported in the following chapter where again we have an epigraph, this time by Alfred de Musset, again praising a woman as "simple et bonne," a variation on Chaucer. This is Eliot's cleverness, putting these angelic projections in the mouths of historic poets when really these visions are coming straight through the rose colored glasses of Will Ladislaw.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Jan 04 '22

Spoilers Apparently I'm starting a second year of Middlemarch, but about Chapter 21 in Book 3

0 Upvotes

It begins with a Chester Avenue a graph

Hire facounde eke full womanly and plain No contrafreted terms had she To semen wise

I think this translates to

Her speech also for womanly and plain, No affectation did she need To seem wise

The chapter concerns Dorothea, so I assume so, too, does the epigraph, but by this point, we've already met Dorothea and are familiar with all her positive and negative qualities, so of what need this homage to Dorothea? Did Eliot mean it sarcastically? Or is Chaucer responding to Dorothea complaint "How I wish I had learned German when I was at Lausanne! There were plenty of German teachers. But now I can be of no use." Maybe Chaucer is telling her that she is smarter than she thinks has no need of such contrafeted learning?


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Jan 09 '22

Chapter 19 -- Spoilers Spoiler

1 Upvotes

A child forsaken , waking suddenly, Whose gaze afeard on all things round doth rove, And seeth only that it cannot see The meeting eyes of love.

Like a recurring musical motif in an opera, whenever the chapters turn towards the subdued love between Will and Dorothe, Eliot inserts a whimsical and satirical epigraphs about innocent love. In this case, the fact that these two don't ever speak about it, not even to themselves, preserve its innocence.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Jan 04 '24

2024

6 Upvotes

Is there a calendar for 2024?


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Feb 25 '24

The Best Characters: Caleb Garth, Mary Garth and Camden Farebrother

9 Upvotes

Not sure if controversial, but please let me know who your favourite characters are and why! The title is my opinion lol, I am of course not an authority.

I am currently on Two Temptations and at this point in the novel, a lot of the other characters have become a little unlikeable. Their particular flaws of pride, dishonesty, ambition or self centeredness are really causing issues in their lives, and it is quite difficult to read

Yet Caleb and Mary Garth and Mr. Farebrother remain like a breath of fresh honest simplicity. Their unostentatious kindness seems lacking everywhere else in Middlemarch, and really it feels like without them acting as a moral center I feel like characters who have tonnes of potential like Dorothea would be totally hindered from growth.

Do you agree? Who are your personal darlings?


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Apr 26 '25

Weekly Discussion Post Book 3: Chapters 25 and 26

6 Upvotes

Welcome back! We have a short section this week, but I think we can still get some discussion out of it.


Chapter 25

“Love seeketh not itself to please,

Nor for itself hath any care

But for another gives its ease

And builds a heaven in hell’s despair.

. . . . . . .

Love seeketh only self to please,

To bind another to its delight,

Joys in another’s loss of ease,

And builds a hell in heaven’s despite.”

—W. BLAKE: Songs of Experience.

Fred goes to Mary and confesses about the money. Later, Caleb visits her and tries to caution her against Fred.

Chapter 26

He beats me and I rail at him: O worthy satisfaction! would it were otherwise—that I could beat him while he railed at me.

—Troilus and Cressida.

Fred gets sick. The doctor, Mr. Wrench, doesn't think it's serious, but when Fred is still sick the next day, Mr. Lydgate is called in. Lydgate diagnoses Fred with typhoid fever.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Jul 05 '25

Book 5, Ch. 43-44

8 Upvotes

Welcome back to Middlemarch, as we begin with Book 5. We are also officially on the second half of the book!

Ch. 43

"This figure hath high price: 't was wrought with love

Ages ago in finest ivory;

Nought modish in it, pure and noble lines

Of generous womanhood that fits all time

That too costly ware; majolica

Of deft design, to please a lordly eye:

The smile, you see, is perfect-wonderful

As mere Faience! a table ornament

To suit the richest mounting."

Dorothea wishes to speak with Lydgate about his conversation with Mr. Casaubon, and ends up visiting briefly with the new Mrs. Lydgate, previously known as Rosamund Vincy. Mr. Lydgate is not home, but it turns out Will Ladislaw is visiting with Mrs. Lydgate, and they have been having a merry time singing together. Will offers to fetch Mr. Lydgate from the hospital, but Dorothea decides to go herself, alone. Once Dorothea leaves, Ladislaw decides to take his leave as well, seeming troubled. Later, when her husband gets home, Rosamund describes the encounter, and they end up discussing Lydgate's work.

Ch. 44

"I would not creep along the coast but steer

Out in mid-sea, by guidance of the stars."

Dorothea meets with Lydgate at the New Hospital, who tells her her husband's condition has not changed, he simply had some anxieties about his illness. Lydgate then immediately launches into a sales pitch for the hospital, and finds the perfect patron in Dorothea. They discuss the unpopularity of Mr. Bulstrode, despite his good intentions, and the pettiness of Middlemarchers who seek to thwart him. Dorothea pledges to give 200 a year to the hospital. Later, she tells Mr. Casaubon of this, and he agrees.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Aug 29 '26

Weekly Discussion Post Book 6: Chapters 56 & 57

8 Upvotes

Welcome back, Middlemarchers, to our discussion of chapters 56 & 57. Following his absence while he was away getting an education, these are Fred-heavy chapters

Chapter 56

“How happy is he born and taught

That serveth not another’s will;

Whose armor is his honest thought,

And simple truth his only skill!

This man is freed from servile bands

Of hope to rise or fear to fall;

Lord of himself though not of lands;

And having nothing yet hath all.”

—SIR HENRY WOTTON.

Caleb Garth is quite impressed with Dorothea's business skills and compares her speaking voice to Handel's Messiah. Caleb loves music. Dorothea has put him in charge of the farms of Lowick.

Railways were an exciting topic among the people of Middlemarch. Everyone debates the pros and cons of building a railway through their properties.

Mr. Solomon Featherstone enjoyed talking to everyone he met. He has a conversation with Hiram about the railways. He thinks the railway people who come out to survey and measure the land should be run out of town if anyone sees them, though he's not willing to do it himself.

Caleb goes out one day to measure a piece of Dorothea's land he thinks he can sell to the railway company for a good price.

Fred Vincy was sent in an errand for his father. He laments being pushed in different directions by his father and by Mary and wishes he could find a job that suits him. He stumbles upon a scene of four railway workers being threatened by townspeople with pitchforks. Caleb Garth rushes to the scene too. His young assistant had been knocked down.

Fred breaks up the conflict with his whip, chasing off the laborers. He exchanges some fighting words with Hiram. Fred and Caleb both feel lucky they happened to be passing by in order to break up the fight before it got really ugly.

Caleb asks Fred for some help since his assistant injured his ankle. Fred agrees, it first he wants to go fight Hiram. Caleb says no, stay put. He knows the fight started out of ignorance and thinks he can talk some sense into the men.

Though he has a fear of speechifying, he does speak to the workmen and tells them the railroad will do more good than harm. Fighting it will only land them in jail.

Timothy Cooper believes the railroad will only enrich the rich and leave the poor folks behind. Caleb can't argue with that, but reiterates fighting the surveyors will make things harder for themselves and he gets them to agree not to meddle anymore.

Fred helps Caleb and feels good about doing hard work and getting his hands dirty. He starts to envision a future for himself that hadn't ever occurred to him earlier this morning.

He asks Caleb if it's too late for him to learn his business. Caleb says it's not too late, but learning comes from experience in the field, literally, and not from books. He says to do this work, one must love it and be proud of it. If you are always looking for something else to do or something better, it's not for you.

Fred realizes that's how he'd feel if he became a clergyman. He confesses his love for Mary and promises he'd work hard at taking care of the land and cattle if given the opportunity. Caleb has to think on it, and ask his wife.

In their marriage, Susan made most of the decisions, but once in a while Caleb felt strongly about something and took the lead. This was one such occasion. He tells his wife he'd like to hire Fred and make a man of him so he can become a suitable husband for Mary.

Susan is a bit hurt Mary never spoke to her about her feelings for Fred. She thinks it's a pity Mary won't marry Farebrother. Caleb is confident Fred can become a good man worthy of their daughter with his guidance. Susan holds her tongue, but is quite upset by this turn of events. She doesn't have the same confidence Caleb has in Fred.

The next morning, Caleb asks Fred to do some writing and arithmetic for him. Though it's not what Fred had in mind, he complies. His penmanship is apparently illegible and Caleb is angry at the educational system that allowed this. He says he taught himself to write and Fred can do the same if he practices enough.

Fred goes home to tell his parents he has been hired by Mr. Garth. Mr. Vincy is disappointed Fred has chosen to go down a step in life rather than using his education to rise up. He says Fred can continue living at home without paying rent, but he'll have to pay to keep his horse and pay for his own clothes.

Fred apologizes for vexing his father and they shake hands.

Mrs. Vincy is devastated because she knows Fred will marry Mary. She looks down on the Garths and thinks her son will become plain and careless like they are.

Four days pass and she is still down in the dumps about Fred's life choices. Mr. Vincy never liked Rosamond's marriage, but he's over it and thinks his wife can do the same about Fred. We learn that Rosamond was "disappointed of her baby; but she got over it nicely," and that Lydgate "is making a mess of his practice, and getting into debt too."

Chapter 57

They numbered scarce eight summers when a name

Rose on their souls and stirred such motions there

As thrill the buds and shape their hidden frame

At penetration of the quickening air:

His name who told of loyal Evan Dhu,

Of quaint Bradwardine, and Vich Ian Vor,

Making the little world their childhood knew

Large with a land of mountain lake and scaur,

And larger yet with wonder, love, belief

Toward Walter Scott who living far away

Sent them this wealth of joy and noble grief.

The book and they must part, but day by day,

In lines that thwart like portly spiders ran

They wrote the tale, from Tully Veolan.

Fred goes to call on Mrs. Garth and finds a family gathering, including all of Mary's brothers and sisters — Ben, Letty, Jim, and Christy, the oldest boy who works as a tutor.

Christy and Fred seem to compare themselves to each other. Fred admires Christy's scholarship; Christy admires Fred's fine clothes and graceful manner. Fred is taller.

Mrs. Garth sits knitting while Fred talks to her about his intentions. He says he doesn't want to give up on himself as long as Mr. Garth and Farebrother haven't given up on him.

She confesses she is surprised Mary has given Fred encouragement. She says Fred made a great mistake using Farebrother to ascertain Mary's feelings. Fred is surprised by this and tries to get Mrs. Garth to be more specific, which she is reluctant to do.

Fred figures out she means Farebrother is in love with Mary. Mrs. Garth is pleased with herself for making Fred feel bad, but also cognizant she may have gone too far. Before she can walk it back much, their conversation is interrupted by the children and their pets. Mrs. Garth later confesses to her husband she may have said too much to Fred earlier.

Fred leaves the gathering to go see Mary at the parsonage in Lowick. He kicks himself for sending Farebrother on that errand, not recognizing his feelings for Mary, and he doesn't like that he may be standing in the way of Mary making a better match.

He finds Mary among the ladies of Farebrother's family. He tells her the news that Christy is visiting, and that he is to work for her father. Mary is glad, but unable to react fully while in company.

Mrs. Farebrother can't believe Mary would be glad a young man would give up the Church for which he was educated. Mary explains she doesn't like clergymen, except the Vicar of Wakefield and Mr. Farebrother. Mrs. Farebrother is shocked. Mary tries to explain, but the women are puzzled.

Farebrother walks in and Fred feels jealous. He concocts a way for Fred and Mary to speak privately in the other room. Fred misinterprets everything until Mary sets him straight. Fred feels slightly less threatened by Farebrother after the conversation, but Mary now feels worried she is slighting Farebrother and is happy to have a reason to go home and think. She loves Fred and only Fred.

Notes (courtesy of u/the owed bookshelf)

Chapter 56: Scaur is a steep cliff or bank, from the Scottish

Clemmin’ means starving

Chapter 57’s poem mentions characters in Waverley by Sir Walter Scott

References: (courtesy of u/rissaroo28)

  • The epigraph for chapter 56 is a quote from Sir Henry Wotton's 'The Character of a Happy Life' (1651).

  • 'In the hundred to which Middlemarch belonged...' this is a reference to how the county Middlemarch is in was divided.

  • Cholera is mentioned in chapter 56 and it's interesting to note that there was an epidemic of the disease between 1831-32, concurrent to with the latter parts of the novel.

  • 'The 'oald King George...' The character, Timothy Cooper is referring to the previous monarch, King George III who was declared insane in 1810. His son, King Geroge IV then became regent and later inherited the throne (in 1820). George IV was the ruling Monarch during the period most of the book is set in.

  • 'clemmin his own inside' - this is slang for being hungry or starving.

  • [The Rights of Man] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rights_of_Man) is the name of the pro-French Revolutionary pamphlet by Thomas Paine. By this period of time it was also a byword or general term referring to the ideas of the reform movement.

  • The epigraph of chapter 57 refers to a place called 'Tully Veolan', which was a Perthshire estate in 'Waverly' by Sir Walter Scott.

  • Richard Porson, 1759-1808, was a classical scholar.

  • 'One of the foolish women speaketh' this is a quote from the bible, Job 2:10

Join us next week for a discussion of chapters 58 & 59 with u/lazylittlelady.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Jun 06 '26

Weekly Discussion Post Book 4: Chapters 36 and 37

8 Upvotes

Welcome back, dear Middlemarchers, as the will has repercussions for all, a marriage is called into question, and politics are in the air.

"I think his own feelings at the moment were perfect, for we mortals have our divine moments, when love is satisfied in the completeness of the beloved object"-Chapter 37

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Summary:

"'Tis strange to see the humors of these men, These great aspiring spirits, that should be wise:

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . .. . .

For being the nature of great spirits to love To be where they may be most eminent; They, rating of themselves so farre above Us in conceit, with whom they do frequent, Imagine how we wonder and esteeme/All that they do or say; which makes them strive To make our admiration more extreme/Which they suppose they cannot, ‘less they give Notice of their extreme and highest thoughts." –DANIEL: Tragedy of Philotas

Chapter 36 in the Vincy household, post will-reading, Mr. Vincy advises Fred to return to college and complete his education, but it remains unclear in this chapter whether Fred will follow this advice.  He then starts to question the engagement between Lydgate and his daughter, Rosamond. He instructs his wife to persuade Rosamond to break off the engagement. Rosamond, however, convinces her father to not call off the engagement. Lydgate remains largely unaware of the family's monetary difficulties until Rosamond mentions her father's altered stance to him. Fearing that Mr. Vincy might dissolve the engagement against their wishes, the chapter concludes with the couple deciding to fast-track their wedding date.

"Thrice happy she that is so well assured/ Unto herself and settled so in heart/
That neither will for better be allured/ Ne fears to worse with any chance to start/ But like a steddy ship doth strongly part/ The raging waves and keeps her course aright: Ne aught for tempest doth from it depart/ Ne aught for fairer weather’s false delight/ Such self-assurance need not fear the spight/ Of grudging foes; ne favour seek of friends; But in the stay of her own stedfast might/ Neither to one herself nor other bends. Most happy she that most assured doth rest/ But he most happy who such one loves best.” –SPENSER: Amoretti

Chapter 37 starts with some political analysis.  The demise of George the Fourth has left the government transforming. The local political newspapers are similarly experiencing a shift. One such paper, The Pioneer (recently purchased by Mr. Brooke), has recently put forth an article claiming it's an opportune time for competent men to play more significant roles in politics.

Ladislaw continues his stay with Mr. Brooke and it is revealed that Brooke has proposed a job at the paper to Ladislaw. Ladislaw is giving the offer serious thought. Concurrently, Mr. Casaubon is expressing hostility towards Ladislaw's presence in the vicinity. Ladislaw has been circumventing Casaubon, yet he also yearns to meet Dorothea. One day, he starts sketching near Casaubon’s residence, in hopes of catching a glimpse of Dorothea on her daily stroll. However, rain forces him to take refuge in the house, which, fortunately, Casaubon has vacated for the day.

Dorothea is thrilled. They discuss various topics, mostly revolving around the shared family history of Casaubon and Ladislaw. Ladislaw brings up the job offer and Dorothea advises him to seek Casaubon's viewpoint.

Later, Casaubon returns home and upon learning of Ladislaw’s visit, voices his displeasure about Mr. Brooke offering Ladislaw a job. He pens a letter to Ladislaw the following day, advising him to decline the job offer and relocate.

Having gleaned more about their family history, Dorothea ponders over the ethical correctness of Ladislaw’s reliance on Casaubon.  Dorothea, aware of Casaubon’s will favoring her, wishes to restore some justice for Ladislaw. One night, she voices her desire to Casaubon; she wants him to assign a living allowance to Ladislaw, owing to his moral and potential legal rights. She also proposes that Casaubon amend his will, reallocating a larger part of her inheritance upon Casaubon’s demise to Ladislaw.

Casaubon shrugs off her proposal and prohibits her from ever broaching the subject again. The chapter closes on an ominous note, with Casaubon resolved to thwart Ladislaw’s decision to stay in the area and accept the job, by any means necessary.

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Context and Notes:

  • Santa Lucia was a third-century virgin martyr. She is the patron of people with eye diseases and is usually depicted holding two eyes in a dish.

  • "Valenciennes" refers to a popular style of lacework, originating from Valenciennes itself, that was popular at the time.

  • Charles James Fox - was a Whig statesman and reformer (1759-1806)

  • "He shall be prettily pumped upon" is a phrase that refers to a punishment of being put under a working water pump and soaked.

  • "A low set of dark-blue freemen" refers to the Whig (Liberal) colors. The speakers are referring to the local men who have the 'freedom of the borough' and can vote in elections, presumably in favor of the Whigs.

  • The Rights of Man is the title of a pro-French Revolutionary book, published in 1791-92 by Thomas Paine. This book advocated for male suffrage.

  • William Huskisson was a (moderately) reformist Tory statesman (1770-1830)

  • A "pocket borough" refers to a small constituency that is controlled by one family.

  • "passionate prodigality" is a reference to Sir Thomas Browne's work 'Urn Burial'.

  • Casaubon asks Dorothea to read him some "Lowth" - this potentially refers to the writings of Robert Lowth (1710 - 1787), a bishop and a Hebrew scholar.

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Questions: Feel free to discuss anything else!

[1] Do you believe the Vincy family is heading towards a downfall, as Mr. Vincy fears in this chapter? Do you think Fred will return to his studies?

[2] What's your take on Rosie's decision to prioritize love over wealth in her marriage-or has she indeed done this? Has love altered her perspective? Lydgate describes Rosamond as 'docile' in this chapter. Do you think this characterization suits her?

[3] Are there disparities in Rosamond and Lydgate's relationship becoming apparent? They appear to have contrasting views on numerous issues.

[4] Mr. Brooke seems to be stepping up his political engagement locally. Do you believe he is finding acceptance among the locals or will many align with the opinions of the chapter's opening characters, Mr. Hackbutt and Mr. Hawley?

[5] With the escalating tension between Dorothea and Casaubon, do you think there's room for their relationship to improve? Do you believe Dorothea is being attracted to Ladislaw due to Casaubon’s shortcomings?

[6] Is Ladislaw being impulsive by choosing to remain in the area? Does Casaubon possess the authority to overrule his decisions and influence his career?

[6a]What actions do you anticipate Casaubon will take next? Do you believe he will channel his frustrations towards Dorothea? What is your opinion on Casaubon's decision to keep his thoughts to himself rather than confide in either Mr. Brooke or Sir James Chettam?

[7] How do you foresee the future unfolding for both couples (Dorothea and Casaubon, Lydgate and Rosamond)? Are there any parallels between them?

[8] Any thoughts on the epigrams or quotes that stood out to you?

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

We meet next week to discuss Chapters 38 & 39.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Mar 19 '22

Weekly Discussion Post Chapters 17 and 18 Discussion

11 Upvotes

I'm really enjoying seeing the politics of Middlemarch unfold. I think we are in for a lot of drama down the line. As usual, questions will be in the comments.

Summary

Lydgate visits Farebrother's home and learns that the vicar is supporting his mother, sister and aunt on a small salary. Following a chat with his opinionated mother, Farebrother shows Lydgate his natural history collection. The men begin to bond, but Farebrother warns Lydgate that voting for him to gain the chaplaincy in the new hospital will make him lose favour with Bulstrode. Farebrother also states that his interest in the job comes from wanting to gain a larger salary.

Over the next few weeks Lydgate muses on what he should do. He doesn't like the idea of becoming Bulstrode's man and contemplates who he really wants to vote for. The day of the vote comes. We see that, despite his money and power in Middlemarch, Bulstrode doesn't have complete control over his council. Farebrother is in favour with many of the voters, due to his previous unpaid experience in the role. The vote is evenly divided, with both of the official doctors voting for Farebrother. Lydgate is last to arrive and his vote decides the matter; he votes for Bulstrode's desired candidate Tyke.

References:

‘Scottish Metaphysics’ - Mr. Farebrother compares the his mother's strong opinionated attitude to George III’s dismissal of ‘Scottish metaphysics’ aka the idea that his government was allowed to disagree with him over Catholic emancipation. She doesn't accept or believe people who disagree with her.

Lutheran doctrine – Bulstrode’s way of thinking/living lies in the belief that salvation comes through faith over religious works or sacraments. Dr. Minchin, while sharing similar views, is slightly more flexible in his beliefs.

Prodicus – this version of the Hercules myth tells of Hercules choice of duty over pleasure. In the myth, Hercules put on a shirt doused in what his wife believed was love-potion but turned out to be poison.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Apr 05 '25

Book 2: Ch. 21-22

11 Upvotes

Welcome Middlemarchers, to our last (chapter) discussion of Book 2! I can't believe it, but we seem to be about 25% of the way through this book!

This week we continue in Rome with Dorothea, Mr. Casaubon, and the charming free-spirit, Will Ladislaw.

Ch. 21

"Hire facounde eke full womanly and plain,

No contrefeted termes had she

To semen wise."

-Chaucer

Dorothea admits Will Ladislaw into her and Mr. Casaubon's lodgings after her crying session, when Mr. Casaubon isn't around. She explains that he is off reading at the Vatican Library and can only be reached by appointment. Ladislaw is outraged to find that Casaubon is spending his honeymoon "groping after his mouldy futilities" instead of paying attention to his wife. Dorothea and Ladislaw talk about art, which Dorothea admits she doesn't really "get". They talk about Mr. Casaubon's studies until Mr. Casaubon himself shows up, when they invite him for dinner the following night.

Ch. 22

"Nous câusames longtemps; elle était simple et bonne.

Ne sachant pas le mal, elle faisait le bien;

Des richesses du coeur elle me fit l'aumône,

Et tout en écoutant comme le coeur se donne,

Sans oser y penser je lui donnai le mien;

Elle emporta ma vie, et n'en sut jamais rien."

-Alfred de Musset

Ladislaw spends a delightful dinner with Mr. and Mrs. Casaubon, and invites them both to a studio the next day. They meet Ladislaw's German painter friend, Naumann. They look at some of the various paintings and sketches, before Naumann suggests that Ladislaw make a sketch of Mr. Casaubon's head for his picture of St. Thomas Aquinas, while Naumann wishes to make a sketch of Dorothea, simply as herself. The next day, as Dorothea is preparing to head back to England, Ladislaw visits her again. They discuss what it is that she wants, and Dorothea suggests he should be a poet.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Mar 14 '26

Weekly Discussion Post Book 2: Chapters 15& 16

11 Upvotes

Welcome back to Middlemarch in it's the titular mid-month (!) and we go deeper with Mr. Lydgate and specifically about the medical context Lydgate has come up in.

"He went home and read far into the smallest hour, bringing a much more testing vision of details and relations into this pathological study than he had ever thought it necessary to apply to the complexities of love and marriage, these being subjects on which he felt himself amply informed by literature, and that traditional wisdom which is handed down in the genial conversations of men"- Chapter 16

_________________________________________________________________________________________________

Summary

"Black eyes you have left, you say

Blue eyes fail to draw you;

Yet you seem more rapt to-day,

Than of old we saw you.

Oh I track the fairest fair

Through new haunts of pleasure;

Footprints her and echoes there

Guide me to my treasure:

Lo! she turns– immortal youth

Wrought to mortal stature,

Fresh as starlight's aged truth–

Many-named Nature!"

Chapter 15 opens with Dr Tertius Lydgate, aged 27 and popular with lady patients because of his skill. He was orphaned before he started med school. As a child he read any and all books– even the dictionary. He read a passage about the heart and its valves from a “cyclopedia” and was hooked on anatomy. Medicine was his calling from them on.

He was unimpressed by quacks and pill-pushers. Lydgate wished to make great discoveries like Edward Jenner and vaccinations. A new law said doctors can't charge for prescriptions. He might be smart in medical matters, but not so when it came to matters of love. It was implied by his thoughts and actions that he was better than everyone else.

When he was in Paris, he took a break from studying galvanism to see a play. Lydgate became besotted with the actress Madame Laure. She stabbed her real husband for real on stage. She said her foot slipped and was found innocent. Lydgate tracked her down in Avignon where she performed and professed his love for her. She confessed that she had meant to kill her husband and wouldn't marry again. Fortunately, no one in Middlemarch knew of his past and were fine with how he presently appeared.

“All that in women is adored

In the fair self I find–

For the whole sex can but afford

The handsome and the kind.”

– Sir Charles Sedley

Chapter 16 opens up with the banker, Mr Bulstrode, who runs the town and has his hands in many people's affairs. Mr. Tyke is nominated to be hospital chaplain. At a dinner party, Mr. Vincy says he prefers Mr. Farebrother over Tyke. It will be up to the doctors to decide.

The doctors argue over what a coroner's purpose should be; Lydgate unwittingly insults all the local doctors in the process. Lydgate does notices Rosamond Vincy, the daughter of the hosts. She was to sing that night and took over playing piano from Fred. She can play and sing passably. Mr. Farebrother comes in and plays whist.

Lydgate admires Rosamond, but it's not an infatuation. She is an ideal kind of woman for him to marry, but not yet. At home, he read higher things like a book on typhoid fever by former colleague Pierre Charles Louis. He is proud of himself that he picked such a pleasant profession.

Rosamond assumes Lydgate is in love with her as most men of his kind would be. His prospects are good, and she could live the posh lifestyle she so envies in the Brookes. She continues her refined hobbies. Her aunt, Mrs. Bulstrode hopes she marries well enough to support her wants.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________

Context & Notes

  • The “great historian” and “Fielding” of chapter 15’s opening are the same person. The joke is that he wrote a novel, Tom Jones, which was subtitled as a history, though it is fiction. 

  • Public schools in the UK refer to fee-paying private schools.

  • Rasselas refers to a book by Samuel Johnson, who wrote the first dictionary.

  • Gulliver refers to Gulliver’s Travels, one of the first major novels in English. Lydgate is clearly a big reader! 

  • “Makdom and fairnesse” is Old Scots for form and beauty; the quotation is taken from James I’s essay on Scots poetry. 

  • Jenner is Edward Jenner, a pioneer of vaccination.

  • Herschel is William Herschel, an astronomer. He discovered the planet Uranus.

  • Bichat is Marie Françoise Xavier Bichat, a pioneering anatomist. 

  • Saint-Simonians believed in a kind of proto-Socialist Utopia.

  • In the lengthy section about the state of the medical profession in Britain, there is a reference to “a recent legal decision.” This refers to the Apothecaries Act of 1815, the first attempt to regulate the medical profession in Britain.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________

Discussion questions but feel free to post your own comments or other thoughts on these chapters!

_________________________________________________________________________________________________

1. What purpose do you think it served to take a closer look at the medical establishment in this set of chapters? What is Eliot trying to say here about the larger picture?

2. What do you think of Lydgate's views towards his profession? Does he have the measure of himself he believes to? How does the background story of the murder in Paris fit into his character study?

3. How does Bulstrode fit into Middlemarch? We hear he is a newcomer, like Lydgate.

4. Lydgate says “I have made up my mind to take Middlemarch as it comes, and shall be much obliged if the town will take me in the same way.” How do you think he’s going to find Middlemarch, and how will Middlemarch find him? How have YOU found Middlemarch, and are you enjoying taking it as it comes? Any surprises

5. We're at home with the Vincy's one evening. What was your impression of this household?

6. What were your favorite parts? What quotes did you like? Anything else you want to mention?

7. How do you interpret the epigrams in the beginning of each chapter?

_________________________________________________________________________________________________

We meet next Saturday, March 21 to read Chapters 17 and 18.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Feb 24 '24

Weekly Discussion Post Book 1: Chapter 12

19 Upvotes

Welcome to the discussion of Middlemarch Chapter 12, Book 1! Thank you to u/sunnydaze7777777 for leading the discussions for the earlier chapters in this book. Next week we will have a discussion of the entire Book 1 led by u/lazylittlelady, which is a good chance to catch up if you have fallen behind. (Schedule post) With many thanks, I am borrowing the summary below from those who marched before us.

Chapter 12 Epigraph:

He had more tow on his distaffe

Than Gerveis knew.

—CHAUCER.

From The Miller's Tale, The Canterbury Tales and Other Poems, by Geoffrey Chaucer

Chapter 12 Summary

We meet Mr. Featherstone, his sister Mrs. Waule, and Mary Garth. Mr. Featherstone is ill and childless, and Mrs. Waule is worried because she has heard rumors that Fred Vincy bragged about inheriting Featherstone’s estate after his death.

Fred and Rosamund arrive and Fred talks to Mr. Featherstone while Rosamund talks to Mary Garth, a family friend and Mr. Featherstone’s servant and caretaker. Mr. Featherstone confronts Fred about the rumors. Fred feels guilty because he may have been bragging about his expectations while drunk, but he swears that he has not borrowed money using his expected windfall from Featherstone as security. Featherstone makes Fred swear that he’ll get a letter from his uncle, the banker Mr. Bulstrode, certifying that he doesn’t believe Fred has borrowed money in this way.

Meanwhile, Mary and Rosamund talk about their romantic prospects. Rosamund asks Mary about the new doctor Mr. Lydgate and the two discuss the rumors about Fred. Rosamund disparages Fred because he has dropped out of university and declared that he will not be a clergyman as expected, but Mary defends him. Rosamund implies that Fred plans to propose to Mary. Mary says she would not accept, but it’s clear she has a soft spot for him.

We finally get to meet Mr. Lydgate in person when he arrives to care for Mr. Featherstone. Rosamund has carefully engineered their meeting, coming to the house when she knows he is likely to call. There is a spark between them, and she fantasizes about a future as Mrs. Lydgate when she will have access to his network of superior relations and good breeding.

Context and references

Mrs. Waule says the Vincys are no more Featherstones than a Merry-Andrew at a fair. A Merry-Andrew is a clown.

Rosamund and Mary know each other from school, where Mary was an articled pupil. This means that she had to work at the school to offset the cost of her attendance.

When discussing Mr. Lydgate, Mary says “il y en a pour tous les goûts.” This is French for “there is something for all tastes.”


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Mar 01 '25

Weekly Discussion Post Book 1: Summary and Catch Up!

11 Upvotes

Dear Residents of Middlemarch,

Congratulations on reaching the end of Book 1: Miss Brooke. We are 1/8 of the way already! This is our first waystation for those that need a week to catchup or take a break. It is our place to consider Book 1 as a whole section.

I'll just throw off a few questions but feel free to discuss anything you want below in the sections we have read!

  1. What are your thoughts on the book so far? Is it what you expected?

  2. What are your favorite plot lines, quotes or epigrams?

  3. Who is amusing? Who is driving you crazy? Who is intriguing? Who are you rooting for?

  4. Book 2 is titled "Old and Young"-any predictions? (No Spoilers!)

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

We meet again next Saturday, March 8, when we begin Book 2: Old and Young and discuss chapters 13 & 14 with u/Adventurous_Onion898 leading our discussion!


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • May 31 '25

Weekly Discussion Post Book 4: Chapters 34 and 35

8 Upvotes

Welcome to the start of Book IV: Three Love Problems.


Chapter 34

“1st Gent. Such men as this are feathers, chips, and straws,
Carry no weight, no force.

2d Gent. But levity
Is causal too, and makes the sum of weight.
For power finds its place in lack of power;
Advance is cession, and the driven ship
May run aground because the helmsman’s thought
Lacked force to balance opposites.”

It's Featherstone's funeral. Featherstone has apparently micromanaged his own funeral from beyond the grave, right down to "I want Cadwallader to bury me because Casaubon sucks." Speaking of Casaubon, we spend this chapter watching the funeral from his house. Dorothea, Mrs. Cadwallader, Celia, and Sir James are watching, while Casaubon has gone back to his work. Mr. Brooke shows up, and this is how Casaubon finally learns that Will Ladislaw is visiting.

Chapter 35

“Non, je ne comprends pas de plus charmant plaisir
Que de voir d’héritiers une troupe affligée
Le maintien interdit, et la mine allongée,
Lire un long testament où pales, étonnés
On leur laisse un bonsoir avec un pied de nez.
Pour voir au naturel leur tristesse profonde
Je reviendrais, je crois, exprès de l’autre monde.”
—REGNARD: Le Légataire Universel.

Things go weird at the funeral when multiple wills and a stranger named Joshua Rigg show up. It looks like this Rigg guy will be taking the name Featherstone, and the money will be going to him, and to the founding of an alms-house.

Notes

Penguin Classics provides this translation for the Chapter 35 epigram:

"No, I can't imagine a more delightful pleasure
Than seeing a grieving crowd of heirs,
Looking dumbfounded, with long faces,
Listening to a lengthy will which turns them pale with shock,
As, cocking a snook at them, it leaves them empty-handed.
To see their deep sorrow so clearly,
I would return on purpose, I think, from the next world."


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • May 03 '25

Book 3: Ch. 27-28

9 Upvotes

Welcome back, to another week in Middlemarch! This week we see Fred start to recover from his illness, Lydgate flirts with Rosamund, Mr. and Mrs. Casaubon return to Lowick, and Celia gets engaged! So exciting!

Ch. 27

"Let the high Muse chant loves Olympian:

We are but mortals, and must sing of man."

Lydgate continues to check on Fred regularly, allowing him plenty of opportunities to speak with Rosamund. As Fred recovers, the Vincy household becomes more joyous with plenty of visitors. During these gatherings, Lydgate and Rosamund flirt, which does not make Lydgate many friends among the other eligible bachelors of Middlemarch. Lydgate inserts himself into a conversation Rosamund is having with Ned Plymdale while they are looking at a publication of The Keepsake. A few days after this party, Lydgate is unexpectedly called to Lowick by a servant of Sir James Chettam.

Ch. 28

"1st Gent. All times are good to seek your wedded home

Bringing a mutual delight.

2d Gent. Why, true.

The calendar hath not an evil day

For souls made one by love, and even death

Were sweetness, if it came like rolling waves

While they two clasped each other, and foresaw

No life apart."

Mr. and Mrs. Casaubon return to Lowick Manor. Mr. Casaubon is busy in his library, and Dorothea doesn't have much to do except stare at the miniature of her husband's aunt Julia, Will Ladislaw's grandmother. Luckily, her uncle and Celia are coming to visit. Celia blushes a good deal while discussing wedding journeys with Dorothea, because it turns out she is now engaged to none other than James Chettam!


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Aug 16 '25

Book 5 Summary

8 Upvotes

Hello, Middlemarchers! We're well into the second half of the novel, and there have been some big changes for a lot of our friends. This week is more of a catch-up and summary week to go over what's been happening so far and what you think might happen in the next book. Some questions for discussion are below. Feel free to comment with your answer to any or all of them.

- Dorothea's storyline took centre stage in Book 5. What do you think of her current situation, especially regarding Casaubon's death and that spiteful codicil?

- We also saw Ladislaw and Mr. Brooke's struggles with small-town politics. Did that play out the way you expected it to? Where do they go from here?

- Book 6 is The Widow and the Wife. While it's probably safe to assume Dorothea and Rosamond will be the focus, what other characters are you hoping will make an appearance?

- Which storyline is the most interesting, in your opinion? Which characters have shown the most growth so far in the story?

And of course, if there's anything else you want to discuss, feel free to do so!


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Feb 15 '25

Weekly Discussion Post Book 1: Chapters 10 and 11

16 Upvotes

Hello everyone, you’ve made it to another week of Middlemarch! I hope your Valentine’s Day was better than Dorothea’s.

We got some glimpses into the mind of Mr. Casaubon, the marriage does not look promising and many new characters are making an appearance! 

Don’t forget that we will be reading only Chapter 12 with u/Amanda39 next week, and we will finish Book 1! 

—---------------------------------------------------------------------------

CHAPTER 10

"He had caught a great cold, had he had no other clothes to wear than the skin of a bear not yet killed."--FULLER

Mr. Ladislaw leaves for Europe. The wedding day is approaching, but Mr. Casaubon finds that his feelings for Dorothea are still mild and he does not feel as happy as he expected to be. Dorothea, however, is enthusiastic about the idea of becoming a cultured woman.

They are planning to go to Rome during their honeymoon, but when Casaubon tells her he plans to leave her alone for most of the time while in Rome (because he has to study. Was any of you surprised?), she starts feeling annoyed.

That night, they hold a dinner party, where we meet some new guests. Dorothea in particular has a lovely conversation with Mr. Lydgate, a young doctor who hopes to bring new discoveries in medicine. 

The marriage happens offscreen, and Dorothea and Casaubon go to Rome.

CHAPTER 11

"But deeds and language such as men do use, And persons such as comedy would choose, When she would show an image of the times, And sport with human follies, not with crimes." --Ben Jonson

Mr. Lydgate is a poor and ambitious man, with a crush on Rosamond Vincy, who comes from a family of rich manufacturers.

We get a glimpse of the family during breakfast: Rosamond often criticizes her brother, Fred, who sleeps until late in the morning and has not finished his degree. 

When Fred arrives, a discussion about slang and social class occurs (is anyone else surprised that the word is so old?). 

Later, Rosamond and Fred play together, and then he takes her out for horse riding. 

—---------------------------------------------------------------------------


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Jun 21 '25

Weekly Discussion Post Book 4, Chapters 40, 41 & 42

7 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I’m happy to share that we have officially reached the end of Book 4! Only four other books to go!

Reminder that we will take a break next week, and post a catch-up post on Saturday before starting Book 5, The Dead Hand. Mmh, what a title!

—---------------------------------------------------------------------------

CHAPTER 40

“Wise in his daily work was he:

To fruits of diligence,

And not to faiths or polity,

He plied his utmost sense.

These perfect in their little parts,

Whose work is all their prize—

Without them how could laws, or arts,

Or towered cities rise?”

The Garths are having breakfast. Mary is considering teaching in a school in York, even if she is not excited about the idea.

Mr Garth receives a letter from Mr Chettam, asking him to manage his and Mr Brooke's properties. This opportunity would allow Mary to stay at home!

In the evening, Mr Farebrother comes to visit: Fred has asked him to tell the Garths that he is going away to study, but is too ashamed about his debt to face them directly. We learn that Mary told her parents about Mr Featherstone's will.

Farebrother senses that there may be something between Fred and Mary, and finds himself a little jealous.

Mr Garth is thinking of asking Fred to become his assistant, since the boy doesn't see himself fitted for clerical life. He also mentions that he thinks Riggs is selling some of his land to Bulstrode.

CHAPTER 41

By swaggering could I never thrive,

For the rain it raineth every day.

—Twelfth Night. 

Elliot spends a lot of time making sure that we understand that Mr Rigg Featherstone resembles a frog. He is talking to a man named John Raffles, his stepfather. Raffles is trying to convince him to give his mother money, but it's clear Rigg thinks poorly of Raffles, claiming that he made his mother miserable. 

CHAPTER 42

How much, methinks, I could despise this man

Were I not bound in charity against it!

—SHAKESPEARE: Henry VIII. 

Mr Casaubon is growing paranoid, and fears that, in case of his death, Ladislaw will be ready to marry Dorothea to get his fortune. This brings him to the resolution to ask Lydgate's opinion on his illness.

Lydgate believes Casaubon to have a fatty degeneration of the heart, but he does not know how much time he has left.

This bothers the man deeply. He walks with Dorothea towards the house, taking comfort in her presence, but unable to talk to her. Dorothea feels resentful, but they are able to sweetly reconcile before going to sleep.

—---------------------------------------------------------------------------


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Oct 19 '25

Book 7 - Chapters 69 to 71

7 Upvotes

Good evening, Middlemarchers! We've got a whole lot of shocking new developments to get through this week, with Bulstrode in particular getting the worst of it. Let's see how he got into his mess.

-----------------

Chapter 69

"If thou hast heard a word, let it die with thee." - Ecclesiastes 19:10

Mr. Garth meets with Bulstrode and mentions that his very best friend Raffles is at Stone Court, apparently at death's door. Bulstrode wants to have Lydgate examine Raffles, but Mr. Garth tells Bulstrode that, due to a few things Raffles has let slip to Caleb, he can no longer work for Bulstrode out of good conscience. Bulstrode tries to persuade Caleb to change his mind, but he refuses, yet says he will not repeat what Raffles has told him. Bulstrode goes to Stone Court and hopes that Raffles really is as sick as Mr. Garth says he is, but it seems like it's alcohol doing the talking, mostly. Lydgate arrives and says Raffles will live, much to Bulstrode's chagrin, and gives instructions on how to care for the man. When Lydgate returns home, he finds Dover's people taking away his furniture, and Rosamond is beside herself. She wants to stay with her parents until Lydgate can clear things up, but convinces her to stay for now because she might get lucky and he might break his neck or something. What a ray of sunshine.

Chapter 70

Our deeds still travel with us from afar,

And what we have been makes us what we are.

Bulstrode riffles through Raffles' pockets and finds nothing but bills and a few pence. Raffles refuses to take any food, and Bulstrode seems to believe the man will die at some point, and that comforts him. He does wish he'd helped Lydgate out with his money troubles, though. Speaking of Lydgate, when he returns to examine the patient, he notices his condition has worsened, but is still confident Raffles will make a full recovery. Bulstrode then writes Lydgate a nice cheque to cover his debts and tells the doctor he can pay him back whenever. When Lydgate leaves, Bulstrode is left alone to care for Raffles for a while, then leaves him in the charge of Mrs. Abel while he gets some shuteye. Bulstrode eventually realizes he never told Mrs. Abel how much opium to give Raffles and wonders if that's such a terrible thing after all. Mrs. Abel goes to see Bulstrode, telling him that Raffles wants brandy even though Lydgate expressly forbade it. Bulstrode thinks for a bit, then gives her the key to where he keeps his booze because sure, why not? In the morning, Raffles really has taken a turn for the worse and finally dies that afternoon when Lydgate drops by for a visit, thoroughly perplexed that his patient died so unexpectedly. After leaving Stone Court, Lydgate mentions to Mr. Farebrother that Bulstrode gave him a loan to cover his debts and outlines his plans for the money.

Chapter 71

Clown. ...'Twas in the Bunch of Grapes, where, indeed, you have a delight to sit, have you not?

Froth. I have so: because it is an open room, and good for winter.

Clown. Why, very well then: I hope here be truths

- William Shakespeare, Measure for Measure, Act 2, scene 1

It's been five days since Raffles has died, and the Middlemarch rumour mill is in full swing. The gossip is all about how Bulstrode got so rich and his connections with Raffles. One of the men in the crowd, Bambridge, tells them what he himself had heard from Raffles, and that story spreads like wildfire. Eventually Caleb Garth has to admit what he heard from Raffles himself, and now the whole town thinks Caleb is the one who started spreading the story around and it's chaos. The rumour mill also has some ugly things to say about Will Ladislaw because racism. They also discuss Lydgate's sudden and suspiciously timed windfall. Even if the doctor did nothing wrong, they still treat him with suspicion and distrust. Bulstrode, now convinced the coast is clear with Raffles gone, decides to stay in Middlemarch and attend a town meeting. Things go horribly wrong for him, with the members calling on him to resign due to the accusations of how Bulstrode gained his fortune. Bulstrode vehemently denies this, but is still asked to leave. Lydgate, seeing Bulstrode struggle to walk out the door, gets up to help him, sealing his fate in the community. Lydgate now seriously thinks Raffles' death is suspicious and wonders if that loan was really a bribe to keep him quiet. After the meeting ends, Mr. Brooke and Mr. Farebrother visit Dorothea, back from Yorkshire, to tell her the news about Lydgate. She's shocked and refuses to believe Lydgate has anything to do with the matter.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Apr 19 '25

Weekly Discussion Post Book 3: Chapter 23 and 24

9 Upvotes

Welcome everyone to Book 3 of Middlemarch! 

We go back to Fred's questionable life decisions, talk a lot about horses, and get to meet the Garths!

Next week, u/Amanda39 will take us through chapters 25 and 26. See you in the questions!

—---------------------------------------------------------------------------

CHAPTER 23

“Your horses of the Sun,” he said,

“And first-rate whip Apollo!

Whate’er they be, I’ll eat my head,

But I will beat them hollow.”

Fred is in debt of 160 pounds to Mr Bambridge, which he renewed a while ago with the signature of Caleb Garth. He felt confident that he could find the money in time. 

We are told that the Vincys siblings have been friends with the Garths since they were children, as Mr Featherstone had married Caleb Garth's sister. The Garths used to be wealthier, now they are living in poorer conditions but Fred still considers them a second family. Mr Garth had full trust in him, but didn't tell Mrs Garth about the signature.

Fred has difficulties in finding the money to pay off his debt, so he decides to sell a horse Mr Featherstone had gifted him years ago at the Houndsley horse fair, where he goes with Bambridge and Horrock.

Fred trades his horse for another one, which he considers superior and he is sure he will be able to sell.

CHAPTER 24

“The offender’s sorrow brings but small relief

To him who wears the strong offence’s cross.”

—SHAKESPEARE: Sonnets.

Fred's new horse turns out to be too violent. Without enough money, he decides to talk with the Garths. When he arrives, he meets Mrs Garth, a former governess. When Mr Garth joins them, he confesses that he has only 50 pounds to pay the debt: the Garths are now afraid they won't have enough money to cover their expenses, so Mrs Garth suggests they use the savings they had put aside for their son to become an apprentice. They'll also use Mary's money.

Fred is ashamed and tells them he will repay them eventually, but it will be too late for Alfred to start his apprenticeship by then. Mr Garth also apologises to his wife for having co-signed the debt without telling her.

—---------------------------------------------------------------------------


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Jun 08 '25

Book 3: Chapters 36 & 37

9 Upvotes

Welcome to another week of Middlemarch drama! Rosamond and Lydgate's engagement is causing a stir, while Casaubon squares off against Ladislaw. Who is going to succeed and who is going to be frustrated in their plans? I look forward to reading your thoughts below!


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Nov 08 '25

Where are people going after this novel?

16 Upvotes

TL;DR what are you reading next?

Hello, I fell deeply behind the group in February due to illness but eventually finished Middlemarch last week. I looked in from time-to-time for your insightful comments.

This was a fantastic book for me and I can see why it is a classic. One of you at the r/ayearofwarandpeace subreddit inspired me to pick it up.

Where is everyone going next? Any groups planned with something just as interesting? I am reading the Iliad from now to end of the year with the group in r/bookclub.

I’ll need something to start 2026.


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Oct 05 '25

Weekly Discussion Post Book 7, Books 65 & 66

6 Upvotes

Sorry about the delay, dear Middlemarchers! Please see this week's discussion right here!

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

"One of us two must bowen douteless,

And, sith a man is more reasonable

Than woman is, ye [men] moste be suffrable"- Canterbury Tales (Wife of Bath's Prologue) by Geoffrey Chaucer

Chapter 65

Apparently, Sir Godwin Lydgate will not be riding to the rescue of Tertius and Rosamond's financial difficulties. And, in fact, his letter causes a tiff between the couple as Rosie's previous letter seems to be duplicitous. Lydgate states some home truths, but Rosie easily counters and after a few tears and remonstrances, Lydgate leaves home knowing Rosie holds the scepter.

"'Tis one thing to be tempted, Escalus,

Another thing to fall"- Measure for Measure by William Shakespeare

Chapter 66

Lydgate takes a gamble in the Green Dragon, driven by the pressure of his circumstances. He is playing well and determinedly when young Fred pops in, to see his old haunt. Hawley changes the play with Lydgate and Fred is called up on to intervene in the situation, to help his brother-in-law. Luckily, Farebrother gives him an excuse to pull him away from the game before too much damage is done. Farebrother and Fred have a walk and a serious chat.

Notes and subtext:

More about Chaucer's Canterbury Tales, specifically The Wife of Bath

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

We meet next weekend to discuss Chapters 67 & 68! Discussion below!


r/ayearofmiddlemarch • • Mar 29 '25

Book 2: Chapters 19 and 20

17 Upvotes

Hi, everyone! I'm back to running discussions. (Thank you again, u/Lachesis_Decima77, for covering for me last time.) This week we finally return to the characters we started with, Dorothea and Casaubon.


Chapter 19

“L’ altra vedete ch’ha fatto alla guancia

Della sua palma, sospirando, letto.”

(See the other, who, sighing, has made a bed for her cheek with the palm of her hand.)

—Purgatorio, vii.

Will Ladislaw is looking at art in the Vatican when his German friend points out a beautiful woman and says he'd like to paint her. Ladislaw recognizes the woman as Dorothea.

Chapter 20

A child forsaken, waking suddenly,

Whose gaze afeard on all things round doth rove,

And seeth only that it cannot see

The meeting eyes of love.

Alone in her room, Dorothea cries. Casaubon is oblivious to her suffering, just as Dorothea seems to be oblivious to how much Casaubon is struggling with his writing. The two end up arguing when Dorothea suggests that Casaubon should start making progress on his writing.

Notes

The Sleeping Ariadne is the statue that Will Ladislaw saw Dorothea standing by. He also looks at the Belvedere Torso.