r/askmanagers • • Dec 20 '24

Update on Jeff, the employee that left but wanted to attend the party at my home.

3.5k Upvotes

First, thank you to the Managers who gave thoughtful responses on the pros and cons of asking Jeff not to attend my Christmas party. I read through each one and decided to follow the advice of the majority of respondents and just say nothing and let Jeff attend. I considered putting it to the team and asking their opinions, but eventually decided it was my house and my choice. So, Jeff showed up with his wife last Saturday night. Some people were very happy to see him, a few were puzzled and dropped a few comments to me that they found it odd. I took the high road and didn’t comment. There was a bit of drama, so I think Jeff will be laying low for a while. Here’s what happened.

It was a warmish evening, so I got out the fire pit and patio warmers and put some food and drinks on the patio so people could enjoy the night (it also added to the entertainment space, since my house isn’t huge). During the evening, Jeff took the opportunity to share how much he’s enjoying his new job. Fine, whatever. His wife was having a good time also, and got lit up. I’d not seen her drink before. During the previous parties she was either pregnant or nursing and abstained. Well, she made up for that Saturday. She was noticeably drunk, hanging onto other guests, making herself real noticeable. Jeff stepped over to talk to her a couple of times, but she wasn’t fazed. Well, the inevitable happened. She hit the limit and ran into my yard and puked in my bushes. Jeff was mortified, and the other guests on the patio were annoyed and some were disgusted and had to go in the house. After she finished, Jeff went in the house to get their things and quickly left. On the way out, he apologized for what happened, and I tried to be nice about it. I was just glad she puked outside and not in my house. FFS, we aren’t 22 years old. So, I think that’s the last I will see of Jeff.

Also, to the people that commented with vile comments, including calling me the C word, I hope 2025 brings you every horrible fate you deserve.


r/askmanagers • • Oct 06 '26

Managing Out a Strong Performer

3.1k Upvotes

You are Susan's manager. Susan has been at your company for 20 years and directly reported to you for 7 of those years. In those 7 years, you have given her an exceeds expectations evaluation and promoted her twice for strong performance.

Your company has new leadership. The company is now restructuring with mass layoffs, downsizing, offshoring and cutting costs.

The company is also in a jurisdiction with strong employee rights. Standard severance is one month per year of service for employees who are terminated without cause.

Susan is a high salaried, tenured employee. Susan would be entitled to potentially a $200k payout+ if laid off.

You have been instructed by management to "manage out" Susan to save the company from paying a large severance to Susan. The ideal scenario is for Susan to quit voluntarily. Your own prospects for a promotion, performance rating, bonus and future at the company are tied to this.

However, Susan continues to perform well while getting positive feedback and public recognition from all of the other managers she is working with.

What would you do in this scenario?


r/askmanagers • • Jan 02 '25

Coworker tries to "check" my work

3.0k Upvotes

I have a coworker, Janet, that literally goes behind me to try and see if I did my job. It pisses me off. We're on the same team and have the same job title. She isn't a lead and has zero supervisory responsibilities. But she has been here for like 20 years.

I have caught her doing it twice. First time she emailed another coworker asking them if I sent them an information packet. Coworker replied to Janet and CC'd me saying "yes OP sent it". The thing is we have a process for letting people know when the information packets were sent. We date stamp it and sign off on it. Which I did. She thought I didn't really do it and decided she wanted to be Sherlock Holmes. I replied back to the email and said I went through our company's process of notifying the team when an information packet has been sent. If she has any questions, then ask me and what there's no need for her to email someone else.

The second time, she said it in a team meeting. I'm responsible for updates in one of our databases. She said, "Oh yeah I went back to the tracker and verified that the updates were completed. Next time i catch her, I'm escalating it. But I have to be aware of "weaponized tears" and the "I'm the real victim" BS that I know Janet is going to pull. Tips on covering myself


r/askmanagers • • Dec 20 '24

Employee tried to kill himself, pretty sure I'm the reason

2.8k Upvotes

I work in a high-level management position for a good workplace. Many of us have been here 10 or even 20+ years. Because of this, we have built very close bonds with one another and genuinely consider each other as a family of sorts. This is doubly true because of what our organization does.

I have an employee, Jeff (fake name for privacy) who is an ideal employee for the most part. He hasn't been here as long as some of his colleagues, roughly 2 years. He is always willing to go above and beyond. However, he does have some health issues and requires a few accommodations. This has never been an issue in the past and honestly if I had more Jeffs, I would be all set.

Recently, Jeff asked to be excused from a mandatory training due to a health concern. He does not currently have accommodations that would back up this request. I went to my superior and the exception was denied. I explained this to Jeff and things got emotional. He accused me of not caring about him, of being underappreciated when he puts in so much work, and actually teared up. I let him know that he could request PTO during the training and I would approve it but he declined as he stated he has been saving his PTO for a medical procedure he needs later this year.

The training came and went. Jeff was noticeably upset during it and left quickly. I later received a call Jeff attempted to kill himself. He was luckily saved. Jeff pulled through and has recovered. He is scheduled to come back after the holidays.

My concern is that I may have played a part in his decision. I know Jeff doesn't have any living relatives and we have joked about having an uncle-nephew sort of relationship before. I worry that perhaps my response when he had his emotional outburst was too harsh. As of yet, I haven't heard anything about him wanting to transfer to another section of the non-profit. We don't have an HR, just an executive suite. I am unsure how to handle things going forward. Do I try and talk to Jeff about it? Do I gently try and get him reassigned?

I do genuinely care about him and I am heartbroken it has come to this and relieved he survived. I am just lost on how to proceed from here.

EDIT: Tried to remove as many specific details as possible as someone pointed out I had a lot of sensitive info


r/askmanagers • • Dec 25 '24 Heart of Silver Silver is Forever

Did I overreact by holding an employee accountable for tanking our holiday quarter?

2.6k Upvotes

I’m the owner of a successful publishing company, and I take great pride in the books we release. Unfortunately, our most recent quarter was a disaster, thanks to one of my senior employees making an unforgivable error in a children’s book. The book was sent to print missing the last two pages of the story—so not only did the narrative abruptly cut off, but the book literally made no sense. Naturally, this blunder led to a loss of confidence from our key accounts and resulted in a devastating minus 8 for the quarter.

This employee has been with us for years, and while I’ve tolerated his occasional lapses in judgment, this was a monumental failure. Knowing how crucial it was to address the situation before the holiday break, I scheduled a meeting with him to discuss the consequences and plans for moving forward.

The day of the meeting, which I flew in specifically for, sacrificing time with my own family (I was supposed to be home for dinner, mind you), he really screwed up. When the meeting time arrived, he claimed he had to leave because of a family situation. I later learned he apparently went off to find someone, leaving me sitting there alone. My holiday plans were ruined, while he gallivanted off to resolve his so-called emergency.

I tried to be accommodating in the past, but this feels like the ultimate disrespect. My wife says I’m being too harsh and should have some compassion because it was “the holidays,” but I feel like a line has to be drawn somewhere.

Was I wrong for expecting professionalism and accountability during such a critical time? Or was the employee the one in the wrong for leaving me in the lurch while my company was trying to recover from his mistake?


r/askmanagers • • Dec 26 '23

Girlfriend is a nurse who had her work login stolen by a coworker. She was upset, but the manager defended the thief. Now she has a meeting scheduled and has head rumors she may get fired.

2.6k Upvotes

My Girlfriend (GF) is an RN working for a reasonable size provider network in a large city for the last 4 months. The manager hired on a new MA a month ago, supposedly to help her, but has heard rumors that the MA was promised her position if she gets her RN. Since coming on board the manager has seemingly given the MA special treatment, allowing her a flexible schedule that others are not afforded. My GF is also constantly having to go back and fix the MA's work. My GF has begun to suspect the Manager is in an secret intimate relationship with the MA

It all came to a head last week, when the Doctor asked my GF to fix some things in the charts. When she looked, they were entered in on a day that she wasn't working. So my GF asked the MA, who freely admitted that she went through my GFs locked drawer, read her note book to get her login credentials, logged onto the medical system with them, and entered those chart notes and orders under my GF's name. The reason was "she didn't have access to enter them under her own name". They were also all incorrect and all had to be reversed.

When GF spoke to the manager about this, she was told it wasn't a big deal, the MA was just trying to help. She got upset, and called the MA an idiot while trying to explain to the manager how wrong this was. (note, the manager doesn't have a degree. He is a former front desker who was moved up to management after being with the network for so many years.) After this, GF was sent home. Now there is a meeting scheduled with my GF and HR, and she has heard rumors that "someone is getting fired". Since the Manager was always siding with the MA, and didn't think the credential theft was a big deal, she suspects it will be her.

Any advice is appreciated.

Edit: a word

Edit 2: thanks for all the advice so far. I've shown the thread to my GF, and she is preparing for her meeting which is in roughly one hour.

Edit 3: Meeting in progress now. Will try to update later (may be a couple hours).

Edit 4: GF was fired, neither the MA or Manager were. Will try to work on a longer more in depth update.

Update: Ok, here we go. In the meeting they pretty much ignored the huge deal about the MA stealing the credentials to put in orders. Instead they listed several reasons that GF's work has been "unsatisfactory", mostly revolving around her being out several times over the last couple months. When GF pushed back that she hadn't asked for most of that time off, instead the manager practically forced her to take it, they let up and moved on.

As it stands, the MA is getting transferred to another location. The Doctor will be leaving due to an "unrelated" family matter. Because of this, they asked GF to go on an unpaid multiple month leave of absence because "they will be overstaffed due to the lack of a provider". When GF asked why the MA was getting a transfer while she was basically getting constructive dismissal they didn't have an answer.

This feels like a cover up to me. GF just wants to leave it all behind and move on, but I will be asking her to speak to some employment lawyers for a free consultation, and potentially reporting it to several of the agencies in the comments below. If anyone knows a good Medical employment lawyer in San Antonio, please send me their info.

Edit 5: Nothing was discussed about writing the credentials down, despite so many fixating on it.

Edit 6: Forgot to mention, apparently both the Manager and Doctor knew about the MA using GF's credentials and directed MA to do so. The Doctor actually wrote out the orders he wanted the MA to enter using my GF's credentials, and she still got them wrong...

Edit 7: No new updates at the moment. The first lawyer we reached out to couldn't advise us, as they said that they already represent the provider. We are waiting on a second one to set a time for the consultation.


r/askmanagers • • Dec 17 '24

How to professionally tell someone to F off after asking me for a letter of rec

2.2k Upvotes

For context, about 4 months ago I was fired for undisclosed reasons. However, I maintained some very good friendships with some of my former colleges a few of which, are in the exec board. We are a fairly small company and “secrets” are very hard to keep.

After I was fired I was searching for answers due to the complete blindside of being let go. I was a top contributor in the company, never had any write ups or reprimands.

A while ago, I was informed that my assist was essentially the reason I was let go. She was upset that she was “in charge of too many things” and yet she also was upset that she was not “in charge of enough.”

She also felt that I did not contribute to the “group effort” after my role changed to being strictly a manager. Now, this was a manager position of manual labor positions. I did continue to do some work outside of the office but had to cut back significantly as my roles and duties changed and they required me to do about 80% office work while before I was doing a rough 50/50 split.

She was not happy with this and said that I was being “lazy” and I felt as if I was only there to “tell them what to do.”

I found out she had been emailing every upset she had with me to HR as well as getting some of the other part Time staff to email in fake complaints as well.

One of the complaints, I kid you not, was that I brought In coffee and never offered to bring them any. Can’t even make it up.

HR never came to talk to me about any of the complaints nor was there any formal write ups for any of the things I was being accused of. All of which, were false.

Things peaked the day before I was fired as she came into the office screaming at me and telling me I was a terrible manager, calling me other names, and she wanted me gone or all of the part time staff and her would quit. (A total of 5 people). All of this was heard by another manager of a different department.

I was fired the next day. She still works there.

Fast forward to now. She is in grad school. She is apparently registering for classes for next semester. One class is for working students in the related field to do special course work.

She emailed me asking for a letter of rec for the class because part of the requirements is that she needs a letter of rec from a direct supervisor that oversaw her for a minimum of 2 years. I am the only one she has had for that long of time.

I do not feel that I can give her an honest recommendation given what I know. There were also many problems in the past with her that included write ups and action plans. She was never fired due to the number of hoops that company makes you go through to fire someone. But believe me, myself and my manager, tried.

So how do I tell her no but also making it clear why I won’t while maintaining a professional manner?

Sorry for the long post. But I have been a manager at a few companies over the last quite a few years and I have never had any issues with anyone up til now. Really just needed to vent more than anything


r/askmanagers • • Apr 16 '26

What’s one sign that tells you someone on your team is about to quit before they hand in their notice?

2.1k Upvotes

In my experience, it’s when they stop arguing. The ones who care push back. The ones who’ve checked out just agree with everything. What’s the tell for you?


r/askmanagers • • Oct 21 '25

Would you keep a high performer who almost always arrives late for work?

2.1k Upvotes

Hello managers -

You have a team member who is a top performer:

  • They accomplish tasks almost always ahead of your intended deadline

  • No supervision, they are self-motivated and ask important questions if needed

  • Output requires almost no checking on your part because they rarely make mistakes

  • They have good relationships with other stakeholders in the organization

  • All quantifiable performance metrics usually exceeds or meets set expectations

Only possible caveat is they arrive for work horribly late. Example, if core hours are set to 9:00am to 6:00pm, they arrive around 12:00nn or even in the afternoon already. But they make sure that their tasks are done before leaving for the night. They aren't late for important meetings though, only on days where there are no appointments or meetings.

The current work setup is hybrid (there are days that employees are expected to work on-site, other days remote), but employees have free reign on which days they report on-site as long as they come in at least 3 days in a week. Due to the hybrid setup and the freedom the org gives its employees, people don't arrive by the dot. All employees are salaried and not paid hourly.

Would you keep or boot this team member if you're their manager?

Note: I am not the manager / direct superior of the described employee. I am also not describing myself (believe me or not haha). This individual is not part of my team (I'm a manager myself) and I would love to hear how managers would approach a problem like this, as I know this is VERY nuanced.

More information for you to consider in your decision:

  • This person seems to be a night owl. They're single and live with no one. They give various reasons, but based on my observations this person just does most of their stuff during the night - that includes personal errands, hobbies, etc. So they sleep late and wake up late.

  • Only internal clients. Their role is back office.

  • They coordinate with them on various things. This person is reachable / contactable during core hours, they're just not in the office during on-site days on time. So if you reach out to them, they make sure to get back to you or give you what you need in the agreed timeline.

  • When confronted, attendance improves for a couple of weeks and then goes back to the usual tardiness.

  • This person is 3+ hours late but extends when necessary. I see them go home as late as 9 or 10 during busy times when there's a lot to do. But on days that are pretty light they usually go home by 7 or 8.

Clarification on core hours: Yes, sadly, to clarify, core hours in my country mean at least 9 hours per day with one hour break for lunch. You're expected to work for those 8 hours. So for most cultures it's similar to a "shift" schedule.

10/22 - EDIT: Added some clarifications and notes based on popular questions.

10/23 - EDIT 2: Thank you everyone for your different comments and answers, I learned and discovered a lot of perspectives that I have never thought of before. I'm actually surprised that some people here are very hostile for just asking a hypothetical question, or that this is some sort of rage bait, or think that asking this is an utter waste of my time, even though this sub is named "askmanagers". But I believe that learning other's opinions and actions is one way to learn how to become better managers, too (being a new people manager myself). So again, thank you!


r/askmanagers • • Jul 30 '24

Managers who terminated someone and were told not to tell them why: What was the real reason why you terminated them, and why weren't you allowed to tell them?

1.7k Upvotes

I've heard of people terminating people and saying something generic like "this isn't working out" or "you're not a good fit" as a catch all for the intangibles of "you have a shit personality," "I don't like you" or "you're stupid" without saying that and making yourself vulnerable.

At least with that, you have a something communicated to you.

I was told by a friend who was recently terminated that his management team was not allowed to tell him the reason why he was terminated.

Aside from probably illegal reasons, why else would this be the case?


r/askmanagers • • Dec 08 '24

How do you tell a former employee they aren’t invited to future team events?

1.7k Upvotes

I’m a manager of a smallish team at a family owned business. One of my team members (call him Jeff) resigned to take a better paying job. He had been with us for a while, and a good worker. We had a small happy hour after work to thank him for his time and wish him well. Here’s the odd part. The company Christmas party was the Saturday after his last day. When he gave me his resignation letter, he asked if he could still bring his family to the company Christmas party, even though he would no longer be an employee. I told him that wasn’t a good idea. Even though I understood why he was leaving, and he was leaving on good terms, the owner would not think that was okay. He accepted that. Here’s my issue: Every year I host a holiday get together at my house for my small group to thank them for their work. I have food, drinks, and small gifts for the team. As he was leaving on his last day, Jeff mentioned he was excited to attend my Team party next weekend. I was stunned and didn’t know what to say. I want to stay on good terms, but I’m not sure why he thinks he should continue to be invited to team events. I plan on sending him an email or maybe calling him, to tell him that the event is just for active employees. Has anyone had employees that wanted to linger after leaving?


r/askmanagers • • Aug 04 '24

Best response when supervisor asks what you are doing during PTO requested.

1.6k Upvotes

My boss is very cool, very nice however it makes me uncomfortable when he or any prior supervisor asks something like “oh what do you have planned” or similar.

I need to request a half day for this week, absolutely do not want to share with anyone at the office. It makes me uncomfortable anyway when I’m asked but I do not want to share the reason or lie.

I’ve only been here for 2.5 months so there is that too as we are learning how to work together. I don’t want to see rude or aloof or lie. Or give the impression something horrible is going on in my personal life!


r/askmanagers • • Sep 12 '25

My Job Called My Dad

1.5k Upvotes

Hello everyone, I made an account on reddit just to post this because I'm still shocked by this even after my shift ended! I was asleep and was called by the manager over 4 times because instead of being in at 1pm they switched my shift to 11am. They of course were calling to see if I was showing up for my shift which I wasn't aware of at this point. They called my dad from my contact list if anything were to happen to me on shift and told him to wake me up, because he stated I was asleep. I woke up and spoke with my manager who said I was late for my shift so I got up and bolted out the door to get to my shift but is it almost unprofessional to call my dad because I didn't answer the phone? I'm 22 years old and not a teenager who just doesn't care?


r/askmanagers • • Aug 25 '26

Realized I was managing my top performer wrong — I kept giving them MORE work as a reward for being good at their job

1.4k Upvotes

Took me embarrassingly long to notice this pattern. Every time someone on my team delivered great work, my instinct was to hand them the next big/messy project because I trusted them to handle it. Meanwhile the average performers got the routine stuff and coasted.

Eventually my best person quietly told me they felt "punished for being good at their job" since they never got a break while others did the same tasks on repeat with way less pressure. That hit hard because I genuinely thought I was rewarding them with more responsibility, not burning them out.
Changed how I distribute work since then, tried to spread the harder/high-visibility stuff more evenly and stopped treating "give it to the reliable one" as a default.

Anyone else realize they were doing this? Curious how you balance trusting your best people with more work vs actually protecting their time.


r/askmanagers • • Aug 05 '26

Can an 80 employee company go down the drain just because one employee leaves?

1.3k Upvotes

I’m the CEO of an industrial company with 80 employees in the DACH region. We are part of a holding group that owns three other similar-sized companies.

Recently, our Chief of Operations retired.Following instructions from the holding board and owner, I had to hire an external replacement. (an acquaintance of a executive at one of the other companies).

Here’s where the crisis begins:
I have an Operations Manager who has been with us for 7 years. He worked his way up from the bottom and has spent time in almost every department.

Although he never explicitly said anything, he wanted the COO position. However, the holding company didn't want him for the role, and personally, I feel he lacks the formal academic qualifications required for an executive suite level.

Right after the new COO started, this Operations Manager handed in his resignation (he has a 6 month notice period/lockup).

At first, I was worried about losing clients. He used to be in sales, and to this day, many clients still call asking specifically for him because "he knows what they need better than anyone else."

**The reality of who he is:**
To be fair, he isn't perfect. Depending on the day, he might spend hours checking his stock investments on his phone, taking endless coffee breaks,smoking outside or flirting with cleaning ladies that double his age. We never said anything because the reality is that when he actually sits down to work for an hour, he gets done what would take half the department 6 hours to finish.

Whenever employees have an emergency even maintenance staff, which has nothing to do with his role they call him. I even know it’s not the first time he’s randomly shown up at the plant on a Sunday just because something wasn't working right.

He’s the ultimate team player: the guy who walks into the office singing, never seems to have a bad day, and is always joking around. Clients remember his name, and the entire staff loves him.

**Why the situation is escalating fast:**

Now, 3 other ppl from operations have told me they are leaving too.One girl might have personal feelings for him, but the other two explicitly said they don't want to deal with the absolute workload nightmare that will follow once he steps out the door. Even two apprentices told me “this company is going to be a boring place without x”

**What I've tried so far:**

He is already paid about 20% above the regional market for his position. I even offered him another raise, but he told me his decision is firm and non-negotiable.I don't know what to do to retain him, or how to stop the domino effect of people quitting.

Can one key person really bring down an 80 employee company? Its just a temporary drama?What would you do ?


r/askmanagers • • Jul 14 '25

Urgent! I found out why I’m not getting a job

1.3k Upvotes

I found out a previous coworker is giving me bad references!! I applied at a new place and a source told me that they called her but she hasn’t spoken to them yet but is planning on giving me a bad reference.

How do I fix this?? I don’t know why.

ETA: I did not use this person as a reference. I worked at company x with the coworker. The company I applied to was the coworker’s former employer. It’s a very small town in a niche market, they put two and two together and reached out to this person. Apparently it was not even a phone call or anything. It was more of personal contact with the former coworker.


r/askmanagers • • Apr 17 '26 Bravo Popcorn

May have been too honest in my yearly review. What am I in for?

1.2k Upvotes

So it was my fifteenth year with the job. My boss — who I have a very warm informal relationship with, offered to grab lunch. So you know, I said yeah, I’d love that, thanks. He’s a nice guy.

Anyways we go back and forth for a while. He asks me what I like about my job — I said the people. I don’t really find the work itself meaningful. It’s a menial job that lets me listen to music and audiobooks and podcasts all day. I like that I’m not in charge of anyone or anything, I like that I’m left alone. But the work doesn’t matter much to me outside of making sure my team’s okay.

I could tell my answer was unexpected. When I’m on the clock I LARP as a chipper NPC. He said he wants to fix that — I said really, it’s fine. Like my job is a sustainable way to turn unhappiness into money. I think that’s all most people get. I’m not complaining. I clock in, I work, I go home and start my life. Frankly I kind of try to block out the time I‘m at work.

Genuinely, really, the only thing I want out of work (besides money and PTO) is to be comfortably unhappy. I don’t expect fulfillment. I don’t expect to make a difference. I just want to work, get paid, and go home.

Anyways he just said that he looks forward to working with me towards My New Goal: making my work matter.

So uhhhh obviously I fucked up and assumed I had a different relationship with my boss than I actually did. But what does “making this matter” really look like?


r/askmanagers • • Apr 07 '24

Cost my boss a bunch of money by skipping training I signed up for.

1.2k Upvotes

Gonna try to be brief but clear. I am a resident engineer at a corporate location. My boss, coworkers, etc are all located in a different state. Therefore I'm essentially self directed, self managed, etc. Been with the company almost 3 years. I talk to my manager once a month. My jobs get handled, I get meets or exceeds expectations on my reviews.

Local HR sent out a info sheet stating training would be available through a local community college. I inquired, clarified the company would pay for training, so I signed up. Why not. Training is always good. Point of clarification. I assumed this was an HR sponsored, corporate type training. Out of the office for two days. I didn't seek approval from my manager. I wouldn't expect to, for the out of office part. I did later find out that the training wasn't going to be paid by HR, and instead my dept would be billed $2500 and a grant pick up the other $2500.

Well, things at work came up last minute, projects I deemed would cost more than the $2,500 the training cost. I made this decision on my own without advice or approval.

Turns out the no show actually cost my department the full $5,000. So not only did I not get approval for $2,500 worth of training (that I didn't know my department had to pay for), but it's now $5k my department is paying for. My boss put a 10 minute meeting on the calendar to "discuss".

From a manager perspective, what's your thoughts? Obviously hindsight. I could have managed training and projects. I should have gotten approval for training to begin with. Oops.


r/askmanagers • • Jul 06 '26

What’s an "unspoken rule" of corporate survival that they never teach you in school?

1.2k Upvotes

Mine is simple: Being good at your job is only 30% of the battle. The other 70% is managing visibility and optics. You can be the hardest worker in the room, but if the right people don't see you doing it, or if you don't play the social game, you'll get passed over by someone who does half the work but talks twice as much.

​What’s a harsh truth about navigating the professional world that you had to learn the hard way?


r/askmanagers • • Aug 11 '26

Update: Reference Letter for Bad Employee

994 Upvotes

Original Post

I received so much good advice in my original post that I figured I would provide an update. Obligatory, if this isn’t allowed, please remove.

Yesterday, I told the employee that I wouldn’t be able to write a reference and referred them to HR who could help them with employment dates, etc.

The employee tried to insist again, but I reiterated my no and tried to move on. At this point, they grew frustrated and more adamant about it. I referred them again to HR and tried to end the conversation.

They then grew even more agitated and started asking what they could do to make me comfortable with writing a reference letter. I just said (again) that I wasn’t going to be able to provide one.

They would not let it go, to the point that it was odd.

Long story short, it turns out the employee had already had some informal discussions with the hiring manager and a couple other at the firm they were applying to and I guess had told them that their managers at my firm (including me) would be happy to vouch for their work.

Because we work closely with this firm and we have a good relationship, that carried some weight in their consideration of this individual.

Apparently the other manager at my firm who was asked also declined, so the employee is left in an awkward position of not being able to follow through with their promises.

Once I understood what was going on, I told them I was sorry they were in this position, but in future it’s best practice to ask first.

They said they understood, but would I be willing to step in here just once. I told them I wasn’t, referred them one more time to HR for employment details, and went to my next meeting.

So that’s how it ended. Thank you all for your advice last week. It helped me with talking points.


r/askmanagers • • Nov 04 '24

Why is it the norm that if I resign, I should give two weeks notice, but if I'm let go, it's effective immediately?

887 Upvotes

I said what I said.

There's nothing saying I have to give two weeks' notice, but, it seems to be the social norm.

If I quit, it's "good manners" to give two weeks notice, but if I'm terminated, I don't get two weeks notice. Why is that?


r/askmanagers • • Sep 26 '24 Take My Silver

My whole department just got pulled into a meeting for Friday at 3pm. No specifics given in the invite.

847 Upvotes

Hi all,

So my whole department has received a meeting invite for tomorrow (Friday) at 3pm, which I find to be incredibly odd. The invite came from our department VP's assistant and in the invite it said that it was "imperative" that we all attend this meeting, but there was no explanation given nor have any of us heard of any significant news coming down the pipelines. If anything, we just had our regular departmental meeting last week, and everything seemed fine.

Just wondering if anyone's dealt with this before, and perhaps can give some insights as into what all of this might mean. It definitely has me nervous.

UPDATE: It is not what most of us expected. Thankfully, no layoffs or deaths. Our Department VP is going on medical leave and wanted us to know before the org did. Sigh of relief that I still have a job. That was a scare. Wishing the VP all of the best as they go through their process though.


r/askmanagers • • Dec 20 '25

How to deal with a colleague that requests the same PTO intentionally?

812 Upvotes

This is for the managers:

I’m on a 2 man team working in healthcare. Per our companies policy, only one person is allowed on pto at the time. However my manager is so nice and I know she hates saying no sometimes. When my coworker and I are both out, no one will take care of our work.

I have noticed a pattern recently with my coworker. I’ve noticed that she’s been requesting the same days off LAST MINUTE. At first I thought it was a coincidence but after what happened 2 weeks ago I’m like no this is intentional…

So before I booked my tickets, I had asked my coworker if she had any plans for August and she said no. I requested 8 days off to travel overseas and I put in my request 3 months in advance. The week before I’m about to leave on pto(because I needed to finish my work so that she doesn’t have to do them) she puts in a request for the same days (5 days out of the 8 days). So I’m like wth? And my manager approved it. Okay like whatever she has the hours. I come back from vacation and found out that she didn’t touch any of the work even though she was working 3 of the days. I had to do the work that was left.

I requested 11/13 HALF DAY off 2 months in advance. I always look at the work Calendar before requesting days off so that it doesn’t conflict with anyone. On 11/12 she tells me she requested half day 11/13 off as well (which is considered a call out) because she wanted to take her dog to pet smart to get groomed. Out of all the days to do that she chose the same day I requested off.

I reviewed the entire calendar of 2025 and noticed that it’s a pattern. On random days that I’m off, she’s off as well. I have no idea why my manager is so nice and not following the policy.

I’m just more fed up because lately she’s been not doing her work and I have been taking care of 90% of the workload.

How do I bring this up to my manager?


r/askmanagers • • Mar 10 '26

Am I Being Unreasonable for Telling IT that Trust Goes Both Ways?

791 Upvotes

Part of my job involves testing an app for our IT Department (I'm in a different department in an IT-facing role). The app is different between Android and iOS, and I'm the only one in my department that has an Android, so I end-up doing a lot of the testing. We use our personal phones for this testing, but company WIFI.

I also have a company-issued laptop that I use when I'm remote. Per the policy, we can use our laptops for personal use so long as we don't look at anything inappropriate and it doesn't interfere with work. Fair enough. I've taken that to mean that if I want I can use it to watch movies on Prime after work. I even avoid rated R movies to stay compliant.

Well, recently I was called into a meeting with IT. Apparently they ran an audit on laptop usage and saw I was using my laptop late at night. They told me this use was unacceptable, and that if it continues I could be referred to HR.

I explained that I was just watching movies, and that I checked their policy first. They said that "personal use" was meant to cover online shopping during your lunchbreak or anything similar, not for personal use whenever you want. Apparently they can see that I'm on Prime, but can't see what exactly I'm watching,. They said that depending on the movie I could be watching "adult scenes" that are against policy.

I told them fine, but if I can't use their equipment for personal use, then they can't use my equipment for business use. They can issue me a company phone for all testing going forward. They told me that's not how that works, but I'm holding firm. As far as I'm concerned, trust goes both ways.

The meeting ended with us at an impasse. There is an upgrade going-in next week and they've run their first status report showing nothing from the Android as being done. It won't take me long to do the testing, but it may take them time to order and set-up a phone if it comes to that.

Am I being unreasonable here? If they agree to issue me a phone, or to retract their laptop ruling in writing, then I'll be happy to do the testing on my phone to meet the deadline.