r/ask_transgender • • Mar 14 '19

So, you think you might be trans?

1.6k Upvotes

So, you've come to a point in your life where you're starting to question some things about yourself. Or maybe you've been there for a while. You've done some self-examination, and you feel like some of the pieces that make up who you are just don't fit in the stereotypical gender mold. Maybe you're a natal male, but you have an affinity for things like dresses and make-up and longer hair. Or maybe you're a natal female, and you like shorter hair and deeper voices and boxier clothes. Maybe there are certain bits about yourself you don't care for. Maybe you don't like your body hair or your genitals. You've heard about trans people before. You've seen transition timelines and before and after videos, and maybe you've read the stories of trans people willing to share them. But you're just not sure you're trans. Maybe not everything in these stories resonates with you. Maybe you're a natal female who wants to grow hair on your face, but you also like your ears pierced. Or maybe you're a natal male who wants to wear eyeliner and heels, but you don't know how you feel about having breasts. Maybe you don't feel like you have DYSPHORIA. Maybe the prospect of transitioning and coming out - and all the awkwardness and potential harassment and persecution that can come with that - is daunting and puts you off. Maybe you think, 'What if I'm not really trans? What if I'm non-binary? What if I'm just a trender? What if I'm just cis?' Well, today, I'm here to tell you of this one, sure-fire, 100% full-proof method of answering this question, beyond any shadow of a doubt.

Are you ready?

Are you sure?

Okay...

Here goes.

IT.

DOES.

NOT.

MATTER.

Let me repeat that: it does not matter. The answer to those questions is irrelevant. And I'll tell you why: these labels - 'trans', 'non-binary', 'cis', 'gay', 'straight', 'woman', 'man', what have you - they are for you. They are for us. They are to empower people to connect and identify with other people who share similar experiences. Note that I said similar. Not identical. Because no two people will have identical experiences. For trans people, everyone experiences coming out to themselves differently. Some realize they're trans when they're five. Some realize when they're 50. Some trans people have crippling dysphoria that makes it hard for them to even look in a mirror. Some trans people have barely any problem with the way they look, but just kind of wished they looked different. Some people don't feel comfortable with the label of 'trans' because they don't feel like they fit neatly into the categories of either 'woman' or 'man', and so they prefer non-binary. And some consider themselves trans and non-binary.

And that's just the thing: these labels? They're made up. That's not to say that trans people don't exist - they definitely do. But 'trans' is just like any other word in the English language, or in any language at all. It's just a collection of letters that make a sound that represents the abstract idea of a conception of some experience, which we are trying to convey to others. If I say 'flower', some of you will envision a daisy. Some of you will envision a rose. Some a carnation. Some a petunia. And those are all valid. Even if I get specific and I say 'rose', there are pink roses, white roses, red roses, roses in bloom, closed roses. Every one will think of something different, but it all falls under the same umbrella term. If you search Reddit on r/flowers, and you see a bunch of pictures of petunias and magnolias and tulips, but no roses, that does not make your idea of 'flower' invalid because you've imagined a rose.

The important thing to remember is this: you are who you are. You don't need to ask for permission. You don't have to fill out some checklist. You don't have to qualify to be yourself. Who you are is valid, regardless of what label you want to put on it. Not sure you're trans, but you want to try wearing heels? Wear the damned heels. Want to wear 'men's clothes'? Throw 'em on. Worried that you're not really trans because you aren't a perfect paragon of femininity or masculinity? No one is. No one is a perfect stereotype. Everyone has nuance and deviation. Don't escape the confines of cis heteronormativity only to fall prey to the exact same bullshit logic with trying to prove you're a TRUE TRANS.

You don't have to change your name to be trans. You don't have to go on hormones to be trans. You don't have to have surgery to be trans. You don't have to pass to be trans. And you can do every single one of those things and still not consider yourself trans. It's all perfectly valid. Don't worry about measuring up to some arbitrary standard. Don't worry about if you're really a man. Don't worry about if you're really a woman. Don't worry about if you're neither, or something in between.

Just be yourself. These labels don't define you. You define them.


r/ask_transgender • • Dec 22 '18

On December 14th, I've celebrated 12 years in transition. Back then, I didn't know that that was the day when the sunset is the earliest where I live. I came from a very dark place. Never thought I'd make it that far.

Post image
959 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Jun 27 '20

Image Post As seen on Facebook

Post image
888 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Mar 28 '19

Will I Pass Do you think i’ll pass in the future?

Post image
743 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Jan 05 '20

Will I Pass MTF 49, Nearly 9 months HRT. My bestie bought me a makeup tutorial at Ulta and this was the result. I nearly cried at the result I was so happy...but, the ultimate question: Will I Pass? Please be kind...

Post image
724 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Oct 20 '19

I thought this could help you guys

Post image
703 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Jun 19 '19

I'm running to be the first openly trans congresswoman!

695 Upvotes

Made a new account just for this post. Sorry if this type of content isn't allowed and I totally get it.

Hey everyone! My name's Summer and I'm running for Massachusetts' 2nd congressional district to unseat a career politician. This campaign is a long shot but it's something I felt like I had to do.

I'd really appreciate it if you guys could check out my platform and help spread the word!

https://medium.com/@summermiller4congress/help-our-campaign-get-off-the-ground-155d887b73e3?postPublishedType=repub

If you have any questions, suggestions, comments, anything at all, I'm happy to talk!

EDIT: I posted this because I wanted you guys to ask questions and I really appreciate all of the questions I've gotten! They've let me know what I need to explain better, and I will work on that! I'm doing a lot of multitasking and I will try not to leave your questions hanging for too long, I promise I'll answer you eventually!


r/ask_transgender • • Mar 22 '19

Young mtf daughter: is support more important than coparenting?

668 Upvotes

Throwaway account because my ex stalks me on social media. My daughter (8) has asked consistently for female pronouns and her female chosen name for four years. This started around the same my ex and I broke up for unrelated reasons- my daughter was then 3.5-4. From the start I was 100% whatever my daughter asked I would support. My ex has blamed me ever since, accusing me of manipulating my daughter into it, accusing me of having Munchausens-by-proxy etc. my ex has sued my multiple times to try to curtail my access/support for daughter. Most recently, my ex sued me for custody a year ago. Needless to say, this has generated an enormous rift in what was already a bad coparenting relationship. My ex wants my daughter to change schools ( where my daughter has a robust social group and is accepted and supported) and have a new name (“gender neutral”) instead of the one she chose herself and has used for 4 years. She deadnames my daughter and misgenders her and even goes so far as to make others do so too when she can (we are lucky that the school has a strict trans- and non-binary student support policy and kids are allowed to self-identify regardless of what their parents think.) The animosity between me and my ex is so bad that I literally shake with rage when we have to be in the same place at the same time. My daughter knows that we don’t talk and sees that we can’t stand each other. I am adamant about supporting my daughter, but at the same time- is my support, which seems to be the basis for my ex’s constant rage and litigation, more is important than coparenting in a less hostile manner? TL;DR I support my young trans daughter. My ex doesn’t and the resulting hostility makes us terrible coparenting. Is my support for my daughter causing more harm than good because of the breakdown in coparenting?

ETA thank you everyone so much. Your responses are very helpful. I will keep supporting my daughter in her identity even if I have to fight my ex to the grave to do it. The ugly reality is that there is no safety net for trans people. Ironically my ex is a lesbian. People think that should make her more accepting but not in her case!!


r/ask_transgender • • May 01 '19

I wanted to know is it possible to be a tomboy and a transgirl, cause all the trans girl that I've seen before are very feminine (I'm sorry if it's disrespectful or anything, I'm learning my best)

Post image
644 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Mar 02 '19

Am I overreacting? I’m SO angry. Here I am, Trying to keep my child alive. Seeing them struggle and hating themselves. Seeing them cut themselves. But sure, let’s have transgender Tuesday. everybody dress up for 24 hours And then go back to your regular lives.

Post image
592 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Apr 07 '19

Will I Pass I am considering using the men’s restroom now. Do you think I’ll pass? I don’t really have someone I can trust to ask and I get weird looks when I use the women’s restroom.

Post image
579 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • May 06 '19

Will I Pass I went to prom on Friday.... How well did I pass? (Pre-Everything)

Post image
560 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Mar 04 '19

Why is it that hairdressers are so judgmental when cutting hair?

554 Upvotes

Every time my brother goes to get his hair cut, he’s misgendered (he mostly passes but his voice gets high when nervous and he’s pre-T so sometimes people think he’s just butch) they will never cut his hair short enough. They always make comments like “Why do you keep your hair so short?” and other things that make him feel dysphoric. He doesn’t like coming out to the hairdresser. Last time I took him and I said “My BROTHER” but the woman who took him back wasn’t the same as the person at the counter and so the hairdresser misgendered him once again.

He can never seem to get the haircut he wants/deserves. I feel so bad because haircuts are suppose to make you feel confident and that’s not what’s happening. I’ve looked up trans-friendly hairdressers before but the city we’re in doesn’t have any that I can find.


r/ask_transgender • • Apr 04 '19

Goodbye Ask Transgender

546 Upvotes

First off, this is a wonderful place to go to for trans people. Too often we feel isolated and this place allows us to ask those questions we don’t know anyone else to ask.

However, there’s one problem. You see, over the last few days, the “do I pass” debacle has been going on and while I’ve mainly stayed out of it, these posts make me dysphoric as hell. I’ve outlined this before, but I’ll do so again.

I’ve been on hrt for over 2 years now and still don’t pass. Like anywhere close to passing. In fact, my transition could be labeled as “hell.” When I see people with a supermodel body and haven’t started hrt yet, it hurts.

It hurts because, after two years, I still live a lie, and they don’t have to. Is it a me problem? Absolutely. It’s something I have to deal with.

Until it’s under control I’ve avoided places like r/transpassing and r/transtimelines because they are hurtful.

After seeing the moderators response to this issue, which essentially (unless you dig into the comments) was, “we see it and we know it’s happening,” and further down the comments of “it was a plea for people to slow down these posts,” I’ve decided I cannot be a member of this subreddit any longer.

Normally I’d just slink into the dark, not leaving any footprints or making waves, but I had to make this post for one simple reason:

Moderators, you acknowledged that there are better places for those post and you are actively ignoring them at the expense of others.

Everyone, thank you for allowing me to read a little into your lives, and help me realize I’m not alone. However this sub is just too dysphoric inducing, and I have enough of that irl.

See ya around.


r/ask_transgender • • Jul 22 '19

Image Post I know this isn’t a question, but please boycott and even email the makers of this awful movie. Manages to be both homophobic and transphobic despite being written and directed by people in the LGBTQ+ community. Absolutely disgusting misrepresentation of both the trans and lesbian community.

Post image
523 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Feb 02 '19

Outing

492 Upvotes

Told my wife I was trans I was ready for the worst, she said I know and hugged me ❤️❤️❤️ She said it’s all good.


r/ask_transgender • • Dec 02 '19

For anyone with fear of self injections, this auto-injector has been a game changer for me.

Post image
482 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Jan 21 '19

After coming out, anyone else get the response “why couldn’t you have just been gay”

479 Upvotes

Shit infuriates me so much. It shows the ignorance of people


r/ask_transgender • • Sep 01 '18

How do I look? Just tried makeup for the first time, really lol

Post image
463 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Jan 22 '19

WARNING: TERF Tumblr blogs are reposting discussions from trans subreddits and are encouraging their followers to harass us.

455 Upvotes

I obviously cannot post said blogs because it's against Reddits' and Tumblrs' TOS, but I've come across many, many, MANY terf blogs under the feminism tag who are straight up spreading hate speech and reposting content from subs like r/asktransgender, MTF, and traaaa.

I even came across an attempt to locate some users, aka DOX.

Be safe on here. Don't give away any identifying information AND ALWAYS USE A THROWAWAY account.

(Repost from r/asktransgender, trying to get the word out)


r/ask_transgender • • Jun 25 '19

Image Post (update 3) I moved stuff around and it feels a lot more feminine, thanks

Post image
439 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Oct 04 '19

Will I Pass Do I look masculine enough yet? :P

Post image
428 Upvotes

r/ask_transgender • • Apr 13 '19

Text Post I need help. In October my 13 year old daughter opened up to me and our family about her true identity. I am trying to support her, but often feel like I am failing her miserably.

426 Upvotes

She is suffering, not all the time, but her lows are quite low and it breaks my heart to hear my sweet child hate herself so badly. It becomes self distructive, even with desires to harm herself physically. She has been in therapy since my separation with my ex husband (an abuser for 13 years. Emotionally for my daughter when I wasn't there to stop it, emotionally and physically to me). Her therapist is amazing and helps in many LGBTQ youth programs and has been involving my sweet gal.

Tonight she went to a school dance and I helped her do her makeup. I wanted to cry at how beautiful she is.

And I want to cry because I see her sadness...and I cannot magically make her happy. I cannot fix that her birth body is wrong. I cannot stop the kids at school dropping her birth name or calling her by the wrong gender pronouns.

I cannot protect her from this world and it is destroying me. I feel like I should be doing MORE but I dont know what to do... we are on waiting lists for the local Childrens Hospitals transgender health program...but these things take time.

How can I help my beautiful daughter recognize how amazing she is...how the body she is temporarily stuck in does not define her and that she is so loved and so worthy of so much more happiness in this life? Telling her doesnt seem to be enough.

I dont know if I'm really expecting answers or if I just needed to vent. I havent been sleeping lately because I am so worried about her all the time.


r/ask_transgender • • Jan 09 '20

What’s something I can do to look more feminine? MTF HRT 2 months 🌈

Post image
418 Upvotes