r/askrecruiters • • Jul 02 '26

Had an offer pulled for asking for 5k on a 6 figure offer…

225 Upvotes

I have 7 years experience as a BSA. working as a senior level jack of all trades/plug every hole, extremely technical position from concept to finished workflow etc. Lots of ai exposure, Ive owned product builds professionally and self hosted software that I’ve built at an enterprise level (database set up, row level security, onboarding wizards), the whole 9. I’m good at what I do, and opposite of how this is coming across, I truly am humble about it, I’m just lost for words right now and kind of pissed off.

day one: recruiter tells me the band is 110-120k, incentives, etc. on call number 1.

i interview with the hiring manager, then a panel, then:

company flew me to another state for a final round. put me up, wined and dined me whatever. did the interview with the directors and a vp of the initiative.

i get home and they offer me:

110k base, 8% annual incentive target, 10k relocation sign on.

i counter:

125k base, 10% incentive target, 15k relo, and a title change to “senior” level. and I say why and I also say my priorities are base pay and title tho… so I am closable with some work in my target areas.

they respond:

110k base, 8% incentive, no title change, but add 5k to relo… so 15k now.

i call her this time and speak to the recruiter and i say thank you, i appreciate the increase in relo, yada yada, when we first spoke you said the range was 110-120 and with my direct experience in this specific thing you guys need, and my response about my priority being focused on the base, i was surprised to not see the movement there. i understand the title change and incentive are company level based and that’s fine, but if we could align somewhere in the middle on 115.

she said “if we move it to 115 would you move forward today” I said “yes I’d be happy to sign on today”.

she called me back 30 minutes later and said they were going with another candidate and ended the call. my jaw was on the floor.


r/askrecruiters • • Nov 07 '25

My recruiter lied for me when I told them I got fired

118 Upvotes

I recently got fired a few months ago for poor performance and had a hard time looking for work. I lucked up and just got a verbal offer from a company but I had to have a conversation with the recruiter to clear things up.

When she asked me why I left my last job, I told her that I got fired for poor performance. Thinking that I was going to lose the offer, she told me that she is going to tell the company that I decided to resign from my last role to focus on entering the industry the job is focused on.

Why would a recruiter do that for a candidate? Is she not worried that the company will find out and fire both her and me?

Please recruiters, what are your thoughts?


r/askrecruiters • • Apr 01 '26

Before you use Chatgpt for an interview.....

100 Upvotes

I had a Data Science candidate that interviewed yesterday for my main client and it went horrible. She interviewed with two senior staff and they described her answers as lacking any technical understanding in addition to being "vague and winding". Please understand that using Chatgpt for or during an interview is not a secret to anyone and it a big reason people are being passed on. Use it to brush up on knowledge or as a refresher but understand that when you are using it, your speech patterns are different, conversation flow is different and managers generally know.


r/askrecruiters • • Jul 01 '26

I’m an HR generalist, and the weirdest resume pattern I keep seeing is making good candidates look average

93 Upvotes

I've been doing HR for a while now, and there's a pattern that drives me a little crazy because it's so fixable and so common: talented people writing resumes that make them sound like everyone else.

Here's what I mean. I'll get a resume from someone who clearly did great work - I can tell from the interview, from references, from what they built - but the resume itself reads like a job description. Stuff like:

  • "Responsible for managing social media accounts"

  • "Worked with cross-functional teams on projects"

  • "Handled customer inquiries and resolved issues"

None of that tells me anything. It's not wrong, it's just... invisible. Every other resume in the pile says some version of the same thing, so nothing sticks. Meanwhile the person telling me about it in an interview says something like "I grew our Instagram from 2K to 40K followers in eight months by completely rebuilding our content strategy" - and I'm sitting there thinking, why isn't THIS on the page?

A few things I think cause this:

  1. People undersell out of habit, not humility. They don't want to sound like they're bragging, so they default to neutral task-description language.

  2. They forget the reader has zero context. You know your accomplishments cold, so "improved the process" feels obvious to you. To a stranger skimming 200 resumes, it's just noise.

  3. No numbers. Even a rough estimate - "cut onboarding time by about 30%," "managed a $50K budget," "trained 15 new hires" - does more work than three sentences of description.

The fix is almost always the same: replace "responsible for X" with "did X, which resulted in Y." You don't need to be a marketing genius about it. You just need to say the actual thing that happened.

This is where getting a second pair of eyes can really help. It could be a recruiter friend, a career coach, or a service like proresumehelp. I have seen a few people use ProResumeHelp when their resume was getting almost no replies, and the improvement was pretty simple: the resume became cleaner, easier to read, and less generic.

From what I have heard, Proresumehelp is a good option if you feel stuck and do not know how to describe your experience. They are not doing anything magical. They just help organize the resume, make the bullet points stronger, and turn vague duties into something that sounds more clear and useful. Sometimes that is exactly what makes a resume work better.

I also get why people end up googling things like "best resume writing service," or "what is the best resume writing service" after months of silence. The search itself makes sense. The important part is choosing help that actually explains your experience clearly instead of stuffing the page with buzzwords.

Anyway - if you're job hunting and your resume feels "fine" but isn't getting responses, that might be exactly why. Fine is the problem.


r/askrecruiters • • Apr 02 '26

It’s been around 3 months since graduation, 120+ applications and no updates. Is my resume that bad ?

Post image
88 Upvotes

And yes, I do tailor my resume for each job role based on the job description before applying. Any sort of feedback is welcome and please be brutally honest!


r/askrecruiters • • Feb 20 '26

Help me with my resume. Over 300 applications but no interviews.

Post image
87 Upvotes

The company mentioned in professional experience that I worked for is located in India.


r/askrecruiters • • Feb 12 '26

I’m in HR for a multi billion dollar company that does not use an ATS and requires recruiters to view every application before they leave for the day. I’m here to help.

78 Upvotes

Ask me anything. As you can see from the title, we intentionally don’t use an ATS so candidates don’t “slip through the cracks”. We are required to clear our requisitions every day by before we leave (and get audited if we don’t). I’ve viewed over hundreds of thousands of resumes in my lifetime.

Fire away.

Edit: sorry, wasn’t clear. We use an ATS but we do not have any features that auto eliminate applications or “rate” best match in the system.


r/askrecruiters • • Jun 13 '26

Advice Needed: Accounting / Finance, 10 to 15 Apps a day, 8+ years of experience, No Interviews

Post image
72 Upvotes

Hi All,

I hope everyone is doing well.

I’m reaching out to the community to see if you could provide some advice on if there are some changes i should make to my resume. I’ve changed it multiple times, and still no interviews. Not even screens. So, at this point, I’m somewhat lost and I have good experience. Not sure what’s changed in the market.

Any advice would be appreciated

As the title mentions:
- 10 to 15 applications a day
- 8 years of accounting / finance in consulting
- Experience has been progressive
- The two short stints obviously an issue

Thank you in advance


r/askrecruiters • • Mar 13 '26

Applied to 500+ Jobs with no interviews, what am I doing wrong?

Post image
70 Upvotes

r/askrecruiters • • Jul 23 '26

Be honest, is the secret job market really a thing?

67 Upvotes

I met with a recruiter as a perk of a mid-career fellowship I've been doing and it felt kinda like snake oil / fear mondering to me.

According to them, resumes and cover letters mean almost nothing, and now that's even more true because of AI applications and filtering. Apparently the best jobs on the market are ones that never go through open applications at all. In the past several years since graduating I've landed multiple jobs in my sector through cold start applications, or very tangential rec's, so what they're describing hasn't been my experience, but I also haven't been in the job field since AI really took off. And I'm in no way saying networking isn't important, but do I really need to hire a recruiter to get a job after my current contract ends?


r/askrecruiters • • Mar 17 '26

Unemployed for two years. NO Calls or interviews

Post image
66 Upvotes

Hi guys,

I have been out off work since 2024. Applying everyday for two years with no call or interviews. Please help me. I need any kind of advice or help🙏


r/askrecruiters • • Mar 14 '26

Applied to 150+ jobs no responses

Thumbnail
gallery
65 Upvotes

Chat are we cooked?

My partner got laid off and we’ve been applying and haven’t had any responses from recruiters

I’ve been working since I was 15 and honestly this seems like the toughest job market we’ve had since 2008

They work more in analytics and operations but would love any advice. The 2nd image is a summary but is that needed? It’s located above the experience but feel like that might just be extra filler

Any advice is welcome 🙏


r/askrecruiters • • Jul 16 '26

How many applicants are you getting that are qualified? Is the job market really as bad as they're saying?

64 Upvotes

We all know the job market has taken a turn for the worst, but I'm curious from a recruiters perspective, what exactly are you seeing and what industry are you in? Have you noticed dramatic change in the last 2-3 years? If you're receiving hundreds of applications, are they all qualified? How many resumes appear written by AI?
I work in a highly niche/technical flow cytometry analysis role. I've hired 3 times in the last two years and received 200+ applications each time. Most were not qualified for the job, as they were IT and generic data analysis applicants. The ATS our company uses is useless, and scored candidates as A+ if they copied and pasted the job description in their resume. Of the 200+, I had about 20-30 bench scientists apply which is a much better fit for background. Obviously 20-30 good applicants is still a lot but a far cry from 100+ good applicants. Most apps on LinkedIn (at least for biotech) say 100+ applicants for every posting.

I'm curious what other people are seeing in their field.


r/askrecruiters • • Mar 09 '26

+250 job applications, 0 interviews. Any advice?

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/askrecruiters • • Jul 16 '26

I’m so fucking done with this job market. I’m tired. I’m angry. And I’m honestly at my breaking point.

60 Upvotes

I’ve spent the one half year doing nothing but applying, studying, interviewing, getting referrals, and hoping that maybe this application would finally be the one.
My parent is a manager in SAP technology. I have cousins working in IT. People assume that means getting a job is easy.
It isn’t.
Not once did any of those connections magically get me a job. Every interview I’ve attended has been on my own.
I’ve interviewed for companies like Microsoft, Guidewire, SAP Labs, American Express, and many others. Cleared rounds, failed rounds, got ghosted, got rejected. Again and again. Have got a huge list of companies i interviewed beginning from startup to fang maang
I went to Infosys training for 4 months in Mysore due to health issues i had to discontinue and come back
Then I accepted a 3-month non-IT contract job just to avoid having a huge gap on my resume. Everyone says, Don’t have a gap. Fine. I didn’t.
Now that same decision has come back to bite me.
I got a call from Volvo. The recruiter told me that because I have three months of experience and a PF account they can’t consider me for a fresher position. Apparently I’m no longer a fresher… but I don’t have enough experience to qualify for experienced roles either.
What kind of bullshit is this?
So I’m not fresh enough for freshers.
I’m not experienced enough for experienced hiring.
I’m stuck in the most ridiculous fucking limbo imaginable.
People keep saying, Just keep applying.
To what? Companies that ghost candidates? Companies that reject you in minutes without even looking? Recruiters who disappear after asking for documents? Systems that reject you because you have too little experience or too much experience?
I’m doing everything people tell graduates to do.
Learn new skills.
Build projects.
Network.
Take referrals.
Prepare for interviews.
Don’t have a gap.
And somehow every decision becomes the wrong decision.
I’m exhausted. I’m angry. I’m tired of pretending that hard work always pays off because sometimes it just fucking doesn’t.
I don’t want sympathy.
I just want this broken hiring system to make some fucking sense.


r/askrecruiters • • Jul 28 '26

Message to recruiters and companies

59 Upvotes

Applied to a job at 8:50pm. Woke up to a rejection. “Your application was carefully considered.”

Different job, different week. Applied Friday evening after work, rejection landed Sunday. Same exact line.

Nobody is carefully considering anything overnight or on a weekend. Something ran a keyword check, and a template did the rest.

Honestly the automated part doesn’t bother me. Companies have to filter volume somehow, and I’d rather get a fast no than wait three weeks to hear nothing.

What bothers me is the phrase. It’s pretending a person sat down and read my application at 8am the next day, or on a Sunday. Nobody did.
If a system rejected me, say a system rejected me.


r/askrecruiters • • Jun 11 '26

2.10 years of experience applied 250+ jobs no callback what am i doing wrong

Post image
56 Upvotes

I've been applying for Software Engineer roles for quite a while now and I'm honestly feeling stuck.

I've revised my resume multiple times, updated my profiles, and applied to hundreds of jobs, but I'm barely getting any interview calls. At this point, I'm wondering if there's something fundamentally wrong with my resume that I'm not seeing.

Would anyone be willing to take a look and give me some honest feedback? I'm completely open to constructive criticism. I just want to understand what I can improve and stop spinning my wheels.

Thanks in advance.


r/askrecruiters • • Mar 06 '26

Just graduated. Ready to mass apply. Your honest thoughts?

Post image
56 Upvotes

Thank you in advance.


r/askrecruiters • • Sep 08 '26

Are recruiters really facing a problem regarding finding good candidates?

53 Upvotes

Do recruiters actually experience a significant problem when trying to find qualified candidates, and how costly or time-consuming is this problem for them?


r/askrecruiters • • Mar 13 '26

Hiring managers: what are the biggest green and red flags on LinkedIn profiles?

48 Upvotes

I see a lot of advice about optimizing our LinkedIn profiles have the right headlines, banners, posting consistently etc. But most of that advice comes from creators, not the people actually hiring. So I’m curious recruiters and hiring managers, what do you actually notice when you look at someone’s LinkedIn profile?

What stands out the most, and what are some common red flags people should avoid?


r/askrecruiters • • May 25 '26

100+ Applications, less than 4 interviews - anything I can improve?

Post image
45 Upvotes

Granted, I’m applying within an extremely competitive field (Customer Success), but this is now the fourth iteration of my optimized resume and I still haven’t seen much improvement in traction.

So far, I’ve:

  • Removed the profile/summary section, since most recruiters mentioned it isn’t necessary for mid-level roles

  • Reduced overall wording to make the resume easier to skim quickly

  • Reworked bullet points to lead with measurable results rather than responsibilities

  • Kept the resume to a single page, since that still seems to be the standard for candidates below the Director level


r/askrecruiters • • Jul 14 '26

Getting no interviews, Looking for entry IT jobs

Post image
44 Upvotes

So this resume gets no callbacks at all. I know it is bad and applying to what feels like near 100 jobs with no interviews really tells it.

I'm looking for entry level IT jobs such as help desk mainly to break into IT and gain some experience. Sometimes I would try for data science or data entry jobs and adjust the skills section to be more aligned for those roles, but again still no interviews. The resume is basic but that is mainly because i don't have much experience and what is on the resume is all I have so I'm not sure how to add more.

Any feedback is appreciated I just would like some insight from people who know this stuff since most resume builders are ai and tend to give not good results so anything helps.


r/askrecruiters • • Jul 29 '26

Just graduated, been told my resume looks good but I have gotten 0 interviews. Looking for anything software or coding related

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/askrecruiters • • Sep 17 '26

Are interviewers ever actually surprised when you are interviewing at other places?

42 Upvotes

I'm getting late stage in some interview processes and the interviewers would ask or I would naturally tell them I am interviewing with other companies as well. It's the truth. I've gotten replies like "oh course you are chatting with others" and "I would be surprised if you're not" ​​and "I wouldn't expect otherwise" Is it that normal? lol