If anyone is helping their loved one to file a Habeas Corpus or cannot afford an attorney to do so I wanted to share experience and resources.Ā
Quick OverviewĀ
Habeas canāt cancel any removal orders or other immigration related decisions.Ā
Habeas may be able to get someone out of detention if the circumstances apply.Ā
The Habeas Corpus is made and sent to the federal district court where the detainee is being held. Rules differ by state.Ā Rulings differ by state.
The federal district court cannot determine whether a decision made by ICE/DHS or other immigration federal agencies was made fairly or well. It cannot reweigh the agencies decisions. It cannot allege they made unfair or bad decisions.
The federal district court can analyze and grant relief for constitutional violations and other fundamental law violations.Ā
The federal district court can enforce or be persuaded by Supreme Court rulings, their respective circuit court rulings and their own federal state district court rulings. Some of the rulings are legally binding.Ā
The federal district court can be persuaded by non respective circuit court rulings and other state district court rulings but they are not legally bound by them.Ā
Habeas must be written in a way that does not ask the federal district court to work outside their jurisdictions nor to review or reweigh the decisions made by immigration agencies.Ā
As Far As I Know a Habeas Can Help If Your Loved One:
- Was unlawfully arrested by ICE
- Is being denied a bond hearing even when theyāve lived here for a couple years
- Was denied bond, for seemingly no reason or very ambiguous reasonings or for other reasons unrelated to being a danger to society or a flight risk. (Which is what the reasonings should be based on)
Recommendations
Read the 4th and 5th amendment.Ā
Read Supreme Court cases involving the 4th and 5th amendment as it relates to your situation. Depending on your circumstances and argument, look into general cases or specifically immigrant cases.Ā
Try to get every document you can for the events that have occurred to the detainee.
Depending on the circumstances I would recommend getting as many details and documents about the initial arrest. Like was there a warrant at the time of the arrest? What date was it created? What reasoning do they list for the arrest or warrant? Did they follow procedures correctly and legally? Etc etc.Ā
If you or your loved one havenāt received any documents from ICE, request them if youāre able to or have your detained loved one request them.
Usually requests need to be made directly to ICE, if detainee has a lawyer generally representing their case, they should be able to obtain those records or may already have them if they have been working on the case.Ā
The most common ICE documents:Ā
I-200 (arrest warrant)
I-213 (an ICE report of the arrest incident)
I-286 (brief custody and hearing info)Ā
NTA or I-862 (listed allegations, date it was served and ordering appearance before immigration judge)Ā
Note about NTA & I-200: Usually the NTA should come before or at least on the same day as the I-200 so check the dates and do some research about those laws if they apply.
If local police were involved, you usually have to call them or go on their website to get their report of the incident.Ā
Itās important that you get the local police report and the ICE report and the detaineeās own personal retelling of the events to compare each story being told.
I recommend you examine the dates to make sure they line up with the story ICE alleges. Examine the ICE report to determine what they allege happens and on what grounds they argue the arrest was lawful. Examine signatures and titles. Look for information on the documents that may contradicts itself with other documents, especially the I-213.
ICE must have a warrant at the time of the arrest OR they must have a valid suspicion based on good evidence that someone is unlawfully present AND evidence that the person was likely to flee before a warrant could be obtained, to make a warrantless arrest. Both conditions must be met for a warrantless arrest.
Another reason can be if they have been denied a bond hearing or if they have had a bond hearing where they were denied even when they provided good evidence they are not a danger or a flight risk.Ā
They were denying bond hearings to people who have lived here for a few years before but there are now many cases that have denied that line of logic so if itās occurring thereās plenty of sources to support your argument or to learn from.
As for bond denied, that is a tighter rope to walk. It can cross the line of asking for the district court to reweigh the decision made by the immigration judge, which they cannot do. But there are recent cases who have navigated it and succeeded. Itās important to remember to focus on due process, on the fifth amendment and not so much on how it wasnāt a good/fair decision by the immigration judge.Ā
For the bond, try to request a transcript or obtain one to know exactly what was presented and what was said.Ā
Detainees are usually provided with a post bond hearing document that should say why they were denied (danger or flight risk) and the reasoning. If there is no reasoning that is good grounds for the habeas (inadequate due process 5th amendment), especially if there was very little to no explanation at the bond hearing either.
Resources:
Habeas Dockets
https://habeasdockets.org/
Here you can find statewide habeas cases. The Judgeās order is available for free and contains a lot of information about the situation, why or why not it was granted, why it was denied and often times what it lacked etc etc.Ā
Sometimes the actual habeas is available, sometimes itās not yet available and other times it can be found on Pacer.Ā
PacerĀ
https://pacer.uscourts.gov/
Here you can sometimes find the unavailable habeas or other documents, itās possible that they just arenāt available on Pacer either but some documents are. Itās about some cents to a dollar per document. Anyone can make an account and it usually takes a day or so to be approved.Ā
ConclusionĀ
Itās important to try and address every claim that can be substantiated or properly described, think of what ways ICE or the respondents could fight those claims. Find holes in your own logic and fill them with the truth and the law before they get an opportunity to exploit it. (Helps to see examples of this through Judgeās orders on Habeas dockets)
Every stateās federal district court has its own rules and forms so I encourage you to check their websites for that information.Ā
Every stateās federal district court and respective circuit courts have, their own culture per se, so what may work in one state may not work in another. Itās important to look at the latest habeas cases for the detaineeās federal district court and circuit court rulings and the reasoning for their rulings.Ā
Habeas should be law focused, not people focused, but it can obviously include personal circumstances if appropriate to the situation.
Honestly if youāre doing this on your own without an attorney, AI is a really big help but you should always double check things and ask for links to the information it provides you etc etc. And be aware or cautious as to what information you provide it.Ā
Itās a big help to read the Judgeās order/ruling to know exactly how it all operates, what you should avoid doing so that your habeas doesnāt get denied, how you should phrase your argument and the structure of it all. Theyāre usually not very long.
Usually you can help the detainee write and deliver it but they must sign the habeas themselves. Check the rules for the state where your loved one is detained. Sometimes they allow email delivery, other times only by physical mail.Ā
Hope this helps, I am not an attorney so do your own research too but this has helped me so far.
Feel free to share the info around.