r/asoiaf • • 1m ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Ned must have some ambitions before his life took an unexpected turn, right?

1 Upvotes

Does Ned Stark have any ambitions at all? Like hints of it? I’m talking about pre-Rebellion Ned back when his family were alive? Since he was never gonna be Lord of Winterfell, did Ned had dreams to make a name for himself? Maybe work as a knight for Jon Arryn or Robert Baratheon? Join the NW? Find love? Find glory? I guess we never know becuaze his life turn out differently.

Still post-Rebellion Ned lacked any ambition, nor did he desire power or glory even if he could claim it.

I don’t know if Ned would be okay with living in his brother’s shadow but he not the resentful type.

And despite what the play said I’m certain Ned must have some goals in life or his father had plans for him.

His siblings and children does but Ned…

Or is he really that non-ambitious?


r/asoiaf • • 1h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers extended) What really happened to TWOW in 2017?

26 Upvotes

I know this is a topic that has been discussed countless times, but there’s one thing I still can’t wrap my head around, and I’d like to hear your take on it: how is it physically possible that, back in 2017, George R.R. Martin believed it was likely The Winds of Winter would be released by the end of that year? Given that, as of 2022, he was still hundreds of pages short (around 400–500), how could he have thought he was so close to publication in 2017? Did he just provide an overly optimistic estimate or decide to change direction while writing, and therefore have to remove or revise some things?or was he just lying?


r/asoiaf • • 1h ago

EXTENDED Sweetrobin UNDERMINES the Ashford theory (spoilers extended)

10 Upvotes

For those unfamiliar, the Ashford theory is the idea that the five champions (Baratheon, Tyrell, Lannister, Hardying, Targaryen) foreshadow Sansa's betrothals/marriages. Except it all falls apart when one remembers that Sweetrobin should be included. Lysa explicitly said that Sansa would be married off to Robert after Tyrion was executed.

For those who say that it wasn't a real betrothal well neither was the one to Willas. That was just a scheme by the Tyrells, Sansa was never officially engaged to Willas. Yet supporters of this theory still consider it official. And if you consider the Tyrell betrothal official then you should see the Arryn betrothal the same.


r/asoiaf • • 2h ago

PUBLISHED (Spoilers Published) Sandor Clegane can stop being the Hound. The Hound apparently can't stop existing.

8 Upvotes

Something about the Hound's helmet has been bothering me on this reread, and it's how little Sandor himself actually matters to the reputation attached to it.

Think about the journey that ridiculous dog-shaped piece of metal takes.

Sandor wears it while serving the Lannisters. He earns a genuinely frightening reputation, some of it deserved. He's done terrible things, he's killed people, and he deliberately presents himself as someone nobody should mess with.

Then he leaves King's Landing, travels with Arya, gets badly wounded, and eventually disappears from the story.

The Elder Brother tells Brienne that the Hound is dead. He describes burying him and leaving his helmet on the grave.

If the gravedigger theory is correct, this is actually a pretty remarkable moment. Sandor has finally found a place where he might be able to exist without being the Hound.

Except the helmet doesn't stay buried.

Rorge takes it.

And suddenly the Hound is back, committing atrocities at Saltpans.

From the perspective of practically everyone in the Riverlands, this makes perfect sense. Sandor Clegane was already a notorious killer. People see a large, terrifying man wearing his distinctive helmet, hear about the slaughter, and naturally assume the Hound has become even worse.

Why wouldn't they?

We know Rorge is responsible because we have access to information the characters don't.

But imagine being one of the survivors of Saltpans. As far as you're concerned, Sandor Clegane is the monster who destroyed your town.

Then Brienne kills Rorge.

Surely that's the end of it?

Nope.

Lem Lemoncloak picks up the helmet and puts it on.

Now the man wearing the Hound's face belongs to the Brotherhood Without Banners, an organisation that originally existed to protect the very people who were being terrorised by men like Rorge.

And Thoros is clearly unhappy about Lem wearing it.

I find this much more interesting than the usual question of whether the helmet somehow corrupts its wearers.

I don't think it needs to.

The helmet already has a reputation. Whoever puts it on inherits the fear associated with Sandor Clegane, along with all the crimes committed by the previous man wearing it.

Meanwhile the real Sandor, assuming he's the gravedigger, could spend the rest of his life quietly digging graves and never hurt another person.

It wouldn't change what people believe he did at Saltpans.

He could genuinely become a better man, and the world might continue remembering him as a monster who only became more monstrous.

Which is particularly cruel given how much of Sandor's character revolves around the difference between what someone is called and what they actually are.

He hates knights because the title doesn't make a man honourable. His brother is a knight. Plenty of supposedly noble men are monsters.

And now his own identity has become a costume that actual monsters can put on.

The really interesting question to me is whether Sandor could ever reclaim his name without also reclaiming the Hound.

Suppose he eventually leaves the Quiet Isle. Suppose he does something genuinely heroic.

How many people would believe it was the same man who supposedly butchered Saltpans?

And even if he managed to prove that Rorge was responsible, would that matter to anyone who'd already spent months believing the story?

I'm not convinced Sandor's real challenge is going to be defeating his brother or even learning to live without violence.

It might be accepting that he has no control over what the world thinks the Hound is.

Do you think Martin is setting up a confrontation between Sandor and the identity that's continued existing without him? Or is the whole point that Sandor can find peace only by letting that identity belong to somebody else?


r/asoiaf • • 6h ago

PUBLISHED [Spoilers PUBLISHED] Re-reading: Tyrions tenure as hand is Terry Pratchett comedy

26 Upvotes

Tyrions misrule and undermining Lannister power at court+killing tywin and inadvertibly getting Joff killed made is insane to read about. It also sets up Cersei to fail to cling on to power while protecting the incest secret (i.e. turning to Kevan or even Jaime).

Just looking at the list of Lannister men Tyrion wiped out:

Kills Allar Deem.

Exiles Janos Slynt.

Killed Tywin.

Got Joffrey killed, by bringing in the Tyrells with no plan of how to share power.

Got the Mountain killed by telling Red Viper he murdered Elia.

Got the High septon killed in the food riots started when Tyrion orders the court thru the streets in a parade. At least Joffrey knew to close the portcullis when the mob came around.

Got Tyrek Lannister killed in the same food riots.

Got Aron Santagar killed in the same food riots.

Got Willem Lannister killed by refusing to exchange hostages with him.

The Kingsguard is massacred under Tyrion: Preston Greenfield in the food riots, Mandon Moore by Pod, Aerys Oakheart killed in Dorne where Tyrion sent him, Blunt is atagonized by Tyrion, Balon Swanns defects to Myrcellas Dornish handlers.

Sends all 100 Redcloaks to Riverrun to their death in zany plot to free Jaime. This opens the door for Kettleblacks in Red Keep.

Antagonizes the merchant class and makes them become antlered men (for stannis).

Tyrion blunders thru the Small Council:
-alienates Varys and Littlefinger by betraying them in the 'tell each a different story' chapter and is shocked when they betray him.
-Littlefinger sends Mandon Moore to kill Tyrion afterwards.
-Imprisons Pycelle, who testifies against him in trial.

Tyrions treatment of the royal family is even worse:
-Sends Myrcella to Dorne where she is almost killed (as predicted by Cersei).
-Kidnaps Tommen from Rosby and threatens to rape him.
-Beats up Joffrey twice.
-He poisons Cercei to gain power as regent for a day.

Tyrion makes the Hound desert by ordering him into the flames outside Kings Landing.

Tyrion also steals Cerseis idea of using the Wildfire vs Stannis. But he ends up burning most of the royal fleet up.

All the while Tyrion is patting his own back and drinking wine.

Cant believe people read Clash of Kings and doesnt laugh at how incredibly useless Tyrion is.

The only persons Tyrion does treat nice are Bronn, the sellsword who refuses to fight for him unless paid, and the whore who betrays him first thing.

The only thing he actually does get right is the Chain, which he is actually complemented on in universe by the Tyrells, Tywin and the Stannis faction.

Is the entire Tyrion saga as Hand ment to be read as satire or Terry Pratchet style comedy?


r/asoiaf • • 6h ago

EXTENDED [Spoilers Extended] How does the storyline in the north get concluded

6 Upvotes

Just like the title says I want to find out what people thing the storyline of the North plays out in Winds, because the importance of the north is obvious and I find it interesting that its trajectory is vastly different to how things are playing out in the south; while the south is still experiencing death and war, the north on the other hand is replenishing its forces - the wilding force made of 30-40k able warriors added on with the +/- 200 giants, house Manderley's galleys etc., who do you think is the biggest winner and losers after everything is concluded.

Things to consider:

  • Robbs succession

How does Robb's will carry in light of Rickons revelation. Is a will written in ignorance of the truth carry more weight then traditional succession laws? Does GRRM avoid this bottleneck by killing Rickon before he is known to be alive or does Rickon throw a spanner in the whole succession of the kingdom of the north and the riverlands? We already know that Sansa was explicitly disinherited but what about Rickon or Bran who were believed to be dead? Does succession laws carry weight in light of explicit naming of a successor? Is this `The Dance of Wolves?`

  • Jons parentage

If it does come to light that Jon is not the son of Ned how is his succession perceived? The whole premise of him being a successor to Robb is based on him being the son of Ned, the beloved lord of the the North/Winterfell and if he is actually not the son of Ned, does the north perceive him as a foreign ruler here to take over their region?

  • Winterfell

Who becomes lord of Winterfell? We know that Jojen had a green dream that there will be a Stark in Winterfell; but can there be a Stark in Winterfell and not be king/lord at the same time? We know that Jon does not fit the criteria of "a `Stark` that must always be in Winterfell" - Winterfell will most likely reject him like it did Theon. Say Jon becomes king in the north, can he rule the north from the Dreadfort? Or from the gift? Will the northern bannermen reject this because of custom or tradition even though he might arguably bring a great host with him in the form of giants and freefolks? (I watched Preston Jacobs video on the `Schemes of the Halfhand` and he makes total sense - Jon is being setup as the king of the freefolk through Bael so the wildings and giants are basically his army/force)

Notable mentions:

  1. Stannis - Stannis' presence is a thorn to the story. His removal is likely as he stands in the way of a lot of the story's progress. His presence hinders Jon's blossoming as a king as Stannis demands homage and rule. Does his victory in the battle of ice (which I don't believe will happen - the pink letter is true) make him a part of Dance of Dragons 2.0 since he has a bit of dragons blood or does he meet his end beyond the wall or while battling Aegon and his southern allies?

  2. Sansa and the Vale - Do Sansa and Littlefinger have a role to play in the northern story or does GRRM goes ahead with killing her? (it would simplify the story) Her marriage to Tyrion blocked her out of Robbs inheritance so does she team up with Littlefinger and scheme to take Winterfell and kick out her `bastard brother`? Does the terrible winter coming make the North dependant on the Vale for food to the point that their influence - through Littlefinger - usurp Jon?

  3. Osha Greyjoy - we know that the Iron Islands has been left unmanned since the whole host is waging war in the 7 kingdoms, does this help Osha usurp her nuncle as queen with the help of the north in return for homage and possibly lord of ships of the northern kingdom with the Manderly galleys? Or does she burn?

  4. Lyseni ships - the Lyseni slavers are planning a voyage to Hardhome to capture fresh slaves which I expect are gonna be pirated by Eastwatch and Salladhor Saan and used to transport the wildings south of wall and possibly add to the north's fleet and army. So expect 30+ galleys from Manderley as well as about +/- 40 trader ships from Lys added to the Northern fleet. I also see Saan as a possible captain of one of the fleets - he deserves recompense after the bust that was Stannis' campaign

tl;dr How does the story of the north come together in light of robbs will, rickon being alive, jon being the son of lyana, jon having the biggest force in the north (freefolk/giants), stannis constant presence, sansa and littlefinger conspiracies to take back winterfell through using the Vale as a bread basket, osha greyjoy possibly adding the iron islands as bannermen to the north and who ultimately rules winterfell. do you need to rule winterfell to be king or does the status as king count more then the castle? who are the winners and losers - besides the eradication of house Bolton


r/asoiaf • • 6h ago

[Spoilers PUBLISHED] Why is Craster sacrificing sheeps to the "Cold Gods"? Spoiler

25 Upvotes

We all assume the Others take Craster's newborn sons to turn them into more Others (largely because the TV show explicitly showed that).

But if you look strictly at what is written in the books, there is a glaring plot hole in that assumption: Craster doesn't just give them boys. When he runs out of sons, he gives them sheep and when he runs out of sheep, he gives them dogs.

In ASOS (Samwell II), Craster’s wives explain this directly to Sam. Stop and think about that for a second: What would ethereal, ice-armored Others who don't eat warm-blooded flesh possibly want with domesticated sheep and dogs? Are they making "White Walker sheep"?

When you look closer at the exact wording GRRM uses across the books, four weird details line up:

  1. The Whitetree "Sheep" Clue:

    • Right before reaching Craster's Keep, Jon Snow inspects the massive weirwood at Whitetree: It was the biggest tree Jon Snow had ever seen, the trunk near eight feet wide, the branches spreading so far that the entire village was shaded beneath their canopy. The size did not disturb him so much as the face . . . the mouth especially, no simple carved slash, but a jagged hollow large enough to swallow a sheep. Those are not sheep bones, though. Nor is that a sheep’s skull in the ashes. (ACOK, Jon*)*

    • GRRM deliberately puts the idea of sacrificing a sheep in our heads, only to explicitly tell us: no, weirwood sacrifices are human, not sheep*.* Then, in the next Jon chapter, we arrive at Craster’s Keep where Craster’s "cold gods" do accept live sheep and dogs.

    • This also establish that weirwood sacrifice can be children or grown man it doesn't matter.

    • In other words, GRRM establishes first that the Old Gods / weirwoods do not take sheep as burnt sacrifices to later let the reader spot this odd behavior that Craster indeed sacrifice sheep to the "Cold Gods" that we assume are the Others or related to the Old gods.

  2. The Eyes ("Blue Stars" vs. "Ice"):

    • Throughout the books, GRRM describes the Others as having eyes that "burned like ice" (AGOT Prologue) or "eyes of ice" (AGOT Eddard).

    • He consistently describes wights as having eyes like "blue stars". Forexample: Othor ("eyes like blue stars burning"), the wight bear ("shone like frozen stars"), and Small Paul ("two blue stars").

    • When Gilly describes the "white shadows", "cold gods" who take Craster's sons (ACOK Jon), what color does she say their eyes are? "As bright as blue stars." By GRRM's own visual rulebook, wights are the ones collecting Craster's offerings, not the Others.

  3. Small Paul and the Missing Children Wights:

    • At Whitetree (ASOS), wighted Small Paul goes straight for Gilly's baby.

    • Even stranger: across all five books, we never once see a child wight. In the AGOT Prologue, Will specifically notes eight dead wildlings, men and women both, "No children I could see." Why would GRRM mention this here: "No children I could see."? Seems odd. Even at Hardhome, we never hear of child wights. Why aren't children being turned into wights? Because they are being taken alive.

  4. Who Actually Needs Live Sheep, Dogs, and Boys and could communicate?

    • Undead wights don't eat mutton, and ethereal ice-spirits aka Others don't herd sheep and I pretty sure neither of them can communicate with Craster to make a deal. So the wights are just couriers for someone else.

    • Who is starving underground in a massive cave system, can communicate with dreams, eating mushrooms and blind white fish, and openly admitting their species is dying out because "there are fewer of us every year"? The Children of the Forest.

    • If the COTF are using wights to collect offerings from Craster, livestock for food and cloth and living boys to replenish their dying numbers (much like how they intermarried with humans in the past to create the crannogmen), then suddenly every piece of Craster's bargain makes literal, practical sense.

That would make Craster's arrangement much more sinister, he might believe he's sacrificing his sons to supernatural beings, while unknowingly supplying the Children of the Forest with something they desperately need.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note: to understand why would the wights bring this to the COTF please check my other posts:

  • Summary of the relation of COTF, wights and Others..

  • You can also check the long explanation in one of the comments.

  • And you can find the old explanation with book references of the relation of COTF, wights and Others.

Briefly: the wights are reanimated and controlled by the COTF.


r/asoiaf • • 6h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) What will Euron do next?

9 Upvotes

We all know that Euron Greyjoy and his forces have taken the Shield Islands and are on their way to threaten Oldtown and battle with the Redwyne Fleet. But what will he do next if he succeeds in defeating the Redwyne Fleet, most surely thanks to magic shenanigans using the casualties of the battle as blood sacrifice, and in attacking Oldtown?

What is the true goal that Euron is seeking in Oldtown? And after leaving Oldtown, since he and the Ironborn can't hope to conquer or hold the city truly, what will he do next? Where else could he go?

Will Euron and his threat remain focused on the Reach? Or are there other places where he could go after Oldtown?


r/asoiaf • • 7h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers EXTENDED) All casualties in the Dance of Dragons.

4 Upvotes

So this will be my calculation for how many people died in in the Dance of the Dragons

(Note this is a very rough estimate in many battles the casualties are stated to to be very high or very low, And only a few of the battles has confirmed casualties, So this will be a rough estimate. And I will include only the major battles and events. Plundering and burning will not be covered)

Note I will be using the book version of the conflict. For many of the battles in the series are completely different. However, I will use the figures that appear in the series if I cannot find figures for a battle that occurs in both the series and the book.

This is the second war I'll be covering i have already covered the War of the Five Kings (Spoilers EXTENDED) All casualties in the War of the Five Kings So far : r/asoiaf)

Opening moves

Upon the death of King Viserys I Targaryen, Queen Alicent and Lord Commander Criston Cole sent out the Kingsguard to summon the small council members

The Small Council Meeting
Casualties
Team Black 1 man (Lyman Beesbury)

Assault on Harrenhal
Casualties
None

The Dance over Shipbreaker Bay
Casualties
Team Black 1 man (Lucerys Velaryon)
Dragon 1 (Arrax)

Blood and Cheese
Casualties
Team Green 1 boy (Jaehaerys Targaryen)
Team Black 1 man (Blood)
Small folk (rat chaser) 10 (Estimate)

Duel of the Cargyll Twins
Casualties
Team Green 1 man (Erryk Cargyll)
Team Black 1 man (Arryk Cargyll)

House Blackwood vs House Bracken

Battle of the Burning Mill
Casualties
Team Green/House Bracken 500 (Estimate)
Team Black/House Blackwood 500 (Estimate)
described as hundreds dead in both book and show accounts and Tyland Lannister notes that casualties were so severe that calling it a “victory” is difficult

Taking of Stone Hedge
Casualties
Team Green/House Bracken 100 (Estimate)
Team Black/Prince Daemons host of Darrys, Freys, Pipers, and Rootes 50 (Estimate)
Amos was slain in the Battle of the Burning Mill, and Ser Raylon Rivers led the green survivors back to Bracken territory They returned to Stone Hedge only to find that it had been captured in their absence with most of the Bracken forces away the blacks quickly stormed the castle. When Raylon returned to Stone Hedge, he yielded to Daemon.

The Crownlands campaign

Sack of Duskendale
Casualties
Team Green/The Royal Army of House Targaryen 100 (Estimate)
Team Black/House Darklyn 200 (Estimate)
We know that the royal army advanced with over 2,400 men and attacked the garrison. We also know that the garrison was isolated. During Aegon’s Conquest, 3,000 men were mobilized from both Houses Darklyn and Mooton, but that was a full levy; the garrison may well have been much smaller I would guess around 300 men. Furthermore, we know that the defenders suffered heavy losses. Therefore, 200 is a plausible figure.

Battle at Rook's Rest
Casualties
Team Green/The Royal Army of House Targaryen 900
Team Black/House Staunton/Rhaenys Targaryen 101
Dragon 1 (Meleys)
Note in House of the Dragon they say they are up in the 900 But it also say that 800 died of the dragon fire, so maybe 100 more died during the storming of the castle. I will use 900. Take what number you want.

The Dragonseeds
Casualties
Team Black 25 (Estimate)
Silver Denys stepped forward to claim Vermithor and was burned to death immediately .The same event states Vermithor then killed “dozens more” dragonseeds in a fiery rampage

Battle of the Gullet
Casualties
Team Green / Triarchy: 6,200 (Estimate)
Team Black / House Velaryon: 9,000 (Estimate)
Dragons: 2 (Vermax and Stormcloud)
Smallfolk: 3,000 (Estimate)

Explanation

Medieval warship crews: Warships required sailors, rowers, officers and marines to operate the vessel and fight enemy ships. Byzantine dromons, for example, could carry around 108 rowers and 35 marines. Therefore, I use an estimated average of 100 men per warship, including sailors and fighting men.

Team Green / Triarchy

The Triarchy deployed approximately 90 warships, but only 28 returned. This means 62 ships were lost.

62 × 100 = 6,200 estimated casualties.

2. Team Black / House Velaryon

The Velaryon fleet lost approximately one-third of its strength. Assuming a pre-battle fleet of 270 ships:

270 ÷ 3 = 90 ships lost.

90 × 100 = 9,000 estimated casualties.

3. Smallfolk of Spicetown

The Triarchy sacked and burned Spicetown, killing inhabitants and destroying homes and businesses. High Tide was also burned, and many of Corlys Velaryon's servants died. I estimate 3,000 smallfolk killed, although no exact figure is recorded And Spice Town is still a ruined to this day..
What a battle it took me so long to calculate Only in this battle 18,202 deaths

The War in the Reach and the Riverlands

Battle of the Honeywine
Casualties
Team Green / House Hightower: 1,500 (Estimate)
Team Black / Houses Rowan, Caswell, Tarly, Beesbury and Costayne: 4,000 (Estimate)
Lord Ormund Hightower commanded 5,000 regular troops alongside thousands of sellswords and levies. Despite being attacked from two directions, Daeron and Tessarion's arrival turned the battle in the Greens' favour. I estimate 1,500 Green casualties. The Black army, led by Rowan, Flowers, Beesbury, Tarly and Costayne, suffered a devastating defeat after Tessarion's intervention caused its forces to collapse. With Tom Flowers killed, Owen Costayne mortally wounded, and Beesbury and Tarly captured, I estimate 4,000 Black casualties.

Battle at the Red Fork
Casualties
Team Green / Houses Lannister: 1,500 (Estimate)
Team Black / Houses Piper and Vance: 2,500 (Estimate)
Lord Jason Lannister led the Westermen against the Riverlords, who were initially outnumbered. The Greens attempted to cross the Red Fork three times, suffering casualties during repeated assaults. Jason Lannister was mortally wounded by Pate of Longleaf during the third attempt. Ser Adrian Tarbeck subsequently led 100 knights upstream, crossed the river and attacked Tristan Vance's forces from behind. The Riverlords' resistance collapsed after Tristan was killed. I estimate 1,500 Green casualties and 2,500 Black casualties,

Battle at Acorn Hall
Casualties
Team Green / Houses Lannister, Tarbeck, Lefford and allies: 500 (Estimate)
Team Black / Houses Piper and Smallwood: 1,000 (Estimate)
The Green army, led by Ser Adrian Tarbeck, advanced east after its victory at the Red Fork. Lord Petyr Piper joined forces with Lord Joseth Smallwood to resist the Westermen, but the Greens prevailed. Piper was killed after reportedly seeing his grandson's severed head displayed on a spear, while Smallwood retreated into Acorn Hall. I estimate 500 Green casualties and 1,000 Black casualties

Battle by the Lakeshore (The Fishfeed)
Casualties
Team Black / Houses Stark, Frey, Blackwood and Riverlands allies: 15,000
Team Green / Houses Lannister,: 30,000
The Black army included approximately 2,000 Winter Wolves, 200 Frey knights, 600 Frey infantrymen and 300 Blackwood archers, alongside substantial Riverlands reinforcements and levies. Two-thirds of the Winter Wolves were killed or wounded, and the Black forces suffered an estimated 12,000–18,000 casualties. The Green army had at least 8,000 men, including 1,000 knights and 7,000 men-at-arms, alongside thousands of additional sellswords and levies. Attacked from three sides, the Lannister army was driven into the lake, where hundreds drowned. Its army was ultimately completely destroyed, with losses potentially reaching 30,000 men.
Jesus Christ, why are these battles so bloody?

Prince Aemond's Burning of the Riverlands
Casualties
Team Green / House Targaryen: 0
Team Black / Riverlands: 5,000 (Estimate)
Smallfolk: 10,000 (Estimate)
Prince Aemond Targaryen used Vhagar to burn numerous Riverlands settlements, including Darry, Lord Harroway's Town, Lord's Mill, Blackbuckle, Buckle, Claypool, Swynford and Spiderwood. The attacks devastated villages, destroyed homes and killed inhabitants. I estimate 10,000 smallfolk killed and 5,000 additional military casualties, although no exact figures are recorded.

Butcher's Ball
Casualties
Team Black / Houses Stark, Frey, Blackwood and Riverlands allies: 3000 (Estimate)
Team Green / Ser Christian Cole Targaryen host: 150 (Estimate)
Criston Cole's army had already lost approximately 400 men through desertion and deaths before the battle. During the battle, the Black vanguard charged and the The green soldiers got killed by the hundreds in the rout. The massacre became known as the Butcher's Ball. Given the scale of the rout, I estimate 3,000 Green casualties.
The Black forces also suffered losses, although no exact figure is recorded. I estimate 150 casualties.

Fall of King's Landing

Casualties
Team Green / House Targaryen: 500 (Estimate)
Team Black / House Targaryen / House Velaryon: 100 (Estimate)
King's Landing fell to Rhaenyra's forces in 130 AC after Daemon and Rhaenyra arrived with Caraxes and Syrax, while Corlys Velaryon's fleet entered Blackwater Bay. Daemon's former Gold Cloaks opened the city gates, allowing the Blacks to take the capital in less than a day. The Greens offered little organised resistance, although hundreds of Green loyalists were killed or captured. Otto Hightower and Jasper Wylde were executed, while Tyland Lannister was tortured. I estimate 500 Green casualties and 100 Black casualties,

The Red Kraken

Seizure of Fair Isle
Casualties
Team Green /House Farman: 600 (Estimate)
Team Black /House Greyjoy: 100 (Estimate)
So House Greyjoy declared for the blacks. With Lord Jason Lannister dying after the Red Fork, his Lannister army destroyed at the Fishfeed, and the green armies of the Reach marching east to Tumbleton, the coasts of the westerlands only had skeleton defenses. For several years, Dalton and his ironborn raided and pillaged the coasts of the westerlands and the Reach. Dalton nearly captured Kayce and seized Fair Isle, and though the ironborn could not force entry into Casterly Rock after Jason's widow Johanna closed its gates, they sacked Lannisport.

Sack of Lannisport
Casualties
Team Green /Houses Lannister: 3,000 (Estimate)
Team Black /House Greyjoy: 750 (Estimate)
Lannisport smallfolk killed 2,000 (Estimate)
Explanation

Using the same method as the Battle of the Gullet, I estimate an average of 100 men per warship, including sailors, rowers and fighting men.

  1. Team Green / House Lannister

Assuming the Lannister fleet had approximately 30 ships, three-quarters were captured and the rest sunk by the Ironborn.

30 × 100 = 3,000 estimated casualties.

2. Team Black / House Greyjoy

Assuming the Ironborn lost approximately 7–8 ships during the attack:

7.5 × 100 = 750 estimated casualties.

3. Smallfolk of Lannisport

The Ironborn sacked and looted Lannisport, killing inhabitants and abducting more than 600 women and girls. I estimate 2,000 smallfolk killed, although no exact figure is recorded.

Total: 5,750 estimated casualties.

The Hightower/Green offensive

Siege of Longtable
Casualties
Team Green /House Hightower: 200 (Estimate)
Team Black /House Merryweather 500 (Estimate)

Sack of Bitterbridge
Casualties
Casualties
Team Green / House Hightower: 50 (Estimate)
Team Black / House Caswell: 300 (Estimate)
Smallfolk of Bitterbridge: 1,000 (Estimate)

Prince Daeron attacked Bitterbridge with Tessarion and Lord Ormund Hightower's army. No significant Green military losses are recorded. I estimate 50 casualties.
The castle garrison was ordered to be put to the sword after Lady Caswell surrendered. I estimate 300 casualties among the defenders.
Tessarion burned the town, destroying inns, storehouses and homes. Hundreds of wounded people died inside the sept, while other inhabitants were slaughtered by soldiers or drowned in the Mander. I estimate 1,000 smallfolk killed.

First Battle of Tumbleton
Casualties
Team Green / House Hightower: 1,000 (Estimate)
Team Black / House Targaryen / Riverlands: 3,000 (Estimate)
Smallfolk of Tumbleton: 3,000 (Estimate)

The Greens suffered losses during the fighting, including the deaths of Lord Ormund Hightower and Ser Bryndon Hightower. However, they ultimately won the battle. I estimate 1,000 military casualties.
The Black army numbered approximately 6,000–12,000 men. Following the betrayal of Hugh Hammer and Ulf White, their dragons turned against the town, burning buildings and killing defenders. Many Black soldiers were killed during the fighting and retreat. I estimate 3,000 casualties.
Vermithor and Silverwing unleashed dragonfire upon Tumbleton, burning buildings and causing thousands to burn to death or drown while escaping across the Mander. The victorious Green army subsequently sacked the town. I estimate 3,000 smallfolk killed. \

Fall of Dragonstone
Casualties
Team Green / House Targaryen: (Estimate: 20)
Team Black / House Targaryen: 100 (Estimate)
Dragons: 3 (Moondancer and Grey Ghost Sunfyre eventually died from his wounds later that year)
Aegon II and his supporters captured Dragonstone with little organised resistance. Green casualties were minimal. I estimate approximately 20 casualties.
Ser Alfred Broome and his supporters betrayed the Blacks. Ser Robert Quince was killed, while Baela's forces fought against Aegon and Sunfyre. Several defenders were killed during the takeover. I estimate 100 casualties.

Battle Above the Gods Eye
Casualties
Team Green / House Targaryen: 1 (Aemond Targaryen One-Eye)
Team Black / House Targaryen: 1 (Daemon Targaryen The Rogue Prince**)**
Dragons: 2 (Caraxes and Vhagar)
What a duel

Chaos in King's Landing

Storming of the Dragonpit
Casualties
Team Black / House Targaryen: 1,054 (Estimate)
Smallfolk of King's Landing: 6,000 (Estimate)
Dragons: 5 (Shrykos, Morghul, Tyraxes, Dreamfyre and Syrax)
The City Watch and the defenders attempted to stop the rioters from reaching the Dragonpit. Many defenders were killed during the riots and fighting. I estimate 1,000 Black casualties. Fewer than 50 Dragonkeepers defended the Dragonpit, and all were slaughtered by the mob.

Approximately 20,000 followers of the Shepherd took part in the uprising. Hundreds or possibly thousands died during the fighting, dragon attacks and collapse of the Dragonpit. I estimate 6,000 smallfolk killed.

Flight to Dragonstone
Casualties
Team Green / House Targaryen: 2
Team Black / House Targaryen: 3 (Rhaenyra Targaryen)
Poor Aegon III

Second Battle of Tumbleton
Casualties
Team Green / House Targaryen: 1000
Team Black / House Targaryen / Riverlands: 100
Dragons: 3 (Seasmoke, Vermithor, Tessarion)

Moon of the Three Kings
Casualties
House Targaryen / Black loyalists: 150 (Estimate)
Ser Perkin's followers: 100 (Estimate)
Gaemon Palehair's followers: 100 (Estimate)
Shepherd's followers: 200 (Estimate)
Smallfolk of King's Landing: 300 (Estimate)
Executed prisoners and political enemies: 10 (Estim
During this period, King's Landing descended into lawlessness. Ser Perkin the Flea took control of the Red Keep and installed Trystane Truefyre as king. Gaemon Palehair established his own following on Visenya's Hill, while the Shepherd maintained his influence over the religious crowds.
Ser Perkin ordered the executions of several knights, including Ser Garth the Harelip and Ser Harmon of the Reeds. Mysaria was publicly whipped through the streets and died from her injuries.
The rival factions competed for influence, while ordinary citizens suffered from the absence of effective government. Eventually, Lord Borros Baratheon marched on King's Landing with his Stormlander forces and restored Aegon II's authority.
Trystane Truefyre was executed, Essie was hanged, and the Shepherd and his most devoted followers were burned alive.

Battle of the Kingsroad
Casualties
Team Green / House Baratheon: 3000 (Estimate)
Team Black / House Tully / Riverlands: 1,000 (Estimate)
The battle took place on the Kingsroad, approximately two days from King's Landing. Lord Borros Baratheon led an army of approximately 6,000 men, including 600 knights, against the approaching Riverlander army commanded by Lord Kermit Tully, Lord Benjicot Blackwood and Lady Alysanne Blackwood.
Borros launched a cavalry charge, but Alysanne Blackwood's archers devastated his advancing knights. The muddy ground disrupted the Stormlander cavalry, while Benjicot Blackwood launched a surprise flank attack from the forest.
The Crownlands forces proved unreliable. Hayford, Rosby and Stokeworth refused to properly engage, the Flea Bottom levies fled, and the knights of Duskendale switched sides and attacked Borros's army from behind.
The battle ended in a decisive victory for the Blacks and effectively destroyed Aegon II's remaining field army.

Assassination of Aegon II 
Casualties
Team Green / House Targaryen: 1

The False Dawn

Hour of the Wolf
Casualties
Team Green / House Targaryen: 2

It was an exceptionally bloody war. One could say that the war continues; hostilities between the Greyjoy and Lannister houses evolved into a new war, and there are still many bandits and raiders wreaking havoc. However, I would argue that the war came to an end with the Hour of the Wolf.

124,086 and 17 Dragons

Total estimated human deaths in the Dance of the Dragons.

Note this is a rough estimate because George doesn't like putting numbers in battles.
That certainly took a long time. And it makes the War of the Five Kings pale in comparison. Next up is Aegon’s Conquest.


r/asoiaf • • 8h ago

MAIN [Spoilers Main] When will I stop thinking about TWOW? Spoiler

24 Upvotes

So I’m not really a big book reader, although I used to read a lot of web novels. This year I binged ASOIAF and now I cannot stop thinking about the next book. I can’t stop thinking about the epic moment when The Mannis will execute Ramsey Snow, or how badly the Ironborn are fucking the Yunkai’i at Slavers Bay right now

And somehow, after rereading some chapters, Jon Connington went from some random I don’t care about, to the goat. At what point did you guys stop thinking about TWOW? Like I think about this shit daily and I finished Dance like months ago

I feel like George cooked up the most delicious feast of my life and then strapped me to a chair forever to just stare at it. Pls I need this George 🙏


r/asoiaf • • 11h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Do Westerosi noble women know how to cook?

24 Upvotes

Cersei, Catelyn, Alerie Tyrell, etc. Do they know how to cook? How do their cooking skills compare to a commoner woman?


r/asoiaf • • 13h ago

MAIN [spoiler main] Is there a ranking of ALL houses in Westeros?

0 Upvotes

Not necessarily all but perhaps top 20-30? I saw a few posts with comments that were fairly comprehensive but no clear list.


r/asoiaf • • 14h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) the shadow of second sons.

6 Upvotes

There is just something fascinating about the burden of second sons and how they lived in their older brother’s shadow. There like the spaee to the throne, the one who either there brother’s greatest ally or their worst enemy. Whether they’re more popular or capable than their older sibling, they will always live in their sibling’s shadow. Even when the younger siblings are equally or more capable or popular than the older siblings like Daemon and Viserys OR Aemon and Aegon IV.

Brandon Stark and Eddard Stark: The Wild and Quiet Wolf. Interestingly, George say that Ned Stark is a much better leader (well battlefield commander) than Brandon, who’s the better fighter. And Ned Stark proves his leadership during the Rebellion and during his rule of Winterfell. Not sure what Brandon would be like except he got his entire team captured and killed. Yet in a world where Brandon doesn’t die, then Ned would remain in the shadow as a supporting actor. Of course, that’s fine by Ned if it means his brother is alive. I think Ned preferred to stay in the background, quiet, and assuming.

Tywin Lannister and Kevan Lannister: Kevan is capable on his own but knowing he can’t escape his brother’s shadow chose to make a place for himself beside him. It worked well for both of them. Well it worked for Kevan but not Tywin’s other brothers who search’s for way to make a name for themselves, with varying success. Than their Tywin’s sons Jaime and Tyrion. Tyrion more capable even if Jaime more popular.

There also Robb Stark and Jon Snow: well Jon Snow have the additional burden of being a bastard but I get the feelings he doesn’t want to live in his brother’s shadow. Jon wants to make a name for himself which is likely one of many reasons why he chose to join the Night Watch. Robb perfectly capable on his own but Jon is also good but if he stay in Winterfell than he’ll continue to be in his brother’s shadow.


r/asoiaf • • 18h ago

(Spoilers AFFC) Lady Stoneheart foreshadowing in Jaime I AFFC? Spoiler

16 Upvotes

I’m currently on my first reread of AFFC and I couldn’t find any discussion on this interesting passage from Jaime I. When Jaime is standing vigil for Tywin and fighting sleep, Cersei appears to him in a way that reminds me of Lady Stoneheart.

“A woman stood before him.

It is raining again, he thought when he saw how wet she was. The water was trickling down her cloak to puddle round her feet. How did she get here? I never heard her enter. She was dressed like a tavern wench in a heavy roughspun cloak, badly dyed in mottled browns and fraying at the hem. A hood concealed her face, but he could see the candles dancing in the green pools of her eyes, and when she moved he knew her.

“Cersei.” He spoke slowly, like a man waking from a dream, still wondering where he was. “What hour is it?”

“The hour of the wolf.” His sister lowered her hood, and made a face. “The drowned wolf, perhaps.”

Mentions of a drowned wolf, a hooded, soaked woman appearing out of nowhere when Jaime is in a dreamlike state totally feels like Lady Stoneheart to me… I’m interested in what people think about this scene! Maybe foreshadowing for a future confrontation? I’m sure it’s been discussed before because I’m a decade plus late but I couldn’t find anything 😓


r/asoiaf • • 19h ago Bravo Mindblown

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Arthur Dayne had lyme disease

395 Upvotes

What

It's noted as remarkable that the kingsguard at the tower of joy were defeated by Ned Stark and his entourage (most critically Howland Reed, according to Bran). Howland Reed helped Ned Stark and his entourage kill Arthur Dayne, Gerold Hightower, and Osgrey Whent by giving the latters lyme disease.

Why

Many characters describe Arthur Dayne as a formidable warrior. Jaime Lannister says of him:

the [Fraud] of the Morning, who could have slain all five of you with his left hand while he was taking with a piss with the right

Bran remembers Ned saying that Arthur was "[t]he finest knight I ever saw", and that "he would have killed me but for Howland Reed".

Jaime even recalls Dayne's prowess with a bit of color:

The Smiling Knight was a madman, cruelty and chivalry all jumbled up together, but he did not know the meaning of fear. And Dayne, with Dawn in hand . . . The outlaw’s longsword had so many notches by the end that Ser Arthur had stopped to let him fetch a new one. “It’s that white sword of yours I want,” the robber knight told him as they resumed, though he was bleeding from a dozen wounds by then. “Then you shall have it, ser,” the [Fraud] of the Morning replied, and made an end of it.

So it's pretty clear that Ser Arthur, at least when armed with his bullshit magical Sword of a Thousand Truths, is extremely formidable. And we know from Ned's fever dream under the Red Keep that Arthur had Dawn in his possession at the fight outside the Tower of Joy, so it should've been a rehashing of the age-old "how many toddlers could you beat in a fight if you had a magic sword?" thought experiment. Ned and his boyz had no business winning that fight.

HOWEVER, there's one key detail that many overlook! Ned remembers Arthur saying this, in that same encounter:

Our knees do not bend easily

Ned even pictures Ser Oswell Whent "on one knee" at the outset of the scuffle, but never seems to imagine him moving from that position. How curious!

This is HUGE. Being able to bend your knees is really important in close-quarters combat. Fighters do it all the time. And you don't just need to bend your knees to fight, it may be even more important if you want to get away, which explains why none of the assembled kingsguard escaped the encounter.

I believe that Arthur Dayne's joint stiffness, which obviously led to his defeat on that day, was not just a happy coincidence. It was clearly part of a genius plan cooked up by Howland Reed, possibly with Ned's knowledge, which is why Ned is ashamed to tell the full story to his children.

How

It's well established that the Reeds are into weird shit. Crannogmen seem to be widely known as spooky Appalachian skinwalkers, safely contained in the Neck by the bravery of the Freys at one end and Moat Cailin at the other. Howland Reed skinchanged into a deer, rolled around in tall grass, then rubbed himself on the three Kingsguard at the Tower of Joy while they slept (which was obviously outdoors because it was a beautiful time of year). Untreated Lyme Disease causes a form of arthritis, which can make it incredibly difficult and painful to move.

Questions and Answers

How did 5 of the 7 Northmen present at the tower still die, if their opponents were all basically crippled? If you give a toddler, especially an underhanded rogue like the Fraud of the Morning, a magic plot-armor sword, he's still likely to get a few good licks in.

Is it possible that Arthur meant "our knees do not bend easily" as a metaphor for surrender? No

Doesn't Lyme Arthritis take a really long time to kick in? Howland can see the future, so he started acting on this plan many months ahead of time.


r/asoiaf • • 20h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Ned.. too nice? A middle ground? Selfless?

3 Upvotes

Like I think Ned Stark is too nice. I’m not saying Ned can’t be stern or harsh, but he is also nice. I say that Ned would give up his own happiness if it the right thing to do and likely suppress his feelings for a girl if another man loves her. This does make him a selfless person because he’s putting the needs of other people above his own. Oh and at the same time, he’s not being a rigid rule-follower.

I think Ned lies in the middle ground between Stannis and Jaime in terms of keeping their vows. Ned won’t blindly follow the laws if it go against his moral code but he won’t completely break his words.

Could Ned Stark have a lighter shade of grey? He is not completely black or white even though he leans more into white.

Even his lies are spoken in a way where he knows he telling the truth even if one thinks he is lying. I’m talking about where he calls Jon his blood.


r/asoiaf • • 21h ago

EXTENDED [Spoilers Extended] The No-Theory of Faceless Men

0 Upvotes

OP's note: This isn't actually my theory, I'm just posting it for a friend (no, really)

I propose what I will call “the No-Theory of Faceless Men”

This theory is that:

a) there is no reason for the Faceless Man to be in the Black Cells

b) there is no connection between the Faceless Man in King’s Landing and the Faceless Man in Oldtown

c) there is no reason for the Faceless Man to be in Oldtown

For the purposes of this theory, we will describe two Faceless Men – the one whom Arya interacts with in Clash we will call ‘Jaqen’. The second, who Sam briefly interacts with in Dance, we will call ‘Peta.’

That established:

a) there is no reason for the Faceless Man to be in the Black Cells

The purpose of the Faceless Man in Clash, a.k.a., ‘Jaqen,’ is to introduce the concept of Faceless Men and send Arya on her path to Braavos.

Let’s run through a brief review of Jaqen’s path through Clash. First, he is pulled from the Black Cells by Tyrion during his general purging of the dungeons to send recruits to the Night’s Watch. Then he is locked in with Rorge and Biter, his fellow Black Cell-mates in the locked wagon. He interacts with Arya, and when Yoren’s caravan is attacked, Arya saves him and his wagon-mates from death. Arya then encounters him as a mercenary in Harrenhal, and he returns the favor of three deaths for the three lives saved. Ultimately, she tricks him into helping her and her friends escape Harrenhal, he changes his face in front of her, and gives her a coin, which ultimately leads her to Braavos.

There is an almost endless amount of theorizing as to the ‘why’ of Jaqen is in the Black Cells to begin with. These theories range from his capture during an assassination gone awry, an arrest during the commission of a horrific crime, such as cutting of faces for harvest by the House of White and Black, or as an assassin in waiting for various parties in King’s Landing.

In stark contrast, I would posit that there is NO REASON for Jaqen’s presence in the Black Cells.

What do we know about the Black Cells? These are reserved for the very worst criminals in King’s Landing. Debased criminals and traitors like Rorge, Biter, or Ned Stark. They are dismal, terrible places. Uniquely, and most importantly for our theorists out there, Varys appears to be in control of the dreary place. For the purposes of the story, a place like the Black Cells might be riven with secret passages like the rest of the Red Keep.

There are two reasons for Jaqen to be there – the first, that he has been imprisoned, and the second is that he chooses to be there. First, we will address either in turn before we come back to the only conclusion: there is NO REASON for him to be there.

As far as his imprisonment goes, the Jaqen we see in Harrenhal is capable, dangerous, and supernaturally endowed. We can assume that the Jaqen who is brought into the Black Cells is similarly endowed. And while Jaqen is extraordinary, it isn’t beyond belief that the goldcloaks could have arrested him.

What do we know about this? And the answer is: nothing. We don’t have stories about a debauched criminal in King’s Landing. We don’t have any rumors about some insidious traitor languishing in the cells next to Ned Stark. There is no snide comment from Tyrion about the Watch being a suitable home for some face-slicing knifeman. Yoren tells nothing to Arya about the particulars of any crime committed by Jaqen, we don’t get a word or a thought from Tyrion or Ned about some vile prisoner and his infamous crimes.

Where there’s a Faceless Man, the assumption that any crime he might commit is most likely murder. What do we know about how that order of assassins commits murder? We have quite a bit to go with – Jaqen’s exploits in Harrenhal and Arya’s training in Braavos. In both instances, we see someone who is quick, deadly, and escapes with nary a trace. Would our goldcloaks have been able to capture an assassin of this ability? Possibly, but unlikely. Moreover: there is no evidence of any assassination or unexpected death in King’s Landing – aside from Jon Arryn, and he’s accounted for.

So… there’s no crime. But there is a criminal? I guess?

Perhaps not.

Let’s go with another theory: that Jaqen chooses to be in the Black Cells. It is outlandish and fantastical that anyone would choose to inhabit such a dank environ, but ASOIAF is a story full of intrigue and dragons, so let’s examine what is probably the biggest theory out there in the wilderness: that someone has a Faceless Man on retainer.

Like the criminal theory, we can also dismiss the retainer theory. We have an inside perspective on the House of Black and White and the Faceless Men. What do they do? They commit assassinations for money, but… the targets are named. And if the order goes out, well, as Jaqen says, one foot after another. The murders are an act of devotion. It seems to me rather incongruous that the House of Black and White would accept a deposit on an assassin and then allow him to rot in the Black Cells under the Red Keep while the target is chosen.

There are several choices batted around for who might have a Faceless Man secreted in the Black Cells – Varys and Littlefinger are chief amongst them. And I could a huge amount of a text debating the merits of either thesis. I’ll dispose of them quickly: neither Varys nor Littlefinger have any need for a Faceless Man, nor would their … menace … be increased by having a Faceless Man in the dungeon. Varys kills with children. Littlefinger with poison. But also… what’s the target that requires a Faceless Man to rot in a cell? And not just any cell, the ones reserved for the absolute most depraved criminals. They don’t have a face. Being in a prison cell doesn’t make a target more available to a potential assassin. It doesn’t provide easier access to potential targets. It doesn’t make it easier to learn information or … anything. A Faceless Man on some mission in King’s Landing wouldn’t be in the Black Cells. He’d be out doing the mission.

While we know astonishingly little about Varys and Littlefinger’s motives and actions, we do have some insights, none of which hint, even tangentially. about the hiring, usage, or maintenance of a Faceless Man.

So… what remains?

Nothing.

There is no crime, nor the suspicion of a crime which Jaqen may have committed, resulting in his involuntary confinement in the cell. Nor do we have any textual evidence that any of the many schemers in King’s Landing would have caged a magical assassin in the a cruel and deprived dungeon. We have not a whiff from King’s Landing or Braavos or Harrenhal or Oldtown that a Faceless Man on assignment does anything other than doggedly pursue his quarry and would suffer to wait in confinement whilst a target was chosen?

So… what must be the conclusion?

There’s no crime. There’s no plot. There’s no explanation for Jaqen’s confinement in the cells. It is a lacuna.

While the fantasist might begin to spin yarns about hidden plots, the reader is instead, left with nothing.

We must accept that there is NO REASON for Jaqen’s presence in King’s Landing.

Let us move on.

b) there is no connection between the Faceless Man in King’s Landing and the Faceless Man in Oldtown.

I will admit that there is no textual evidence that there are two Faceless Men. I am open to admit that it is entirely possible that Jaqen went from Harrenhal to Oldtown. However, it is completely unimportant if they are the same or different people.

Let’s go back to GRRM’s released draft of the original plan for the novels. In it, Arya goes to the Wall and falls in love with Jon.

What happens with Arya at the end of GAME? She’s seized by Yoren, and then we see her in CLASH trudging to the Wall with a gang of prisoners. Amongst whom is the non-foreshadowed Jaqen. GRRM is a gardener. He changes things as they come up to him – look at the maps of the North beyond the Wall.

I would posit that GRRM did not intend for Arya to become a Faceless Man when he finished GAME. Between the writing of GAME and CLASH he change her character’s arc. All good – it’s his book. To get her there, he created the Jaqen character.

Jaqen accomplishes three things in the narrative:

1 – He demonstrates the power of the Faceless Men

2 – He points Arya towards Braavos

3 – He changes his face to that of the Hooked Nosed Man (HNM)

Points one and two are clear for the reader. The third is a trick. Let’s only focus on that.

At the end of Clash, Jaqen changes his face in front of Arya, from the Lorathi sell-sword into the hooked-faced man, which is described in detail. This is a demonstration of the power of the Faceless Men, and is awesome. Jaqen is now free to operate throughout the Seven Kingdoms despite abandoning his post and possibly aiding in the freeing of several prisoners and the murder of a number of guards. Jaqen H’ghar no longer exists, and the faceless man is free to act.

Now… what’s with the HNM showing up in Oldtown at the start of Dance, which occurs, roughly one or two years after the conclusion of Clash? HNM is the face worn by Peta who lures in Pate, a student in the Citadel, and whose face Peta takes.

This only serves one reason: for the reader to be tingled in the right neurons, with many hundreds of pages and possibly years in between their reading of Clash and Dance. They read that precise description and somewhere in their lobes, the right synapses fire, and the reader has an inkling… ‘ where did I read that description before…’ and they pull out their copy of Clash and re-read Jaqen’s farewell, and they think, ‘oh… that’s clever.’

This facial connection is the only reason one might suspect that Jaqen and Peta are one and the same. And, honestly, perhaps they are. But as we’ve seen from the House of Black and White, the Faceless Men share faces. It’s entirely possible that separate faceless men are wearing the same HNM guise, with Jaqen returning to Braavos in the interim, and another taking it up for a separate mission. We’ve established that Jaqen has no reason to be in King’s Landing. We will establish that whatever Peta is doing in Oldtown is similar to Jaqen’s purpose in the narrative. But as there are no reasons to be found regarding Jaqen’s purpose in King’s Landing, we cannot link Peta’s presence to them.

Thus, there is NO REASON to believe that Jaqen and Peta are the same Faceless Man.

Let us move on.

c) there is no reason for the Faceless Man to be in Oldtown

What do we know about Peta? We know that while posing as an alchemist in Oldtown, he wore the same face as Jaqen wore when he left Arya outside of Harrenhal, the HNM. We know that he concocted a scheme to lure Pate to steal his archmaester’s key and later took his face. We know that while posing as Pate, Peta remained in the entourage surrounding Archmaester Marwyn, appearing to be just one of many students at the Citadel.

And… that’s it.

So… what are we to make of this? Well… Peta can be in Oldtown for two reasons: the first, that he’s been hired to assassinate a target, and second, that he’s on a mission of some obscure purpose from the House of Black and White.

Let’s look at the assassination plot first and discard it immediately.

While there is a sprawling cast of characters in Oldtown, none of them live in the archives of the Citadel. So… why would a Faceless Man need the key? Or Pate’s unique face. Either acquisition doesn’t advance any conceivable sacred assassination. Moreover, the death of any particular character in Oldtown – including from Samwell Tarly, and excepting Marwyn, possibly – doesn’t advance our plot. While not advancing the plot is a unique feature of Dance with Dragons, it is also not a reason for Peta to be present in Oldtown.

Let’s move on.

We have the option that Peta has impersonated Pate, key and all, in order to access the secrets of the Citadel or for some other purpose unknown to the reader. This is a more intriguing possibility. It gives atmosphere and a wonderful hook. What do we know is down in the Archives of the Citadel? Dragon lore? Legendaria from the Age of Heroes? The Horn of Winter? The possibilities are only as boundless as the imagination of the theorist. But to the reader, we are only aware of one item in all of Oldtown – beyond the Pate’s key – which can both be of interest to the House of Black and White AND drive our plot forward: a glass candle. Thus, the presence of even a better mousetrap in the Citadel’s deepest hole cannot be a REASON for Peta’s mission.

There’s a glass candle right there in Marwyn’s lab. All the archmaesters have them. Peta doesn’t need a secret key to steal one if that was the goal of his mission.

It takes training to learn how to use a glass candle. Maybe Peta is masquerading as Pate to learn its secrets from Marwyn. And this is a totally valid excuse for masquerading as Pate, but is not a valid excuse to take the key. And here is a bit of theory: the key itself is unimportant to Peta. If Peta’s mission is to learn the mystery of the glass candle, his request for Pate to bring the key was only a ploy to lure our poor Pate to a location where his face can be safely stolen. The key? The only means by which Pate might have to pay for the potion. It gets our Pigboy to his death. Thus, we have a rationale for the theft, a reason for the key being important to the reader, and a reasonable Martin-esque distraction: we are looking at the key, but the actual trick is in the face. A slight-of-literary-hand not uncommon for our author.

Wow. That’s a great mini-theory right? And when Peta has learned the hidden art, he can lift the candle and return to Braavos. A mighty coup indeed.

But… Winter is Coming. What would any of this have to do with Samwell Tarly? Marwyn the Mage has gone! Perhaps Peta has not finished his training, and our secret agent must find yet another archmaester (and accompanying student’s face?) to continue their training. But… is this a REASON which has been included into our plot? What would this possibly have to do with Samwell Tarly? In what interaction could Samwell have with Peta which might advance Sam’s plot in a meaningful way? Sam can neither help nor hinder Peta. Peta may well hurt Sam, but unless we are repeating the Arya plot from Clash, then Peta will have no conceivable reason to assist Sam. We have come to the crux of it: why is Peta masquerading as Pate? What is he doing?

Similar to Jaqen’s imprisonment… nothing. There is no reason for him to be there.

Suppose that Sam has to escape from Euron’s invasion with Sarrela, and along the extent of that adventure, they grab a glass candle… well… does that require Peta? Surely they could take one themselves if they desired. Even if in the chaos of that attack, Peta accompanies Sam and Sarella, is Peta going to teach them the arts of the glass candle in some future travel journey to Horn Hill or wherever?

No. A faceless man wouldn’t do that. Peta would accomplish the mission, with accompanying diversions for making up for deaths kept from their god, and move along. But again, do we expect a repeat of the Arya storyline with Sam? No.

So… what’s the reason for Peta to be in Oldtown? And the answer, which I return to, and is… there is no reason.

Peta cannot move things along, cannot assist Sam, Sam cannot help him, and if he were to oppose Sam, our beloved Samwell would quickly die. Peta exists for only one purpose, for the reader to suppose that something might happen in the future. But as we have discussed, with the text we have, there is NO REASON for the Faceless Man to be in Oldtown.

In summation: We’ve established that there is NO REASON for Jaqen’s imprisonment in the black cells. We’ve established that there is NO REASON to suppose that Jaqen = Peta. We’ve established that there is NO REASON for Peta’s presence in Oldtown.

Addendum: While preparing this post to be published it did occur to me that there may in fact, be a plot purpose for Peta in Oldtown: to become a friend and ally to Sam in his future adventures. I leave that to the reader to make their own conclusions as to whether this is a possibility for the forthcoming novels.


r/asoiaf • • 21h ago

NONE Reading order/Break after the 3rd book [No Spoilers]

2 Upvotes

Hello. I’d like to preface this post by saying that I’ve watched all three shows set in the ASOIAF universe. I was even thinking of rewatching Game of Thrones, but since I didn’t like the last two seasons and deeply disliked the ending, I decided not to do it, but to read the books instead. I don’t regret it, I’ve read the first three books and really enjoyed them. I finished A Storm of Swords today, and it was fantastic.

I should also mention that I already read Rise of the Dragon (the abridged and illustrated edition of F&B) before starting the main series (I’d just watched House of the Dragon). I’ll read Fire and Blood last.

My question is this: should I take a break from the main series now and read The World of Ice and Fire and A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, or should I finish the main series? I don’t think I’d be spoiled since I’ve watched the shows.


r/asoiaf • • 23h ago

EXTENDED [Spoilers Extended] GTA VI has two references to ASOIAF.

453 Upvotes

Jason has a book on his nightstand titled ‘The Battle for Zantoroth’ written by T.D.D. Ewell with a cover that resembles the previous mass market paperback editions. To be fair this might also be a Tolkein reference.

There’s also a Weasel News (GTA equivalent of Fox News) report about a man who drank gas to become a dragon dying in the ER, this of course is similar to how our friend Aerion Brightflame died. It seems like the maesters also poisoned the gasoline in this universe too.


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) for his friends or family, Ned would sacrifice personal happiness and love

8 Upvotes

Eddard Stark was risking a happy marriage when he brought his supposed bastard Jon Snow to Winterfell.

This make me realize Ned would give up his personal happiness for the sake of his friends and family and if the right thing to do.

Assuming Ned and Brandon both had a crush on Ashara and Brandon wasn’t bethrothed to Catelyn. I think Ned would suppress his feelings or hide it for Brandon’s sake.

I wonder if it come from a feeling of inferiority?

Oh and Ned too honorable to ever resent anyone if they achieve something he love or want


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) You're a defense lawyer tasked with naming 7 Targaryen's that best exemplify that they really are more god than man. Who do you choose?

10 Upvotes

Show me a top 7 (in honor of the 7 gods) of "good ones" in the lizard people house that suggest maybe Targaryen's are more god than man. We know of all the assholes/ mad lizard folk, but who are the best nobles from their dynasty?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

PUBLISHED (Spoilers Published) Cersei’s chapters in AFFC are actually hilarious

152 Upvotes

The funniest thing about Cersei is how convinced she is that she’s outsmarting everyone while making everything worse.
Honestly, her complete lack of self-awareness makes those chapters so entertaining. Anyone else find her more funny than intimidating?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED Major Characters Fleeing King's Landing Incognito (Spoilers Extended)

16 Upvotes

Background

In this post I thought it would be interesting to look at a potential pattern I noticed and that is the recurrence of a major character fleeing King's Landing in disguise/incognito/pretending to be someone else/wanted/etc.

AGOT

  • Arya (Arry the Orphan)

Arya leaves King's Landing under the guise of Arry the orphan boy:

Afterward he told her that from there to Winterfell she'd be Arry the orphan boy. -ACOK, Arya I

  • Barristan (Arstan)

After Barristan is dismissed from Joffrey's service, he is given the name Arstan as he travel to the "true king":

He bowed his head. “At Qarth, when you asked my name, I said I was called Arstan. That much was true. Many men had called me by that name while Belwas and I were making our way east to find you. But it is not my true name.” -ASOS, Daenerys V

If interested: The Arstan Reveal

ACOK

  • Sandor Clegane (Sandor/The Hound Split, creation of legacy character)

After the Blackwater, Sandor flees King's Landing becoming an outlaw in the Riverlands, during that time, the Hound "dies" and Sandor becomes a gravedigger on the Quiet Isle, while his helm is used by others (Rorge/Lem).

If interested: Legacy Characters in ASOIAF

ASOS

  • Tyrion Lannister (Yollo/Hugor Hill)

After his trial by combat goes south, Tyrion is condemned to die, but Jaime/Varys free him. He then drinks his way across the narrow sea and becomes Yollo/Hugor Hill:

Yollo? Yollo sounds like something you might name a monkey. Worse, it was a Pentoshi name, and any fool could see that Tyrion was no Pentoshi. "In Pentos I am Yollo," he said quickly, to make what amends he could, "but my mother named me Hugor Hill." -ADWD, Tyrion III

  • Sansa Stark (Alayne)

After the Purple Wedding, Dontos helps Littlefinger spirit Sansa away to the Vale where she starts going by Alayne:

"I . . . I could call myself after my mother . . ."
"Catelyn? A bit too obvious . . . but after my mother, that would serve. Alayne. Do you like it?"
"Alayne is pretty." Sansa hoped she would remember. -ASOS, Sansa VI

  • Jeyne Poole (Arya Stark)

Not necessarily a major character, but Jeyne (It Rhymes with Pain) Poole is taken away from King's Landing as fArya:

Jaime studied her closely. "You know me, then?"
She bit her lip. "You may not recall, my lord, as I was littler then . . . but I had the honor to meet you at Winterfell when King Robert came to visit my father Lord Eddard." She lowered her big brown eyes and mumbled, "I'm Arya Stark."
Jaime had never paid much attention to Arya Stark, but it seemed to him that this girl was older. "I understand you're to be married." -ASOS, Jaime IX

AFFC/ADWD

  • Aurane Waters (The Lord of the Waters)

Not necessarily major nor was it incognito but he fled King's Landing once Cersei was arrested with the crown's ships and has likely set himself up as a pirate king in the Stepstones (unless Salladhor Saan took his place):

Aurane Waters, her admiral, had fled to sea with the dromonds she had built for him. -ADWD, Cersei I

and:

A new pirate king has set up on Torturer's Deep. The Lord of the Waters, he styles himself. This one has real warships, three-deckers, monstrous large.  -TWoW, Arianne I

TWoW

  • Cersei (TBD?)

One thing I go back and forth on in the series is what GRRM's plans are for Cersei. From the Mercy chapter it seems like she has regained power, but we do have Young Griff/Aegon VI showing up soon. We should expect to see Casterly Rock (GRRM had Kevan POV there seemingly at one point) soon and she could be our POV. At the same time she's a great villain (which are hard to find), especially sitting there in King's Landing.

If interested: Inside the Walls of Casterly Rock

TLDR: Just a quick list of some of the more major characters who flee King's Landing in disguise/incognito/wanted/etc. at the end of each book.


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) What would Robert Baratheon do if his marriage with Lyanna goes through but soon afterwards…

0 Upvotes

…his wife starts to pop out children that look more and more Targaryen? How many pairs of purple eyes and how many silver manes will take for Robert to consider that maybe is not a throwback from grandma Rhaelle after all?