r/askmusicians • • Aug 14 '25

Wtf is music theory

1 Upvotes

so I’ve bought a new guitar and I’m trying to learn guitar using music theory.

I’ve done my best to learn music theory through the Pentatonic scale or different chords or trying to figure out other scales but I have no idea what I’m doing, even when I play on the Pentatonic scale I just don’t know what I’m doing. I’m just pressing my fingers where it’s supposed to go.

wtf are chord progressions, how does the notes on a guitar work ?? on a piano it’s linear but on the guitar it’s so weird.

i’ve tried looking at videos or stuff but it’s genuinely hard to understand when adds keep popping up or when some people gatekeep knowledge for their online courses.

please if you have tips, tricks or know the order of things i’ve got to learn let me know.


r/askmusicians • • Sep 12 '26

Why do you think we don't have a "The way you are" by Bruno Mars equivalent but written by a heterosexual woman and directed at men/a man she is dating?

2 Upvotes

And I mean from that "you are an absolute square but I love you being a square", and not "loving you despite you being a square" tone/framing. I am curious why it seems that level of vulnerability to love a very unremarkable man only shows up when citing regrets in break up songs as an almost insult. But with male authored songs aimed at straight women living an unremarkable lady for being unremarkable is the meta.

And please note I love unremarkable people more than remarkable ones, as I am an absolute cardboard myself. I'm just curious


r/askmusicians • • Aug 29 '25

Which instrument is the easiest to learn?

1 Upvotes

r/askmusicians • • Sep 13 '26

Will I ever make it into the music industry?

0 Upvotes

I’m a teenage male but I have no musical talent in any instrument whatsoever. But I am realizing my voice is actually quite good in singing since I’ve been training for about a year since at first my friends rated my covers a 5-6/10 but now this year they rate it a 7-8/10. I know there’s a lot of artists that were like me and actually made it, for example d4vd didn’t know how to play any instruments or anything but he had his voice and created covers on different songs and searched up “indie type beat songs”, which I think I can do! (I don’t support d4vd at all anymore)


r/askmusicians • • Sep 03 '25

Why are so many musicians full of themselves?

0 Upvotes

I'm young, but I've already met many musicians, artists, singers, and a large portion of them are very arrogant, perhaps the majority. I have heard many times musicians who really believed they were someone important, had huge egos, and constantly tried to crush others. Is this just a symptom of stupidity, or is there a reason behind it? It seems absurd to me that so many people really believe they are the best of the best


r/askmusicians • • 25d ago

Do you have to study before becoming a professional musician?

0 Upvotes

Hey there! I'm new here... I'm 17 and my goal and dream is to become a professional drummer. I know that you obviously need skill to do so. But another important factor is connections.

But staying on skill side: Do you really have to study music at a university or something like that to do this as a job. Because nobody in a band asks wether you studied your instrument, right? They just want to have a good drummer and imo becoming one is also possible without studying.

Obviously I know the other advantages of studying (second instrument, music theory, ...).

Just wonder how you guys think about that.

(I'm not talking about orchestra and classical music, I'm talking about anything in pop.)


r/askmusicians • • Jun 01 '25

hey guys please help me out here, what is the meaning of " bar " and " key " in music, mainly hip hop

2 Upvotes

i dont understand what people mean when they ask what key is your beat in or anything related to bar and stuff

like i j create stuff that sounds good to me and have enough space for rapping and singing, so what is the meaning of it? can someone please explain me like m 5 or sumn


r/askmusicians • • Jan 20 '26

What do you guys think of this list of the “50 best musicians of all time” according to “global statistics” I wasn’t born to watch a lot of these legends while they were in their prime.

0 Upvotes

r/askmusicians • • Sep 30 '26 Bravo

When should I actually start learning music theory?(short sample of my recent projects for reference)

3 Upvotes

So almost 1 year has passed since i started producing and unlike most i had little to no problems creating chords by ear (i was diagnosed with perfect pitch back when i was 6 or something, that’s probably why) but i wonder if im missing out on something because i dont know theory. Also somedays pr weeks i cant come up with any melodies and i think knowing music theory would help becayse of the chord progressions(at least to get inspired). Should i start learning and would it make my songs less creative?(if they are)


r/askmusicians • • Mar 16 '26

Where do you think the line is between inspiration and cultural appropriation in music?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately and I keep going back and forth on it....

Music history is full of people borrowing from other cultures. Blues feeding into rock. Jazz shaping pop. Hip hop built around sampling and re-working existing sounds. Music has always travelled between people, places and communities.

At the same time, we hear more conversations now about cultural appropriation in music.

So I keep wondering, where do people actually draw the line?

What does cultural appropriation mean to you as a musician? If you were explaining it to someone outside music, how would you describe it? Is it mainly about copying a sound or style? Or is it more about power, credit and who benefits?

Are there examples where you’ve thought that crosses the line?
Who benefited , who didn’t? Do you think intention matters?

I also wonder about the role of the music industry in all of this...

Does the industry sometimes reward certain versions of culture more than others? Do certain voices get amplified while the people who originally created the sound remain less visible?

And then there’s technology. Music now moves around the world incredibly fast. Sounds, styles and ideas can travel globally almost instantly. Do you think technology has made cultural borrowing easier? And when music spreads that quickly, does some of the original cultural context get lost?

Curious how musicians here think about this, because it feels like one of those topics where the answers are rarely simple.


r/askmusicians • • Dec 28 '25

i wanna write a song in every country in the world and make a documentary series around it to get back history behind the music

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/askmusicians • • Jan 11 '26

How do you handle that craving for success?

0 Upvotes

And please don’t say the “make music for yourself” speech I’ve heard it way too many times that I’m being driven slowly insane. I make rock music, I have learned multiple genres, I have a day job at a Burger King (please kill me) and I keep trying to find a good research for like modern musicians that aren’t pop, rap, K-pop and from America. Cause unfortunately we have no actual successful rock artists here. And if I hear another person say “what about mäneskin” cause we don’t have a Eurovision here so no way of spreading the name out there. Yes I use social media, I’m consistent, I am trying my best to be unique and I have merch. I know you all want to be famous and you can’t prove me wrong with how many of you say the “I make music for myself”.


r/askmusicians • • 15d ago

They could not tell I was playing

3 Upvotes

So I am active in the classic car community and have a decent PA in the trunk of my car. I decided to try and play live with guitar from the PA at a meet yesterday. I played against backing tracks I had prepared. I talked to people afterwards. A spontaneous question I got like 10 times was "But did you play for real?" Like omg off course.

So not sure what to do. The tracks have original vocals but no guitar. I guess I play it well enough that it sounds like the original guitar, which is a good thing. The setlist is heavily guitar focused with bands like ACDC, GnR, Mötley etc. So that cannot be the issue. The guitar was set to play louder than in the original mix.

The guitar has a wireless setup which I guess adds to the illusion of not playing, but would rather not play with a cable.

Not sure what to do? Maybe backing tracks far different than the originals would make people not assume I am not playing? Putting in parts with guitar improvisation between tracks? Anyone else who had this problem?


r/askmusicians • • 21d ago

What is the deal with country music hate?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I need some opinions on the country music lovers of today...my gf and some of my friends absolutely hate country music, and I try and introduce them to the classics (Hank Williams, Brooks and Dunn, Alan Jackson, George Strait, yada yada...), but they still think it's all about whiskey and women. Help reddit people!


r/askmusicians • • Feb 24 '26

What exactly is a “take” when recording music?

5 Upvotes

Hi all!

I am a huge fan of rock music (mainly 70’s and 80’s era). One question I have always wonder is what is considered a “take” when recording music? I am asking because I have heard in interviews from a few bands things like “What you hear on the record is the first take we ever did” and “we actually never even rehearsed the song together…Phil, the producer got us into the studio and just hit the record button and then magic just happened”…huh?…. How could that be happen if they never practiced the song?


r/askmusicians • • Sep 15 '26

2 hour practice???

1 Upvotes

We have a brand-new worship leader—let’s call her Happiness. For some background, Happiness is primarily a singer. She doesn’t play an instrument and doesn’t have much knowledge of chords, music theory, or the technical side of leading a band. There have already been several situations where the band has become frustrated because some of the decisions she’s made seem to come from not fully understanding how the musical side of the team works.
Now, Happiness has changed our practice schedule without consulting the band or asking for anyone’s input. She wants the band members to practice for two hours, with the singers coming in an hour after the band starts. During that first hour, the band is expected to go through the set twice. She has also said that if a band member doesn’t come to both hours, they won’t be allowed to play on Sunday.
Am I crazy for being upset about this? Is this a normal way for a worship team to operate, or am I just uneducated about how these things are usually handled?
My biggest issue honestly isn’t even the extra practice time itself. It’s the lack of consideration and communication. If she had talked to the team beforehand, asked about everyone’s schedules, and worked with us to find a practice time that made sense, I would feel very differently about it. Instead, it feels like a decision was made for the entire team without actually involving the team.
Most of our band members are pretty young and work crazy hours. We’re also all volunteers, while Happiness is the only person who is paid. So I’m struggling with the idea that she can unilaterally add an additional hour of required rehearsal and essentially tell volunteers that if they can’t accommodate it, they won’t be allowed to serve on Sunday.
I genuinely want you to be brutally honest with me. Am I wrong for being upset about this? Is this actually a reasonable expectation for a worship team, and if it isn’t, what would be the right way to address it without creating unnecessary conflict?


r/askmusicians • • Dec 10 '21

Is there any musically complicated artist who can actually write good lyrics at the moment?

1 Upvotes

I've been spending the last month or two binging a lot of funk/jazz music lately. And i just can't find an artist who's both musically literate AND a lyricist.

Something along the lines of vulfpeck, silk sonic, dirty loops, snarky puppy.... but with competant lyrics.

The closest I've got is 'Beatenberg' who are an excellent south african band with amazing lines all over the place. But there's surely more than one band capable of this right?!?!


r/askmusicians • • Jul 10 '26

how do you make it as a songwriter????

0 Upvotes

I’m 16 and songwriting is probably the biggest passion I have. The problem is I can’t sing.
I’ve written a song that I’m actually really proud of. I made some of beats and since I don’t have a singer nor can I sing. I used AI to sing the lyrics It honestly turned out way better than I expected and I genuinely think it sounds good and something I would actually listen to on a day-to-day basis
The thing I’m struggling with is figuring out what to do next. How do people actually get songs into production? How do songwriters who aren’t singers find artists to work with? Is there a realistic path for someone my age, or am I getting ahead of myself?
I’m not saying I’m some amazing songwriter!!!! but I know this is something I truly lovee and I want to keep getting better. I just don’t know where to start or how to turn this dream into something real.
If anyone has advice I’d really appreciate it. And if you’d be interested in hearing the AI song with my original lyrics and giving honest feedback let me know. I’d love to hear what you think.

Thank youuu


r/askmusicians • • Jun 15 '26

I got ragebaited and now I'm doubting myself

0 Upvotes

Online argument on discord that I don't need settled there, but I want y'all's opinions here. Topic: The key of a song/piece does not matter. Unless you have perfect pitch, it doesn't even make a noticeable difference. I've transposed songs before, to make it possible for me to sing them or easier to play on guitar. Person online responded with "you aren't a musician, are you?" The original argument he(?) was making was that Indie Boyz by Pacifica could not have been based on Bailando by Paradisio because "they aren't even in the same key"

Is his argument actually valid? Is there like a genre or an instrument where that argument makes sense? Thx in advance


r/askmusicians • • Apr 18 '26

Joni Mitchell

0 Upvotes

I wanna write a song like Joni Mitchell I don’t ever know how to have such great vocabulary like for example, Alanis Morissette Taylor Swift, Olivia Rodrigo I feel like all of their songwriting is very like intelligent and I feel that way about Joni Mitchell and I really want us to write a song like all of them


r/askmusicians • • Jan 23 '25

How does adding "trap" elements a song make it any better?

0 Upvotes

It is really infuriating when a song has a nice melody just for it to be ruined electronic hi-hats spread across the entire length. Is there a justifiable reason to ruin music with trap trap sounds to appeal the lowest common denominator?

Listening to these songs with headphones, the trap sounds are ear stabbing, I feel like songs with trap sounds are meant to be blasted over a speaker. Should songs have the additional trap sounds to it are the melody is good enough?

Example trap reference sample: samplefocus samples/trap-closed-hi-hats

The songs in question:

  1. ミツキヨ (Mitsukiyo) / Candy Dreamy (18 seconds in)

  2. Seycara / Butterfly Bossa (20 seconds in)

  3. Potsu / Bossa Uh (14 seconds in)


r/askmusicians • • Apr 28 '26

Is playing two shows in two days a no go?

0 Upvotes

My band played our first show yesterday and our set caught the attention of some guys in a band, so they asked us to play a show with them the 15th. We said of course since were taking any gig thrown at us. Today we got asked for play a gig with other bands on the 16th. That means wed play two shows two days in a row… It feels odd since ive never seen a local band do it. Should i say no to the offer?


r/askmusicians • • Mar 01 '26

Which is a good place to start a punk band Seattle or florida, I need your help

0 Upvotes

After I graduate I plan to move to one of these places and start a punk band, which cities in Florida are good places to start a punk band