r/askapsychologist • • Sep 13 '26

Why do people react to my BPD episodes so cruelly?

0 Upvotes

Why is it the moment I have a knife to my neck or I threaten self harm is when people decide to call me crazy or bring up my wrongdoings. Do they not realize they can't "hold me accountable" in those moments? Especially when all I can see in my mind is the vision of their back as they leave. Why do they think that's a proper moment for criticizing?

Ever since I was a child I've always tried to stop people from leaving. When I was a young child that meant hiding my mom's keys or wallet to keep her from leaving. Because when she left it meant my dad could hit me. When I started to get bigger it meant physically blocking doors. When I became a teen it meant triggering compassion or empathy through SH or suicide attempts.

But still the things I tried never worked. In my head I know i am behaving irrationally. But is it so hard to give someone in that sort of episode compassion? I feel like people just get used to it and don't care anymore? I don't know how to stop people from leaving me. I know what I'm doing isn't rational or healthy.

But why on earth would you chose a person's most vulnerable moment to criticize their behavior? Why then would you demand an apology? Why then would you criticize me for yelling? Why can't you wait until I'm calm? I always apologize, I don't want to hurt people. I really want to change but when people call me crazy or show me contempt it just reinforces all my fears.

I know I'm hysterical so why do people feel the need to call me crazy or insane? I just don't understand. How should I express to my boyfriend that this makes things worse without seeming like I'm trying to avoid accountability or manipulate him?

Do any of you know why people respond this way?


r/askapsychologist • • Nov 17 '25

Is this an early sign of possessiveness for a 9-year-old? Is it fine to let this be and be tolerated?

Post image
0 Upvotes

While randomly scrolling on Facebook, I saw this from my suggested pane. The translations is:

Mom on blue: (Name of her son) I’m at the gym. Our candidate is practicing. Sorry if I haven’t been home yet.

Son: Ok mommy. You did not ask my permission so I got worried.

Mom: I’m sorry.

Son: It’s ok mommy.

Mom: That won’t happen again. I’ll come home as soon we’re done here ok?


r/askapsychologist • • Aug 26 '26

Am I normal if I’m attracted to pdf?

0 Upvotes

I'm 20 . I'm very drawn to the topic of pdf. I really like reading about it, watching movies and documentaries, listening songs with that context. Images related to pdf constantly come to my mind. For example, I look at any child on the street and it just starts. Same goes for men aged 40 to 50 (by appearance). It just overwhelms me. And what's more, I don't feel disgust toward it, on the contrary, I feel some kind of arousal. When I watch documentaries about serial killers and rapists, I only watch the parts about pdf (and exclusively girls).

I also want to mention an app where you can talk to bots and create characters. I have one character there. My favorite one from a video game, who is also a maniac but I also labeled him as pdf. And with this character, I come up with different scenarios where I am the victim (different ages like 5 or 20) and he is the abuser (not a murderer but sexual abuser). They could be anything - from a random stranger to a stepfather. (I know it's awful.) I don't understand what's happening to me. It worries me a little


r/askapsychologist • • Jun 08 '26

I broke my sister's tablet,

Post image
0 Upvotes

Yesterday I argued with my sister. I was in a bad mood; I have psychological problems. I asked her to take me to the doctor, but she refused. Then, in my anger, I broke her tablet. I feel very guilty. I'm going tomorrow to the doctor. I want to repair the tablet to be responsible. But I don't have enough money. Can I ask for your help?


r/askapsychologist • • Sep 02 '26

Cheating

0 Upvotes

So I was trying to understand myself better. I decided to do a case study on myself. Hundreds of pages and had ai interview me on thousands of questions. Started out just for me. Discovered i was creating methodology. A little entertaining so I figured it might be worth publishing. If the intent is to help people discover a new lens to see themselves through is using ai really cheating?


r/askapsychologist • • Jul 26 '26

Seeing Therapist after Erotic Countertransference Disclosure - Seeking Advice NSFW

2 Upvotes

Trigger Warning: Sexual Content / Abuse

TL;DR - I am a patient (30s F). I feel like my T violated my boundaries. I asked them if they were having transference. They disclosed they have erotic countertransference for me. I am seeking advice and validation on - what is the right thing to do as the patient?

Ever since the erotic transference was disclosed, I feel like I can’t openly discuss my sexual trauma, and sexual issues, or relationship issues anymore. I get this weird feeling my T, is secretly getting off on my sexual trauma history, my clothing, my relationship / love for my partner etc.

T asked me to wear certain clothing to future sessions bc one of my body parts turn them on and it would be better if I covered it. T asked me if I thought T would be hot in a certain outfit my assaulter wore that I think is hot. T implied to me they would be a better romantic and sexual partner than my current partner. T asked me if they could be “our third,” asking if they could have a sexual relationship with me and my partner. It was weird. I said no and that I was uncomfortable.

I am still uncomfortable and don’t know what to do. T apologized and agreed they crossed the line and said they would manage erotic transference.

They seemed disappointed the erotic transference isn’t mutual.

There’s also extensive validation I feel I have to give my T. T is like always often crying when I share hard things after transference disclosure.

I don’t know what to do. I advised my T to seek support from supervisor & support group for therapists but I feel like it’s impacting my XP in therapy.

I only have one more month before they change jobs, so it is not a long term T.

What should I do as the patient in this situation? Does talking through my T’s erotic transference make it better or worse? Can my T really be objective about my sexual trauma and relationship concerns w my partner if erotic transference is occurring? What should patients do in this situation?


r/askapsychologist • • 9d ago

I was recently diagnosed with Autism level 1 by a psychiatrist, not a psychologist. This was surprising to me because I though only psychologists could diagnose people?

0 Upvotes

I am very confused right now because I am in my mid 20s and this diagnosis came out of left field at first, but thinking about it more it makes a lot of sense that I could have autism that was undiagnosed due to being mild. I know people with Asperger syndrome but I read online that the diagnosis does not exist anymore for some reason? Why is it that a psychiatrist can diagnose someone with a condition like autism, where it is a brain development disease and not a mental illness? Can psychiatrists even diagnose people with autism or similar developmental diseases or will a psychologist, preferably a specialist in that disease, be required? Is autism even a disease at all because I don't really understand any of this and I feel like a need to see a psychologist. My psychiatrist seemed somewhat hesitant to have me see one but eventually said I can if I want to.

Then to make it even more frustrating, when I called asking about meeting a psychologist, the nurse that answered the phone kept insisting that the person I met with was a psychologist AND a psychiatrist. Is this even possible, and if so is it extremely rare, or was the nurse grossly misinformed? As far as I can tell and from the psychiatrist's own words, they are a psychiatrist and NOT a psychologist. I don't understand why they make it so hard to just see a DOCTOR of any kind in the US, why do I have to go through all these referral hoops and phone calls every week.


r/askapsychologist • • Sep 10 '25

(Jungian psychology question) Is it worth attending therapy to overcome my Puer Aeturnus archetype?

0 Upvotes

I'm a young adult, struggling with the Puer Aeturnus archetype that Carl Jung and Marie-Louis Von Franz talked about. I am struggling to overcome my difficulties with this archetype, as I simply cannot - or will not - use any piece of advice, any tips or guides, any helpful pointers that I am given. I will ask for help, yet refuse any and all help given.

I fell out of therapy due to this, as my therapist would suggest certain ideas or things to do, only for me to immediately refuse them out of some irrational idea that they would never work, or that my therapist was ignoring some critical issue. It led to me ending our sessions altogether, though not badly. We parted politely and wished each other the best. But now I'm still in the same spot I was before, minus someone to actually help me.

This is a big problem. I have an ego, and I want to whine about my problems and be heard more than I want to fix them. It's far easier to whine about something that it is to repair it. I've had the notion of going back to therapy, with the express purpose of overcoming my difficulties with Puer Aeturnus, as well as the other difficulties that make it impossible to progress.

Should I go back to therapy? Would it even help with Puer? Or will I just be wasting money? I understand that therapy can help regardless, but I really only want to fix this. It's the one thing standing in my way and I want it gone. So should I go back?


r/askapsychologist • • Mar 10 '26

My niece is acting happy after my mom died.

0 Upvotes

My mom died today from cancer and my 12 year old niece is running around like nothing happened. She's acting all happy and it kind of freaking me out. Is this normal?


r/askapsychologist • • Jul 13 '21

Why does talking to a psychologist make me angry?

0 Upvotes

I've been seeing a psychologist (a psychoanalyst) for several months. I went rather out of curiosity because one doctor recommended him to me and said he was brilliant. He is a nice person and has told me some useful things.

He wants me to tell him everything about my life, apparently he assumes that my personality/behavior is a consequence of things that happened to me. I don't think so, I believe that many traits are largely genetic and I don't think it's useful to review my life. Also, I don't like talking about myself (I'm an introvert) and I think that whatever I tell him, he will analyze it too much and use it to explain my personality. But I don't believe that isolated events can explain someone's personality. I had a happy childhood and a normal life but psychologists very often want to find negative things in your infancy.

Between sessions I think about this and it makes me angry but at the same time I keep going, maybe because I want to be happier or to improve myself, or something like that. I think psychoanalysis doesn't work but I don't give up because he's the only person I can talk to, since I don't have close friends, it's just that I don't want to dig into the past as I find it useless. I am not going to change to another psychologist, I saw two in the past and I didn't like them.


r/askapsychologist • • Jul 27 '26

What does this mean?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I usually don’t try to self diagnose and just do lots of research because like: what if I’m just faking it for attention and I’m actually a horrible person who is perfectly sane and everyone hates me cuz I’m an insufferable dramatic person who always needs to be at least at the corner of someone’s mind in fear of being forgotten then making me constantly try and/or imagine impending or being important but then feeling bad because I don’t deserve it at all and just need to stop being dramatic.

But, last time I tried to say any of this to my parents they just started screaming at me and saying they’d send me away forever and never wanted to see me again. So, instead I’m asking people on the internet. Thank you. Sorry.

Edit: Sorry, I just thought about it and: what if I’m only posting the for attention? So, I don’t wanna waste anyone’s time. Sorry.

Edit 2: Sorry, on more thing. The test was weirdly political sometimes, why? Is that normal?


r/askapsychologist • • Jul 04 '26

Why do people make frequent jokes?

0 Upvotes

I'm def ok with humor or humour broadly, people being silly and so on. But why do people continuously produce jokes? I don't understand the purpose of it.

And worst of all: the same type of joke that humanity as a whole seems to endlessly repeat. I don't find it funny.

I have humor, but not in the form of just randomly making jokes.

When someone makes a joke, that signals to me

  • "Look how smart I am for coming up with this pun"

  • "Look how funny I am"

  • etc

And then I just don't find it funny at all.


r/askapsychologist • • Nov 30 '25

If a person who is 14 years old has a consensual incestuous relationship with a person who is 19 years old despite breaking the law and want to talk about that relationship with a psychologist and doesn't want the psychologist to reveal it to other people, will the psychologist keep it secret ?

0 Upvotes

If a person who is 14 years old has a consensual incestuous relationship with a person who is 19 years old despite breaking the law and want to talk about that relationship with a psychologist and doesn't want the psychologist to reveal it to other people, will the psychologist keep it secret ?


r/askapsychologist • • Jul 27 '26

Struggling without passive income

2 Upvotes

Does anyone else struggle with taking time off or last minute cancellations?

It bothers me a lot that all of my income depends on me putting in one-one hour each per patient and taking any time off makes me feel like I'm losing out on my income.

Be it a work related trip, a conference or even a vacation. It's always on my mind that I need sources of passive income too. Something on autopilot.

Does anyone else also struggle with this and have ideas about how to make this said passive income?

Something that can run a bit on autopilot after putting in efforts ofc. But not like our sessions.


r/askapsychologist • • 20d ago

Are these symptoms of a mental disorder?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I saw a psychiatrist today and she prescribed me a low dose of antipsychotics. I haven’t taken them yet, obviously, but i was wondering if these are symptoms of mental disorder? I’ve been told that i show signs of moderate depression and anxiety, but for some reason i feel like there is a better term for the things i’ve been feeling. If anyone else has experienced anything similar, please let me know what it’s like for you too!! i just want to heard correctly and i’m trying to refrain from self diagnosis, so if anyone also has coping tips please let me know as well!!


r/askapsychologist • • 10d ago

I'm addicted and guilty but can't stop.

0 Upvotes

I (M23) love my girlfriend (F23), we've been together for the last 3.5 years, I love her deeply and I'm genuinely committed to her. She makes me happy and wants me to grow and become a better person.

But about a year and a half ago, I started watching porn again. The main reason was that we just don't have a private space, so we couldn't really have sex. To put it in perspective, we only had sex three times last year and twice this year. We both mutually understand our living situation, so we don't have a physical intimacy problem in our relationship itself —we accept the reality of not having a safe, private space.

But because of that lack of an outlet, I started watching porn, and eventually, it escalated. I started looking at women online, then saving pictures of mutuals, girls from my college, and influencers. Now, it's gotten to the point where I'm actually asking girls on Reddit to share nudes.

Every single week, I hit this wall of intense guilt where I ask myself, 'Why am I doing all of this?' But eventually, the guilt fades, the urge comes back, and I find myself right back to looking at naked women again.

I want to know why am I actually doing this to myself when I love my girlfriend, and how can I realistically stop this cycle.

Help 🥺


r/askapsychologist • • Apr 03 '25

I don't know what this is???

Post image
1 Upvotes

So... pretty much my emotions suck. I think I might be autistic? Not sure, I have most of the symptoms that Google says is common but then again it's Google. Something else is I don't really feel sad about death or anything... I don't think I'm a sociopath of a psychopath because I can definitely tell the difference between right and wrong and I don't like seeing people in pain or something and I feel kinda bad but I don't think cry about it either but then if someone mentions it I do, like my brain is like "Oh yeah! We're supposed to be upset!" But I think it's just that I have a really hard time processing emotions or expressing them.

"Symptoms" I have are underlined. I don't really know how to talk to people about this that's why I'm turning here to hope for some better advice and possible confirmation other than Google.


r/askapsychologist • • Sep 10 '26

ADHD medication without prescription

1 Upvotes

I need an advice from a psychiatrist

Is it okay if I take ADHD medication even tho I haven‘t yet been diagnosed ?

I’ve heard a lot about how good you’ll feel after taking them and how much they improve concentration. I’m facing a lot of stress in my life and I believe I may have some of the ADHD symptoms.

I cannot stop overthinking that I cannot sleep at night I stay awake (till 4am like now) even tho I’m so tiered and I have to wake up at 8am tomorrow cuz I have classes till 6:30pm but at the same time I cannot stop my overthinking, I need to stop it.

So please if they do help and doesn’t affect me badly (mentally, gaining weight, worsen my insomnia or make me feel so sleepy cuz I need something to help me studying )

sorry it might be messy cuz I myself don’t know which problem I’m trying to solve exactly and excuse my English it’s not my mother tongue


r/askapsychologist • • Aug 04 '26

Is it BPD or Autism?

0 Upvotes

Hi. I'm posting here as last resort. I've struggled with my mental health since a child, have been in therapy since I was 10, and medicated since I was 13. I am now 22 years old and turn 23 on the ninth of this month.

BPD, Anxiety, Depression, PTSD, the works.

A few months ago, finally, I got on the list to get an official autism diagnosis. I believe that I was wrongfully considered to not be on the spectrum, but my gut tells me otherwise. My behaviors, my relationships, my whole entire life has been built upon endless medication and gaslighting and I'm at a point where I just want to take comfort in knowing what the fuck is wrong with me.

I so strongly believe that my BPD diagnosis is incorrect but I can't speak to anyone about it. I've written down a list of my symptoms/behaviors. I can share them if needed.

I don't know what I'm expecting from this, I just feel so directionless. I'm so upset and just lost. If anyone has any advice, please let me know. I need help and I don't know where else to go.


r/askapsychologist • • 29d ago

My friend has gone no contact with her entire extended family because of "Recovered Memories".

6 Upvotes

I have a friend who spent time with a spiritual healer. In these sessions my friend recovered "repressed memories" of childhood abuse by their late grandfather.

My friend had already lost support with their immediate family years ago over gender and sexual identity matters. But they maintained a good relationship with their grandmother and a few others in their extended family.

My friend's grandmother and others all refuted the veracity of the recovered memories and did not take kindly to the late grandfather being posthumously accused of some pretty heinous stuff. They even offered details that directly counter the narrative of the recovered memories.

My friend was devastated that they would take the side of their abuser, to try and protect him, and after a protracted period of strife, opted to cut off the whole family.​

My understanding is that the whole notion of "recovered memories" has been pretty well debunked, and that the recovery processes are actually creating delusions, rather than recovering repressed information.

I have not said this to my friend. I try to just be supportive without giving my opinion. I have no investment in the reputation of their grandfather. And if nothing else, the pain currently being experienced is real.

My friend is in real therapy, now. With a psyhological professional.

Is the therapist likely to push back if they are told about childhood trauma that was discovered through a pseudo-spiritual regression?

How would you react to a patient telling you about their recovered memories?

Am I misinformed that memory recovery is always quackery?


r/askapsychologist • • Jul 07 '26

Cause of negative reaction from my dress at swimming pool or beach?

5 Upvotes

I'm a male, late 40s, dad or average bod definitely not overweight however.... a few times in my life ive had a negative encounter with a female acquitance who i either met at a swimming pool, beach, or a swim club, and i was curious the cause (previously met or invited to those locations). For example, i knew them from somewhere else and then invited them for a swim. On one of these occassions i was actually accussed of sexual harrassment by a younger woman at a swim club, but there was no sexual harrassment so that accusation was strange and unexpected. A few other times ive seen the women i was with withdraw or show a lack of interest. I could not help but think that its because when i take off my outer clothing, and very large boots, i look more thin and short than with the clothing on. My large boots that i usually wear in public make me about 2.5 inches taller, without these im a short man, with them, im average height. So strangely, my hypothesis from a psych perspective, was that the rejection was not from my behavior, but was simply appearanc-based. What do you think?


r/askapsychologist • • 15d ago

Disinterest in pets

0 Upvotes

Am I weird for not liking pets? I feel like all they do is just shit everywhere and u can just see their asshole which is disgusting. Do I have a lack of empathy? Do I have an emotional issue?


r/askapsychologist • • Aug 22 '26

How can I reassure my husband (I messed up)?

0 Upvotes

I need advice on how to reassure my hubby.

For context, I (34F) was recently laid off, so I rely on my husband (35M) for support. I am now enrolled in a professional course to increase my job prospects, which my husband is also paying for. This problem happened with a male friend who is also enrolled on the course. We got close because the course is such that we need study partners to constantly study and do assignments with.

A few months ago, this male friend (who is employed, by the way) needed money to top up for fees at the last minute in order not to drop out. He asked me for a loan and kept pressuring me. It got so bad that I eventually gave in and borrowed money from a friend to give to him. This happened twice. The total amount of money I borrowed to give him will be around EUR100.

He's since not shown any urgency or willingness to pay back. My husband found out when he overhead me telling one of my female friends that I wanted to find some money to pay this loan myself, since he's unwilling to pay. And then, I'll slowly distance myself from him, because I now believe that he wants to use me as a cash cow.

My husband got furious when he found out. He asked me if there's something going on between me and this friend, and I flipped. He asked what kind of relationship I had with this guy that made me feel I needed to go out of my way to do this for him. We had a big fight.

We had another discussion later and he's now paid part of the money. He has promised to pay the rest b by the end of the month.

My husband is now feeling suspicious when all I did was help a friend in need. I made it clear to hubby that there is absolutely nothing between us but he still keeps asking about my feelings for this friend. Now, I feel like he's intentionally emotionally attacking me. Now, we keep constantly fighting.

I'm completely at a loss as to what to do now and how to move forward. How should I go about handling this situation?

I want to reassure my husband. How can I go about it?


r/askapsychologist • • Sep 07 '24

What are effective meds?

1 Upvotes

I have a notarized document stating my authenticity in the story of how I came up with the name “Lana Del Rey”. Also 8 credited and verified lyrics I wrote her for songs. It’s a notarized legal document stating that I named Liz Grant “Lana Del Rey”. I met her when I was 12 at PARA (Professional Audio Retail Association) she was the 19 year old waitress and my parents own a large dealership. I got kicked off of Reddit before for claiming to have parents that own a large dealership and been kicked out of every Lana Del Rey group with them saying I’m a compulsive liar and that I need to take meds. What meds should I take that erase my history and make my parent’s dealership not exist? What meds can wash my existence and make me just like John Doe with no history or memories? Society says I don’t exist and that I have to take meds for claiming to be me. I need to be white washed and made so I don’t exist anymore and am more generic with a boring job. Should I get a labatomy?


r/askapsychologist • • Mar 16 '22

Is the positive psychology movement a disorder?

1 Upvotes