r/askmath • • 1d ago

Algebra The Impossible Intersection

Guys, I looked at this problem for 2 hours, but it just seems impossible. The wording is also confusing: I don't really understand what the question means with "exactly ONE point". Anyone have an idea on how to solve it?

Consider the two functions:

f(x) = x² + 1

g(x) = mx + 2

where m is a real number.

Find a value of m such that the two graphs intersect at exactly ONE point, even though neither graph is tangent to the other in the usual way.

Can you find such an m and prove that it works?

11 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

11

u/LucaThatLuca Graduate 1d ago edited 1d ago

“Exactly ONE point” means the number of points is 1. Note this is to the exclusion of the other possible numbers of points, 0 and 2.

It is indeed impossible. Any (non-vertical) line that passes through the middle of a parabola has to cross it on both sides (i.e. exactly twice). Alternatively, x^2 + 1 = mx + 2 is a quadratic equation and you can use the discriminant to easily check it has exactly 2 solutions.

2

u/Impossible-Border383 1d ago

Thanks for confirming that it's impossible Luca!

3

u/StoicTheGeek 1d ago

Every line will intersect a parabola at exactly two points, by Bézout’s theorem. (If you look at it the right way - OP was quite vague with the question).

3

u/Throwaway-Pot 1d ago

This is only true if:

-The varieties are over an algebraically closed field like C. In R, you can have no intersections at all.

-The intersections have to be over projective space, since usual affine space misses intersections at infinity. Consider two parallel lines.

-More importantly than all, this is up to multiplicity. A line can be tangent to a parabola and have a ‘single point’ intersection

1

u/StoicTheGeek 7h ago

Thanks for spelling it out - I was too lazy. There’s just something about Bézout’s theorem that I find enormously satisfying. It feels like all is right with the world that this should be the case.

2

u/Throwaway-Pot 6h ago

I agree!

9

u/DrakeSavory 1d ago edited 1d ago

Proof that the line intersects the parabola in 2 points

Set the two functions equal to each other: x2 + 1 = mx + 2

Set equal to 0: x2 - mx - 1 = 0

Calculate the discriminate: D = √(m2 + 4)

Notice this is always positive so when you solve for the x-coordinate of the point of intersection and you calculate (m ± D) ÷ 2 you will get two different solutions meaning the line and the parabola intersect in two different points.

2

u/FireCire7 1d ago

Are you sure it isn’t y=mx-2 ? 

1

u/bluesam3 1d ago

This does not change the impossibility.

2

u/FireCire7 1d ago

Yes it does - it puts the point the line is going through to (0,-2) which is now outside of the parabola. This lets tangent line y=2sqrt(3)x-2 be tangent to x2 +1 at (sqrt(3),4) (there’s also one with slope -2sqrt(3)). 

1

u/bluesam3 1d ago

You didn't read the question, did you?

3

u/FireCire7 1d ago

Ahh, I guess I had missed the part where it explicitly said not tangent in the usual way. In that case, my example doesn’t work, since it would be in the usual way, but that just makes it an extremely poorly done question since I can’t think of any simple variations that would let it have a non-contradictory answer. 

1

u/bluesam3 1d ago

Yeah, it's certainly a terrible question.

1

u/johnpeters42 1d ago

At best, it was intended as a trick question, and asked "Can you _____" on purpose (because the correct answer to that is "no, and here's why not").

2

u/dpb365 1d ago edited 1d ago

If you set the functions equal to each other you get: x2 + 1 = mx + 2 -> x2 - mx - 1 = 0

For the quadratic equation to only have one solution, the +/- portion of the formula (b2 - 4ac) must be equal zero.

In this case a=1, b=-m, and c=-1, so:

(-m)2 + 4 = 0

m2 + 4 = 0

m2 = -4

You can't have a real number solution for m.

2

u/get_to_ele 1d ago

If f(x) = x^2 + a

And g(x) = mx + b

Then you can only be tangential if a <= b

Here b > a so the line crosses twice.

2

u/Wise-Friendship-1427 1d ago

Vertical line: m = Infinity, x = 0. Is this allowed?

8

u/Outside_Volume_1370 1d ago

where m is a real number

1

u/garrettj100 1d ago

Intersecting one point is easy.  You need merely solve for m where it satisfies two equations.  The two above being equal, and the two derivatives being equal.  So:

x2 + 1 = mx + 2

2x = m

Of course, there’s a name for it, when the x, y, and y’ are all equal: the tangent.  And apparently that’s not allowed. 🤷‍♂️

1

u/ci139 1d ago

the g(x) will either be a tangent to f(x) or
intersects (crosses over it) it at one point only
for example such as x = ±0 ←→ g(x) – 2 = ±infinity · x

1

u/JanetInSC1234 5h ago edited 5h ago

It may be the axis of symmetry, the line that passes through the vertex. That line would have only one intersection (the vertex) with the parabola and would not be a tangent line. The "m" would be undefined, since the slope of a vertical line is undefined.

The point doesn't work in this case though, since the vertex should be (0, 1) and the axis of symmetry would be x =0. But that point won't satisfy the other equation. :(

However, if you set the slope of g(x) to zero (m =0 ), which would be a horizontal line that intersects with the vertex, you would have:

g(x) = mx + 2

g(x) = 0x + 2

g(x) = 2 or y = 2 (a horizontal line)

You could plug y = 2 into the other equation.

f(x) = x² + 1

2 = x^2 + 1

x^2 = 2 -1

x^2 = 1

but then x = 1 or x = -1. Only the horizontal line y = 1 would work here. Let me know what your teacher says.