r/ausenviro • • 16h ago

Oberon Council ordered to pay $75,000 after raw sewage released into Fish River

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
14 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 1d ago

News Court backs Victoria’s ‘loophole logging’

Thumbnail
thesaturdaypaper.com.au
11 Upvotes

On an autumn morning in 2024, wildlife surveyor Blake Nesbit found the still-warm body of a glider flattened within logging machine tread-tracks on the forest floor at Yarra Ranges National Park. He called Jordan Crook, vice-president of Wildlife of the Central Highlands.

“I felt sickened,” Crook tells The Saturday Paper. “Blake was crying. He said: ‘They killed a glider.’ It was in one of the trees we’d told them [the government] about. This was just one critter we knew about.”

Protected under federal law, the greater glider had been uplisted from “vulnerable” to “endangered”, with remaining numbers unknown. Allegedly killed by a swig machine, the glider became pivotal to Warburton Environment Inc v DEECA, or the “Hollows case”, a Federal Court test case against “loophole logging” by Victoria’s Department of Energy, Environment and Climate Action.

After years of litigation with mixed results, optimism was high on Thursday in a courtroom overflowing with conservationists. That is, until Justice Christopher Horan dismissed all claims. “It was not established that there were significant impacts on the greater glider or Leadbeater’s possum,” he said, and there was “insufficient basis” to conclude significant impacts in future.

The ruling coincides with breaking news that Victoria’s lowland Leadbeater’s possum has been declared “extinct in the wild” due to forestry and invasive species mismanagement. It’s an expert classification rejected by the government.

The implications of Thursday’s outcome are yet to be fully analysed, Warburton Environment president Nic Fox said outside court, but forest groups will “keep fighting”.

“It’s been such a hard campaign,” she tells The Saturday Paper. “How do you fight a case against something that the government claims doesn’t exist?”

Fox is referring to state government claims that “loophole logging” doesn’t exist. She says a Hollows case argument was that Forest Fire Management Victoria’s (FFMVic) “sudden increase” in removal of habitat trees “does not correspond with a sudden increase in the severity of the hazard they pose” but “does correspond with a sudden increase in funding for tree removal contractors previously retained by VicForests [Victoria’s defunct logging company]”.

The litigants sought to compel FFMVic to heed the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation (EPBC) Act, which was designed to protect species on the pathway to extinction. Evidence mostly centred around more than 800 towering, hollow-bearing trees that Wurundjeri custodian Stacie Piper calls “our baban darrang, our grandmother trees, our ancient ones”.

Recognised as essential keystone species, without which ecosystem function would collapse, the trees measured up to 2.85 metres wide. Centuries old, they safeguarded the rainforest “long before colonisation”, Piper tells The Saturday Paper.

In early 2024, DEECA staff spray-painted them with pink circles and perpendicular “slash lines”, marking them for felling.

By then, logging had officially ended, but former VicForests staff were absorbed into FFMVic, which maintained that continued felling was necessary for “forest management” and “community safety”. VicForests had scheduled roughly 4000 hectares annually for logging until 2030; FFMVic replaced this with equivalent deforestation – an additional 6000 kilometres of clearings, some up to 40 metres wide, for “fuel breaks”.

Even after successful lawsuits against VicForests, FFMVic felling proved impossible to legally challenge. It was not bound by the “already weak” state laws governing VicForests, explains Fox. FFMVic could deforest national parks “with impunity”, bypassing federal laws with “community safety” pretexts. Nor was FFMVic accountable to the Office of the Conservation Regulator.

This makes the Hollows ruling a blow for citizen scientists who have tallied large volumes of native trees being felled, removed and stockpiled across the state: box-ironbark forests in Central Victoria, in the Grampians National Park near Dunkeld, in Mount Baw Baw and the Dandenong Ranges, in Wombat-Lerderderg National Park in the central north, and in Croajingolong National Park in far eastern Victoria.

In the Hollows case, giant trees had formed hollows occupied by rare mammals – greater glider, smoky mouse and Leadbeater’s possum among them. These hollows take hundreds of years to form, so replanting trees still leaves animals “homeless, with a housing crisis”, explains Fox. Cool temperate rainforest covers less than 0.1 per cent of Victoria, and old trees are these mammals’ only chance for survival.

Months before their case was filed, ecologists, surveyors, Wurundjeri custodians and DEECA’s own advisers submitted reports to ministers and FFMVic alongside peer-reviewed findings that old, cool temperate rainforests are themselves natural firebreaks and that FFMVic’s clearing itself increases bushfire risk. Some joined Wildlife of the Central Highlands as “stagwatchers”: monitoring after dark, amassing thousands of infrared film hours, datasets and video case files with GPS coordinates and timestamps.

These filled colossal court books but, the court heard, none of this evidence was heeded by FFMVic, which felled up to 1000 hollow-bearing and “recruitment trees” – trees that are developing hollows. FFMVic did not challenge the court-book data.

“Independent arborist assessments found the trees were low risk,” said Crook, himself a qualified arborist. A second expert-witness arborist “found none of the trees he assessed needed to be cut down”, said Fox. Motivations for the felling, conservationists believe, remain industrial.

Since VicForests’ closure, the government introduced the State Forest By-Products Framework, allowing DEECA to sell logs. Conservationists say this is “loophole logging”, which the government denies. In September, Animal Justice Party MP Georgie Purcell moved a motion for “transparency and oversight” in forest operations, telling parliament, “The evidence does not support the state’s claim that logging was necessary to reduce fire hazard.”

Her motion stated: “Community groups and scientists raising concerns have been met with non-engagement and forced to pursue costly court action as the only available accountability mechanism.”

Labor MP Ryan Batchelor insisted Purcell’s motion was “misleading” because “commercial native timber harvesting ended in Victoria in 2024”. He said logging “does not happen in Victoria” and logs were a mere “byproduct” of fuel breaks.

The Hollows case follows a succession of legal interventions challenging this. Forensic accounting commissioned by Environmental Justice Australia using documents extracted under freedom of information found “native forest logs still moving through Victorian supply chains”. The audit found the $1.5 billion to transition out of logging “failed to deliver the outcomes promised” and it raised “serious questions” about “how such vast amounts of public money were used”. Much remains unaccounted for, with “discrepancies and significant gaps in transparency”.

Some of these gaps were already revealed in Warburton Environment Inc v VicForests (2022). A DEECA official admitted records had “not been maintained” about logged fuel breaks, nor had the clearing of these breaks been “formally recorded” and “the full number” of them “is still unknown”.

In his Hollows case affidavit, FFMVic chief fire officer Chris Hardman allowed that some fuel break records remain “not as accurate, consolidated or complete” as others. Under cross-examination by barrister Jonathan Korman, who repeatedly asked whether FFMVic knew how many hollow-bearing trees were felled in Forty Mile Break (where the glider was killed), Hardman responded, “I can’t tell you the number … I don’t know whether any other individuals knew how many … I don’t know the numbers.” Asked why he hadn’t heeded DEECA advice to consult the EPBC Act, he replied, “Just removing a small number of hazardous trees … wouldn’t have triggered a thought that it would have a significant impact.”

By contrast, citizen surveyors recorded precise numbers and impacts. “It’s been an extraordinary community effort to challenge the destruction of homes for endangered wildlife and hold the government to account,” says Fox. Community groups were “forced to take legal action to stop the government killing endangered wildlife”.

“Today’s decision shows why we urgently need stronger laws to protect threatened wildlife and the forests they live in and depend on. State and federal governments are failing threatened species. Without community groups documenting this destruction and challenging it in court, who is holding the state government to account?”

The case coincided with several peer-reviewed studies finding forest fuel breaks create wind tunnels, dry forests and increase flammability. Several detailed questions were put to the state government, but a media staffer noted its “limited” capacity to respond while in caretaker mode ahead of the November 28 election.

The recent Improved Native Forest Management carbon credit method, a federal regulation that makes native logging unviable, hasn’t been applied in Victoria because the state claims to have ended logging. Victoria is currently negotiating a federal agreement to conduct its own EPBC assessments – a proposal conservationists characterise as “FFMVic marking its own homework”.

Fox says Thursday’s ruling “raised serious questions” about the effectiveness of nature laws and “the same agency being responsible for delivery, assessment, compliance and assurance”.

“It’s the fox guarding the henhouse.”


r/ausenviro • • 5d ago

Report / Study Overheating cattle: more and more dangerous heat is coming for northern Australia’s herds

Thumbnail
theconversation.com
4 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 7d ago

News Investigation links Australian deforestation to beef farming and major bank loans

Thumbnail
phys.org
24 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 9d ago

News Anti-fire ant eradication activist convicted after using legal arguments ‘similar to sovereign citizens’

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
9 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 10d ago

News / Editorial Cows and cyclones: New push to design solar farms for cattle and climate, but is Australia ready?

Thumbnail
reneweconomy.com.au
3 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 10d ago

News Echidna sightings on Aboriginal-owned Lungtalanana/Clarke Island excite after extensive bushfires

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
5 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 10d ago

News Koala population on fringes of Newcastle could be chlamydia-free

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
14 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 13d ago

Unlike anything I’ve seen: why this whale season has marine scientists puzzled

Thumbnail
theconversation.com
10 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 15d ago

Indigenous rangers, scientists work together to revitalise Great Desert Skink population

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
12 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 26d ago

Court hears gas power plant for Moss Vale data centre could be mothballed

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
7 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • 27d ago

News Earth's oldest evidence of life is written in stone in Western Australia—but it's at risk of disappearing

Thumbnail
phys.org
19 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Oct 17 '26

Research shows dingoes in WA's Great Sandy Desert protect native wildlife by eating feral cats

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
32 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Oct 16 '26

Scientists Tested the Tasmanian Tiger’s DNA — And Found Something Nobody Expected

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Oct 16 '26

Hordes of yabbies are trashing rivers in Africa. How did this happen?

Thumbnail
theconversation.com
6 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Sep 24 '26

News Scientists probe connection between deadly frog disease and coal wastewater

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
9 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Sep 21 '26

News Paruna Wildlife Sanctuary's popular Possum Loop reopens after flood damage repair

Thumbnail ausleisure.com.au
2 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Sep 19 '26

News How to fix the safeguard measure

Thumbnail
thesaturdaypaper.com.au
5 Upvotes

For decades, federal politics has been plagued by fights over carbon pricing – the conceptually simple idea of imposing a cost on greenhouse gas emissions to incentivise reducing them. Between 1995 and 2009, there were five failed attempts to establish a national scheme. Things looked up momentarily in 2011 when the Gillard government created the carbon pricing mechanism with the support of the Greens. It ran for two years before being repealed by the Abbott government.

In its place, Tony Abbott instituted a Frankenstein policy known as the safeguard mechanism that was designed to achieve nothing – and it succeeded. Abbott’s safeguard remained in place until March 2023, when the Albanese government overhauled it; reforms described at the time as a momentous change that would set the economy on the path to net zero.

The enthusiasm for the revitalised safeguard has since waned. It has kept big polluters happy but, three years on, belief that it will drive rapid decarbonisation has dissipated and many environmental groups are pushing for significant changes.

Into this charged political environment comes the recently initiated 2026-27 safeguard mechanism review – with a consultation period that closed on Friday. Promised during the 2023 reform process, the review is meant to ensure the safeguard is “effectively delivering emissions reductions and that scheme settings are operating as intended”.

While presented in dull bureaucratic terms and smothered in technocratic jargon, the review has set the scene for yet another lively scrap over climate policy.

The safeguard imposes emissions caps on large facilities that release more than 100,000 tonnes of emissions a year. It covers about 220 facilities, with most emissions coming from coal and gas operations – the likes of Yancoal, Woodside Energy and Santos. Grid-connected electricity generators are excluded.

The scheme imposes a price on emissions by requiring operators of the covered facilities to buy and surrender tradeable credits to cover any emissions that exceed their caps.

Under Abbott’s safeguard, the caps were generally set well above the facilities’ actual emissions. This meant they were rarely penalised – it was a carbon price in name only. The Coalition had no plans to reduce the caps.

Anthony Albanese’s reforms reset the caps to levels based on historic average emission intensities at each facility and then set them on a downward trajectory over subsequent years. A new type of credit was also introduced. Where previously facilities could only use carbon offsets known as Australian Carbon Credit Units (ACCUs) to meet liabilities, now they earn Safeguard Mechanism Credits (SMCs) if their emissions are below their caps. Facilities that earn SMCs can sell them to other facilities, who can use them to cover their excess emissions.

So, has the revitalised safeguard worked? The short answer is no.

In decarbonisation terms, three years is not a long time. Generally, the large emitters have expensive, long-lived equipment that takes time to replace or upgrade. Even accounting for the resulting expected lag in emissions reductions, it is clear the safeguard is not up to the task of driving emissions reductions in line with our climate targets.

Since the revitalised safeguard started, it has done almost nothing to reduce emissions. Covered emissions have fluctuated between 130 million and 143 million tonnes since 2017, with the ups and downs largely attributable to facilities dropping in and out of coverage and swings in production. Where abatement has occurred, by and large, it has been as a result of factors other than the safeguard, including via ACCUs and direct government support.

For the scheme to work, the financial penalty on emissions must be big enough to motivate the shift to low-carbon technologies or, where there are no viable abatement options, the closure of the facilities.

Therefore, the safeguard’s effectiveness depends on two main factors: the stringency of caps and the magnitude of the carbon price.

The caps determine facilities’ exposures to the carbon price. If the caps are too high, only a small proportion of their emissions will be subject to the penalty, meaning there is little incentive to reduce them. Buying credits becomes a cost of doing business rather than a motivator of change.

Under Labor’s revitalised safeguard, the emissions caps are set to fall by between 1 per cent and 4.9 per cent a year through to 2030, with a scheme-wide average annual decline of 4.3 per cent. However, last financial year, only 10 per cent of emissions from covered facilities were subject to the carbon price because the caps are still too high. Further, almost seven million SMCs were issued to covered facilities, most of which stemmed from artificially inflated caps rather than genuine abatement efforts.

The other hole in the safeguard is the price of credits. Whether facilities choose to decarbonise, or opt to buy and surrender ACCUs or SMCs instead, depends on the cost of cutting onsite emissions relative to the credit price. If the credit price is below the marginal cost of cutting onsite emissions, businesses will logically choose to rely on ACCUs and SMCs.

As any basic economic textbook tells us, prices are a function of the interaction of supply and demand. With the caps on emissions set to fall, demand for credits should increase and prices should rise, pushing more facilities to reduce emissions.

While this is true, consideration needs to be given to the supply side of the market. Herein lies the problem. Successive Australian governments have manipulated the ACCU scheme to ensure it throws out a seemingly endless number of cheap, low-integrity credits.

By law, each ACCU is supposed to represent one tonne of genuine abatement that would not have occurred without the incentive provided by the scheme. In practice, this legal requirement has meant close to nothing.

The ACCU scheme is now generating more than 23 million credits a year, the overwhelming majority of which do not represent genuine emissions reductions.

Many ACCU projects are farcical. This financial year, more than 10 million ACCUs will be issued for fake reforestation projects in desert and semi-desert areas that have never been cleared of native vegetation. In other words, they are claiming to reforest areas that were never forested or that already had forests when the projects started. Some of these projects are in the Nullarbor, a place that derives its name from the Latin, nullus arbor, meaning “no trees”.

About five million credits a year are going to companies to capture and combust methane emitted from tips – even though most of the sites would do so anyway. More than 60 per cent of the soil projects that have been credited to date have somehow achieved sequestration levels that are between four and 11 times what is scientifically possible.

The scheme is a rort and it is wrecking the safeguard by artificially lowering the carbon price as the market is flooded with phoney credits. The result is the big emitters face a carbon price, currently about $38 per ACCU, that is less than half of the minimum necessary to keep global warming to below 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. The international target being pursued under the Paris climate agreement is 1.5 degrees.

The artificially suppressed credit price is driving big emitters to rely on junk credits rather than cutting their own emissions. Since those credits do not represent genuine emissions reductions, there is no abatement – the offset providers pocket the money but Australia drifts further from its targets. Not only that, the suppressed credit price makes good projects unviable, creating an unvirtuous cycle where the market is increasingly dominated by “lemons”.

Time is now short. Decades of delay mean the option of gradual transition is gone. The Albanese government’s instincts are to tinker, but substantive reform is needed.

Reflecting this, the safeguard’s emissions caps should be beelined to zero no later than 2030; either that or the scheme should be converted into a cap-and-trade scheme – the same as planned in Gillard’s carbon pricing mechanism and as occurs in the pricing schemes in Europe, California and South Korea. This would ensure all emissions are penalised.

Offsets have failed. Almost 30 years of experience has shown they rarely work and that the failings are systemic, arising not from technical issues but the governance dynamics that develop around them – principally, the incentive to use them to manipulate prices.

If the safeguard is going to work, offsets need to be excluded from the scheme. In its place, a standard cap price should be instituted, allowing big emitters to pay a set, transparent amount per tonne of emissions into a decarbonisation fund. The decarbonisation fund could then be used to finance emissions reductions in hard-to-abate facilities and in the land, waste and agricultural sectors.

This is not radical. The Albanese government created a similar arrangement for biodiversity under national environmental laws late last year.

This structure would strip away the incentives driving the corruption of the ACCU scheme, while ensuring good offset projects could continue to be financed through the fund. It would also provide a pool of resources that, working with the newly created biodiversity fund, could be used to restore the cleared and degraded ecosystems that support most of our threatened biodiversity.

It is time for our political leaders to heed and act on the climate science, both in relation to what is needed to avert dangerous climate change and what works in driving emissions reductions.

The author thanks Professor Don Butler and Dr Deb Wilkinson for their assistance with this piece.


r/ausenviro • • Sep 09 '26

Videos capture humpback whales stopping to snack as they migrate along Australia’s coast

Thumbnail
theconversation.com
8 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Sep 08 '26

News A court will decide the future of Yuraygir’s feral horses. That matters for native plants and animals

Thumbnail
theconversation.com
8 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Sep 07 '26

Activism / Action What was Australia's largest single military deployment over the last 50 years?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Sep 06 '26

Environmental career - Australia (West aus)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Sep 04 '26

Report / Study Denialism doesn’t change the reality that roaming pet cats are a scourge for Australia’s wildlife

Thumbnail
biodiversitycouncil.org.au
18 Upvotes

r/ausenviro • • Sep 03 '26

Seeking conservation perspectives on biodiversity governance in the Pilbara, Western Australia

3 Upvotes

I’m an undergraduate student in Melbourne currently researching biodiversity governance in the Pilbara, Western Australia, as part of the Tsinghua Global SDG Case Competition.

My research looks at how biodiversity conservation is managed where mining and regional development, Indigenous stewardship of Country, government responsibilities, scientific knowledge, and conservation priorities intersect.

I’m particularly interested in hearing from people with experience or interest in conservation, ecology, environmental policy, Indigenous land management, mining, research, or environmental management.

I’ve put together a short anonymous survey exploring perspectives on:

* the main pressures affecting biodiversity in the Pilbara
* current conservation and governance approaches
* Traditional Owner involvement and Indigenous ecological knowledge
* stakeholder collaboration
* the role of industry
* what effective conservation outcomes could look like

No specialist knowledge of the Pilbara is required, and there are no right or wrong answers. I’m interested in your perspective and experience.

The survey takes around 6–8 minutes and does not collect names or email addresses.

Survey: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfGH4dTtp690s75q1pmHizudMhmQdsW8v8OcLwlOHbUIepjzw/viewform

If you have worked or lived in the Pilbara, I’d especially appreciate your perspective.

Thank you for taking the time to contribute!


r/ausenviro • • Sep 03 '26

Global heating will hit at least 1.8C, UN warns, and there are ‘no good outcomes’

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
13 Upvotes