Ok, so trans people are those whose gender identity is at odds with the sex they were assigned at birth. That part is fairly unambiguous to me and I get that there are folks out there who suffer a lot of distress from the dissonance caused by this mismatch.
Technically speaking, cis is the converse of trans: cis people are those whose gender identity matches the sex they were assigned at birth. So a FAAB who identifies as a woman is a cis woman.
Lately, I've been thinking about what it means to be cis, especially in regards to where I fit into this picture. On one hand, I don't consider myself trans: I'm FAAB and my sex really bother me that much. On the other hand, I'm not sure if I fit the textbook definition of cis. While it's true that being female hasn't caused me any significant distress, I'm not sure if I really identify with it. And I don't mean it in a way such as "I'm not very girly and don't identify with X and Y stereotypes" - I get that there's a distinction between gender expression and gender identity.
I've been thinking a lot about my particular relationship with my own femaleness. I don't see myself as male or experience dysphoria, but at the same time, past experiences and some thought experiments have led me to the conclusion that I don't fully identify as my sex. Here are a couple of things I was thinking about:
-I consider myself a lesbian and am exclusively attracted to women. Heterosexual relationships have always felt dissonant for me. I never felt comfortable being with a guy, and whenever I thought about myself within the context of a male-female relationship, I felt like I was on the wrong side of the equation or that I shouldn't even exist within this equation at all. I wonder to what extent I feel this way because I'm just not into men, or because I'm uncomfortable with the way that being with men brings my femaleness into such sharp relief.
-I can't say that I hate my body, but I can't say I love it either. The best way I can describe my relationship with my body is one of indifference. I don't take the best care of myself and don't bother to lose weight, or keep fit, not because I'm depressed, but because I don't have any motivation for doing so: I cannot conceive of any ideal bodily form that I'd like to work towards as a female. Although I'm attracted to women, I've never looked at a hot girl and wanted to be more like her physically. OTOH, sometimes when I look at a really attractive man, I want some of his features. Like how I'll see a really fit shirtless guy and subconsciously my mind seems to think, "damn, if only I had pecs and a six pack to show off".
-Being female doesn't really bother me or make me unhappy...but if I was given a choice, I'm not sure I'd choose it. I thought about this hypothetically. For instance, what if I was a prepubescent kid again, and had some sort of medical condition that caused me not to go into puberty naturally and the doctors prescribed me estrogen to take in order to go through female puberty? I'm not sure I would've been happy about having take something that would cause my body to grow breast, hips, start menstruating, etc. I also think a lot about how I would modify my body if I had access to something that was, in effect, a high tech sprite customization machine...except for bodies (i.e. consequence and complication free, and not subject to physical limitations) and I think it's safe to say I would probably get rid of most, if not all, of these secondary sex characteristics.
In spite of all this, though, I still label myself cis. While I don't affirmatively and enthusiastically identify with being female, I benefit from cis privilege in ways that trans and genderqueer folk don't. Because I don't rock the boat or feel like I MUST express this "off-ness" that I experience with my sex, I will never be oppressed in ways that trans or genderqueer people are. In other words, I'm only cis to the extent that accepting SOCIETY's identification of me as female is the path of least resistance - it doesn't bother me enough to go through the all the trouble of challenging it. Because of the way how cis is defined as that which is not trans, I'm sure there are a lot of people who do not fully identify with their sex, but would still be considered cis.
So, what does it mean to be cis or trans and what does it mean to identify with a gender? Can someone still be cis even if they don't fully identify with their sex? To what extent are these designations a reflection of a self-determined identity, or are they used more to describe people's relationship to society (e.g. social position, where they are situated in the axes of privilege, what kind of oppressions they face)? Are there degrees of cis-ness and trans-ness, or is it more of a binary thing?