r/asoiafreread • • Aug 04 '14

Community Will there be Dunk & Egg etc. spoilers?

0 Upvotes

Hi looking forward to this reread but I haven't read the novellas yet (I'm waiting until they get published together). Do you reckon there will be many spoilers for these floating around?


r/asoiafreread • • May 26 '14

Community A Kingdom of the North, Riverlands and the Vale ruled by a Stark?

0 Upvotes

(Spoilers AFFC)

So, this is something that I've seen a lot. The idea that the Starks will come back (I believe they will) and that all of the Lords from these three Regions will declare them King or Queen of a united Kingdom ruled from Winterfell. It makes sense that the Riverlords and the Northernlords would do this, but why the Vale?

  1. The original reason that the North seceded is that they didn't want to be ruled by Southrons who didn't know their ways. Fair enough, but what do they know of the ways of the Vale? They're completely different culturally. The North is full of First Men. The Vale is the purest line of Andal nobles. The Northerners worships the Old Gods. The Valemen are fervent worshipers of the Seven.

  2. The Riverlords declared a Stark their King. Why wouldn't the Vale? Well, the Tullys have never been Kings and the Riverlands haven't had their own Kings in at least 1000 years IIRC. In comparison, the Vale has been ruled by an Arryn King for 6000 years. If they're going to declare any non Baratheon/Targaryen King, why would it be a Stark instead of an Arryn? Furthermore, the Riverlords declared Robb their King because he saved them. In contrast, the Starks would be drawing the Vale into their war.

  3. Ned had a lot of friends in the Vale.

It's true that Ned had a lot of friends in the Vale. However, so did Robert and if we're being honest, Robert probably had more friends.

4) Sansa and LF will kill off SR so she can claim the Vale by marrying Harry.

Well, first of all I don't think this marriage is going to happen. But even if it did, Harry would have the power. Not Sansa. Furthermore, if they do kill SR and the Valelords find out they'd likely execute both of them for it.

5) The Vale is richer and has a military that's at least equal if not greater than the Norths (uncluding their own fleat). Why should they be ruled by their inferiors?

So, can someone tell me why the Vale will bend the knee to a Stark.


r/asoiafreread • • Aug 03 '14

Community Are the mods gonna add TWOW on to the end ReRead #2?

4 Upvotes

Assuming it's out by October 2016. I want to believe


r/asoiafreread • • Aug 05 '14

Community Help/thoughts on re-reading on smartphone/tablet device?

2 Upvotes

TL;DR: Having problems going through a re-read, discussing possibility of smartphone/tablet software helping.

Hi! This subreddit is fairly new to me, but I've searched - to my best abilities - for a thread already covering this subject. I didn't really find what I was looking for, so hopefully you guys can help me.

I'm having BIG attention issues reading this series. Often I find myself not having read for a couple of months and when I pick a book back up, I can't remember what happened last time. I find it difficult to keep track of characters, storylines, history of houses, legends, pretty much everything (I know I'm not the only one with these issues, bear with me).

Now, I've considered a separate notepad to keep track of every character, what they are doing and their relation to every other character (with personal opinions), but that would really make reading ASOIAF even MORE of a big deal for me. Even those colored stickers for every POV character, that crossed my mind too, but I figured I could solve this with technology.

So I bought the books on the Google Play Books app on my Android, and it worked pretty well. Insanely comfortable, if a little less cozy, always have it with me etc.

But I want to try and maximize the use of this for my issue above. I still have huge gaps between reading sessions, and the chapters names doen't really tell which POV character is being portrayed, the maps are not as easy to access as I would like, for instance. There has to be a better way to re-read this epic in this day and age.

Questions:

  • Has anyone read/re-read ASOIAF on a phone or tablet, and how did that work out? Pros, cons?

  • Does anyone know of an e-book app that could be more useful for me than the standard Google app? Why?

  • There is probably already threads about this, but if anyone has any general reading tips for someone with my problem, that is also welcome.

Basically, I want to start a new re-read, a real proper one, and I want to get as deeply involved as I possibly can. Thanks a lot!

Edit: Some formatting and whatnot.


r/asoiafreread • • Aug 11 '14

Community (no spoilers) Is it possible to post the new chapter thread 3-4 hours earlier?

5 Upvotes

It's all in the title, really. I know we won't be able to find the best time that works for everyone everywhere perfectly, but I was hoping to get a sense of how many of us are noticing the thread timing, and what the people of this (probably) minority might prefer.


r/asoiafreread • • Mar 09 '15

Community Help Get WesterosCraft to the Rooster Teeth Gaming Convention!

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone! After contacting your subreddit moderators, I was graciously given permission to share our fundraising efforts with you!

I help run WesterosCraft, a project that is recreating the entire continent of Westeros in minecraft. We are a part of the GRRM network on reddit; you may have also seen some of our stuff on reddit. I post this thread to request support in our effort to get WesterosCraft a booth at the upcoming Rooster Teeth Convention in Austin, Texas. We are not heirs to the gold of Casterly Rock and we can't afford the Iron Price, so we have set up an Indiegogo page to gain your support for the booth. Anyway, the page does a better job of explaining (complete with a quick narrated video explaining our project and fundraising efforts). If you can't donate, sharing this wherever you see fit is equally helpful. Any support provided is thoroughly appreciated!

IndieGoGo page

Website

/r/WesterosCraft

Thank you for reading!


r/asoiafreread • • Jul 12 '14

Community Does anyone else think the re-read will take too long?

7 Upvotes

ADWD is scheduled to end in October of 2016. That's 2 years from now.
Could we the chapters from one every 2-3 days to one every day.
That way the books would only take a month instead of 4 months.


r/asoiafreread • • Jul 15 '15

Community (No Spoilers) Have you ever wanted to live the Westerosi life?

16 Upvotes

Been feeling deprived of action since that cliff hanger on Game of Thrones last week? Still waiting for The Winds of Winter? Out of art ideas? If you answered yes to any of those questions why not join /r/westerosrp ?

This subreddit is a group role play based approximately 100 years after the events of A Song of Ice and Fire. Here you can create a character and tell their story in a group (or solitary if you prefer) environment. You can be a man sworn to change the nightswatch to even a member of the royal family - the opportunities are endless. This is a subreddit that fosters growth and development of writing skills, medieval/feudal/political knowledge and friendship. So come on down to the brand new, shiny /r/westerosrp We’d be honoured to have you!


r/asoiafreread • • Jul 02 '14

Community (Spoilers All) Reddit Meetups and Google Hangouts: ASOIAF In-Person Book Clubs

10 Upvotes

Hey all,

You may have seen the announcement in the sticky, but here it is again for those who didn't catch it:

Introducing /r/abcoiaf, A Book Club of Ice and Fire.

Like /r/asoiafreread, /r/abcoiaf is dedicated to rereading the series while providing a venue for people to discuss it in-person.

Currently, there are two formats for doing book clubs:

  • Meetups: Like Reddit meetups, we'd get together weekly and discuss the books.

  • Hangouts: Book clubs conducted through Google Hangouts (or whatever video conference service you want to use) for people who aren't necessarily in a densely populated area.

Right now, I'm trying to get a group together for the DC-MD-VA area.

I'd ideally like to get a group together that follows the cycle over at /r/asoiafreread via Google Hangouts at some point, hopefully within the next week since I love the novellas.

I know that all sounds pretty confusing, so if you have any questions about how it will (hopefully) all work, post them here!

edit// Just to clarify, I wanted to say that I have received permission to make this post in this subreddit and I'm not trying to spam it up.


r/asoiafreread • • Aug 18 '14

Community Speed read ASOIAF with "Spritz"!

0 Upvotes

I'm using my iPhone 4s and the "ReadMe!" App, which uses Spritz, to speed-read the ASOIAF series. I downloaded an ePub version of the series and was able to add it to my "ReadMe!" Library. The app has a bit of improvements to do but when I read at 700wpm, I can't really complain. Each chapter at this pace is 3-6 minutes, depending on length. It's fantastic!


r/asoiafreread • • Jun 24 '13

Community [X-post /r/gameofthrones] Game of Thrones Exchange at Redditgifts Starts Today!

0 Upvotes

r/asoiafreread • • Aug 24 '16

Community How are you reading A Feast For Dragons?

10 Upvotes

I'm late to the reread and just got up to A Feast For Dragons. Just wondering how people are reading it. Are you jumping from each physical books to the other or is there a edited PDF version you're reading?


r/asoiafreread • • Aug 04 '14

Community Could we get a roll call of who is in on this re-read?

16 Upvotes

Just curious how many people are joining in on the re-read.


r/asoiafreread • • Oct 25 '12

Community [recommendation] At significant chapters, include an episode of Game of Thrones to watch and discuss

5 Upvotes

I understand that this is about the books, but it might be enjoyable to include an episode from the TV show after a certain number of chapters covers the episode in question. Obviously, episode one of Season 2 will be coming up, so perhaps right now submit the last episode of Season 1 for discussion.

When this reread repeats itself, we should have 3 seasons to rewatch along with the reread by that time.


r/asoiafreread • • Apr 06 '15

Community [No Spoilers] /r/PureAsoiaf: We Do Not Show

30 Upvotes

This post was pre-approved by the moderators of /r/asoiafreread through the GRRM Network

As the massively popular HBO series Game of Thrones nears the premiere of its fifth season, we would like to spread awareness of another, more narrowly focused subreddit: /r/PureAsoiaf.

With the new episodes airing, discussion of television show content will be popping up more often and in wider circles than it has in previous months. The difference this time, is that the new episodes are increasingly likely to contain unreleased content from future novels. We acknowledge that there is a huge range of fans, some of whom wish to discuss the show and the books separately. We also know that there are many fans who will temporarily abstain from watching the show, for fear of TWOW spoilers.

Whether you are watching this season or not, we would love to have you participate over at /r/PureAsoiaf. The golden rule is simply no TV show discussion. Come share your love of the books with us!

We welcome new readers and veterans alike. Links to our Discussion Policy and Spoiler Policy

Respectfully,

The /r/PureAsoiaf Mod Team


r/asoiafreread • • Jul 30 '25

Update

32 Upvotes

We’ve had minimal interest in aCoK, so I'm scrapping the re-read. Apathy seems to have set in amongst the fandom; I’d encourage all of you to take this time to read other books.

If you haven’t read LotR, read it: it is worth it.

The Dune Saga will scratch that itch for well-built worlds and reasonable consequences.

Guns, Germs, and Steel by Jared Diamond is a non-fiction read that is ideal for contemporary fiction and world-building.


r/asoiafreread • • Aug 06 '14

Plea to artists re: (spoilers) The Princess and the Queen

0 Upvotes

please give me an image of Warrick Wheaton. Keep in mind, should anyone google it, yours will come up first since gis produces nothing.


r/asoiafreread • • Apr 15 '12

Community Regarding the T.V. Series...

6 Upvotes

I think we can all agree that Game Of Thrones on HBO is a great show. I for one would not have started reading these books if it hadn't been for the show. Personally I enjoyed starting the books after seeing the show because I could see Winterfell and King's Landing in my head more vividly, and got to have a face and voice for all the characters. The actors, the settings, the costumes and makeup, everything really brings the show to life in a great way. I really don't have enough good things to say about it.

|

However, this community is not about the television series. This is about the books, and anyone who has read them knows that as great of an adaptation as Game Of Thrones is, it is not really A Song of Ice and Fire. Because of this, I would like to see as little discussion about the show as possible. There are other reddits for that. This is not a blanket rule; there is room for some discussion, but especially on matters where the two media differ, please keep it to a minimum. The book series is canon. The T.V. series is not.

|

TL;DR: Don't talk about the show.


r/asoiafreread • • Jul 15 '12

Community Concerning Season 3...

9 Upvotes

So Season 3 is set to premiere on March 31st and will probably end on June 2, by which time we'll be 34 chapters into Storm of Swords, which is just about, wouldn't you know, half the book, roughly the amount of material that the show is covering.

I mention this because, even though this re-read doesn't take into account the tv show's plot, I think it'd be silly to assume we aren't going to be talking about the show to some extent with these chapter discussions.

Do you think it'd be wise to take this into account and revise the reading schedule to be more in-tune with the show? Perhaps delay the reading of Storm of Swords until the premiere, and then read up until the (approximate) same point in the show?

This isn't a big deal, just thought it was an interesting thought, wanted to know if other people had any opinions on the matter.


r/asoiafreread • • Oct 25 '12

Community Has anyone immediately began a reread after finishing the first time?

9 Upvotes

I just finished for the first time. I'm seriously considering starting again... Just afraid I might burn out. I took a while to read the series. Took breaks in between books, etc.

What's the recommended break time before restarting?


r/asoiafreread • • Sep 24 '14

Community Community Question

10 Upvotes

Hi All!

I remember when we started there was a question about whether discussions could be posted earlier since not an insignificant amount of community members are on Eastern time. At the time we mods were very hesitant to "give up" the Previous-POV, Next-POV, Previous-chapter, Next-chapter navigations within self.post body--but holding on to this preference may be doing a disservice to everyone waiting to post to the group discussions.

We're in the process of setting up Automoderator to put up the regularly scheduled posts, but before the work gets put in, there are two questions we'd like to pose to everyone:

  1. Do you want automated discussion posts?

  2. If so, what would be the best time to have the posts go up? For example, 12 AM PST (UTC-08) = 3 AM EST (UTC-03) = 7AM UTC+0

If we move forward with Automoderator, we will replace the previous/next navigation with a link to the wiki page listing all of the archived discussion posts.

The decision will be made on a simple majority vote. And of course, any other suggestions are welcome.

Regards,

Angrybiologist & Co.


r/asoiafreread • • Jul 29 '13

Sansa [Spoilers All] Re-readers' discussion: aSoS Sansa IV

11 Upvotes

A Storm of Swords - Chapter 59

Starting on page:

659799659BG 239504072406
US hardcoverUS paperbackUK hardcoverUK paperbackKindle BundleePUB

.

Previous and Upcoming Discussions Navigation

Sansa III
Tyrion VIISansa IVTyrion VIII
Sansa V

r/asoiafreread • • Dec 08 '15

Community New guy here!

12 Upvotes

I' just curious, I noticed that you guys have done the reread twice I believe. Wondering if this is something that will just continuously happen. Like once your done with Dance with Dragons are you going to go back to GoT and do it all over again?


r/asoiafreread • • Oct 18 '14

Community Does this community have a plan for The World of Ice and Fire?

14 Upvotes

Mods, perhaps when it comes out you can make a post for discussion?


r/asoiafreread • • Oct 30 '15

Community If TWOW is released in say April, would people be interested in accelerating the re-read?

27 Upvotes

We have 150 chapters left, at 3 a week we will finish this time next year, at 5 per week (weekdays) we will finish in mid-June and at 7 per week/every day we would finish in mid-April.

I know that the current MO is to take a break from the re-read, read TWOW and then pick the re-read back up (tacking on TWOW at the end?) but I'm just curious what people's feelings are...