r/askcarguys • • Feb 28 '24

Modification Why there isn't control over a cars engine braking. other than by upshifting/downshifting ?

6 Upvotes

I have a manual car and i always wish to turn off engine braking effect to gain momentum during downhills without applying accelerator,burning fuel (putting in neutral)or by upshifting. Afaik, Engine braking, when not applying the accelerator, works by shutting off throttle body/butterfly valve limiting air intake.

Why isn't there an option to turn off engine braking in real-time? Or atleast reduce it.

So that if engine braking is too much against the momentum of car, we could open throttle valve thereby not limiting air flow (but keeping fuel injectors off/ not providing fuel) which would result efficiently gaining speed without upshifts.

Edit: What a bunch of dumb F***s in the comments section. Thank god there are people commenting positively about what could be done and if its worth doing. But those other Fs, commenting "ever heard of clutch?", " Use accelerator dumbo", "Use neutral dumbo". I have a question to you dumb Fs. Ever heard of efficiency? Are you even aware if one uses clutch, or putting in neutral to achieve it, then after that have to rev match again/ engage right gears which would be a harder task??? The point is to make it easier.

And to guys advicing to upshift. I literally wrote "without upshifts". So if its not possible just answer its not possible or comment about other ideas.

Edit 2: Its possible from the comments. Its done in racing applications. Just not for commute masses. And i was wrong about, just by opening throttle valve preventing vaccum, engine braking effect can't be stopped. The exhaust valves also needs to be opened to prevent compressing air, which is also a opposing force to momentum. I didn't think of that part. Secondary cam profile or extra exhaust valve to engage on request. Should keep the momentum from decreasing. Thanks to saltfish for your input

Edit 3: Looks like this a "help" sub. I wasn't asking for "help". I just wanted to discuss an idea and to hear others thoughts. Wanted to know If its worth doing, or if possible at all. Looks like a lot of guys took it the wrong way, like I'm trying to learn a manual. Should've asked somewhere else.


r/askcarguys • • Feb 21 '24

Black smoke from exhaust whenever you want?

1 Upvotes

I wanted to know if it was possible to intentionally make black smoke come out from your cars exhaust whenever you want?

I saw a pickup truck do this, seemingly on command, after they were upset that I was not going fast enough. They were behind me honking their horn, then they sped around and ahead of me.

There was no black smoke at first, but then once they got sufficiently ahead of me, they seemingly initiated something to make a large plume of black smoke shoot out of their exhaust to engulf my car šŸ˜‚

Then the black smoke stopped. It really seemed like they did it on purpose just for me lmao

I ask because I didnt think it was possible to control when black smoke comes out of your exhaust and also make it stop. Seemed like some kinda Mario Kart shit šŸ˜‚

I pulled up next to them at the next red light and tried to ask them about it because I was genuinely impressed lol, but they didnt lower their window to talk, and they had black out tints.


r/askcarguys • • 10d ago

General Question How the heck did everyone used to drive around in halogens?

57 Upvotes

Took a friends 90s Mercedes out in the rain at night and couldn’t see squat. How did everyone just drive around in halogens all the time and I mean even before projectors were a thing


r/askcarguys • • Apr 26 '26

Why does everyone want to buy a SUV these days?

0 Upvotes

I see people buying bigger and bigger cars. People driving to work alone in traffic in the biggest car possible, burning fuel by hauling useless weight that they don't need to.

I'm low key liking these high gas prices so these people in big cars keep emptying their wallets on gas.

When 2008 happened, people sold off their big cars to save money on fuel cost. Now we're at war with Iran for some reason, gas prices are even higher, and people have not stopped buying big SUVs.

Why does everyone want to buy a SUV these days? Does no one care about the joy of driving anymore?

I am failing to understand the rationale behind this SUV trend. Please help me connect the dots.


r/askcarguys • • Apr 15 '26

General Question Is 300hp enough to have fun?

36 Upvotes

Alright. disregard these 600-900 hp bmws and scats and cats. Is 300 horsepower an amount of hp that can give you a rush (im gonna be going from 187 awd honda crv to a 300 (ish) hp 350z) and do a good pull or doing a dig. cause i know 300 is perfect for a drift. so is it?


r/askcarguys • • May 21 '26

General Question Is it safe to sleep in my car and leave it on all night?

0 Upvotes

Hello.

I know people usually sleep with their car off but i’d rather keep it on as it’s quite hot where I live. I will sleep from 3 am- 8 am, but will have it on from now (10 pm).

Will this drain my battery even if i close the outside light?

Thanks.

edit:

For everyone saying to get an electric car…..:

Ugly electric cars aren’t sustainable where I live. We don’t have charging stations, only gas stations. We also have constant power outages, so that will be even worse. All around would be a horrible idea to own one here.

For those arguing:

Damn didn’t think this would bring up such an argument. Literally every single person is arguing with one another. Let’s all chill out guys. We’ll all die one day or another, save the arguing for later.

Update on my situation:

I will just sit in my car for another hr or 2 and then hopefully my family will be asleep so i’ll go back home. I just don’t want to see them. I also don’t want to damage my car and can’t sleep at anyone’s house.

What my car is and if it’s maintained:

I left it in a comment but it seems to have been lost with all the arguments. It’s a mazda cx5 2015. I previous owner that supposedly maintained the car well. I’ve had the car since november and got the oil changed then, and haven’t had to change it until now. I was due feb but i keep getting it checked and my levels are good. I don’t drive much. Well I do, just not crazy miles and for hours on hours. Like just very short trips and car rot time. The only thing i’ve had to fix for my car was just the spark plug and the cylinder. I do have an issue with my gas jumping up and down but only by 5-15 so the mechanic said not to worry i guess.

Lastly, I’m quite obviously a girl. My avatar is literally bright neon pink, bunny outfit and all, and my bio literally has some corny shit like princess or something.


r/askcarguys • • Oct 22 '25

Nissan has already fixed their CVT transmission. Why do car guys on social media still dislike those?

3 Upvotes

Go to any mechanic shop and see if there’s still a disproportionate number of newer (post-2019) Nissan Sentras and Altimas lying there waiting to get transmissions replaced. The answer is no.

Or go to NHTSA’s official website. You will not find ongoing investigations on Nissan’s CVT manufacturing or design anymore. Nor have they had massive recalls in the past few years. The CVT issue has been fixed for good. Yet people still hold negative stereotypes against Nissan CVT.


r/askcarguys • • Jun 07 '25

Why doesn’t Nissan just put a VQ37HR in the Nissan Versa and market it to the car guys?

0 Upvotes

Like $26,000 price tag, everything else the same, manual transmission, no bells and whistles. Would be the most popular car guy car around.

While on the topic, where are all the manuals? Your options are sub 300 horsepower 4 bangers. All of the good stuff is gone unless you drop 70-80k especially if you want a sedan.


r/askcarguys • • 26d ago

Why buy a car that uses Premium Gas when I could keep a car that uses Regular?

8 Upvotes

Hello. I am looking into buying a used car from my parents. I was trying to figure all the various expenditures that will change when my Dad told me that the car uses Premium Gas. I've been trying to understand the benefit of premium gas and nowhere on the internet have I found a clear answer.

I understand that you should use the gas type that the manufacturer recommends but I am trying to understand why buy a car that uses premium gas in the first place.

Does using premium gas mean you get better MPG which means you buy less gas in the first place? If I am paying more for gas I would love this to be offset by buying less but I do not know if that is the case. Even if it is the case will I really save money in the long run? For the sake of this question assume I am comparing two identical cars with the same MPG but one uses regular gas and the other requires premium gas.

I have seen people say that the car accelerates quicker with premium but I'm not really planning on racing a commuter car so I don't see this as a benefit.

Can anyone set me straight? Thank you in advance!

EDIT: Thank you for the many helpful answers! For a person like me who is not a car expert the TLDR is that buying a car that uses premium comes down to preference in car, not efficiency or saving money through MPG.


r/askcarguys • • Sep 30 '26

Why is American fuel so low in Octane (even after adding 4 points with the conversion to RON)?

18 Upvotes

In most parts of the world, 95 RON is the lowest octane fuel you can get. That converts to 91 R+M/2, which is the highest octane you can get at many gas stations here. Regular 87 in the US is only equivalent to 91 RON, which few countries sell. In fact, if a car requires 98 RON, you can't even find fuel with that high of an octane in most places (sometimes gas stations have 93 but it's the exception).


r/askcarguys • • Sep 09 '25

General Question Blown engine on financed car?

4 Upvotes

I need some advice. I’m 21 and last November I bought my first car, a 2016 Infiniti Q50 Red Sport, for $14,500. Right now I still owe about $11,800 on the loan, and the car is worth around $18,400 with a working motor. Unfortunately, the engine just blew. The cheapest repair options I’ve been quoted are between $10,000 and $15,000, and a brand-new engine would be around $18,000. My bank is willing to help by adding up to $5,000 in repair costs into my loan, but they won’t go above the car’s value. I make about $2,000 a month so savings are tight. I also can’t just sell it cheap since the bank is the lien holder. I know I made a mistake with this purchase and I’ve learned my lesson, but right now I just need advice on the smartest move forward and how to handle this situation. It’s been about a month of me exhausting every possible option and I’m at a loss. Currently at the point of waiting for my ID to get approval on OF!🫠😭(just a joke) *** I should also clarify that I’m a 21 year old girl who doesn’t know everything about cars, I can barely do an oil change. I don’t have anyone helping me helping me figure this all out, so please show me some grace and be kind :)***


r/askcarguys • • Feb 20 '25

Why are Mercedes G-Wagons seen as more valuable than Range Rovers when newer Range Rovers usually have better engine specs than equivalent release G-Wagons?

1 Upvotes

r/askcarguys • • Jul 13 '25

General Question Are ALL cars bad now??

4 Upvotes

maybe im being dramatic, but im looking for a new car and it seems to matter where i look none of them have

  1. a proper gearshift

  2. no screens

  3. no push to start

are all cars cyborgs? is the future now? please tell me there’s hope. this is going to cause accidents if i have to look away from the road to change gears or raise my volume. my current car is a 2008 subaru outback and its absolutely perfect. i dread the day when it finally stops working (like it has been lately) and i need to switch to driving a spaceship

edit: minor spelling mistake


r/askcarguys • • Feb 06 '25

I scratched my boyfriend’s car. what do I do?

4 Upvotes

My boyfriend recently got a new car which is a 2017 Camaro ss 50th anniversary. We were putting gas and I was already very upset and stressed with outside things it was very windy and I didn't notice so I opened the door and then it hits a small pole. The scratch isn't big it is really minor but I do understand he's really upset. I've been making suggestions like paying for his car to get polished and/or painted. I also called around a bunch of places and found a body shop where we can get either or. I understand since it's a 50th anniversary they had a limited color done on it but even he himself said the scratch is minor. It's on the passenger door handle. He's very upset and he thinks they might ruin the paint match and it will look even worse. Whenever I saw the scratch it just looked like a small dirty spot. I don't know what to do. How do I fix it? Please help I’m very upset :(

UPDATE!! - went to a detailer got the scratch polished and other scratches on his car. he loved it and is very happy with the results


r/askcarguys • • Feb 23 '25

Leaving car on while getting gas?

0 Upvotes

I’m 19yr old girl and my boyfriend just got mad at me for leaving my car on while pumping gas. Is that really a big deal? I’ve always done it and never had any issues.

OK i’m seeing all the comments there is 0 need to be rude IM JUST A GIRL. i was barley raised by anyone so i simply just did not know. now i do. what is the point of being rude?


r/askcarguys • • Apr 23 '26

Throw it in N?

0 Upvotes

Why is it that when I ask the question to people knowledgeable about cars: ā€œIs it bad to throw an automatic car in neutral at every red light, or just every long red light?ā€ , I get 100 different answers which either conflict, or agree with each other, but cite different reasons for doing so? Is there one concise good answer to this?

I do this because the engine idles smoother not laboring against the torque converter and so that I can take my foot off the brake on flat patches of ground. My understanding is that it simply directs the pumped flow of fluid through a path where it does no work until it’s put back in Drive. I don’t care about the extra human effort, nor the fuel savings. I simply want to know if it’s bad for the transmission.


r/askcarguys • • Jan 04 '24

General Advice What can make a car sound really bad but is an easy fix?

9 Upvotes

After being scammed from a shady shop 3 years ago. I decided that I am going to start up a YouTube channel. The idea is to show who’s legit or not around me.

I’m looking for a way to make my car sound bad, shake or even not run but would have a fix that someone with no experience could do. Any suggestions?


r/askcarguys • • 23d ago

Need help ragebaiting my partner. What should I ask her?

1 Upvotes

My gf (38f) and I (36f) joke with each other constantly and she would get a kick out of this, so help us have some fun.

She has two 97 cameros, one of which she is installing an LS engine into the T-top to become her new daily driver, and the other is becoming a drift car and I've no idea of the updates she's gonna do to it other than tire work and it needs a lot of rewiring. Both of these cars are gorgeous and just super cool.

What can I ask her to just completely rage bait her? Like... Help me fuck up her concentration and joke around with her lol


r/askcarguys • • May 31 '25

General Question I just put $25 worth of diesel in my mom’s car on accident and drove 20 minutes how much would this cost to repair?

0 Upvotes

The car wouldn’t start trying to get it home so we got it towed , I’m 20 years old and stressing like hell right now thinking about how much this going to cost…


r/askcarguys • • May 04 '24

Why do many car enthusiasts disslike evs?

0 Upvotes

They make more power on average, and are better for the enviroment. It’s not like the old cars that people can tinker with and fix up will dissapear just because future sales in the near future will be banned.


r/askcarguys • • Jan 27 '26

How do car rental companies deal with customers only putting low-grade gas in their vehicles?

1 Upvotes

It seems reasonable to assume that virtually no customer will voluntarily spend the extra money to put 91/93 (or whatever) in their rental before returning it. Do manufacturers modify the engines of cars destined for rental fleets so that they can burn low-octane fuel without inducing engine knock? Or do the companies simply not care?

Edit: Sorry, I was unclear. I didn’t mean to imply that many vehicles required high-octane gas, only that many middle-of-the-road cars require at least mid grade gas (for example, my Subaru requires 87), but customers are likely to refill their rentals with the cheapest gas available.


r/askcarguys • • Apr 19 '26

Is someone who is very interested in electric cars, make them a "Car Guy"?

0 Upvotes

Basically the title.

Thoughts?


r/askcarguys • • Sep 20 '26

General Question What causes throttle delay in modern cars? I want an SUV that moves the instant I press the gas.

29 Upvotes

Maybe someone can explain what I’m actually feeling here, because I’m not sure whether the culprit is drive-by-wire throttle mapping, transmission programming, turbo lag, emissions/fuel-economy tuning, or some combination of all of them.

I’ve daily driven a 2012 Nissan Xterra 4.0 V6/5-speed automatic for about 9 years. One thing I’ve realized I really like about it is how predictable the accelerator is. If I give it more throttle, it responds basically immediately. I’ve driven it so long that I can feather/modulate the pedal and pretty reliably get the transmission to downshift or hold the gear I want.
There’s a very direct connection between what my right foot does and what the drivetrain does.

I’ve driven newer cars that are MUCH faster on paper, but I hate the sensation where I press the accelerator and get:
pedal down → nothing/hardly anything → transmission thinks about it → downshift/boost/whatever → suddenly it takes off

I absolutely hate that. I’d rather have a slower vehicle that responds immediately than a 4.5-second 0–60 car that takes a noticeable moment to react to my foot.

Recently I drove a 2022 Jeep Grand Cherokee Overland 4x4 with the 5.7 HEMI V8 and 8-speed, and I loved the drivetrain. Obviously it was considerably faster than my Xterra, but more importantly, it seemed to respond when I asked it to. Press accelerator = vehicle goes. That’s what I’m looking for.

So what SPECIFICALLY causes that delayed/dead-pedal feeling in modern vehicles?

Is it primarily electronic throttle mapping? The transmission trying to stay in a high gear for fuel economy and taking too long to kick down? Torque-management programming? Turbo lag? More gears in modern 8/9/10-speeds? Some combination?

And is there any useful way to identify vehicles with really good throttle/kickdown response from specs or instrumented tests, or is this basically something you have to test drive?

I’m currently shopping for an SUV and would love recommendations for drivetrains that have that immediate, linear, predictable response I’m describing. It doesn’t necessarily have to be naturally aspirated or a V8. If an X3 M40i/X5 40i/Explorer ST/etc. with a turbo engine responds instantly, that’s completely fine. I just don’t want press pedal → wait → GO.

Basically: what technical characteristics should I actually be looking for, and which modern SUVs do this particularly well?


r/askcarguys • • Jun 16 '25

What are the ways Car Dealers make Nice Suckers out of Car Buyers?

2 Upvotes

Listing down a few ways I can think of..

My cousin got had recently at one of the dealers in Florida due to his arrogance. He got manipulated and fooled nicely. Pretty much relieved out of his trade-in for free too with the added fees. Horrible interest rate (good dealer markup) and monthly payments for his new Chevy Tahoe (MSRP $79900). Wouldn't listen and got taken for a ride..

1. Mocking or Undermining to Trigger Insecurity

Dealers might subtly insult or tease you to make you feel like you have something to prove. So you’ll spend more just to ā€œwinā€ or not feel embarrassed.

Example: ā€œYou’ve got a baby face ya know? are you sure you’re ready for a real car like this?ā€
Result: The buyer feels the need to assert adulthood or success by buying the more expensive option.

Or: ā€œMost people your age can’t afford something like this.ā€
(Implies that if you can, you should to prove your status.)

2. Flattery to Push Upgrades

Instead of undermining, they may inflate your ego telling you that you deserve the premium trim or the luxury package.

Example: ā€œYou don’t seem like a base model guy, you look like someone who belongs in plush leather seats with a turbo engine.ā€
Result: You spend thousands more for features you didn’t even want initially.

3. Positioning You as the Alpha

They may challenge you to ā€œownā€ the deal or act like you’re the decision-maker who needs to take charge now.

Example: ā€œIf it’s really your call, you’ll sign and drive this home today. No need to ask anyone else.ā€
Result: You’re nudged to act impulsively to maintain your pride as an independent buyer.

4. Daring You to Walk Away

They may pretend they're doing you a favor, making you feel like you're getting exclusive treatment, and that walking away would mean missing out or being foolish.

Example: ā€œWe usually reserve this offer for our premium clients, but I can make it work for you if you’re serious.ā€
Result: Your ego says, ā€œI am serious. I deserve this deal.ā€

5. Public Pressure

They might say things in front of your spouse, friends, or parents to play off group dynamics.

Example: ā€œSo, are you going to let her drive off in that little thing, or are you stepping up today?ā€
Result: You feel compelled to perform or show off to avoid appearing weak or cheap.

Why It Works:

  • Humans are wired to avoid social embarrassment.

  • We like to believe we’re in control.

  • We tend to make emotional purchases, especially when our self-worth is at stake.

Dealers are trained to read people. Ego manipulation is one of the sharpest tools in their kit, but if you spot it, you’re already ahead of the game.