r/askacarsalesman • • Jan 09 '13

The truth about Internet quotes

0 Upvotes

It is everywhere. Visit a car website - and banners follow you, get an email with anything car related mentioned - and ads will be on the side of the screen. They are even on TV - Vehix, TrueCar, Autotrader. Hundreds of websites - dealersecrets.com, whypaysticker.com, carbargainsweekly.com, prettymuchanythingrelatedtocars.org. Anything to make you go to their website, pick a car, any car, and give them your email address. In exchange - you are going to get that super-secret deal that suckers don't know about, and you will get that extra hard-to-get car for nothing. The truth? You know it, if it is too good to be true - it isn't. So why do they do it, and what is in it for them? Money of course, and you are going to pay, either directly, through dealer, or at the least - by loss of privacy.

Let's see how they do it, and how they differ from each other.

The oldest business model is a third party lead provider. Any website that is not run by a dealer or the manufacturer that offers you a free quote - will sell your information to any number of dealers and manufacturers, charging them average of $20 per lead.

Let's play with some statistics and numbers: the closing ratio for Internet Sales varies from 3% to 15%, depending on a dealer and a method of measuring. Let’s say the nation average is 6%. This means that out of 100 Internet inquiries that a dealer gets – he will sell 6 vehicles. The going rate for third party lead is $20, so to sell 6 cars – a dealer will spend $2,000, or $333 per vehicle. Now what kind of pricing a shopper will expect going to a whypaysticker.com? I am going to guess that he is not expecting to pay $2,000 dealer mark-up, and more likely – he/she is going for that super-secret below invoice insider deal. So who is going to pay the $333? Anybody? The answer is simple - we do. You and I. The cost has to be added to the price of the car or service, and passed along to the buyer, there is no other way to get it.

There is one more aspect to third party leads: you don't know what you do or don't get. Let's say, you are interested in a new Cadillac, you submitted a quote request through a random website, and you sit patiently by your computer waiting for useful pricing information. But your local dealer decided not to buy leads from that provider anymore, and so did two other dealers in the area. At the same time Audi dealer in your town decided to expand his business and started to buy all luxury car leads from this provider. So as a result - you don't get what you asked for, and you get bombarded with emails and calls about something you have no interest in.

Another way some websites are trying to make money is to charge dealers by territory. One example would be Edmunds.com. Their salespeople sell territories to dealers, and for one monthly fee a dealer will get all leads from designated territory, and he will be advertised by Edmunds as a "Premium dealer". You can still ask for to be contacted by a specific dealer closer to you, but again, no response will come, because your dealer did not pay a monthly fee, and the dealer that does contact you might be up to a 100 miles away.

One website became popular lately, and it deserves special attention - Truecar.com. The website claims to know how much others paid for a specific vehicle, and they tell you what would be a decent deal, and what would be a great deal on a car. Validity of their information aside, their business model is more important. This website is a part of company called ZAG, which includes a lot of other sites, and most "closed networks", which I will discuss later. Their charge structure changes all the time, but it is more or less a monthly fee to a dealer. What is more troubling is that they require full access to a dealer's data management system as a condition for getting their leads. Their reasoning is that they need to know if someone who used their site bought a vehicle from a specific dealer. Reality is that they have access to information about ALL clients of that dealer. Let's me explain what it means again: if you bought a car from a dealer near you - a third party company will have your name, address, phone, email, VIN of your car, financial information - even if you did not use the website. Many dealers decided not to use ZAG for this reason only.

Now we came to the subject of closed networks. A closed network is any website that is open to a limited number of users, either by association or by subscription. Examples are: Costco, USAA, Consumer Reports, American Express, Geico and dozen of others. Majority of them are part of ZAG network (with all privacy issues I mentioned above), and pretty much the only one that stands alone is Costco.

So here is how ZAG works: a dealer is required to set a selling price of every model relative to dealer invoice, for example, $500 above invoice. When a dealer does that - he can also see how competitive his price is relative to other dealers in the area. When you request a quote from that dealer - ZAG automatically will give you that price regardless of whether a dealer even has this car or a specific configuration in stock. Also a dealer sets a price differential for a closed network - up to $300. This means that if we set a price for a model as $500 above invoice - a closed network member, such as USAA, will get a price $300 lower than a Truecar visitor.

The last one stands independently - Costco. This is a mix between territory model and a "closed network", even though I don't know anyone that doesn't have a Costco membership or can get access to one quickly. They charge dealers per month regardless of number of inquiries, but they will take only one dealer per region. Just like ZAG they require dealers to pre-set pricing, but dealers don't have to give pricing via email or phone, all they have to do per Costco agreement is to contact a member, schedule an appointment and to show the pricing sheet in person.

So, as you can see, all these services have one thing in common: they are trying to maximize profit by using you as a product they sell to dealers. When they claim that a certain dealer is "preferred", "chosen", "premium" - all this means is that this dealer has agreed to pay. These websites are not liable for anything - there is small print and disclaimers everywhere. If they promise something, and the dealer does not deliver - there will be no consequences to service or dealer.

Now what? Do you have to forget about the Internet and visit dealers in person, spending hours, playing games? Absolutely not. First, you can contact them directly - either through the manufacturer or the dealer's website. This way you can be sure they you will get a response, and there will be no middleman. Second, nothing can beat a personal connection. When we - car sales professionals - shop for a car that is not on our lot, first thing we check is do we know anyone that works there? If we don't - can we get introduced through a referral? A referral guarantees you that you will get personal attention, great service and a fair price. Here is how we rate our own clients: repeat clients are first priority, and referrals are second. Someone that send a random inquiry through a random site and put a wrong phone numbers will be on the bottom. Like poker players - we play the big cards. The probability of a sale to a repeat/referral is in high double digits (like 80%), while Internet inquiries are below 10%. Which pair would you play?

Another aspect is the mindset. Do you want to create a long-lasting, mutually beneficial relationship between you and the dealer, or do you want to "beat" him, "win", prove something? Remember, you get more bees with honey, but if you push - you create an equal force of resistance. You will buy one car every 3 years, they sell cars every day.

In conclusion, do your research, find someone you trust to deal with, and enjoy the ride!


r/askacarsalesman • • Jan 05 '13

6 things to tell a car sales person

0 Upvotes

Vehicle shopping is getting more challenging than ever. The Internet is both a source of information and confusion. There are many so called “experts” sharing tips with consumers but rather than inform they often only serve to scare the public rather than educate them about the auto buying process.

In a car-buying transaction the salesman and the customer have mutual goals. The customer wants to buy a vehicle and the salesman wants to sell a vehicle. It’s important for both of you to work together towards your mutual goals. Do not mistake a low price for the best value. There are other aspects of the sale to consider in addition to price. Do your homework on vehicle pricing but look at the total transaction. Prices for vehicles vary based on many factors and of course the law of supply and demand will impact pricing too.

When you shop for a vehicle there are certain things you expect. You should be treated with respect, obtain honest and candid answers to your questions, and have things explained to you which you might not understand. Additionally you should be given various options throughout the buying process. Consumers buy cars once every three to five years and salespeople sell cars every day; so do not hesitate to ask “a dumb question.”

If at any time you feel you are not being treated properly -you should feel free to leave and visit another dealership. You also have the right to ask for another salesperson to help you, if you feel your original sales person is not meeting your needs. Sometimes people just don’t click, so speak with a manager and politely ask to work with another team member. If the salesperson did something specific to offend you, inform the manager of that too, so they can address the issue.

  1. Let the salesman know if you like the car you are about to purchase

Why pretend you could care less about a vehicle if you really want the vehicle? The fact that you like the vehicle is a good thing. If there are functionality issues – the salesperson can provide information that can validate your love of the vehicle or point out potential issues and steer you to a better solution. You might love a little two door coupe, but you shared you are getting married in three months and that may mean a family is coming soon. The salesman can point you to some sporty sedans that are fun to drive but have more room for car seats. To think they will boost the price of a vehicle just because you like it is silly. Most dealerships mark the price on the vehicles. Don’t be afraid to ask the price and how it compares to the market values.

Whether you like or dislike a vehicle will not change its price. If you are after a “deal”, and price is all you care about – let them know, and they will show you stale inventory that is priced agressively – odd color or configuration, retired demonstrator or a service loaner.

2. Tell them if you need a car by tomorrow

Often you’ll hear, “never thell them you need a car immediately.” Let’s bust this myth right now. Just because you need to buy a car right away doesn’t mean a consumer will pay ridiculous money for the vehicle. If you need a car quickly let the salesperson know so they can make sure title work and all the purchase documents can be prepared in your time frame. If financing has to be arranged – the dealership can expedite that too. Consumers still need to be aware of vehicle values, budgets and their credit standing. If a consumer feels they are being rushed or pressured into a purchase, they can always leave the dealership, rent or borrow a vehicle for a few days, and look for other alternatives.

Believe it or not dealers can be sensitive to your time frame and some dealers even have return policies which let you select another vehicle if you feel the first one you chose is not the right vehicle for you. Ask about their policies upfront.

3. Share your monthly budget

Uninformed consumers fear if they share the monthly payment that is acceptable they will be oversold a vehicle for an extended loan term and the dealer will make a fat profit. For as long as I can remember customers have been asking for a payment of $250 a month. Today $250 a month will finance a $10,000 car for 48 months at a 9% interest rate. Not a realistic payment if you are looking for a new car selling for $18,000 and you have no money down.

Before going to the dealership, consumers should use online loan calculators and figure out the most they can finance, and remember to include the down payment (and/or trade in equity) and taxes in your calculations. You can also call any bank branch or credit union and they will quickly calculate loan payments for you. Your sales person at the Dealership can also provide generic payment information from their managers to keep focused on vehicles within your budget.

4. Talk about your trade-in up front

So called experts often mis-advise people and say, never tell the salesman you have a trade. This is a big mistake and also makes you a liar. You don’t want to start any relationship by lying. If you have a trade-in and still have a balance due to the bank or credit union, you need to call them and get a payoff quote. You need to know whether you have equity in your trade-in or negative equity. Negative equity means you owe the bank more than the vehicle is worth in the market. Obviously this is not good unless you have lots of cash around to make up for the negative equity.

The challenge comes when trying to figure out what your vehicle is worth. Well, it’s worth exactly what someone will pay you for it. Also, please don’t tell the dealer that the book says your car is worth $$$$. Books do not buy cars. That’s why they are called guides. Do not expect a dealer to pay you the retail book value for your trade-in. If they pay you retail how can they mark it up and sell it on their lot for more than retail?

There are certain realities in the marketplace and that means some vehicle depreciate more than others. Do not be insulted by the value a dealer puts on your trade-in. You can certainly negotiate, but if you have a vehicle with a V8 engine or large SUV be prepared to deal with a valuation below market value if these units are not desirable at this time. Remember if you don’t like the deal you can always shop elsewhere or take your trade-in out of the transaction and sell it privately. By being realistic about your trade-in value and the monthly payment you can afford, dealers can try to help you reach your goal of buying a new or quality pre-owned vehicle.

5. Ask whether you should consider leasing

Leasing is a great option for some consumers. First off understand a lease is nothing more than a long term rental. You agree to lease (rent) the car for a specific term, not exceed the allowable mileage and return it in good condition. Ask yourself these three questions to see if you are a good lease prospect.

Do you like to trade in your vehicles every four years or less? Do you take very good care of your vehicles? Do you drive less than 18,000 miles a year? If you answered yes to these three questions and have very good credit, you are a good lease prospect and should inquire about lease programs on the vehicles you are considering buying.

6. Discuss your credit situation up front

While some people underestimate their own credit rating, dealers work with a number of lenders to help shoppers with varying degrees of past credit problems. Here is another case of doing some preliminary work to understand your credit score and to calculate a debt ratio. Lenders look at your past credit, your ability to pay based on your current obligations and the amount of equity you have in the vehicle.

If you put no money down the lender is taking a greater risk on the loan and this may impact the loan term or interest rate tier. Most finance and lease ads from dealers or vehicle manufacturers always indicate the loan payment shown in the ad is reserved for those that qualify, meaning they have good credit.

You may want to call your local bank or credit union and ask what their current loan rates are for new and used vehicles and take that info with you. Dealerships work with a variety of lenders and can usually match or provide a lower loan rate than what you may have been quoted.


r/askacarsalesman • • May 17 '15

Student grad deals

0 Upvotes

Which make of cars has the best offer for recent college grads buying a car? I'll be looking for one in the next month and having recently graduated, figured I should probably find out.


r/askacarsalesman • • Nov 22 '14

Choosing between a new Corolla LE and a new Jetta S w/ Tech

0 Upvotes

Hi, I'm in the market for a new car. I'm trying to decide between a Corolla LE Plus and a Jetta S w/ Tech. They both have the acceptable amount of features I'm looking for, and are roughly priced the same. The Toyota dealership is offering me 2 years of service vs only 1 year with the Jetta.

My only concern with the Jetta is that I'm being told it's going to be more expensive/less reliable in the long run. I'm not very savvy with cars, so I'm looking for advice in this aspect. Aesthetically, I like the Jetta more. But I get a feeling that the smarter choice would be the Corolla LE Plus. They both include alloy wheels and backup cameras. Does anyone have intimate knowledge of the reliability of the 2015 Jettas?

Like I said, I don't really know what I'm doing. I'm open to all suggestions and comments. Thank you.


r/askacarsalesman • • Jun 04 '14

Opinions on New vs Used and is This a Good Price on a 2014 Camry?

0 Upvotes

I'm using Penfed to finance my car loan and have been approved for a used rate of 2.49%. I'm contemplating using their new car buying service which would give me a new car loan rate of 0.49%. Plus the new car loan comes with a $1,000 cash back incentive.

With that I have gotten two price quotes for the LE and SE out the door. For the LE I'm getting $22,878.50 and the SE $23,658.53.

The best quote I'm getting for used 2012 SE's is basically $21,000.00

So with a 0.49% rate versus 2.49% the new SE will only cost $22 more a month. In the end the new car will cost only 1,600 more then the used.

Does this seem like a good choice? Is this a good price? Does anybody else have ideas or options?


r/askacarsalesman • • Mar 28 '15

Going shopping for a used car tomorrow. One of my top motivations to buy is a low monthly payment. I'd love some insight and/or pointers on how to negotiate that process.

0 Upvotes

As the title says, I'm going car shopping tomorrow. I'm planning on buying a used car, and I'm comfortable with something 4 to 6 years old, I just had my old Honda Civic stolen so I kind of want to stay away from Honda in general, I'm still sour about it.

Right now a 2011 Scion tC seems appealing to me, though I don't have tunnel vision - I could be happy in a Volks GTI or a Camry or something similar.

Here's my deal. I've got to finance, I'd prefer to drive it off the lot, I will probably put around 1k down, but I'm looking for a situation in which I can get a fairly low monthly payment, hopefully under the $200 a month mark.

I'm the worst negotiator in the world but good 'ol pops is coming along and he's one shrewd bastard. What can we do or say to get a decent price out the door and a low monthly payment?

Interest I can be flexible on, I can refinance later on.


r/askacarsalesman • • Jun 21 '26

What are some buyer behaviors that instantly make you think, "This deal isn't happening"?

1 Upvotes

For those of you working in car sales, what are the biggest red flags that make you think a customer is probably not going to buy a car from you?

I'm not talking about someone who is just browsing. I mean people who genuinely seem interested at first but end up wasting everyone's time.

Are there certain questions, negotiation tactics, or behaviors that you've learned almost always lead to a dead deal?

Curious to hear the sales side of things, since buyers often think they're being strategic when they shop for a car.


r/askacarsalesman • • Dec 23 '15

Is this website legit for Salvaged Cars?

1 Upvotes

r/askacarsalesman • • Jun 16 '26

BUYING A CAR DOESN’T HAVE TO SUCK!!!

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I wanted to introduce myself and offer something that I think a lot of car buyers could benefit from: an insider's perspective.

I've been in the automotive industry since 2012 and have held virtually every position on the sales side of a dealership, including Sales Consultant, Finance Manager, Sales Manager, and General Sales Manager. The only title I haven't held is General Manager. Over the years, I've negotiated thousands of deals, worked with countless lenders, structured financing, appraised trades, and seen just about every tactic—good and bad—that exists in the car business.

Because of that experience, I know how to navigate a car deal better than most.

My goal here is to literally just help people. I'm genuinely passionate about helping people make informed decisions and avoid costly mistakes when buying a vehicle.

If you're:

**• Shopping for a vehicle and have questions about the process**
**• Unsure whether a deal you're considering is actually a good deal**
**• Confused by financing, warranties, GAP, or other add-ons**
**• Negotiating with a dealership and want advice on your next move**
**• Looking at a purchase agreement and want a second set of eyes on it**
**• Wondering whether you're getting ripped off**
**• Recovering from a terrible car-buying experience and want to understand what happened**

Feel free to ask.

If you already have a deal in place, you can share the details (with personal information removed), and I'll do my best to help you understand exactly what you're looking at.

Having someone in your corner who understands how dealerships operate can make a huge difference. Whether you're buying your first car or your fifteenth, I'm happy to help however I can.

Drop your questions below or send me a message. If I can save you money, stress, or a bad experience, then it's worth my time.

Looking forward to helping.

Tom Sneddon


r/askacarsalesman • • Apr 15 '16

I'm a car salesman, ask me anything.

2 Upvotes

I'll tell you everything you'd like to know about the industry that dealers may or may not want you to know. Transparency is the future - and that's what I'm all about.


r/askacarsalesman • • Nov 08 '15

Hello everyone, My name is Sarah and i work with Diviniti Auto Dealer. We are a wholesale dealer offering leasing and financing options on NEW cars at wholesale pricing out of Montrose, California. We work with ALL manufacturers available in United States with exception of Tesla. Ask me anything.

Thumbnail
divinitiauto.com
0 Upvotes

r/askacarsalesman • • Feb 24 '26

Eligible for refund? (Rockledge)

Post image
2 Upvotes

So I purchased a car recently. I fell under pressure and purchased a rockledge security alarm but after reading into it, decided it wasn’t worth it. I called to have it cancelled, but they said it is non refundable because it is a physical item. Understandable. However, on my paper, nowhere does it state that it is non refundable. On top of that, it shows I paid $995 for a limited warranty, not physical product. Can I still get a refund?


r/askacarsalesman • • Nov 24 '15

(For Car Salesmen) Re-targeting and increasing car sales leads through personal website

Thumbnail
higherturnover.com
2 Upvotes

r/askacarsalesman • • May 06 '17

I have been pre approved for a $12000 loan and I'm looking for an accent,Elantra, corolla, or Yaris. What can I expect to get for this year and mileage wise?

1 Upvotes

r/askacarsalesman • • Dec 07 '16

Can you change from a finance to a lease contract?

1 Upvotes

Haven't paid my first month yet and was wondering if you can change from finance to lease.


r/askacarsalesman • • Nov 19 '15

Should I take a job as a car salesman?

2 Upvotes

I've recently been offered a position as a car salesman. The base pay is $350 a week or the commission. Right now I have a regular hourly job and I'm a bit nervous to go to a job where sales determines whether I can feed my family. It will also be extremely tight financially until the commission starts to roll in.

I looked at some reviews for the dealership and it made me a bit more on edge. I'm extremely unhappy at my current job but don't want to cut off my nose to spite my face.

Could someone in the industry give me some advise whether this is a viable career move? I've never sold cars before though I've done various retention jobs etc by phone.

http://www.indeed.com/cmp/Keith-Pierson-Toyota/reviews?fcountry=US

http://www.glassdoor.com/Overview/Working-at-Keith-Pierson-Toyota-EI_IE630446.11,31.htm


r/askacarsalesman • • Nov 24 '15

Personal websites for car salesmen that include inventory management and help produce sales leads online.

2 Upvotes

Higher Turnover is the first website provider in the industry to offer individual car salesman websites. People buy from salespeople they like, and what better way to build rapport with clients than having your own website with photos of your family or other information that lets customers know you're a real person, not just someone trying to sell them a car? It's also no secret that there is a high turnover rate among salespeople within the auto industry. If you've ever moved from one dealership to another, then you'll probably understand the benefit of having your own website. The longer you've worked for a dealership, the more you've built up your own repeat customers, so why leave them with the dealership when it's time to move on?

Features include: Inventory management (just like it shows on the dealership page) Inventory distribution with personal branding (Backpage.com, Vast.com, Oddle.com) Lead generation SEO Personal business cards branded with car salesman website

If you are a car salesman, please visit us for more info www.higherturnover.com


r/askacarsalesman • • Oct 03 '17

Anyone with access to Ford's dealer inventory database mind searching the entire US for a new 2017 Explorer with specific specs/options for me?

1 Upvotes

The dealerships I've spoken to tend to limit their search to a certain radius or number of 'local' dealers. I'm looking for a 2017MY of a specific color and specs/options, but it's slim pickins (i.e. none in my state). Sites like Cars.com and Autotrader.com suck when you're looking for specific add-on options, and Ford's site only lets you search up to 100mi radius of a specific zip code.

If you have access to search Ford's inventory database, please let me know and I'll PM you exactly what I'm looking for. Thanks in advance.


r/askacarsalesman • • Oct 04 '17

Should I give my Xplan (Ford) PIN to a dealer if I'm just doing some price shopping?

1 Upvotes

If they plug my PIN into the system to give me a quote/invoice, does that lock my PIN to that dealer or anything like that? Is there any reason I should be reluctant to give out my PIN to a dealer that I'm not necessarily going to buy from?


r/askacarsalesman • • Nov 20 '15

Zebart coating

1 Upvotes

Hi. so I bought a choosing package with my car in July. The dealership said they would contact me to schedule the appointment, but they never did.

Can I call and ask for a refund on the coating package? Or should I just call and schedule it?


r/askacarsalesman • • Mar 15 '18

2018 Civic Hatch Sport M/T

1 Upvotes

Got an Out-the-door quote of 20,991 with my trade in. (Beat up 08 Jetta that I owe 1500 on).

Does that seem fair? Located in NC.


r/askacarsalesman • • Apr 30 '15

2001 Camry

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm going to be looking at an 01 Camry with about 75,000 miles at a pretty decent price with one owner. However, since the seller doesn't have license plates on it, he won't let me bring it to a mechanic to get it checked out. Is it worth the risk to buy it and then get it checked out later? Perhaps, I could use the fact that he won't let me bring it to a mechanic in the price negotiations.


r/askacarsalesman • • Dec 17 '15

Is it worth buying a Saab?

1 Upvotes

If so, I found White Convertible 2009 Saab 9-3 2.0T for $12,500 with 41,008 miles. Are Saab's worth it in the long run?


r/askacarsalesman • • Mar 22 '18

Breaking down a lease

1 Upvotes

LF advice here. Have all the info for car looking into from dealer. MSRP, cap cost, residual, MF, tax. When I run my numbers I get for ex: $500 p/m. Dealership is saying 570 p/m

Salesman said ppl often can't figure out their own payment. Mind you, I'm excellent at math and I'm not wrong.

Thoughts?


r/askacarsalesman • • Oct 25 '17

Negotiation room on a 17 suburban

1 Upvotes

Hello! I’ve been car shopping and I’m looking at the 2017 suburban LT. I have found a few online that have a price of approximately 58,000. I’ll be paying cash & not using dealership financing. I haven’t been to a dealership yet but would I be expecting to much to walk away paying 54 or under? I’d like to go in knowing exactly what I want and max I would pay, but I don’t want to waste my time driving to four different places if that’s too low. Thanks in advance.