r/atheisteaglescouts • u/[deleted] • Dec 03 '12
British Scout Association is consulting its members on plans to draft an alternative oath without references to God, allowing atheists to become full members and Scout group leaders for the first time
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/[deleted] • Dec 03 '12
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/IlliniSSA • Dec 19 '11
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/JaggerA • May 31 '12
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/PennSullivan • Jan 30 '12
I've pretty much always believed that the scout law shaped who I am today from a moral stance much more than any religion ever could. No where in the scout law does it say to hate, harm, or harass anyone. Yes, there is reverence at the end of it and I know what it was meant for but I really think that since religion has evolved into such a monstrous, all-consuming beast there is justification with evolving the meaning of reverence. That is, as it was originally intended in the scout law. I believe it is possible to respect life and nature with a sense of reverence. To be reverent is to be worshipful. Isn't scouting being worshipful of nature and of life? ' The scout oath is another issue that people raise with me about being an Eagle scout and an Atheist. The one segment about "duty to God" seems to be the only thing they focus on. They pay no attention to the entire rest of the oath which, I think, is absolutely foolish of them. The scout oath would make a beautiful thing to recite in the morning. It really sets a good mood for the day. Even when you cut out duty to God it is all an excellent oath. Why is it necessary to have God in it when the whole rest of it sets up just as much good will as if God wasn't there? God omitted, I am still a good person by following the rest of the oath, right? As far as I can tell, there's nothing morally incorrect about following the oath, God omitted.
I follow the scout oath and law every day of my life as best as I can while still being human. Like every other person on the planet, I make mistakes. But I do not need a God to tell me what is right and wrong and to judge my mistakes. I have a conscience. I have my heart. I have had basic moral principles instilled in me ever since I was a tiger cub and I've grown with them my whole life. I'll be damned if anyone says that because I am an Atheist, I do not have any morals. I have twelve excellent moral standards in my mind that I doubt most good Christian boys do everyday. There's a reason I received my Eagle rank last year. There's a reason I am well liked by people. There's a reason I am trusted. Because I am an Eagle scout. NOT because I am a good Christian boy.
TL;DR: The scout oath and law have all the morals I'll ever need in it and I believe those two things are more morally correct than the Bible.
EDIT: Thank you to whoever is responsible for getting this on Facebook! I am very honored that this was worthy of being posted on the Atheist scouting page. Please contribute to the conversation if you have anything to say at all!
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/zck • Jul 14 '15
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/Sigafoos • Mar 07 '12
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/kellistis • May 15 '13
As the title suggests I just passed my BoR 2nite and am officially an Eagle Scout... all this hard work has finally paid off.
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/zck • May 24 '13
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/yourselfiegotleaked • Feb 12 '16
Hey, I've joined your ranks guys!
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/arrow74 • Mar 11 '15
Today I not only join Eagle, but I also join the smaller number of atheist Eagles.
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/metalliska • Jan 28 '13
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/dklco • Sep 26 '11
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/ComeJoinTheFeast • Aug 03 '11
But I have staffed at multiple scout camps, I help teach my councils climbing class twice a year, I have two little brothers on their way to becoming Eagles, and I have devoted a ridiculous amount of time volunteering for service projects, scouting for food, teaching classes, and helping start a venturing crew in my area, but it is fucking ridiculous that if I were to come out as an atheist to a fellow scout that I could lose membership in scouting, be fired from a job at a scout camp, or not be able to continue teaching climbing classes for my council.
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/Dalimey100 • Apr 16 '12
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/Dalimey100 • Oct 10 '11
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/korn101 • Nov 19 '11
I have grown tired of the bigotry in the BSA so much that I do not consider myself an Eagle scout anymore. I have been writing drafts to the letter I am going to send them telling me that an organization as influential as them should be ashamed of themselves for how they treat atheists (which I am) and homosexuals. What else do you think I should add to the letter? I will link it before I send it (It will be a hand written copy, because one of the things I learned in becoming an eagle scout is that companies value hand written messages more than typed ones)
EDIT Due to some family issues I cannot leave my troop right now. Asking to be removed from the charter like my plan was would cause much more trouble than necessary. I am now planning to wait until the summer hits and the issues calm down. I don't want to go into my family problems, i'll just leave it at my brother got in trouble and my relationship with my parents could be comparable to walking on glass. Leaving the troop is not in my best interests. Lastly, I am leaving scouting because my troop really doesn't need me. There are plenty of adult leaders right now other than me. We actually have started limiting the amount of adults that come on trips because we have so many wanting to go. I am not hurting my troop in any way. Plus my dad is still the scoutmaster, so if they need my help they would still have it, I just will not be going on any of the trips anymore
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/ExMoCandy • Feb 22 '19
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/CampBenCh • Nov 02 '15
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/Tarthkin • Oct 09 '13
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/db88uke • Jan 16 '12
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/Alextolly • Mar 18 '12
Reddit is just one of those places where people can just go to be understood. I didnt think there would be another person in the world that would be an atheist eagle scout. (since scouting is mostly religous based) I look forward to great stories to be heard by everyone.
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/metalliska • Sep 01 '11
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/TheAlmightyGinger195 • Oct 24 '15
After an eleven year Scouting career (Cub Scouts included), a fight with brain cancer and depression, I earn my rank of Eagle this afternoon. I'm in shock, I never thought I would make it this far. To my brother Eagles, carry the standard well.
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/denimalpaca • May 17 '12
I've been an atheist since bridging into Boy Scouts (younger than that I really was too young to decide for myself, but I had doubts about "God").
However, for some reason, I have been chosen numerous times, for numerous different events, to give opening invocations or to be Chaplain's Aide. I gave opening invocations at my District's Memorial Day Flag Placement, several flag ceremonies for prominent scholarships for Eagle Scouts, and I was Chaplain's Aide for my National Jamboree troop.
I have no idea where the idea came from that I should be the religious guy. I've never felt bad about doing it, just a little weird because I don't believe in any of it. I felt that it was all rather ironic.
Any of you in the same boat/were in the same boat or have similar stories?
r/atheisteaglescouts • u/surprisinglyaccurate • Jan 16 '12
I've been in scouting for 12 years now, served in countless leadership positions, including SPL and Section Chief in the Order of the Arrow, 150+ nights of camping, hundreds of hours of community service... and if I let slip to my board that I am an atheist that's the end of the story. I know I don't have to explain the feeling to you guys... feelsbadman. :/
Wish me luck? :/