r/askmusic • • Sep 13 '26

Iconic song, dumb-as-bricks lyrics

0 Upvotes

My pick: Smoke on the Water. One of the great rock hooks of all time and the lyrics are like a story a boring guy tells at a party

Edited to say, really shocked at how many downvotes I'm getting for this opinion, ha ha ha. I'm allowed to poke fun at a 54 year old song about a casino fire where nobody was hurt that uses the word "stupid" as a noun.


r/askmusic • • Sep 27 '25

Who’s on your Mount Rushmore of the Greatest Black Rock Singers of All Time?

Post image
0 Upvotes

My Mount Rushmore of the Greatest Black Rock Singers of All Time are:

Chuck Berry 🇺🇸

Lajon Witherspoon (Sevendust)🇺🇸

Corey Glover (Living Colour)🇺🇸

Brittany Howard (Alabama Shakes and Solo)🇺🇸


r/askmusic • • Apr 10 '26

Madonna is overrated

5 Upvotes

I don't understand what people liked about her. I don't find anything she's done particularly impressive. Especially in the last two decades, when her creativity and quality declined significantly (by more than 70%).

It's not that I deny her success or the causes and consequences of what she did as an artist, especially in the '80s.

I know she pioneered women’s sexual liberation and all that, but really—do people actually like vulgarity and obscenity? Seriously? Do they see that as art? Going out on stage half-naked, faking orgasms, masturbating, and stuff like that? There’s nothing artistic about that. It’s just cheap controversy, which Madonna pulled off very well and which other artists, out of naivety, have copied. (It’s no coincidence that her album *Erotica* was a total commercial flop at the time.) And especially her latest albums, where in several songs she only talks about sex. There’s no depth or seriousness in her lyrics.

I don’t deny that she has good songs and videos like *Like a Virgin*, *La Isla Bonita*, *Vogue*, *Like a Prayer*, and *Hung Up*. But we should thank not Madonna, but the costume designers, the fashion designers, the stylists, and the directors. Because I don’t think Madonna created or designed the iconic Jean Paul Gaultier outfit herself, nor her costumes or hairstyles, and many of her videos are the magic of the director and producer, not her. She just puts her face on it. Furthermore, many of her outfits, hairstyles, and dance moves—including singles featuring outright copies of other famous artists, especially from Hollywood’s golden age—with Marilyn Monroe being the most obvious example. We can also highlight Greta Garbo, John Travolta, Elvis Presley, Aretha Franklin, etc.—the list goes on.

Madonna was popular because of the exact time and context, since MTV was the one that launched her artistic career by being a novelty and grabbing attention with controversy and sex, copying other artists, and with the help of good producers, directors, and costume designers. But without them, Madonna wouldn’t be who she is today; if another artist had been in her place, we might also have someone different as the queen of pop. Madonna was simply in the right place at the right time with the right people. Would Madonna have made it big without MTV?


r/askmusic • • Nov 08 '25

Why are Black People Underrepresented in Rock Music when they created Rock Music?

0 Upvotes

Racism


r/askmusic • • Jul 23 '26

Has anyone actually met a ZZ Top fan?

0 Upvotes

I was listening to a classic rock station on my drive home from work and they played "Legs", and it got me to thinking about how I've never met a diehard ZZ Top fan in my life. Do they exist?

Don't get me wrong, I don't hate the band, I just think that their fame was largely due to the fact that their persona was gimmicky. Every song I know of theirs (all 3 of them) have pretty much the same sound and tempo.

So if you happen to be a diehard ZZ Top fan, could you recommend a few songs that'll make me say, "Wow, that's ZZ Top? I never would've guessed."


r/askmusic • • Sep 06 '25

Why do music snobs hate popular songs so much

1 Upvotes

I swear every time I mention liking something thats actually on the radio or has millions of streams, theres always that one person who goes "oh you dont know REAL music" or starts lecturing me about some obscure band from the 70s that nobody cares about anymore.

Like sorry I enjoy catchy hooks and production that doesnt sound like it was recorded in someones garage? Why is accessibility automatically bad in music? Some of the most popular songs became popular because theyre genuinely good, not just because of marketing.

Am I wrong for thinking that music elitists are just gatekeeping for no reason? What made you guys realize that popular doesnt always mean bad?


r/askmusic • • Jul 12 '26

Can we stop with the Taylor Swift overrated posts?!?!

18 Upvotes

And let’s talk about everyone’s last addition to their music collection, either vinyl, cassette, or CD? Also what you last saved onto your music streaming service?

I’ll go first:

March of the Pigs EP (UK) - Nine Inch Nails (CD)

Fixed EP - Nine Inch Nails (CD)

Got these a week or so ago.


r/askmusic • • Mar 21 '26

Who do you think was the better performer: Michael Jackson or Prince?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/askmusic • • Aug 10 '26

Most overrated band/singer?

22 Upvotes

For me it’s Michael Jackson


r/askmusic • • Nov 08 '25

Do you agree that we need more All Black Rock Bands Yes or No and Why?

0 Upvotes

Yes


r/askmusic • • Aug 22 '26

What is a bands “jumped the shark” moment

11 Upvotes

I don’t want to bag on a band for changing direction. But sometimes a band is so Solid for a long time and you hit a song that doesn’t work.
What comes to mind is “the boy with a thorn in his side” from the smiths compilation in the 80s with a lot of good songs like “Panic”.

No post like Swift sucks so bad after X album, just a song mention.


r/askmusic • • Aug 10 '26

Which music artist do you think has more songs that are famous/iconic across multiple generations The Beatles or Michael Jackson?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Tough question I’d love to hear you guys answers.


r/askmusic • • Apr 09 '26

I hate people who say modern music is trash. Send over some songs that prove these stuck-in-the-past oldheads wrong

15 Upvotes

r/askmusic • • Mar 14 '26

Why does Billie Eilish sing in a whisper?

24 Upvotes

I mean, in a lot of songs, it sounds like she’s too lazy to sing—like she’s just whispering, with no energy, like when you’ve just woken up and you’re still half-asleep and your head hurts, or something like that. Why can’t she just sing normally?


r/askmusic • • Sep 22 '26

Best song ever made.?

0 Upvotes

r/askmusic • • Apr 06 '26

I love rap. People rave about Biggie. From the few singles I've heard, I just don't get it. Suggest some songs to change my mind?

0 Upvotes

I dare you


r/askmusic • • Feb 07 '26

Who never had a decent album again after releasing their biggest one?"

13 Upvotes

I was recommended to post this here. Whether it was their first album (1 hit wonder) or their 10th, who completely dropped in quality/popularity after their biggest hit album?

An obvious one seems to be Guns n Roses, as they could never match the acclaim of their debut.

EDIT: okay, GNR is a bad example, as many of you have pointed out. Maybe something like Green Day, who haven't had much relevance since American Idiot.


r/askmusic • • Jul 10 '26

What happened to “toughness” in rock and roll?

20 Upvotes

I’m gonna try to phrase this as best as I can- even at the risk of getting downvoted into oblivion :)

I’m a huge fan of guitar music, rock and roll, and the history of rock and roll. I love so many artists both old and new, and before you flame this post for being too boomer in taste, I should mention that there are indeed so many new(ish) artists that I love- Beck and Courtney Barnett are two of my current favorites.

However, there is an archetype of the tough, perhaps even “dangerous”, rock and roller that I really miss. Some of my favorites are Lou Reed, Keith Richards, Joni Mitchell, Bob Dylan, Chrissie Hynde, Paul Weller, Mark Knopfler, Noel/Liam Gallagher, Alice Cooper (very theatrical, but I love the early stuff), Mick Ronson.

Some of these, especially Lou, Bob, and Mark, were the “strong silent type”- another archetype I love. Kinda like Gary Cooper in those old westerns.

So my question is- what happened to this archetype? Where is it? I don’t see it anywhere in modern rock. Never mind that imo rock is not the same as rock and roll and nowadays there’s lots of rock but very little roll, but that’s a separate discussion….

There’s a great quote by Alice Cooper about Vampire Weekend where he basically calls them “wimpy”- kinda mean but I do agree!

And I do want to emphasize that I don’t think it’s just the slow decline of misogynistic rock (though of course that’s probably part of it). So many of my favorite artists who I consider “tough” are women! Joni Mitchell, Aretha Franklin, Grace Slick, Nina Simone, just to name a few.

Anyway, I hope my question is clear, and I’d be curious to hear any thoughts, particularly from the history buffs.


r/askmusic • • Oct 06 '26

Why is today's music more... accepted than popular music was in the late 90s to early 2010s?

1 Upvotes

Nobody's gonna read this because attention spans seem to have shrunk but oh well.

Just earlier I saw a tweet of an article that Todd Rundgren bashing Taylor Swift for "ruining music" and the comments universally dunked on him. It reminded me of when Gene Simmons said BTS wigonnall never be the Beatles, and everyone in the comment section was jumping on it.

Have you noticed... popular music today seems to get a LOT more respect than it used to?

Rock musicians and fans used to constantly openly diss on acts like the New Kids On The Block, Backstreet Boys, N Sync, Britney Spears and Justin Bieber.

There used to be very violent anti pop merch like "New Kids On The Chopping Block", "Spear Britney", and tons of games where you get to kill the Backstreet Boys and Justin Bieber online. People would act like this teenager went back in time and killed JFK all because he sang some annoying pop songs, before he ever pissed in a mop bucket. Same with Miley Cyrus and One Direction to a slightly lesser degree.

But now, saying any of this against a current pop star makes you look like a douchebag. I grew up as a 2001 baby hating Justin Bieber, Miley, and One Direction, but I have seen plenty of videos of the late 90s of Eminem, Limp Bizkit and Slipknot bashing on pop stars. Every edgy rock or rap show at the time had at least one “Fuck pop music“ bit, it seemed like. I watched a video of the Offspring's singer beating up mannequins of the Backstreet Boys while the crowd cheered it on and realized this attitude had been going on for years. But if you do this NOW to say, Olivia Rodrigo, Harry Styles, or even Taylor Swift, it just looks... corny, performative and kind of mean spirited. People don't say "Fuck Sabrina Carpenter, she fucking sucks" because... I guess they realized it makes you look kinda like a douchebag. They just say "Sabrina Carpenter is mid" or "she's overrated". Compared to how people USED to talk about pop stars... those are practically raves!

When I saw Metallica in 2023, I saw a dude in an Eras Tour shirt. I thought he was brave... and I also thought it was kind of funny. Because even 10 years ago he would have been laughed at for wearing a Taylor Swift shirt at a metal show. Now universities are holding courses based around Taylor Swift's music. She’s the only one I still OCCASIONALLY see this sort of shit with..probably because she’s way bigger than the other artists I mentioned but even then a lot of the hate I see for her just feels almost… corny. It USED to be cool but now it’s just… lame.

My professor told me that when the New Kids On The Block were a thing, people in his high school literally held destruction nights where guests were encouraged to bring an album or tape or poster or some such to be offered up for a bonfire - he went to one. While their intentions were sincere, the people holding these events didn't grasp that they were actually feeding the beast by creating sales for Hanging Tough. Ironic.

I could NEVER imagine doing this now. When I was like 12, I used to print out Justin Bieber and One Direction pictures and paste them on a punching bag and beat them up. Meanwhile, the memes on the most recent teen phenomenon, BTS, were centered around how obnoxious their FANBASE was. Nobody actually hated their music or the group itself. Even though they took a page out of the Bieber/One Direction playbook- feminine men who sing and dance and appeal mostly to preteen girls. Even the memes about the fans... were less about "killing them" (I legit used to see people make memes about how Beliebers and Directioners should die) and more a jokey fear of "Oh god, Kpop stans! Run for your lives!" I saw a video of 2011 Chris Jericho crushing a radio playing a Justin Bieber song while the audience chanted "CRUSH IT". Can you imagine someone doing this with a BTS or Harry Styles song in public nowadays? He'd get torn apart to shreds. Joking about killing Justin Bieber was cool and edgy and celebrated.

But joking about killing, say Taylor Swift or whoever nowadays just makes you look like a loser. It was one thing to say “Justin Bieber sucks”. That’s fine. His early music DID kinda suck. But then it became “Justin Bieber is an F-slur, kill him, I hope he dies.” This was BEFORE he peed in a mop bucket or whatever. It was literally just because: high voice + pretty face + mostly female fans. That mapped to “not a real man,” and people (especially guys) were allowed, culturally, to go feral at that. That was the joke.

Avril Lavigne, who got a lot of shit too for being a “poser” back when people always used that word for some reason ("You like Good Charlotte? You're a POSER who doesn't like REAL music!") was marketed as the “Anti-Britney”. Same with Michelle Branch and Vanessa Carlton. Being the “Anti-Britney” was a whole sub genre. Try marketing an artist as the “Anti Taylor” or the “Anti Sabrina” now and it looks… archaic. It’s almost like we just live and let live now.

Like of course you can say "people hate Taylor Swift, it's not like people don't hate popular music today". That's not exactly the same thing as what I'm talking about. People don't say "GIVE US BACK FREDDIE MERCURY TAKE TAYLOR SWIFT", nor are major artists beating up mannequins with her face taped on it.

And of course we can't forget the half meme hatred of Nickelback and Creed but that has faded and somewhat replaced with the meme hatred of Imagine Dragons and Ed Sheeran...that's pretty much the last example. Even then, the hate for Imagine Dragons was never nearly as big or irrational as the hate for Creed and Nickelback were. People insult you to this day for listening to those bands, but if you listen to Imagine Dragons? Ehh… Memes about Nickelback were about how they supposedly made "the worst music ever" and how people who like them are the scum of the earth. Memes about Imagine Dragons center around the fact that they're the musical equivalent of plain grits. Even MARK ZUCKERBERG got in on the Nickelback hate. They got booed at a halftime show. There were literally petitions to stop them from performing in certain places and nobody cared because "Nickelback sucks!" Because apparently music isn't subjective. That NEVER happened to Imagine Dragons who were just as overplayed in their time as Nickelback were in theirs.

Are things now the best they’ve ever been? Is popular music today actually just BETTER? It might be. Maybe music might be even worse now, we just don’t have the energy? Or maybe it’s none of that and it’s about US?

Part of me likes the fact that being an asshole about popular music seems to have gone the way of edgy atheism, but I wonder what killed this?


r/askmusic • • Apr 21 '26

Do you guys think it’s wrong to still be a fan of Michael Jackson?

0 Upvotes

The King of pop is a polarizing figure to say the least. I mean rather you think he’s innocent or guilty of the allegations his impact on music, fashion, music videos, dance moves, etc… can’t be understated. He’s one of the most iconic people to ever live, but there’s still a lot of HORRIBLE HORRIBLE allegations on his name. Which makes him very controversial. So what do yall think is it cool to be a fan of him or should he be a no go?


r/askmusic • • Aug 18 '26

Cover’s that aren’t needed

0 Upvotes

What song/s have been covered by other bands that you find absolutely no reason why it was needed?

Having to listen to Heart at work, I constantly hear the recent covers of Tracy Chapman’s ‘Fast Car’ and Toploader’s ‘Dancing In The Moonlight’ and wonder why these were done. There’s many others to list, but these two stand out daily.

What covers do you find really weren’t needed?


r/askmusic • • Sep 05 '25

Does anyone else get annoyed when artists change their sound?

1 Upvotes

I've been listening to this one band since their first album and they just dropped something completely different. Like, I fell in love with their original vibe and now it feels like they're chasing trends instead of staying true to what made them special.

Is it fair to expect artists to stick with what works, or should I just accept that they need to evolve? Sometimes I wonder if I'm being too nostalgic or if other fans feel this betrayed when their favorite musicians switch genres entirely.

What's the most dramatic style change that actually worked out for an artist?


r/askmusic • • Oct 14 '26

What is the greatest album ever recorded?

18 Upvotes

I'm talking great, like both ICONIC, BRILLIANT and REALLY GOOD SONGS. It doesn't necessarily be one of the most famous albums ever


r/askmusic • • Sep 14 '26

Do any of you genuinely enjoy Angine de Poitrine?

354 Upvotes

To me it sounds like cartoon fart noises with a drumbeat, and I suspect that a lot of the fans are just performatively pretending to like the music.


r/askmusic • • Aug 30 '26

Have I seen more iconic guitarists in concert than you? I’ll give my list you give yours

2 Upvotes

Vivian Campbell, Joe Perry, Jimmy Page, Joe Walsh, Jeff Beck, Eric Clapton, Robert Fripp, Ritchie Blackmore, Keith Richards, David Gilmour, Pete Townsend, Tony Iommi, Slash, Dimebag Darrel, Larry LaLonde, Trey Anastasio, Jerry Cantrell, Adam Jones, Kim Thayil, Eddie Van Halen, Joe Satriani, Dickey Bettes, Warren Haynes, Buddy Guy, Les Paul, James Burton, Chuck Berry, Dick Dale, Dave Navarro, Peter Distefano, Josh Homme, Carlos Santana, John Fogerty, Robbie Robertson, Kirk Hammett, James Hetfield, Ted Nugent, Randy Bachman, Alex Lifeson, Mike McCready, Jack White, Willie Nelson, Buckethead, Neil Young, Robin Trower, Zack Wylde, Dave Davies, George Thorogood, Angus Young, KK and Glenn from Priest, Derick Trucks, Nancy Wilson, Steve Cropper, Vernon Reid, Albert Collins, Ben Harper, Joe Bonamasso, Mick Ralphs, Paul McCartney, Buck Dharma