r/astrophysics • • Feb 27 '26

Can AI do astrophysics? I put it to the test against my own PhD in high-energy astrophysics

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

I've been seeing a LOT of claims (primarily from large AI companies) that LLMs now have "beyond PhD" reasoning capabilities in every subject, "no exceptions". "Its like having a PhD in any topic in your pocket". When I look at evidence and discussions of these claims, they focus almost entirely on whether or not LLMs can solve graduate-level homework or exam problems in various disciplines, which I do not find to be an adequate assessment at all.

First, all graduate course homework problems (in STEM at least) are very well-established, with usually plenty of existing material equivalent to solutions for an LLM to scrape and train on. Thus, when I see that GPT can now solve PhD-level physics problems, I assume it means their training set has gobbled up enough material that even relatively obscure problems and their solutions now appear in their dataset. Second, in most PhDs (with some exceptions, like pure math), you take courses in only the first year or two, equivalent to a master's. So being able to solve graduate problems is more of a master's qualification, and not a doctorate. A PhD--and particularly the reasoning capability you develop during a PhD--is about expanding beyond the confines of existing problems and understanding. Its about adding new knowledge, pushing boundaries, and doing something genuinely new, which is why the final requirement for most PhDs is an original, non-derivative contribution to your field. This is very, very hard to do, and this skill you develop of being able to do push beyond the confines of an existing field into new territory without certainty or clearly-defined answers is what makes the experience special. 

When these large companies make these "beyond PhD" claims, this is actually what they're talking about, and not solving graduate homework problems. We know this is what they mean because these claims are usually followed by claims that AI will solve humanity's thus unsolved problems, like climate change, aging, cancer, energy, etc.--the opposite problems you'd associate with homework or exam questions. These are hard problems that will require originality and serious tolerance of uncertainty to tackle, and despite the claims I'm not convinced LLMs have these capabilities.

To try and test this, I designed a simple experiment. I gave ChatGPT 5.2 Extended Thinking my own problems, based on what I actually work on as a researcher with a PhD in physics. To be clear these aren't homework problems, these are more like small, focused research directions. The one in the attached video was from my first published paper, which did an explorative analysis and made an interesting discovery about black holes. I like this kind of question because the LLM has to reason beyond its training data and be somewhat original to make the same discovery we did, but given the claims it should be perfectly capable of doing so (especially since the discovery is mathematical in nature and doesn't need any data). 

What I found instead was that, even with a hint about the direction of the discovery, it did a very basic boilerplate analysis that was incredibly uninteresting. It did not try to explore and try things outside of its comfort zone to happen upon the discovery that was there waiting for it; it catastrophically limited itself to results that it thought were consistent with past work and therefore prevented itself from stumbling upon a very obvious and interesting discovery. Worse, when I asked it to present its results as a paper that would be accepted in the most popular journal in my field (ApJ) it created a frankly very bad report that suffered in several key ways, which I describe in the video. The report looked more like a lab report written by a high schooler; timid, unwilling to move beyond perceived norms, and just trying to answer the question and be done, appealing to jargon instead of driving a narrative. This kind of "reasoning" is not PhD or beyond PhD level, in my opinion. How do we expect these things to make genuinely new and useful discoveries, if even after inhaling all of human literature they struggle to make obvious and new connections?

I have more of these planned, but I would love your thoughts on this and how I can improve this experiment. I have no doubt that my prompt probably wasn't good enough, but I am hesitant to try and "encourage" it to look for a discovery more than I already have, since the whole point is we often don't know when there is a discovery to be made. It is inherent curiosity and willingness to break away from field norms that leads to these things. I am preparing a new experiment based on one of my other papers (this one with actual observation data that I will give to GPT)--if you have some ideas, please let me know, I will incorporate!


r/astrophysics • • Aug 22 '26

how valid is the theory of the big bang being a white hole

0 Upvotes

so this has probably been asked before, but what is exactly wrong with the hypothesis of the universe just being a constant cycle of black holes and white holes.

in the plane of space, a supermassive blackhole consuming all matter(the big crunch) and it then being ejected out of a white hole into the same plane of space(the big bang) thus forming a cycle of the universe in its given plane of space. what would the limitations of this theory be(other than white holes being hypothetical as of now)? please enlighten me


r/astrophysics • • Sep 08 '26

Help please I have a question

0 Upvotes

Did a star recently go supernova?
I was just sitting near a window when a flash of red blinked and flashed the room for a blink of an eye, when I turned to see what it was nothing was there.

Any idea as to what it could have been?


r/astrophysics • • Jan 07 '25

Could copies of us exist right now on another planet exactly like Earth?

1 Upvotes

If there are other solar systems just like ours, with a planet exactly like Earth, in every single way (or atleast VERY close to).

I don't care how likely it is, i'm only wondering if it is THEORETICALLY possible that copies of us exist out there on "another Earth"? Or could there be some kind of unknown law that prevents this from being possible? I'm a newbie to all this so i apologize if my question is stupid.


r/astrophysics • • Apr 23 '25

approaching the "BEFORE" the big bang problem

0 Upvotes

time itself as a we describe it came into existence after the big bang but I'm pretty sure this is not a satisfactory answer to most. Now I'm not asking what in your opinion happnd before it, I just want to know how would you approach the problem of finding out what happened before it??


r/astrophysics • • Sep 15 '25

Can we finally agree Time Travel is impossible? Especially into the past? I mean theoretically, maybe? But realistically?

0 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • Aug 06 '25

What if the speed of light were 100 times faster?

4 Upvotes

It's nice to let one's imagination run wild about the potential possibility of traveling to the nearest stars in a more decent time. However, if the speed of light were 100 times greater, could matter, stars, planets, and we humans still exist in such a universe?


r/astrophysics • • May 10 '26

Was gab es vor dem Urknall?

0 Upvotes

Vielleicht eine ganz blöde Frage, aber was war vor dem Urknall da?
Bin nicht so in der Materie, aber das hab ich mich schon immer gefragt. Alles im Universum besteht ja aus irgendwas, selbst die Sachen im Weltall.
Also muss es doch auch vor dem Urknall irgendwas gegeben haben?

Vielleicht begreife ich das alles nicht so und jemand kann mich aufklären, aber irgendwas muss doch existiert haben?


r/astrophysics • • Dec 03 '24

Gravastars: Or why Kurzgesagt makes me want to call in Matt O'Dowd.

0 Upvotes

I just saw today's Kurzgesagt video on Gravastars: https://youtu.be/BmUZ2wp1lM8

I have questions. Where is Dr. O'Dowd?

All of the questions aside as to if either and or both of black holes or gravastars exist, my brain immediately starts down the tangent of white holes. They should exist, but... is the interior of a gravastar just a white hole?

And if not, which is likely not, if gravastars do exist, which is a big if, what is the interior of a gravastar? If it really does contain a very large amount of energy, why wouldn't it do something? Why wouldn't there be a microcosm of activity?


r/astrophysics • • Dec 22 '24

How are galaxies able to attract other galaxies Gravitationally?

0 Upvotes

Even if Milky Way is made up of a Hundred Billion Stars, would not the warping of spacetime created by those stars just end right at the borders of Milky way ? Considering the individual stars, both within and at the edges of Milky way could warp spacetime to a dozen of light years around them or so Individually ?

So how is Milky way on a whole able to create a spacetime warp big enough to attract Magellanic clouds (or Virgo Cluster able to attract other clusters at larger scales, etc). How does local warping by of individual stars add up into a giant Warping by a Galaxy ? Or do the stars within Milky Way create their own spacetime Warp and then also somehow contribute collectively into a larger warp at the galactic scales ?


r/astrophysics • • May 22 '26

The beginning of the universe

0 Upvotes

Every time I hear someone explain a black hole, it makes me think of the beginning of the universe, and in turn, a white hole(inverse black hole).

According to current theories, black holes rip everything apart and white holes spit out the “goop” or the result of such actions.

The Big Bang is the “explosion” of everything fundamental that created our universe, the expansion of the young universe. This sounds exactly like a white hole to me.

Not only this, but quantum mechanics also breaks down inside a black hole and time reacts completely differently. A big bang would have weird time properties as time is connected to gravity and both would’ve been very strange at the moment of the Big Bang.

So my question is, what is stopping physicists from exploring this theory? I’ve heard a few people explore the idea that the universe is inside a black hole but it’s never truly brought up in the mainstream and explored in a serious way.


r/astrophysics • • Jan 25 '14

Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes'

Thumbnail
nature.com
2 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • Nov 18 '25

Humanity becoming a multiplanetary species

0 Upvotes

I think for humans to colonize another planet, Mars and making humanity an interstellar civilization is the most important thing for humanity. We will no longer just be animals with neat inventions. We'll be a society of the cosmos.


r/astrophysics • • Mar 08 '19

Neil Degrasse Tyson Comment if you got it....... :)

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • Mar 25 '25

if everything is relative, are we sure that earth isnt travelling at speed of light or close to it?

1 Upvotes

farthest galaxies seem to be travelling ftl


r/astrophysics • • Jun 23 '25

Big bang and Quasars

0 Upvotes

Is there any body of opinion suggesting that the Big Bang came about via a series of quasar like events.

The singularity existence suggest to me so many questions as to why it would just neatly occur, reverse entropy etc. Could the `big bang event` instead, be a series of quasar events?


r/astrophysics • • May 19 '26

Questions about the Universe ^.^

6 Upvotes

Since we have these huge telescopes and can look back in time even see the cosmic background radiation why don’t we see where the universe started?

Any explosion has a center. Even atomic bombs in space expand outward in a sphere. So why do scientists say the universe is “flat”?

Is it flat like a sheet (---) but so enormous that it looks round to us because we can see stars in every direction out to about 13 billion light years away?

And also, any explosion fades at the edges — there’s usually less material at the outer edge than near the center. Couldn’t we just find where matter is densest and assume that’s the center of the universe?

Imagine you were inside an atomic bomb explosion in space about one minute after it exploded. If you looked around, you could probably tell where the explosion started, because the center would still be hotter and denser than the outer regions. The explosion would look spherical, not flat.

And then there’s the question that seems to make astrophysicists mad:
what is the universe expanding into?

If the singularity started somewhere, then wasn’t there already something outside it? Or not?

I don’t understand why scientists don’t try harder to solve or explain this.

Would an extremely powerful telescope for example, one placed on the dark side of the Moon be able to look back so far that it eventually sees just nothing?

And have we already observed stars or galaxies at the edge of the observable universe fading away because they moved so far that their light can no longer reach us?

Shouldn’t this be happening constantly in deep field images? Could a long series of deep space images, like a GIF over time, eventually show a galaxy disappearing?


r/astrophysics • • May 30 '25

Books on black holes containing universes?

0 Upvotes

I'm interested in the topic of black holes containing universes. I'm an engineer and physics/mathematics enthusiast, but not a trained physicist, so I'm looking for more than a popular science book but maybe less than an academic paper.

Any recommendations on books or literature on this topic?


r/astrophysics • • Dec 21 '14

String theory?

0 Upvotes

Astrophysicists were stumped a few years ago by a light that appeared at a certain point in our Universe, grew to a certain size and brightness before gradually fading to 'nothing'. I believe the light may have been from a 'white hole', or a massive star dying, forming a black hole from within another universe/dimension and releasing its contents into our own. This, in my comparatively small, high school-educated mind, would also explain dark matter 'clumps' surrounding galaxies. Might these gravitational 'clumps', discovered by 'gravitational lensing', possibly reflect the gravity from the gigantic collapsing star and matter that had fallen through to create the super-massive black hole at the center of the galaxy? I'm thinking the force of the collapsing star forced open one or more additional dimensions from the heretofore 'curled up' extra dimensions like a balloon. Also, I understand that gravity is the only detectable force common to all dimensions in 'string theory' and it leads me to believe that our 'Big Bang' might have been a collapsing star from another universe/dimension, or white hole. It makes sense, then, to believe that our universe is being continually 'fed' by other universes, via black hole/white holes, within the grander multi-verse and this would also, by definition, describe the accelerating expansion of our universe. One great thing about my ignorant questions is that I don't have to worry about scathing peer review and can, therefore, spout anything I want. But, does any of this have a place in theory, or can string theory be ruled out?


r/astrophysics • • Dec 29 '24

If voyager1 suddenly started speeding up by 20mkph over the course of 3 months what would that tell us ?

0 Upvotes

r/astrophysics • • Nov 01 '25

Equal Opposite Big Bang

0 Upvotes

I had a shower thought and if you can, let me know if I’m running on nothing.

So, we don’t know what there was before the big bang. We don’t even know what we don’t know about things prior to the big bang.

The big bang was the largest reaction in history because it exploded and brought literally everything. Every action have an equal, opposite reaction, so, what was the equal opposite reaction of the big bang?

Or, is the big bang the equal opposite reaction of something else?

I dunno if that made sense.


r/astrophysics • • Mar 25 '26

How can a black hole gain mass if the crossing event horizon requires the observer falling in to experience time dilation such that they'd witness everything outside the black hole go by?

1 Upvotes

Sorry I couldn't find a way to concisely explain what I mean in the title. Let's say that I'm in a rocketship headed towards a black hole, as I get closer and closer to the black hole time slows for me more and more and from my perspective the rest of the universe is speeding up, until all of the future happens. However, wouldn't this include the evaporation of the black hole im falling into? So before I fall in, that is, before the mass of my body and my rocketship can be added to the black hole, it will have evaporated. But black holes can get more massive. How is this?


r/astrophysics • • Oct 21 '22

Crazy theory about the universe

2 Upvotes

So I've always thought that limiting our understanding of the universe to what we can see is silly. Let me explain: just because light cannot be detected, doesn't mean that nothing is there. It just means that the light hasn't gotten to us yet. So it's possible for there to be mass outside of what we can see that is actually affecting the matter we can see. This is kind of what I think is causing the expansion and acceleration of the universe: matter that is all around our visible universe, but isn't visible to us because it's too far away to detect. Feel free to poke holes, as I actually would love to stop thinking about this. It's like stuck in my head and needs confirmation, or rejection with actual facts. 🤷

I'm editing this post because it occurred to me that people may not read all of my replies that flesh out my hypothesis, so I'll post them here as best as I can.

I was thinking that there could be many many black holes that surrounds our observable universe. When the other black holes around pull on the smallest in the group, to the point where it's internal gravity is overcome by the external pull from all the others, it explodes. This explosion is the big bang.

There would be infinite other black holes. Not just a sphere around ours. I was under the assumption that gravity affects every other object no matter how far away they are. If our observable universe was the smallest black hole (I guess we could look at it like our observable universe is the highest point in the overall universe) I was thinking this would cause the black hole, that is now our current observable universe, to revert back into elementary particles as it's ripped apart by all the other larger black holes that surround it. Inevitably a new "highest point" would emerge after our universe adds its mass to the closest black holes and the process would repeat.

What I'm suggesting is that all the matter outside of our observable universe is contained in black holes. They could exist for eternity and never emit light. which would give any amount of time that's required for the gravity to reach and affect us.


r/astrophysics • • Nov 07 '25

A new equation may explain the Universe without dark matter | ScienceDaily

Thumbnail share.google
0 Upvotes

I'd really really like to get some opinions on this idea as it approaches one I'd previously tried to explain here without sufficient vocabulary or mathematics.