Okay, so I’ve been thinking about this, and I genuinely don’t understand why Reiner thought sending Annie to kill Sawney and Bean was a good idea.
Also was there truly anything during this part of the show that hange could have possibly learned from these two experimental titans that would have been enough to ruin there mission? I mean the enemy’s of Marley knew more about titans than the Paridis people and yet even at this point Marley was still the strongest because of the titans.
I understand that they probably didn’t want Hange learning anything important from experimenting on two live Titans, but wasn’t the Survey Corps already researching Titans? It’s not like this was some completely new thing.
And correct me if I’m wrong, but didn’t Reiner and Birthcontrol already know how technologically behind the people inside the Walls were? Marley knew that Paradis was significantly less advanced, and the government inside the Walls had been suppressing information and controlling what people could learn for years.
So realistically, how much could Hange have discovered with the technology and resources they had available?
I mean, obviously Hange is incredibly intelligent, but it’s not like she had access to modern laboratories or advanced scientific equipment. Even if she discovered something about Titan regeneration, sunlight, or behavior, would that really have been enough to threaten their mission?
What confuses me even more is why Annie would agree to take such an unnecessary risk.
Annie always seemed like one of the more calculated and cautious characters to me. She doesn’t strike me as someone who would unnecessarily risk exposing herself, especially when the potential reward seems so small.
And weren’t those Titans being held relatively close to where the Scouts were stationed? What if someone had seen her? What if she got caught? Their entire mission could’ve been compromised over two random Titans.
I understand that Annie was skilled enough to carry it out, and maybe she was just confident she wouldn’t get caught, but still. Why even take that chance?
And we know that the whole situation eventually contributed to Annie getting exposed because Armin recognized Marco’s ODM gear.
The other thing that bothers me is that killing those two Titans doesn’t actually stop the Scouts from researching Titans.
It’s not like they’re running out of Titans anytime soon, lol. Obviously capturing live Titans is dangerous, but they could theoretically capture more. Killing Sawney and Bean just delays the research rather than preventing it entirely.
So what exactly was Reiner trying to accomplish?
Was he genuinely worried that Hange might discover something that could expose Annie, Bluetooth, and himself? Was there some specific information he was afraid she’d uncover?
Or was Reiner just making an impulsive decision because their mission was already going badly?
I feel like there’s a huge difference between taking a calculated risk and creating an unnecessary one, and this honestly seems like the latter.
Am I missing something important about Reiner’s reasoning here, or was this genuinely just a bad strategic decision?