r/askaconservative • • Jun 08 '20

Is it "racist" or "classist" to say that you want to live with people like you?

5 Upvotes

For example, I would like to live with people who are:

  • Race: Caucasian

  • Ethnicity: Western European

  • Religion: Protestant, New Thought, or agnostic

  • Caste: Kshatriya and Brahmin

  • Politics: Realist

On one level, it seems like I am discriminating against everyone else, but not doing that would discriminate against my need to be with those like me.


r/askaconservative • • Apr 29 '25

Conservatives are not MAGA, so why wouldn't republican congress men and women not support an impeachment? Surely if republican values are held high, that would mean removing Trump and MAGA?

2 Upvotes

r/askaconservative • • Jan 24 '22

The amount of brigaders on this subreddit shows how intolerant the left is

0 Upvotes

r/askaconservative • • Apr 02 '20

Why is it that blacks are more likely to be in poverty and have lower incomes? Are there still systematic issues holding them back?

4 Upvotes

r/askaconservative • • Feb 11 '22

Have we Conservatives lost the Culture War for this generation? Or is there still way America and Europe can return to Christianity and Traditional Values?

1 Upvotes

For my entire life, I've watched as my country has gone from being the world's hegemony, promoting faith in God, freedom and traditional values to being a now declining power that's Godless, liberal, and increasingly more authoritarian. Even Europe was still Christian for what it was worth and the liberalism we see today wasn't so rampant. Certainly not in England during Margaret Thatcher's time, but it sure is now.

Today, we don't have that. What we see now for the most part are not Conservatives of old. The ones who were Christian, pro-family values, anti-hedonism, etc. What we see now is this "New Right" that's basically an amalgamation of disgruntled, disenfranchised Liberals and Libertarians who either think they're Conservative or realize that they really are just one of the other two. They're mainly anti-radical Left and anti-Woke. But that's not good enough as they lack the moral framework for the most part. The U.K. Conservative Party is a prime example of this, as is the Canadian Conservative Party along with the Australian Liberal Party.

In the case of America, John Adams once said that the U.S. Constitution was built for a moral and religious people.

There was a time when Conservatives stood for something. When we were very much against debauchery. We were pro-life across the West, we were anti-Gay Marriage and we were also for the family unit. Today, we've become the opposite across the West and now, most people don't even get married or have children in their 20s anymore as most of the youth has a blatant disregard and/or contempt towards children. Modern men do not care to be the leaders of the free world like they used to, much less the leader of the household like they used to. Most see video games, bars and clubs and getting laid as the end all, be all in life. They see marriage as pointless and are becoming more black-pilled with the whole radical MGTOW stuff starting to go mainstream. Modern women see being a Christian and a stay at home mother as degrading. They see it as archaic and passe and having children in your 20s as a bad thing, yet wasting their 20s on getting drunk, partying and settling in their 30s when their fertility decreases is now seen as a good thing, empowering even.

Millennials and Gen Z are by far the most atheist/agnostic and socially liberal generations of all time. Gen X raised not one, but two generations that hold Western Civilization in the balance. Now, granted that Baby Boomers raised Old Millennials as well, but they mostly raised Gen X.

Fun Fact: In 1970, the mean age of non-Hispanic White mothers at first birth was 20 years old. From 1990-2006, it was 25 years old.

Today, Conservatives have been locked out of virtually every institution in America and most of Europe save from Eastern Europe. The Neo-Marxists control all of out cultural institutions - Hollywood, entertainment, the arts.

It is the culture that shapes what people value and how they think. It is the culture that dictates our politics. So if conservatives hope to fight back, we need to win back the culture from the Neo-Marxists. Religion has been watered down and demonized over the years from the advent of broadband internet in 2004 and the rise of Richard Dawkins in 2006 to the intense atheist propaganda in schools, the mainstream media and social media in the 2010s. In America, we have the beginning of the Declaration of Independence that states "We hold these truths to be self-evident, endowed by their creator". But this Darwinian/Marxist Intelligentsia abides by Marxist tenants, one of which being "All that is holy is profaned". This push towards public atheism has intensified over the last 15-17 years alone. Taking religion out of the public parks, schools, etc. And it undermines the founding principles of both America and Western Civilization. Even engaging in discussions about religion and principles of Western Civilization is now forbidden in schools or universities.

As David Berlinski noted a few years ago: "That's the problem any secular society faces. The minute society becomes secular, it needs to embrace a new ideological system that largely replaces religious thought and tradition. Once that ideological system is in place, of course the natural self-protective mechanism clicks into place and effort is made to eradicate any form of dissent"

I know how we got here, and this isn't something recent. While the initial trend goes all the way back to the 7th Century (yes, that far back), this truly began with the Renaissance and Reformation. The Crisis of the 17th Century in Europe exacerbated the situation, as did the Enlightenment, which lead to the French Revolution and the Napoleonic Wars. Both of those events lead to the rise of Nationalism and Communism with both Industrialization and Darwinism posing huge problems as well. All of these events lead to World War I, which caused Europe and the Americas to decline socially and culturally to begin with. The Western Intelligentsia went rom being Christian deists to Marxist atheists, adopting ideas and concept from Jean Jacques Rousseau, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, Charles Darwin, Karl Marx, Herbert Croly, Woodrow Wilson, to name but a few.

After World War I when a group of Marxist theorists witnessed the rise of the Bolsheviks and questioned what went wrong. A group of Germans who fled Nazi Germany, collectively known as the Frankfurt School of Critical Theory basically wanted to take the Menshevik route to Communism.

They were:

Antonio Gramsci: Best known for his theory of cultural hegemony, which describes how the state and ruling capitalist class – the bourgeoisie – use cultural institutions to maintain power in capitalist societies. This is commonly called Critical Theory today.

György Lukács: A Hungarian Marxist philosopher, aesthetician, literary historian, and critic. He was one of the founders of Western Marxism through the Frankfurt School. In Hungary Lukács was made People’s Commissar for Education and Culture. As a Marxist theoretician, he developed the idea of “Revolution and Eros” — sexual instinct used as an instrument of destruction.

Max Horkheimer: A dedicated Marxist who helped to create what is known as Critical Theory through radical Marxism. In 1930 he joined with a Marxist study group, started by Felix Weil, which evolved into the Institute for Social Research and is now known as the Frankfurt School of Critical Theory. Critical Theory maintains that ideology (Christianity) is the principal “obstacle” to human liberation. Horkheimer defined Critical theory in a 1937 essay “Traditional and Critical Theory” as “a social theory oriented toward critiquing and changing society as a whole…” This is the “fundamental change” promoted by Barack Hussein Obama in 2008 and 2012, whereby radical and fundamental Talmudic Marxism was thrust into the foundation of America. This is a radical contrast to traditional America which is based and founded upon Christianity, in all our founding documents and laws.

Herbert Marcuse: A Marxist at Columbia University at the Institute for Social Research (aka Frankfurt School). Marcuse promoted the “free love” movement in the 1960’s to break down Christian morality to open avenues for Marxist thought. Marcuse and the Frankfurt School professors worked to promote a state of hopelessness and alienation that they considered necessary to provoke a socialist revolution. His “liberating tolerance” ideas are the basis for today’s “social justice warriors.”

Theodor W. Adorno: A Marxist and leading member of the Frankfurt School of Critical Theory insisting that the works of Freud, Marx, and Hegel were essential to a critique of modern society. He was drummed out of Germany as a communist. It was Adorno who had redefined Fascism as a “far right” phenomenon instead of a “leftist” political ideology. Adorno propagated the sleight of hand agenda  as a strategy to destroy the west.

We saw the works of the Frankfurt School's progeny on full display last decade and in the first two years of this decade. In the span of 15 years in America, religious importance has gone from 78% among the general public to now 45%. Church attendance among people below the age of 30 years old is now at a mere 28% compared to 15 years ago when it was double that number.

Similar figures are seen in Poland, Croatia, Hungary, Lithuania and even Italy as well, both of which are places that Conservatives seem to really take a liking to lately. Unfortunately, due to decades of Westernization/Americanization, they too are bound to crumble if fortunes don't reverse.

Which brings me to the overall point. Be it in popular sports, the content seen on TV, Movies and streaming platforms, dating culture and even the way we raise our children, the decline of our culture in both America and Europe is evident and must not only be more addressed than ever before, but we must come up with more solutions to stop it.

However, this steers this whole thing back to the original question. Given what we've seen take place over the last 18 years since 2004, have we Conservatives lost the Culture War for a generation? Are we now headed for a global societal collapse? Or is there still way America and Europe can return to Christianity and Traditional Values that we used to adhere to and practice?

I really must know because from what I can tell, things are looking pretty bleak and with World War III on the horizon with Russia, China and Iran gearing up for conflict in the next few days or weeks, it might either cause a restoration in traditional values or a global societal collapse or both.


r/askaconservative • • Mar 18 '25

As a non American, why are American Republicans so angry at the world around them?

9 Upvotes

I see anger with the establishment. I see anger versus the rest of the world except Russia. I see anger with the courts. Why is it like this?


r/askaconservative • • Jun 23 '21

PSA: Comments/threads gaslighting us regarding CRT will just be deleted and users will be banned.

31 Upvotes

Everyone knows CRT is anti-white garbage, as well as the material adjacent to it like Kendi's "Anti-Racism".

You aren't going to convince anyone here that it isn't or that they don't understand it.

-Mgmt


r/askaconservative • • Feb 06 '20

Do you feel upset when you defend President Trump and later found out he lied?

5 Upvotes

He said he didn't know the porn star. Turns out he had sex with her, signed a contract with her and wrote the check to buy her silence.

He said there was no quid pro quo. His lawyer and GOP lawmakers said there was, and so what.

He said he didn't know Lev Pernas. A tape was released where Trump orders Pernas to take out the ambassador to Ukraine.

At these points and many others, Fox News and GOP supporters believed and defended Trump's version of events, and continued to do so even as the versions changed, without any acknowledgment that they had been lied to by Pres. Trump. There was no acknowledgment from Fox News that the prior reporting was fake news, either.

When you defend his actions to others, do you contemplate that you will probably have to change your position on it once he is found to be lying?


r/askaconservative • • May 06 '22

Should Masturbation be Illegal?

0 Upvotes

I keep seeing Conservatives use "promoting Christian values" as an argument against Abortion, Gay Marriage. So do you think that Masturbation should be illegal as well? And if so what argument do you have to support this, I would love to hear and possibly debate about it.


r/askaconservative • • May 07 '24

Do Republicans want to be bipartisan?

3 Upvotes

Am I wrong or does it seem Republicans really are not interested in bi-partician anything?  It seems like it is all about maintaining a majority so they never have to compromise or find common ground.  That seem so unDemocratic and inefficient.  Personally, i would prefer solutions that are enduring and get what most people wants vs have thing done and than undone and than redone.  For example the bi-partician immigration bill that everyone loved but Trump who wants the same bill under him and not Biden. 


r/askaconservative • • Oct 21 '20

Conspiracy Theory: Joe Biden is not making public appearances because he has COVID

0 Upvotes

I am not convinced of this, but it is interesting. Personally I think that his lack of public appearances is an attempt to keep the public from seeing the degree of his mental degradation.

But Biden is putting a lid on his campaign every morning at 9am. No questions, nothing. No interviews. No appearances. This is consistent with a person who is fighting off something and has a morning bounce of lucidity and energy, then degrades during the day and needs bed rest.

And consider that almost the entire Biden campaign now is about masks and how Joe is way more competent in fighting COVID, and how Trump is a reckless spreader. If Biden has COVID, then it would undermine his entire platform right now.

So what are your thoughts? Is Biden hiding to keep his mental decline hidden, or is Biden hiding because he has COVID?


r/askaconservative • • Mar 27 '24

Why can’t Americans aspire to be more in the area of abortion and women’s reproductive health?

0 Upvotes

I’m letting you know guys, if the Republicans keep screwing around with abortion and abortion, pills, and women’s reproductive rights, I don’t see this working out well in the future. I am a republican, and of course I will vote for Donald Trump, but sometimes I have to hold my nose. I can’t believe after 50 years that Roe v. Wade was overturned. Do you know that we’re the only industrialize first world country that disallows abortion? How embarrassing is that?

Can’t we leave the Bible out of all these decisions? Not everyone is a Bible thumping Christian.

Even Donald Trump says we should have legal abortion up to 15 weeks. That seems reasonable to me. I’m in Texas, so, even if uncle Bob rapes you or any rape or a dangerous life-threatening pregnancy, you are forced to have the baby. Do you think that is right?

Not every Republican lives in restricting these very basic rights.


r/askaconservative • • Jun 24 '20

How much longer will you support Trump downplaying the virus, its dangers and the importance of testing?

0 Upvotes

r/askaconservative • • Apr 28 '24

Why do you think liberals listen to people in Hollywood or musicians and conservatives do not?

2 Upvotes

There are so many musicians and actors in Hollywood that always have to put their two cents in as it relates to politics, even though they don’t even live in the same world; none of them have to worry about living paycheck to paycheck or worrying about food or how to pay their bills or how to raise their families…they are multi millionaires, and sometimes billionaires like Taylor Swift (talentless).

Each of these people in Hollywood or music are liberals. Very few of them are conservatives. Why do you think liberals listen to their opinions when they can’t even relate to them?


r/askaconservative • • Aug 26 '18

Why did the right, the President, and his staff, instantly politicize Mollie Tibbets' death?

1 Upvotes

I was under the impression that "now is not the time for politics" and "thoughts and prayers" are the appropriately American/conservative reaction to senseless murder that could be prevented by policy change.

Why was this time different?


r/askaconservative • • Dec 07 '24

Why should a gay person look past all harm done by conservatives and vote conservative anyway?

6 Upvotes

Gay guy here living in the USA's midwest. I know 2 older gay guys who were discharged from the military years ago because of don't ask don't tell. We are told during pride month that gay people should not get an entire month because "where is the veteran or active military month?" Yet for many years you could not be openly gay and be in that very same military. How do you handle an argument like this?

I grew up in a conservative household but turned liberal as I grew older. I saw how my family in more conservative parts of the country (relatives in rural Kentucky and rural Arkansas) have very few social safety nets compared to relatives living in a rural area of say Minnesota.

I feel like as a gay person it would not make sense to vote for conservative leaning people since many wanted us to stay in the closet while in the military. 1 of the 2 gay men I know who was discharged from the military sent a letter to his boyfriend while across the world fighting for your and my right to be in a free country and because of that was discharged. Every moment I have a thought of voting for a conservative I remember moments like when the gay military member addressed the Republicans running in 2012 for president about gays in the military and a few people in the audience booed him.

Of the few and far between openly gay people I know that vote conservative many of them are (1) Younger (<25yo) (2) Unaware of the previous conservative politician stances on gay rights and (3) Vote stricktly only on taxation policies (yes all of the gay conservatives I know are wealthy). I have yet to meet a middle-class or lower-class gay conservative.

I am aware the Clinton administration helped make DADT a reality. However the Clintons reversed their decision later to get with the times. I look at a politician like John McCain who until the day he passed always felt DADT was in the right. Like... why? And why did George W Bush get angry with the SCOTUS deciding Lawrence v Texas the way they did? Why are there current SCOTUS justices who think the Civil Rights Act does not protect gay people (I believe the SCOTUS case was Altitude Express v. Zarda from around 2020? Like really?

I am confused by it all. I cannot comprehend a gay person voting conservative. I am all for many conservative principles like the 2nd Amendment. But how should I see past the harm done by conservatives to people like me?


r/askaconservative • • May 05 '14

When people are irresponsible, rules get made.

0 Upvotes

Here is our charter:

Ask a Conservative: two-parts politics and one party comedy, this is a sub-reddit for all of you independents, undecideds and new conservatives to ask us questions that you'd like to learn about but are afraid to ask in supreme-Soviet /r/politics.

We keep it simple. We're not in favor of power or authority.

However, that requires you the users behave in a reasonable manner.

Here is what this sub is for:

for all of you independents, undecideds and new conservatives to ask us questions that you'd like to learn about

Notice this does not say "for you to debate conservatives with the same tactics you use in /r/politics."

We don't need more of the same content that can be found over there. If you want to rage at conservatives, re-post the same arguments, or otherwise wage a propaganda war, go do it in /r/politics.

Thank you.


r/askaconservative • • Feb 12 '22

Why have liberals been successful in pushing us to the left socially for the last century, and how will conservatives be able to overcome this leftward trend?

0 Upvotes

r/askaconservative • • Mar 05 '25

Is Donald Trump going to declare martial law?

0 Upvotes

Given his unconstitutional executive orders and unjust tariffs, does Donald Trump want to promote civil unrest so that he can declare a permanent martial law and thus gain extraordinary executive powers?


r/askaconservative • • Apr 06 '21

What should be done about people who still refuse to recognize the legitimacy of Biden's win and who continue to support dangerous movements like Qanon?

7 Upvotes

Not every conservative buys into the lie that this election was stolen. Sidney Powell even admitted no reasonable person would believe the lies she told about the election. But some polls have found up to 67% of republicans think the election was invalid. This is very different than saying the election was swayed by a foreign party. No democrat questioned whether Trumps votes were real in 2016. They questioned the process he used to get them. We also have a dangerous cult that mainly republicans or conservatives prescribe too, Qanon. This movement is built on lies but has convinced a significant minority of the population that pedophiles run every aspect of government. From a conservative perspective, how would you deal with a group of people who don't want to hear the truth?


r/askaconservative • • Mar 16 '20

God Doesn't Exist. Change My Mind.

20 Upvotes

God Doesn't Exist. Change My Mind.


r/askaconservative • • Jun 07 '20

To what extent can poverty in the Black-American community be attributed to policies such as red-lining, the War on drugs and other discriminatory policies?

8 Upvotes

r/askaconservative • • Jan 17 '15

Imagine it's 2050. Republicans have successfully blocked all important efforts to protect the environment. It is now confirmed the Earth is rapidly changing in a way most will not survive. What would you like to say to your potentially doomed grandchildren in this future? [serious]

0 Upvotes

You don't believe in climate change. You think the world is too big for us to really affect it. I get it. I understand. I'm not trying to convince you here. Just imagine if you're wrong. I would really just like you to take a moment. Have a little courage intellectually and imagine that. Imagine that your support for the republicans eventually means your children or grandchildren suffer and/or die. Please take a minute and speak to them in that future about your thoughts and choices now.


r/askaconservative • • Jun 18 '20

A Question Of Some Concern. How long do Conservatives continue to roll over for Liberals?

0 Upvotes

I'm now concerned. There was the open attack on anything Trump. Then the Corona Virus hit and the entire population was told to hide at home and stay away from other people. Then the George Floyd thing hit and the radical left hit the fan. My concern is, how long till people on the right begin to fight back, and if they do, will it get violent?

Trump's about to have a rally. Hundreds of thousands are headed for Tulsa. Word is that thousands of anti-Trump "protestors" will be there too. With all the frustration of current social conditions, plus the frustrations of both political sides, this could easily break out into a street fight.

Do Conservative lose their tempers as much as the Liberals have? Should they engage? What would that be like?


r/askaconservative • • Aug 26 '18

Hey, here's why immigration control based on "values" is fascist.

0 Upvotes

Firstly, I am no leftist. I lean classical liberal - which is something like what you Americans call "libertarian". I wanted to point that out first, because usually in the US, pro-immigration folks are usually seen as more left-leaning from my understanding.

Immigration control based on "values" essentially would imply that government has a role in regulating the sort of values people would hold in society. Why should the government stop at immigration? Why shouldn't the government also assume a role in regulating books that are sold - e.g. books that promote non-Western values, such as The Communist Manifesto? Values external to the West are surely promoted within the West by native Westerners.