I'm going to keep this short. Many people from around the internet (quill18 and EnterElysium included) have been complaining about the UI for Aurora.
"Heya folks, and welcome to another episode of Let's Play Aurora 4x, the ugliest most awesome game ever."~Martin "quill18" Glaude
"Lies, all lies! âDwarf Fortress in spaceâ? This game makes DF look like a user-friendly cakewalk. I have no idea if the game is good or not, because I canât effinâ play it!" ~ A sample comment from here
Aurora does not have a bad user interface at all. The interface is actually one of the best UIs have encountered in a long time. Take for example Europa Universalis IV. That economics screen is missing information. I don't know where the money the user is making is coming from. I could check the ledger but why would there be two screens for the same purpose?
In Aurora 4x on the other hand, each screen is only as complicated as it needs to be to get the job done. No there aren't little, twisted banners between income and expenses but when I'm playing a game I don't care about the banners, I care about the data presented to me. Imagine if Aurora 4x had three-dimensional models of each planet in a map that you could move around. It would be an unnecessary feature. I usually play, and from what I have seen of other people's playthroughs, the user usually keeps the map centered on the central star and zoom in and out as necessary. There aren't impressive particle effects and models for your ships but honestly, how would you see them? You would have to zoom in so far that you lost all other information and data presented at you.
Aurora has the most efficient GUI and one of the best UIs that I have seen (I would prefer some more keyboard shortcuts). Aurora is really more of a triumph of good design than a failing of it. It cuts away the fluff that triple-A game companies add to make them more exciting, just look at the new X-Com versus the old. The old geoscape gave the user control over the time progression the ability to access other parts of the game with a single click while new one takes choice away from the user and is essentially useless compared to a simple list of possible targets. I could offer up the new Elite:Dangerous game as another example, while great in scope it has been criticized for lacking in engagement value.
Ah well, maybe I'm all wrong about this, maybe all we need nowadays is particles over gameplay, GPUs over CPUs. But I will cling to the fact that Aurora is the most engaging game, the best end user designed game (I haven't peeked at the code), and the game I will be playing for years to come.