r/atoptics • • Oct 04 '26

Modpost Feedback wanted: new community rules

53 Upvotes

As many of you know, this subreddit doesn't have any formal rules. That has mostly worked just fine, but it causes uncertainty, and there have been several requests for formal rules of what is allowed and what isn't.

Very little is going to change regarding moderation: very few posts are currently removed, and most that are removed are obvious spam posts with no relation to atmospheric optics.

Proposed rules:

The nested text is what you get when you click the rule on the standard reddit web. For other platforms (old reddit, apps) they will be written roughly like below.

Posts:

  • Posts must feature or closely relate to atmospheric optics

    • Rainbows, halos, aurora, coronas, crepuscular rays and similar are all welcome, as are "what is this?" questions. Plain skies, pretty clouds, sunsets and similar, with no optical phenomenon in particular, should be posted in other subreddits such as r/skyporn, r/clouds, r/sunset. See the community info (sidebar/"About" tab) for more information on allowed/disallowed content.

  • No AI generated or otherwise computer generated content

    • Simulations are welcome if labeled as such. Standard editing including stacking, contrast/sharpness edits, panoramas and so on are perfectly fine.

Comments:

  • Be nice to each other

    • Disagreements are fine; personal attacks or harassment are not.

  • Stay roughly on topic

    • Discussions that drift away a bit are perfectly fine.

Posts and comments:

  • Please use English

    • Reddit may automatically translate text in some cases, but many users will view reddit in a way where that is not available.

  • Keep it science-based: no pseudoscience or conspiracy theories

    • This is a science-based community; the phenomena discussed are fairly well-understood. Topics like chemtrails, UFO sightings, paranormal activity and similar are considered off topic and will be removed.

  • No botting, spam, etc.

Proposed content guidelines:

🟢 Allowed and welcomed

  • Water/ice optics: rainbows (including fogbows, cloudbows, and others), ice halos (22° halos, sun dogs, light pillars, and others), iridescence, coronas, glories, and so on

  • Rays and shadows: crepuscular/anticrepuscular rays, cloud/contrail shadows, mountain shadows

  • Upper atmosphere: aurora, STEVE, airglow, sprites, blue jets, ELVES, nacreous clouds, noctilucent clouds, and so on

  • Other phenomena: mirages, green/blue flashes, rocket exhaust trails, and anything similar to the above

  • Identification requests: "What is this?" photos and similar. Consider mentioning the date, time and approximate location as that helps a lot when identifying some phenomena!

  • General discussion: Any discussion related to the above, including new discoveries, physics, simulations, and so on

🔴 Not allowed

  • AI generated or computer generated content, except for simulations (e.g. HaloRay/HaloSim), which are welcome if labeled as such. Edited photos are fine

  • Plain skies, clouds and sunsets with no optical phenomenon: try e.g. r/skyporn, r/clouds, r/sunset

  • Pseudoscience and conspiracy-related posts and comments: chemtrails, weather engineering, UFO sightings, ghosts/paranormal activity, and so on

If you feel unsure, but your post seems to fit the subreddit theme, feel free to post it!

Nothing above is final, and feedback is very welcome, whether it's about what should be allowed or not, or just things like improving the wording.

I'd like feedback on one additional thing in particular:
What should the rules say about posting clouds, where no other optical phenomenon is visible?
I personally feel that "pretty sky" photos with no optics are certainly often nice, but still clearly off topic. However, they are relatively often both highly upvoted and reported as off topic, so there's no clear consensus there.
It may be that they are popular on the front page, whereas people specifically viewing r/atoptics downvote/report them, in which case disallowing is probably the right call (which I suspect is the case).


r/atoptics • • Jan 15 '25

Atoptics site

37 Upvotes

Atoptics is at www.atoptics.org.uk


r/atoptics • • 10h ago

22º Halo Sun Halo in Johannesburg, South Africa this morning

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 8h ago

A beautiful sight Above South Africa

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Today I captured this fascinating circular halo around the sun .A reminder of how extraodinary our skies can be.Zahra mommy shot this especially for you ❤️


r/atoptics • • 17h ago

22º Halo A 22 Halo, Noon in Australia

Post image
83 Upvotes

Sorry if this isn't the best photo; I took it on my phone camera, but I thought it was interesting. Does anyone know what this means weather wise? Because it's been so hot in North QLD.


r/atoptics • • 16h ago

ID REQUEST ID help

Post image
46 Upvotes

Not sure what this is called, snapped with my phone today.


r/atoptics • • 1d ago

Five lights

Thumbnail
gallery
156 Upvotes

There appears to be five bright shiny lights in the sky of erbil
The south part
I think it might be light pillar any one have an idea what that is?


r/atoptics • • 1d ago

Other Spotted a pink "rainbow" at sunset without any rain

Post image
41 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 2d ago

22º Halo Sun halo over the Besseggen Rapids, Norway.

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 2d ago

Parry Arc both types of parry arc within a few hours, 10/21/26, Bucks County, PA

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 2d ago

Crepuscular Rays Anti-crepuscular rays from this morning

Post image
95 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 2d ago

ID REQUEST Possible circumzenithal arc over downtown Knoxville, TN — October 20, 2026?

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

Photographed at approximately 4:57 PM EST from the intersection of Gay Street and Union Avenue, facing roughly west.

The Sun was low and obscured by buildings. The colorful arc was nearly overhead, curved upward at both ends, and appeared to remain stationary while clouds visibly drifted through it.

I'm leaning toward a circumzenithal arc, but I'd love confirmation or an alternative identification!


r/atoptics • • 2d ago

Rainbow in San Diego :)

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 3d ago Heartwarming

Round rainbow from 24th floor (from u/hag68)

639 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 4d ago

Iridescence Some wild iridescence

Thumbnail
gallery
216 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 3d ago

Subsun Subsun and subparhelia

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

Last one through a tinted window


r/atoptics • • 4d ago

Coming into Sydney

Post image
103 Upvotes

Taken through a pretty grubby window so I tightened up the levels a bit and cropped, but otherwise untouched.

Is this a rainbow, a fogbow, a cloudbow or something else?


r/atoptics • • 4d ago

22°+46° sunhalo today November 11th

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

rare double halo 22°+46°


r/atoptics • • 4d ago

Rainbow 🌈☀️🐕

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 5d ago

Multiple Display Beautiful halos

Thumbnail
gallery
97 Upvotes

Beautiful display this morning. Temperature -5°C and an open lake nearby, which probably caused these. If I'm right, there's a 22° ring, sun pillars, sun dogs (?) and an upper tangential arc? Someone can correct me on that if it's not right.


r/atoptics • • 4d ago

What's this unusual dark band in the sky?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 6d ago

Circumhorizon Arc Rainbow clouds

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 6d ago

Iridescence Iridescence today midday

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

r/atoptics • • 7d ago

ID REQUEST Not sure if this belongs, but it was definitely an odd V shape above the setting sun.

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Ojai, California